Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think teachers should be able to spell

367 replies

Brieandcamembert · 06/04/2022 09:20

I have increasingly noticed recently teachers (often of primary age) who make very basic spelling and grammar errors. Surely having excellent basic skills in this area is an essential criteria for teaching it?

I'm really concerned that we are raising a generation who will have appalling literacy skills.

I have seen the classic "of / have" confusion
I have seen "been" used instead of "being"
I have also seen phonetically similar words interchanged with one another.

OP posts:
Abitofalark · 08/04/2022 16:49

@SpringIntoChaos

I am a teacher...primary...and I have to agree with you OP 🤦‍♀️ I am also old (will soon be retiring thank goodness 😅)

As an oldie, one of my (many!) hats is to mentor new teachers, which requires lesson observations and 'book looks'. Only last week, I had to have a 'quiet word' with one young teacher, to ask her to correct her spelling on the actual Learning Intention (LI) that she'd written on the board for her Year 4 class to copy. She had written:

LI: To use apostrophes for singular and plural posession

Granted, possession is a tricky word, but if you're a) being observed, and b) writing it for 30 young people to copy, you make absolutely sure that you nail any 'tricky bits' before you start!

(And don't get me started on 'of' instead of 'have' 😨)

What's a Learning Intention? We didn't have those in my day. We did learn grammar and spelling.
ChocolateCakeYum · 08/04/2022 13:58

I remember going to my nieces parents evening and having a very long conversation about spelling and grammar with the teacher and how everything she was teaching was incorrect. Her worst error was teaching the children the word “don’t” as “do’nt”.

Still gives me the rage after 20 years!

JudgeJ · 08/04/2022 13:04

[quote ClaudiusTheGod]@JudgeJ You mean ‘quandary’ not ‘quandry’.[/quote]
Yes, probably!

saraclara · 08/04/2022 12:35

Of course it's a rare person who has flawless English, and I'm certainly not one of them. But there's a huge difference between a teacher making the odd typo or mistake, and one who consistently mis-spells or mis-punctuates the same simple words, or who 'corrects' a word with her own incorrect spelling.

Anything that I sent out to parents was very very carefully checked by me before it went. So if class newsletters or webpages are consistently full of errors (not just a single typo) it's pretty clear that the teacher isn't just having a distracted moment.

ReadtheReviews · 08/04/2022 12:21

They absolutely should be able to. I have a primary teacher friend who can't, neither does she know the difference between sat and sitting. In the school where my mum works, the number of spelling errors on the staff noticeboard is hilarious; it's a fairly expensive private school.
Just have to rely on parents having a bit of input and correcting their children I suppose.

Fairislefandango · 08/04/2022 12:05

Nobody has flawless written English.

A lot of people would have practically flawless written English in the context of a primary school classroom environment. I don't make spelling mistakes. I just don't. Are there really obscure words I might have trouble with, such as technical vocab I hadn't met before? Sure. Do I make typos? Definitely! Do I make spelling mistakes when writing on the board or correcting a child's work? No.

But lots of teachers (including primary) have fairly poor spelling of quite basic words. They commonly make mistakes with the exact spellings, grammar and punctuation that they are trying to instill in their pupils.

I was teaching Spanish a couple of weeks ago to a primary class while their class teacher was putting up a beautiful display on the wall in the classroom. It took her ages. She wrote out a lovely, inspiring poem in big letters in the middle. It contained two incorrect apostrophes (including 'it's' instead of 'its'). She's a lovely, lovely woman and I couldn't bring myself to say anything!

SiobhanSharpe · 08/04/2022 11:32

There's a difference in misspelling the word 'mummy' and the word 'possession' -- one is clearly a one-off slip between the mind and the hand due to distraction, as the PP illustrated, the other looks more like ignorance and is likely to be repeated.
For complete disclosure. I'm a good speller but a really crap typist.

LeastofLeicester · 08/04/2022 10:59

It's always the simple words you make mistakes with isn't it, which kind of proves its not due to lack of spelling ability, but because of tiredness/distraction.

ldontWanna · 08/04/2022 10:55

@LeastofLeicester weirdly enough I also had a total brain freeze with mummy. I was making notes on the board, started writing and then totally forgot if it's one m or two. The more I thought about it,the more flustered and confused I became ,arguing the right way in my head until I gave up and asked.Grin

LeastofLeicester · 08/04/2022 10:36

@Lazzaroni

IdontWanna

That is simply not true. People can easily make typos if they're working on the computer. However, nobody who can spell and punctuate and who has a proper grasp of grammar and syntax makes mistakes if they are writing by hand. Your hand just won't allow you to do it. You might just as well ask that same person to hold their breath for ten minutes. It would be equally impossible for them.

