Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think teachers should be able to spell

367 replies

Brieandcamembert · 06/04/2022 09:20

I have increasingly noticed recently teachers (often of primary age) who make very basic spelling and grammar errors. Surely having excellent basic skills in this area is an essential criteria for teaching it?

I'm really concerned that we are raising a generation who will have appalling literacy skills.

I have seen the classic "of / have" confusion
I have seen "been" used instead of "being"
I have also seen phonetically similar words interchanged with one another.

OP posts:
SpringsSprung · 06/04/2022 20:58

@annabell22

Some teachers have dyslexia- it doesn't mean that they shouldn't become a teacher.
I respectfully disagree
CecilyP · 06/04/2022 17:05

A mess really and I'd love to what happened or didn't happen in school.

You’d love to what? As you’ve illustrated, anyone can make mistakes and it’s more likely poor proofreading than anything else.

saraclara · 06/04/2022 16:55

Dyslexia in a secondary school subject teacher - fine
In a primary teacher, not fine. If you have a problem in a certain area, you don't apply for a job where it's important to be able to do it accurately.

I was horrified at some of the spelling and punctuation errors that my fellow teachers (and my headteacher!) made. They weren't even in tricky areas. Really basic mistakes that weren't made out of carelessness, just ignorance of the correct spelling/punctuation/grammar.

It's a real worry, as the shortage of teachers becomes more and more of an issue. Just having someone in front of a class of 7 year olds isn't enough. And the problem will replicate itself as fewer and fewer children get taught the correct SPAG and see examples from their teacher of the the wrong spellings.

twominutesmore · 06/04/2022 16:29

@maddy68

Teachers have to have both English qualifications plus an additional literacy test before being able to qualify as a teacher
GCSE grade 4. The skills tests were scrapped in 2020. It's a low bar.
WarmCrossBun · 06/04/2022 16:28

I recruit mid level/senior roles, we now set a written assessment. The reason for this was that literacy, despite a glowing CV, was so poor. The role requires written communication, in the form of emails. They're often very detailed and need to accurate, and spelling needs to be correct.

Some of the examples I've seen are so poor. Text speak, spelling, grammar. A mess really and I'd love to what happened or didn't happen in school.

Leol · 06/04/2022 16:24

One solution would be to have specialist teachers teaching younger age groups. This would require more funding though. As well as funding issues, teachers wouldn’t know the children as well and some of younger children would struggle to cope with lots of different teachers.

MrsHamlet · 06/04/2022 16:22

You also don't have to have a PGCE

MrsHamlet · 06/04/2022 16:21

@maddy68

In UK state schools you have to have Qts
No you don't
maddy68 · 06/04/2022 16:20

In UK state schools you have to have Qts

Leol · 06/04/2022 16:18

The messages on this thread demonstrate how difficult SPaG can be. Where are all these perfect people going to be found? Even if they do exist, they might not want to be primary school teachers. I used to teach in a traditionally male dominated subject area. My students got excellent GCSE and A-level results but a lot of men liked to try to catch me out on my subject knowledge. Some of them had much better subject knowledge than me, which they felt very smug about, but I don’t think many of them would have been very good at teaching.

KirstenBlest · 06/04/2022 16:18

@maddy68

Teachers have to have both English qualifications plus an additional literacy test before being able to qualify as a teacher
Not all teachers qualify as a teacher. It might have changed now but I remember a teacher who was recruited with no PGCE.
maddy68 · 06/04/2022 16:16

Teachers have to have both English qualifications plus an additional literacy test before being able to qualify as a teacher

SiobhanSharpe · 06/04/2022 16:12

@WhenSheWasBad

Teachers do have to pass a literacy and numeracy test before being accepted to train.

I’ll admit I’m crap at spelling. I teach science (mostly Physics). I tell the kids to pick me up on my spelling if/when I get something wrong.
No shame in making mistakes, we just put them right.

My DH, also a physics teacher, did exactly the same! And his pupils took great delight in doing so. He was quite chuffed about it.
Honeymint · 06/04/2022 16:09

I think it depends on the subject. For example my first maths teacher in highschool was incredibly dyslexic and couldn’t spell for beans. He made a lot of jokes about it.

On the other hand my sister, who is very dyslexic, is head of literacy at her school… I can’t say I agree with that at all but she gets very offended if I say anything about it.

