Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think teachers should be able to spell

367 replies

Brieandcamembert · 06/04/2022 09:20

I have increasingly noticed recently teachers (often of primary age) who make very basic spelling and grammar errors. Surely having excellent basic skills in this area is an essential criteria for teaching it?

I'm really concerned that we are raising a generation who will have appalling literacy skills.

I have seen the classic "of / have" confusion
I have seen "been" used instead of "being"
I have also seen phonetically similar words interchanged with one another.

OP posts:
MrsHamlet · 06/04/2022 10:56

Split infinitives are perfectly acceptable in English. The idea that they shouldn't be was introduced by a clergyman called Robert Lowth in the eighteenth century, because he thought English would be more elegant if it had some of the rules of Latin.
This is the point exactly. Lots of the "rules" come from grammarians who wanted to create rules, or lexicographers who decided that one variant was "better" than another.

FangsForTheMemory · 06/04/2022 10:55

@CallmeHendricks

Your OP might have carried more weight with me had you not split an infinitive in the first sentence.
Split infinitives are perfectly acceptable in English. The idea that they shouldn't be was introduced by a clergyman called Robert Lowth in the eighteenth century, because he thought English would be more elegant if it had some of the rules of Latin. Latin does not split infinitives because Latin infinitives are single words.

Read more here: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Lowth

MrsHamlet · 06/04/2022 10:54

@twominutesmore

I had a trainee with me last year. She was terrible. Honestly terrible in every way. We couldn't have supported her more but it was clear she was going to fail the placement. She went off with anxiety. I am not doubting this at all, and was pleased she sought help and was diagnosed. The university told me she would have to repeat the year as she hadn't met the standards or completed her training. The trainee contacted me weeks later to say that she had passed the year due to allowances made for extenuating circumstances. It is unbelievable to me that she is now teaching, and failing horribly. Not fair on anyone.
It's totally believable. You pay your £9k; you get a qualification. Ofsted grade, in part, on successful completion.
ASaucerfulOfSecrets · 06/04/2022 10:53

I worked with a TA in a primary once who labelled everything to assist children with their reading.
We had draws, knifes and cuboards.

The signs had been there for a while and the class teacher either hadn’t noticed or was far too nice to mention it. I quietly changed them once lunch time whilst everyone was out.

twominutesmore · 06/04/2022 10:51

I had a trainee with me last year. She was terrible. Honestly terrible in every way. We couldn't have supported her more but it was clear she was going to fail the placement. She went off with anxiety. I am not doubting this at all, and was pleased she sought help and was diagnosed. The university told me she would have to repeat the year as she hadn't met the standards or completed her training. The trainee contacted me weeks later to say that she had passed the year due to allowances made for extenuating circumstances. It is unbelievable to me that she is now teaching, and failing horribly. Not fair on anyone.

MrsMoastyToasty · 06/04/2022 10:49

During the first lockdown my DS was doing GCSE history and were studying American history. As my child has SEN issues I spent this and every lesson with him.
The teacher was giving a livestreamed lesson and every time she referred to the Sioux Indians she said it as "Sue Ix" rather than "Soo".

Lesperance · 06/04/2022 10:49

@annabell22

Some teachers have dyslexia- it doesn't mean that they shouldn't become a teacher.
I disagree. It CAN mean that they shouldn't be a teacher if they cannot use computers or whatever to make sure that what they show to the class is perfect in terms of spelling.
MolkosTeenageAngst · 06/04/2022 10:49

I think it depends where you’re seeing those errors and how frequently. Everybody makes mistakes sometimes and I think they’re more common now most writing is typed rather than hand-written, autocorrect and spellcheck can sometimes make it worse and mistakes will get missed.

I’m a teacher with good SPAG but like everybody I will make careless errors from time to time. As an example I wrote a report recently and accidentally used there instead of their. I only noticed because I needed to go back and add something to that paragraph so I caught it before it went out but I could have easily missed it. It’s a mistake I would never normally make and would definitely notice if I was reading someone else’s words but I guess I just had a lapse of concentration. I find that when I am typing I am definitely more prone to making mistakes I wouldn’t have made if writing by hand as I type quickly, I try and remember to proof read to catch my mistakes but things can still get missed. I had similar with have and of recently, I was messaging a friend and said ‘should of’ even though it is one of my pet peeves, I didn’t even notice I had written it until she pointed it out and I was really annoyed at myself as I am well aware it’s incorrect. I do aim to proof-read anything formal that is going out to parents but I will sometimes send out emails quickly on my lunch break or at the end of the day between meetings etc and don’t always have time to re-read and in those cases it’s possible I could make a SPAG error and miss it but I would hope not to be judged too harshly by parents if I did. Everybody makes mistakes sometimes and sometimes they can be missed even if you’ve proof-read so as long as a teachers not making constant errors in all writing I wouldn’t judge based on the odd mistake.

LittleMG · 06/04/2022 10:48

@ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave

I agree, but nobody can afford to be picky about who's accepted onto teaching courses right now. There's a massive recruitment crisis.
Was just going to say this. Welcome to Tory Britain.
Lesperance · 06/04/2022 10:46

I could not agree more. And I don't agree it's not the be all and end all. It's an absolute basic. If teachers can't spell, they shouldn't be in the job. They need to have other skills, but this is one of the essentials ones, somewhere after liking kids, for sure, but essential nevertheless.

MrsHamlet · 06/04/2022 10:46

@WhenSheWasBad

To those saying that teachers need to pass Literacy and Numeracy tests before starting their teaching course, this is no longer the case. Apparently it was too big a barrier to recruitment of new teachers

I wasn’t aware of this. So the plan to recruit more teachers is to drop standards? Heaven forbid we actually improve the working conditions to recruit and retain teachers.