Bollocks.

I wrote mumy the other day instead of mummy. Not because I don't know how to spell, just because while modelling writing on the flip chart I'm simultaneously watching individuals to check they're focused, managing behaviour, keeping an eye on the clock to make sure my lesson is fast paced enough, distracted by the TA trying to stop 1 child absconding, trying to take ideas for writing from the class to include them but also ensure the ideas I take include the grammar and content needed for the learning that lesson.

I know how to spell mummy ffs. Still made a mistake.

SpringIntoChaos · 07/04/2022 22:15

I am a teacher...primary...and I have to agree with you OP 🤦‍♀️ I am also old (will soon be retiring thank goodness 😅)

As an oldie, one of my (many!) hats is to mentor new teachers, which requires lesson observations and 'book looks'. Only last week, I had to have a 'quiet word' with one young teacher, to ask her to correct her spelling on the actual Learning Intention (LI) that she'd written on the board for her Year 4 class to copy. She had written:

LI: To use apostrophes for singular and plural posession

Granted, possession is a tricky word, but if you're a) being observed, and b) writing it for 30 young people to copy, you make absolutely sure that you nail any 'tricky bits' before you start!

(And don't get me started on 'of' instead of 'have' 😨)

Oneeata · 07/04/2022 21:54

I'll never forget my English teachers comment in my end of year report "Oneeata should remember to always refer to her dictinery" I kid you not.

PAFMO · 07/04/2022 21:33

Not even David Crystal would claim to have flawless English.

ldontWanna · 07/04/2022 21:03

@Lazzaroni

IdontWanna

That is simply not true. People can easily make typos if they're working on the computer. However, nobody who can spell and punctuate and who has a proper grasp of grammar and syntax makes mistakes if they are writing by hand. Your hand just won't allow you to do it. You might just as well ask that same person to hold their breath for ten minutes. It would be equally impossible for them.

Once again , no one has flawless English. That would require for someone not only knowing every single grammar and punctuation rule,but also every single English word.

What you are talking about is muscle memory. Knowing something is not enough for muscle memory to kick in. It also needs to be used consistently and regularly in order for that memory to form. For example I know how to spell onomatopoeia (be that in writing or typing) but it's not automatic. I have to think about it for a split second. My hand is more than happy to spell it 3 or 4 different ways , unless I engage my brain. That's because despite using it every single year, it only comes up once a year for a week or two in a regular way.

You are also skimming over the fact that SPAG wasn't taught or considered necessary for decades, so many people/teachers don't have that muscle memory to fall back on, despite going to school,and uni and having what was considered at the time a good enough, maybe even extensive knowledge.

So once again, no one has flawless English and while (correctly formed)muscle memory might help , it's not infallible either.

ComeSailAway · 07/04/2022 20:29

Inexcusable in my opinion. "In my day…" etc etc.

Lazzaroni · 07/04/2022 20:27

IdontWanna

That is simply not true. People can easily make typos if they're working on the computer. However, nobody who can spell and punctuate and who has a proper grasp of grammar and syntax makes mistakes if they are writing by hand. Your hand just won't allow you to do it. You might just as well ask that same person to hold their breath for ten minutes. It would be equally impossible for them.

ldontWanna · 07/04/2022 20:06

@Lazzaroni

There is no excuse whatsoever for a teacher to make mistakes with spelling, grammar or punctuation. Being tired and so on are not excuses. Either they can spell and punctuate, or they can't. If they can't, they ought not to be teaching. I would have been very fed up if any of my DC's teachers had not had flawless written English.
Nobody has flawless written English.
Lazzaroni · 07/04/2022 19:35

There is no excuse whatsoever for a teacher to make mistakes with spelling, grammar or punctuation. Being tired and so on are not excuses. Either they can spell and punctuate, or they can't. If they can't, they ought not to be teaching. I would have been very fed up if any of my DC's teachers had not had flawless written English.

