Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think teachers should be able to spell

367 replies

Brieandcamembert · 06/04/2022 09:20

I have increasingly noticed recently teachers (often of primary age) who make very basic spelling and grammar errors. Surely having excellent basic skills in this area is an essential criteria for teaching it?

I'm really concerned that we are raising a generation who will have appalling literacy skills.

I have seen the classic "of / have" confusion
I have seen "been" used instead of "being"
I have also seen phonetically similar words interchanged with one another.

OP posts:
Stellamar · 07/04/2022 13:49

@Brieandcamembert

I'm not sure I agree with the notion of not having enough teachers, so the standards have to drop. I do hope no one ever takes up that idea with surgeons.
I don't think anyone thinks this is a good answer to the problem. A better idea would be to address workload, behaviour and conditions in order to attract better candidates and retain good teachers. However, that hasn't happened and this is the result.
Carpedimum · 07/04/2022 13:37

I’ve got a few family members who are teachers. One is, frankly, thick as two short planks & teaches A levels. They scraped through all their own exams, including 2 degrees with help from others, but just keep ploughing on through education higher & higher & will no doubt be lecturing at a university in the future! To be fair, they are adept with handling teenagers, and also good at absorbing information and regurgitation, but original thought is absent. Their IQ score was below 100. Forget any spelling or grammar, they don’t read unless it is to cut & paste from.

Stellamar · 07/04/2022 13:32

[quote Villagewaspbyke]@WhenSheWasBad - that’s actually higher than most “degree educated professionals”. Perhaps even all (excluding city lawyers and bankers in London- but then starting salaries for newly graduated lawyers and accountants outside London are lower than teachers). As I said when you take into account the huge pension, it’s better paid than most graduate jobs.

Hours are much shorter than many other professions and holidays are better than most if not all. It’s not for everyone but it’s not a bad deal. My ex was a teacher and his job was a lot shorter hours and less stressful than mine.[/quote]
Excellent, so I guess you'll be retraining as a teacher then? Schools are desperate for staff!

Mreggsworth · 07/04/2022 13:19

I would think most know 'how' to spell, but when rushed or writing a lot make mistakes.

I'm not a teacher but have to do a lot of writing in my job, if it's end of the day and I'm flagging a bit I make some silly spelling errors

ldontWanna · 07/04/2022 13:14

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

First of all, SPAG wasn't taught for many many years in school. So you will have teachers that never learned it, or were taught when it was in it's infancy by people that never had to do it before. They went to school,they got good grades ,they went to uni successfully etc. and they were good enough. Even if that was 20 years ago, the ripple effect continued for a lot longer.

Appropriately remunerated wages means a larger number of applicants. Don't forget teachers didn't lower standards the government did. Just like they allow academies to hire unqualified teachers or let TA's teach. That was in response to the teacher recruitment crisis. They took the easy way out. Instead of making the job more attractive, they lowered the standards. If teaching becomes more attractive as a job, the number and quality of applicants will automatically increase. This also means that standards can rise again and unis can be a lot pickier over who enrols on their courses. While that wouldn't solve the issue with teachers today, we need to talk long term here. The aim has been quantity not quality for a while. They're just lucky that a lot of applicants actually are good,dedicated teachers even if sometimes they fall short of the MN standard.

It's easy to spot the problem, it's also easy to put a plaster over it (or pretend it's not happening like the government did in the early 2000s). It's a lot harder to come up with a viable, working, long term solution.

RamsayBoltonsConscience · 07/04/2022 13:09

I agree and, as a deputy head, the teachers know that if I see or hear something that is incorrect they will be alerted to it. I see it as everyone's responsibility to identity and correct errors. We all make mistakes and it's important for the children to see that but we also need to correct our errors where we can. I am happy for people to correct me too. Where I teach there are fundamental grammar errors as part of everyday speech (estuary area) often until it's pointed out, people aren't even aware it's incorrect. Teacher training doesn't pick this up unless the tutor is from outside the area!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 07/04/2022 12:42

@worriedatthistime

In the scheme of things, I wouldn't say that my own job is particularly 'important' when compared to many others, but it does involve written communication, for which basic language skills are required.

As I said earlier on in this thread, I never think badly of a plumber, cleaner, shop assistant, taxi driver etc. if they don't have good written language skills, as that isn't their main job. You are right that it isn't especially a big deal in many jobs, but in many other jobs, it is. How can teachers know what jobs their children will want to do when they grow up? Why would you want to limit what they learn to deliberately close off a large field of opportunities to them?

I know teachers have a lot of pressures on their time - as with many other professions - but why does it always come down to paying more taxes in order for them to achieve some of the foundational standards?