I would say that if the teacher remarks that they can’t spell (like my old maths teacher) then children know not to copy them. However if there’s a teacher teaching children the incorrect spelling/grammar and insisting it’s correct, that’s a problem.

As previous posters have said, there’s also the issue of the teacher recruitment crisis.

sweepeep · 06/04/2022 16:01

@Musmerian but teachers don't JUST teach spelling Hmm

JudgeJ · 06/04/2022 15:22

area is an essential criteria for teaching it?
The singular is criterion and the plural is criteria, which any grammar pedant would know.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 06/04/2022 15:21

MN gets very sniffy about SPaG and tells those who question to go over to Pedants Corner. The inference is, that if what a poster is writing is understandable, it doesn’t matter if their spelling and grammar is incorrect.
I have seen people called cunts and all sorts - there was even an entire thread on just how despicable it is of anyone to point out any aspect of SPaG in anyone else's posting, ever, with a massive pile-on of people queuing up to say just how shit anyone who did this is.

HeArInGhandsgirl11 · 06/04/2022 15:18

@mydogisthebest

A good few years ago a friend's son wrote in his English essay "he walked past the church". The teacher crossed out "past" and wrote "passed"!

My friend spoke to the teacher but the teacher insisted she was right

Confused
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 06/04/2022 15:16

[quote Musmerian]@sweepeep - A level English has bugger all to do with spelling![/quote]
It surely has a lot to do with well written, cogently argued essays in correct English, though - or do they belong in the past, and it’s all multiple choice questions now?

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 06/04/2022 15:14

I once picked up a local university’s leaflet advertising its taught MA in English.
There were two basic mistakes in the short blurb!

Unsurprisingly the university comes fairly low in the rankings.

Musmerian · 06/04/2022 15:13

@sweepeep - A level English has bugger all to do with spelling!

Musmerian · 06/04/2022 15:09

@Nicholethejewellery - pupils are not customers and that kind of transactional language is not helpful. Primary teaching is a vital and hugely skilled job but unfortunately the educational standard of many entrants is not great .

ldontWanna · 06/04/2022 15:07

@Foxyloxy1plus1

There’s something of a double standard going on here. MN gets very sniffy about SPaG and tells those who question to go over to Pedants Corner. The inference is, that if what a poster is writing is understandable, it doesn’t matter if their spelling and grammar is incorrect.

I know that it is a very different thing when it’s about teaching. Of course it should be accurate, but I think plenty of posters have explained that there are times when it isn’t straightforward.

What concerns me greatly, is the notion that people with very basic skills are now being accepted on to training courses. That certainly isn’t going to improve SPaG. We’re getting to the stage where it won’t matter at all, because what will matter is having someone to stand in front of a class of children.

What is preferable? As far as I’m concerned, a high quality, well educated teaching workforce is vital. That’s not the way things are going though.

That workforce doesn't exist though. There aren't enough teachers,regardless of their skills, so plenty of schools go even "lower" hiring unqualified teachers or using TA's to plug the gap.

You can't demand excellence, but then not reward it appropriately or offer any benefits/incentives.

In my area all Schools Direct funding has stopped, so a lot of the people that would've gone into teaching won't anymore, or they're going someplace else to be unqualified teachers or get some kind of pay while they're finishing their course instead of staying in the area /at the schools they started as a TA (for example) in. They might come back eventually after they qualify, but very often that's not the case.

maddy68 · 06/04/2022 15:07

The best teacher I had in my school was severely dyslexic. Got the best results consistently throughout the country

Foxyloxy1plus1 · 06/04/2022 14:51

There’s something of a double standard going on here. MN gets very sniffy about SPaG and tells those who question to go over to Pedants Corner. The inference is, that if what a poster is writing is understandable, it doesn’t matter if their spelling and grammar is incorrect.

I know that it is a very different thing when it’s about teaching. Of course it should be accurate, but I think plenty of posters have explained that there are times when it isn’t straightforward.

What concerns me greatly, is the notion that people with very basic skills are now being accepted on to training courses. That certainly isn’t going to improve SPaG. We’re getting to the stage where it won’t matter at all, because what will matter is having someone to stand in front of a class of children.

What is preferable? As far as I’m concerned, a high quality, well educated teaching workforce is vital. That’s not the way things are going though.