DdraigGoch · 07/04/2022 19:26

@WalltoWallBtards

Everyone makes mistakes sometimes. As long as they don’t make them while actually teaching SPaG rules - which they won’t as they’ll be working from a lesson plan- I wouldn’t sweat it. I’ve been a copy editor and the most educated people making little mistakes all the time.
Didn't you read the posts further up the thread where teachers/TAs were crossing out correct answers and ticking the wrong ones? So "that won't happen" doesn't fly.
Covidwoes · 07/04/2022 19:20

I'm a primary teacher and I think poor spelling and grammar from primary teachers isn't acceptable really. If you're a primary teacher and struggle with spelling, for example, you should really use a dictionary or spellcheck! Rogue apostrophes drive me mad too.

PAFMO · 07/04/2022 19:09

[quote worriedatthistime]@PAFMO because it really doesn't matter does it
You knew what she meant perfectly well so why jump on it
These posts are generally just full of judgement and pretentious people
Most people give zero fucks for the odd mistake
And don't pull me up on any grammar or spelling as I don't care , just continue being judging others and putting them down if that makes you feel better [/quote]
You miss my point rather spectacularly. I jumped on HER post precisely because SHE is being an arse about other people's poor English.

Search my user name. I post on many of these threads telling the people slagging off and correcting other people's SpaG to fucking give over. Mumsnet is a mummy forum not a university dissertation platform.

It is, however, well-known that you absolutely do have to jump in and correct the twats who think they have some kind of superior knowledge about English yet make mistakes themselves (generally pretty basic ones- like that poster did in the middle of her smugness about how wonderful her own SpaG was) and they always, always do.

So yes, you'll see me pulling people up on their SpaG. But only vicious twats who've belittled others first.

That OK with you?

Fairislefandango · 07/04/2022 18:24

Oh btw I'm 50 and went to a good grammar school. Spelling always came easily to me, but I don't remember really being taught English grammar at school. I learned everything I knew about grammar by doing French, German and Latin.

Fairislefandango · 07/04/2022 18:21

When are we talking of? I'm in my mid 40s and I learned it. To be fair, if you're a confident reader - which I would expect most teachers in academic subjects to be - you're exposed to it from books, whether it's explicitly taught to you or not.

Until the introduction of major grammar into the SATs a few years back, it hadn't really been taught for several generations. I've taught foreign languages in secondary schools for over 25 years and also teach adults (mostly retired ones). They tended to know what a noun was, and maybe a verb if you were lucky, but that's about it.

Expecting everybody to be able to just rely on picking up good spelling and an understanding of grammar is unrealistic and smacks of middle class privilege.

Primary school teachers aren't always very academic, and they are being expected to teach grammar they were never taught themselves.

ldontWanna · 07/04/2022 18:18

@WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

  • For several decades up to about 2000, most state schools in England taught little or no grammar, and it is still normal for school leavers to know virtually nothing about grammar; for example, in 1998 it was found that “younger teachers had generally not been taught grammar explicitly as part of their own education” (Anon 1998b:26).

Most younger teachers know very little grammar and are suspicious of explicit grammar teaching. Not surprisingly, therefore, new recruits entering teacher-training courses typically either know very little grammar (Williamson and Hardman 1995) or have no confidence in their knowledge, presumably because they have picked it up in an unsystematic way (Cajkler and Hislam 2002).

Some older teachers were taught some grammar under the old system, but this knowledge is a mixed blessing as a preparation for teaching the new syllabus (“Older teachers did not see their school experience of traditional formal grammar as relevant to the present” Anon 1998b:26)*

You might say, well that was 22 years ago, but the effects probably lasted for several more cohorts or children/teachers.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 07/04/2022 17:35

First of all, SPAG wasn't taught for many many years in school. So you will have teachers that never learned it, or were taught when it was in it's infancy by people that never had to do it before.

When are we talking of? I'm in my mid 40s and I learned it. To be fair, if you're a confident reader - which I would expect most teachers in academic subjects to be - you're exposed to it from books, whether it's explicitly taught to you or not.

It's not like the English language itself was in its infancy a few decades ago, so the knowledge must have been there all along and understood/taught by enough people to keep it going.

I do agree that successive governments are to blame for not making it a top priority for so many years. If they had done, we wouldn't have the issue of people who are intelligent and academically-minded enough to become teachers but still completely bereft of what should be very basic skills.

I remember when they brought in focused 'literacy' and concentrated the curriculum on it; I was astonished that this was seen as a new innovation and ever abandoned in the first place. It must have been like teaching basic car maintenance classes for decades, but never thinking it necessary to mention oil.