I would certainly be in favour of government-funded on-the-job training (maybe even evening, weekend or non-term-time classes, if there was a desire for it) to redress these weaknesses for those teachers who need it, but I don't see how just increasing the salary of a teacher with very poor SPaG will suddenly make them excellent at it.

dyslexia is not comparable to a blind electrician , my own ds cannot be an electrician due to colour blindness
Dyslexia does not stop a teacher being a good teacher and I think it is wrong for you to say that and you are comparing apple and pears

I asked a genuine question earlier on and stated clearly that help, allowances and adaptations should be made wherever feasible, to enable somebody to do a job; but sometimes, there will be people and jobs that are probably not compatible, such as with your DS.

I did not say that somebody with dyslexia cannot be a teacher, but I would expect this issue to be understood and addressed, so as to counteract the difficulties where possible.

There are so many software programs nowadays that can help greatly, by underlining and querying potential errors or typos. If you know that you struggle in this area, I would expect you to take particular notice of these helping mechanisms and not just ignore them, as many presumably must do. If spelling is a challenge for you, keep a dictionary to hand and remember to consult it whenever necessary.

I would say the same for any job. Supposing you're very short, but want to be a painter specialising in ceilings - nobody is stopping you, but you would need to make sure that you have a long ladder or extending pole with you at all times at work. You wouldn't just hold a paintbrush above your head, keep leaping up into the air and expect to end up with an acceptable result - then get frustrated when people criticise your work and angrily retort that "Short people can be perfectly good painters, you know" - which is indeed true.

Patchbatch · 07/04/2022 12:35

@annabell22

Some teachers have dyslexia- it doesn't mean that they shouldn't become a teacher.
I do agree but at the same time there should be someone checking in that case, teaching children incorrect grammar and spelling is a problem.
PurpleFlower1983 · 07/04/2022 12:32

The standards for teacher training have dropped loads in the last few years. So sad but true. We have had loads of students with poor literacy/numeracy skills recently. It’s very hard to recruit good candidates now.

CustardySergeant · 07/04/2022 12:30

I've never forgotten going into my daughter's primary school on a parent's day and seeing in one of her books that her teacher had crossed out her correctly spelled word "scary" and written in red "scarey"! I was not amused.

ClaudiusTheGod · 07/04/2022 12:25

@JudgeJ You mean ‘quandary’ not ‘quandry’.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 07/04/2022 12:19

I think it's very dismissive to state that an electrician "only has one job", when there is a great deal that s/he will need to know in order to do the job - a large knowledge base, experience and practice, training, troubleshooting, keeping up with all of the latest regulations and changes in standards/types of materials and tools.

You might as well say that teachers "only have one job" - to help kids learn basic knowledge - which is also a grossly inaccurate oversimplification of what teachers do.

worriedatthistime · 07/04/2022 12:15

@saraclara but its not all of us experiences and some are citing grammar errors that won't be picked up until much later
Are you saying you have never made a spelling mistake
If someone has that much of an issue surely you bring it up with headteacher
I have seen odd spelling mistake in my kids end of year reports , i accept it as a mistake
If my child had a word corrected wrongly I would speak to the teacher

alfiegirl61 · 07/04/2022 12:13

I used to receive various school forms sent home in my DD's schoolbag. If there was a mistake made with the wording or spelling, I always corrected it before completing and returning the form. I don't suppose it made any difference, apart from annoying my DD, but it's a matter of principle with me...

worriedatthistime · 07/04/2022 12:12

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll dyslexia is not comparable to a blind electrician , my own ds cannot be an electrician due to colour blindness
Dyslexia does not stop a teacher being a good teacher and I think it is wrong for you to say that and you are comparing apple and pears

worriedatthistime · 07/04/2022 12:10

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll probably not as important as your job
But i know lots of jobs where it really isn't a big deal other than basic
Even your posts will have some errors in if you follow all grammar rules
Yes it is but are you happy to pay teachers a lot more and more taxes as the pay is pretty shit nowadays for what teachers do, they have to do so much more than teach

ldontWanna · 07/04/2022 11:54

@saraclara

I'm really embarrassed seeing so many fellow teachers on this thread defend regular poor spelling and punctuation. If primary education is as important as we all claim it to be, then children should not be exposed to incorrect spelling, and especially not to their own correct spelling being marked as incorrect. There simply is no excuse for that.

There should be a straightforward way for SMTs to pick up on any staff weakness in that area, and for there to be further training for that member of staff. It shouldn't be brushed under the carpet with the excuse of "well teaching is a hard job so you can't expect perfection".
There are some things that can slide in a primary school, but spelling, punctuation and basic grammar ('could of' is simply inexcusable) are too important for that.

