Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teacher thinks DS needs to cut hair to avoid bullying

393 replies

calmama · 06/04/2022 09:49

Very upset. DS is 5 and has always been a sensitive boy. Gravitates towards girls and has some (traditionally) feminine (as well as some very masculine) interests. He has long, curly hair and big blue eyes. Has been mistaken for a girl since birth irrespective of dressing in typical "boy" clothes.

His teacher has just now brought up that she is worried he will be bullied because apparently the other kids at school think he's a girl. She's suggested he cut his hair. DH is all for it. I am not, pure and simply because he doesn't want to! DH has pushed many times and he just doesn't want to. I also don't think he should have to masculinise his interests just because he may or may not be bullied.

Ultimately, I am obviously horrified at the prospect of him being bullied, but am struggling to understand why he should have to change who he is to fit some kind of stereotype. Don't know what to do, but I am very, very upset about all this.

AIBU to think this is crazy? It's 2022. WTAF?

OP posts:
BusterGonad · 06/04/2022 13:54

ManateeFair I see what you are saying but my son stands out enough, he hates being stared at, he hates being pointed out. In his own words 'he just wants to left alone to mind his own business' being one of a handful of white kids with wavy European hair, and a tendency to voice his grievances it just wouldn't work with his wants and wishes. Sometimes you've got to do things, for the greater good. No one wants to change who they are for others but sometimes you do need to fit in. Maybe I'm completely wrong. I don't know. But that's my view anyway.

SuitcaseOfWhine · 06/04/2022 13:48

Bit of a strange suggestion from the teacher. Kids get bullied for being overweight, but I bet she doesn't ask parents to put their kids on a diet. I think it is more about her views than the other children's. I think people have forgotten that boys have always had long hair throughout history, it is not a 'new' thing.

If your son likes his long hair, let him keep it. It is upto the school to ensure it is a safe place free from bullying and prejudice. It's not for the kids to change so this can be avoided.

My child has long hair, mainly because any attempt to cut it short would end in disaster. He isn't really talking, but I do think he would be upset if it was cut. The more people bend to people like your teacher, the more it will be seen as not acceptable.

Nomoreusernames1244 · 06/04/2022 13:43

My son is 2.5 and I chose to have his haircut from fairly young because I didn't like seeing him constantly moving it out of his face when he was playing

Would you cut a girls hair for the same reason?

BusterGonad · 06/04/2022 13:41

My son always had short hair, he grew it during covid 19, we were in South East Asia, everything locked down, school online learning was for 2 years, it was easier to just grow it. There was no need to go through the hassle of trying to find a hair dresser as he wasn't really leaving the house.
Me, I've had very short crops on and off as an adult (like Helena Christensen in the early 90s) Mainly in my early 20s when I was nice and slim and had great self confidence, now I'm older, a few stone heavier and cannot get away with it so much. Also I can't be bothered trying to find a decent hair dresser that can deal with thick wavy European hair. Most wet it, cut it, blow dry it. Looks great but them I get home, wash it and it dries looking like a wedge of cheese. Not worth the hassle.

ManateeFair · 06/04/2022 13:38

@BusterGonad

I grew up with short hair, it's very thick, my mum had 4 of us to care for, I was always mistaken for a boy, not a nice thing really when you're a girl and want to look pretty like your friends. I would say that it's effected me. I grew it long in my teenage years. It's long now. My son grew his hair during Covid, 2 years of online learning so he wasn't actually seeing anyone else at this point. My husband grew his hair too. August last year we moved abroad so new school and job for both, they both cut their hair short. It doesn't really matter what we want people to think of us, they'll think what they like but for me getting my sons hair cut was something we wanted to do so he'll fit in, look smart and won't stand out. Kids want to fit in, the last thing they want is to be the odd one out. I wish my mum grew my hair long like all my friends. She didn't. I always felt ugly. My husband cut his hair because he didn't want people to see a guy with long hair and make up their own assumptions about how good he'd be at his job etc..
Except the difference here is that you didn’t like your hair. The OP’s son does like his, and has said lots of times that he doesn’t want short hair. You’re projecting your issues on to someone else - it’s understandable that you didn’t like being mistaken for the opposite sex, but some kids simply aren’t bothered by that. I had short hair when I was 11-13ish and when I first had it cut I was mistaken for a boy quite a bit, and I honestly didn’t give two hoots about it. I just used to laugh and say ‘I’m a girl, but don’t worry, it’s fine!’
Indiana2021 · 06/04/2022 13:38

It's horrible how so many women are prepared to support the teacher's request - as if being called 'girl' is some kind of insult.

That's not really what people are saying though. The hair is possibly a bit of a red herring and there's maybe more to it than that from the teachers point of view?

Even the most forward thinking of schools can't mitigate the ingrained messages coming from many homes, so the teacher is possibly anticipating that the OPs DS may find things challenging due to a variety of factors.

Depressingly it's about being realistic about other people's views and how horrible kids can be to other kids, despite the best intentions of teachers and schools to challenge this.

It's not women betraying women. It's called being realistic, sadly.

greenmeansNogo · 06/04/2022 13:37

Reading your replies now. An undercut makes the hair less thick so this is actually a good suggestion unless he has thin hair.

greenmeansNogo · 06/04/2022 13:33

Why do you have long hair on him? Genuinely. I understand when they choose something, my 5 yo is very particular about certain things, but did he have it short when he was a toddler and choose to grow it ?