Some of the alien words provided by the DFE for y1 to practice contained real words(not necessarily used in common vocabulary,but real words nonetheless). That wouldn't be too bad because the aim is reading , but children were asked to sort them into real and alien words.
ldontWanna · 07/04/2022 11:49

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

Yes it’s so widespread! I’ve had my year 1 daughter’s written work ‘corrected’ to cross out the correct spelling and instead write the wrong spelling.

This is it, really, I think. Your daughter’s teacher clearly sees it as their job to ‘correct errors’ – hence their trying to do it to your daughter’s work.

Either we see SPaG as unimportant, in which case nobody cares, mentions, teaches or corrects; or we do value it and seek to maintain standards, especially amongst those charged with teaching it. We cannot have both.

@worriedatthistime

I’m somewhat confused as that doesn’t appear to answer my question at all, following your earlier assertion that I don’t know the definition of ‘discrimination’.

Does that apply in everything? If you employed an electrician who left exposed live wires and short-circuited your home, would he be justified in retorting that you should just rewire your house yourself, then – rather than that he learn to do his job properly or that a competent electrician (as he falsely claimed to be) should do it instead?

This is not a teacher-bashing thread at all. To suggest that just reminds me of when you tell teenagers not to dump their clothes on the floor or leave cereal bowls everywhere and their instant reply is “You hate me!!”

Most teachers do an amazing job, and it is indeed a very challenging career that requires skill and dedication; but this is one particular area that seems to be universally weak across the board. Should we strive and desire for teachers in general (in fact, people in any career or experts in any area of life) to be better at what they do, when there are clear weak spots, or otherwise should we just accept that mediocrity is the highest that we want to aim for in certain key areas?

I don’t know what your job is or in which circles you move, but grammar is very important in my day to day life and in the world that I recognise. It’s clearly not a skill that everybody has, but it is no excuse to claim that, if you struggle with a particular basic skill – a building block of normal communication - then it’s categorically not important to anybody. It’s a good thing that web developers don’t feel the same way, when it comes to the unexciting but vital coding that makes computers ‘talk’ to and ‘understand’ each other.

I have mentioned things to staff before, when I’ve seen significant SPaG errors – especially in displays – and in a kind, friendly, non-patronising way. To be honest, the responses usually suggest a lack of interest, a belief that it’s petty and unimportant (as we have seen on this thread) or a general air of assumption that they must be right as they are a teacher and I am not. It’s a self-fulfilling belief, really – that those who regularly do something must be the best at doing it at all times and should never be questioned - even on occasions when they are very clearly doing it wrongly.

  1. Proper grammar wasn't taught properly for years as late as the early 2000s. The change wasn't immediate either , and the government glossed over that particular lack of skill.

2.The main difference in my eyes is that a good teacher will know,accept and admit their own limitations and failings and are happy to be corrected and keep trying to improve or ask for help .

  1. Just like the surgeon example,an electrician has one "job". A teacher doesn't just spell. I know brilliant teachers that are a bit crappy at spelling so they use spell check, try to prepare modelled writing in advance ,use dictionaries or other adults in the classroom for support/to check when they're not sure. Mistakes still sneak in sometimes.
  1. What should happen now to solve this? Fire all the teachers that are "sub par " ? We don't have enough as there is. Rise the standards for people applying for teacher training from now on?Sure, but then you also have to support them appropriately, including financially, and pay them accordingly after qualifying at the very least. Demanding excellence is pointless when you don't reward it properly.
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 07/04/2022 11:44

Moreover, I realise that it's a glorified gameshow, but if anybody saw the recent series of The Apprentice, there was a point where not one person in one of the teams knew the correct spelling of the word 'Arctic'. All of these people will have gone to school and completed a standard education.

Not only were they confident that they supposedly knew the correct spelling, when they clearly didn't, but they didn't even doubt themselves to the extent that anybody suggested spending a few moments in checking it.

If you saw the response of the industry representatives to this, you would realise that correctness in basic language skills IS important - and the inability to either know or care to use simple at-hand tools to check it will bring ridicule and rejection in the real world, where a certain simple standard is required.

Even more concerning, none of the 'boys'' team seemed to know that the word 'whiffy' universally means bad-smelling and quite happily gave it as a name to their character who was supposed to encourage children in good, clean hygiene habits using a toothbrush unwittingly designed to look like a turd.

saraclara · 07/04/2022 11:42

I'm really embarrassed seeing so many fellow teachers on this thread defend regular poor spelling and punctuation. If primary education is as important as we all claim it to be, then children should not be exposed to incorrect spelling, and especially not to their own correct spelling being marked as incorrect. There simply is no excuse for that.

There should be a straightforward way for SMTs to pick up on any staff weakness in that area, and for there to be further training for that member of staff. It shouldn't be brushed under the carpet with the excuse of "well teaching is a hard job so you can't expect perfection".
There are some things that can slide in a primary school, but spelling, punctuation and basic grammar ('could of' is simply inexcusable) are too important for that.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 07/04/2022 11:29

Yes it’s so widespread! I’ve had my year 1 daughter’s written work ‘corrected’ to cross out the correct spelling and instead write the wrong spelling.

This is it, really, I think. Your daughter’s teacher clearly sees it as their job to ‘correct errors’ – hence their trying to do it to your daughter’s work.

Either we see SPaG as unimportant, in which case nobody cares, mentions, teaches or corrects; or we do value it and seek to maintain standards, especially amongst those charged with teaching it. We cannot have both.

@worriedatthistime

I’m somewhat confused as that doesn’t appear to answer my question at all, following your earlier assertion that I don’t know the definition of ‘discrimination’.

Does that apply in everything? If you employed an electrician who left exposed live wires and short-circuited your home, would he be justified in retorting that you should just rewire your house yourself, then – rather than that he learn to do his job properly or that a competent electrician (as he falsely claimed to be) should do it instead?

This is not a teacher-bashing thread at all. To suggest that just reminds me of when you tell teenagers not to dump their clothes on the floor or leave cereal bowls everywhere and their instant reply is “You hate me!!”

Most teachers do an amazing job, and it is indeed a very challenging career that requires skill and dedication; but this is one particular area that seems to be universally weak across the board. Should we strive and desire for teachers in general (in fact, people in any career or experts in any area of life) to be better at what they do, when there are clear weak spots, or otherwise should we just accept that mediocrity is the highest that we want to aim for in certain key areas?

I don’t know what your job is or in which circles you move, but grammar is very important in my day to day life and in the world that I recognise. It’s clearly not a skill that everybody has, but it is no excuse to claim that, if you struggle with a particular basic skill – a building block of normal communication - then it’s categorically not important to anybody. It’s a good thing that web developers don’t feel the same way, when it comes to the unexciting but vital coding that makes computers ‘talk’ to and ‘understand’ each other.

I have mentioned things to staff before, when I’ve seen significant SPaG errors – especially in displays – and in a kind, friendly, non-patronising way. To be honest, the responses usually suggest a lack of interest, a belief that it’s petty and unimportant (as we have seen on this thread) or a general air of assumption that they must be right as they are a teacher and I am not. It’s a self-fulfilling belief, really – that those who regularly do something must be the best at doing it at all times and should never be questioned - even on occasions when they are very clearly doing it wrongly.

JudgeJ · 07/04/2022 11:12

@Debroglie

Teachers are massively overworked and make mistakes. I teach physics. I’m pretty academic and have a phd. I wrote on the board last week 2 x 3 = 5 My year 12s reacted with amusement and disgust in equal measure. (I do know that 2x3=/=5) I also spelt a word wrong in another lesson (forgotten what the word was now but the TA corrected me.) We’re not robots. We’re human. We’re tired. We can’t be perfect.
'Congratulations for spotting today's deliberate mistake!' used to be my response to my errors like this. I always warned my exam classes that the mistakes they make will be 1 x 1 = 2 as often as the bigger mistakes. Recently I was running through some Higher papers to help my grandaughter and I misread a couple of questions, another common, human error. 'When all else fails, read the b*** question' , something else I told my classes. As this poster says, we're all human.
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 07/04/2022 11:10

@JudgeJ, I once did it on a printed annual appraisal form (for me) at work - a very basic mistake, though I forget which.
There was never any comment but I did enjoy wielding the red pen!

Funniest teacher error I ever saw was ages ago, when a dd at 11 or so had to make the dreaded cookery apron at school. She loathed needlework, so I need up doing most of it, and though I say it myself, I’m reasonably competent at sewing.

It came back with, ‘C+. Neatness and accuracy are 2 skills which you must practice.’

I still think it was very noble of me not to point out her clanger of a mistake!

bumsnett · 07/04/2022 11:04

@annabell22

Some teachers have dyslexia- it doesn't mean that they shouldn't become a teacher.
No, but if they are teaching reading, they need to work on this and let children know that sometimes these words can get confused.
JudgeJ · 07/04/2022 10:59

grammar was a dirty word when I was teaching EFL abroad in the 80s

A similar thing occurred with teaching Maths in the 70s, 80s and 90s, any form of rote learning, eg times tables, was banned, I once heard a Head berating his wife who was doing supply because she was teaching tables.