BusterGonad · 06/04/2022 13:30

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

WildebeestH · 06/04/2022 13:30

Our son has long hair. He’s always had friends who are girls as well as boys. At primary we had many debates about his hair but he made it clear that he didn’t want it cut. Over time he’s had periods when he’s tried to engage a bit more with interests that are more common among the boys… football etc. Just enough to take part and be included. He’s now started secondary school and he tells me that he’s ‘found his tribe’. They’re mostly boys and nearly all have long hair. They have wide ranging interests and aren’t shy to express they’re opinions. I hope it continues.

Give him the confidence to explore who he is and to be okay not being the same as everyone else.

BusterGonad · 06/04/2022 13:28

godmum56 I would have got it cut regardless, maybe not short short but definitely trimmed as it was out of control. My son never wants to get his haircut, he has autism, if he had his way he'd never bath, wash his hair, get out of bed. I'm here to parent him. He gets choices but not everything goes his way. I wouldn't want him going to a brand new school, being one of a, handful of expat kids and standing out like a sore thumb with out of control hair, he struggles to fit in at the start of a new school as it is, so for him blending in with his new school mates is the best start for him, once he's known, he's found his friends and found his feet then he can chose to grow it longer if he wants, but if he won't let me wash it regularly or get it trimmed, it stays short.

ManateeFair · 06/04/2022 13:22

@Nothappyatwork

My child bloody hates his teeth being brushed but he didn’t do it he’d bullied because he smelt so we brush his teeth. Haircuts are just one of those things that we do.
You only make your child brush his teeth in case he’s bullied? Not because, you know, tooth decay is painful and dangerous? Wow.

Brushing teeth is important for health, so kids should have to do it. A specific type of haircut has no impact on health, so they shouldn’t have to have one.

BIWI · 06/04/2022 13:21

It's horrible how so many women are prepared to support the teacher's request - as if being called 'girl' is some kind of insult. Angry

@calmama not surprised you've left the thread. You are absolutely NBU to do what your son wants. And as PP have said, if there is a bullying problem, then it's the bullies that need to be dealt with. Otherwise this is just victim-blaming.

BusterGonad · 06/04/2022 13:20

Above in response to IAmAporcupine

godmum56 · 06/04/2022 13:19

@BusterGonad

I grew up with short hair, it's very thick, my mum had 4 of us to care for, I was always mistaken for a boy, not a nice thing really when you're a girl and want to look pretty like your friends. I would say that it's effected me. I grew it long in my teenage years. It's long now. My son grew his hair during Covid, 2 years of online learning so he wasn't actually seeing anyone else at this point. My husband grew his hair too. August last year we moved abroad so new school and job for both, they both cut their hair short. It doesn't really matter what we want people to think of us, they'll think what they like but for me getting my sons hair cut was something we wanted to do so he'll fit in, look smart and won't stand out. Kids want to fit in, the last thing they want is to be the odd one out. I wish my mum grew my hair long like all my friends. She didn't. I always felt ugly. My husband cut his hair because he didn't want people to see a guy with long hair and make up their own assumptions about how good he'd be at his job etc..
don't kids get to choose though? I do get that the desire to fit in is a natural one, but surely wanting to fit in is different from feeling that you have to or else you will be bullied....why is it "smart" for a boy to have short hair but "ugly" for a girl? What would you have done if your son hadn't wanted his hair cut?
BusterGonad · 06/04/2022 13:18

Well yeah. My son never wanted to wear a football shirt from his dad's team. It's no big deal. What's my husband suppose to feel about it? Heartbroken? It's a bit extreme isn't it. It's hair/football shirt/hair bows not a leg amputation.

BusterGonad · 06/04/2022 13:16

Sorry my quotes aren't working. This is in reply to Ice Volcano

BusterGonad · 06/04/2022 13:15

Above

BusterGonad · 06/04/2022 13:15

Yes. Hairs hair, whether it's on a male or female.

chirpychirpycheap · 06/04/2022 13:10

Feels like victim blaming to me - I think the teacher might need a little bit of training.

Marvellousmadness · 06/04/2022 13:09

Dont cut his hair
It sounds beautiful
Cut it when your kid says he wants itcut

My kid was always mistaken for a girl whe he was young. He corrected the people and went on playing. No biggie.

Long hair is beautiful. Society is fucked up. Who says long hair is just for girls. Sounds like my ancient parents in laws. Its 2022 people:)

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 06/04/2022 13:06

I don't know why people bother responding to @Viviennemary. They only spout the BS to get a rise.

countrygirl99 · 06/04/2022 13:03

@hattie43

I would do anything to stop my child being bullied . If that means shorter hair so be it .
But forcing someone to change to a hairstyle they don't want to fit in is bullying
QuinkWashable · 06/04/2022 12:59

There are no comments about girls long hair getting in the way or being a distraction as that's what is expected. It's ridiculous.

Are we reading the same thread? There were two comments, one asking if girls also had to tie it back, and one responding that anyone with long hair should have to tie it back..

Which is totally normal in my experience - in fact my son got away with long, loose hair for longer than he should compared to the girls (largely because it's curly so stays out of the way on its own). He even got away with wearing a woolly hat for a few weeks because he was embarrassed about tying it back (thought people would 'look' - although not embarrassed enough by the idea to cut it!), but now we just pull it back into a bun every day and he realised no-one cares at all.

VapeVamp12 · 06/04/2022 12:59

My little boy got curly long hair and he’s 3 no way will I be cutting it in till he wants it cut himself,

My son is 2.5 and I chose to have his haircut from fairly young because I didn't like seeing him constantly moving it out of his face when he was playing. If your son is only 3 does he even know having a haircut is an option? I don't think my son would have ever asked for his hair to be cut.