No requirement to have classroom experience any more either. I'm seeing more and more trainees without a degree in the subject they're training for. SPAG should be the least of people's worries, frankly.
hangrylady · 06/04/2022 10:46

"Unless you are comfortable with people being discriminated against because of a disability, then yes you must accept this".
Such a stupid comment. If the disability prevents someone from doing the job properly then they shouldn't be doing it. That's like saying someone in a wheelchair can be a roofer.

twominutesmore · 06/04/2022 10:45

And the skills tests that several pp have mentioned - tests in English, Maths and IT - were scrapped in 2020 because many candidates resat millions of times and still failed. They prevented some candidates from training as teachers, so they scrapped them.

WhenSheWasBad · 06/04/2022 10:43

To those saying that teachers need to pass Literacy and Numeracy tests before starting their teaching course, this is no longer the case. Apparently it was too big a barrier to recruitment of new teachers

I wasn’t aware of this. So the plan to recruit more teachers is to drop standards? Heaven forbid we actually improve the working conditions to recruit and retain teachers.

mbosnz · 06/04/2022 10:43

My DD had a teacher that constantly marked her spelling as incorrect, when it was correct. It took all my self control not to correct her misspellings, but that teacher already had a down on DD, and as a result I already had a down on that teacher, so I figured that no good would come of tangling horns.

That teacher was very education for both DD and I. For all the wrong reasons!

RaleighDurham · 06/04/2022 10:42

"but who the hell uses an apostrophy for a plural?"

This is amusing.

onewednesdayindecember · 06/04/2022 10:41

I think allowances should be made when teachers have dyslexia and I also agree that mistakes will be made because teachers are so overworked. Anyone would make mistakes with that sort of workload.
Saying that, I was a bit disappointed when I went to a meeting about phonetics at my son’s primary school and ‘pronunciation’ was repeatedly pronounced ‘pronounciation’ by the teachers.

twominutesmore · 06/04/2022 10:41

I'm a teacher and I agree. Anyone can make a mistake while rushing but when the same teachers are making constant basic errors, it's worrying.

I don't think dyslexia is an excuse. Use a dictionary or a spellchecker. Your own difficulties with spelling shouldn't mean your pupils are short changed. An occasional error on the board is human and a good teaching moment. Repeatedly 'correcting' spelling errors that were correct in the first place is not on.

But just look at how easy it is to train as a teacher now. A friend's dd has been accepted onto a PGCE with two Es at A level and a degree in something obscure that she did over many years at OU. She is openly going into teaching for job security and holidays. She has never worked a day with children in her life. She may rise to the challenge and be fantastic, but I feel the odds are against this.

Even five years ago you needed decent A levels, a degree in a NC subject and at least two weeks experience in a school to even be considered at the same college she's going to. It's a shame. But good teachers are leaving and talented people are not choosing it as a career any more. People should consider why that is.

hangrylady · 06/04/2022 10:40

@annabell22

Some teachers have dyslexia- it doesn't mean that they shouldn't become a teacher.
Depends what they're teaching really.
WhenSheWasBad · 06/04/2022 10:39

@Thereisnolight

Btw I’m not talking about maths or science teachers. I’m talking about primary teachers whose job it is to teach children how to write and spell.
Your post lacked clarity. So I criticised it.

Now imagine you are a teacher. And you’ve made a mistake on a kids book, because you know - you are human. Does that teacher deserve hauling over the coals being they made a mistake?

I made a revision booklet for my pupils. I did proofread it, but I’m shit at proofreading.
As we went through it as a class. We had to correct some errors as we went (grammar, spelling and some actual inaccuracies).

We corrected it we went and all was well. But if a parent read that document, they probably would conclude I was shit at my job.

—The booklet was written over half term holidays. It had to be done in a rush and no one is available to proofread the thing—

Plastictattoo · 06/04/2022 10:39

I don’t know of any teachers of primary age OP! Perhaps you need to check your grammar and punctuation in your first sentence. Grin
Don’t worry though. As I tell my class, it’s okay to make mistakes - that’s one of the ways we learn. Wink

MrsHamlet · 06/04/2022 10:38

Part of the reason the skills tests were scrapped was because they were not a good test of the skills teachers need in real situations.
They were also scrapped because they weren't doing their job - when they had to be done BEFORE starting a course and with a finite number of attempts, you could argue that they worked.
Once it became "any number of attempts" and before the end of the course, you could have trainees passing the PGCE with QTS but failing skills tests and not being allowed to teach.

EthelTheAardvark · 06/04/2022 10:37

I remember a large notice on a classroom door at DD's school saying "Standing on the shoulder's of giant's". I could understand one teacher making a mistake, but how on earth did none of the other teachers walking past it regularly fail to pick it up?

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 06/04/2022 10:34

To those saying that teachers need to pass Literacy and Numeracy tests before starting their teaching course, this is no longer the case.

Apparently it was too big a barrier to recruitment of new teachers.

I think it's madness, how can anyone teach Literacy and Numeracy if they can't do it.

There's also a confusing message in it being too anxiety inducing and difficult for prospective teachers to do a timed test but absolutely fine to put yr 1s through phonics assessments, the timed yr 4 multiplication test, as well as yr 2 and yr 6 SATs.

www.cumbria.ac.uk/blog/articles/professional-skills-tests-scrapped-for-2020.php

Killergigglebunnies · 06/04/2022 10:34

I have to check the reports that go out to parents as part of my job. You’d be surprised how many times they spell the kids name wrong or write the wrong name. I spend hours doing this as sometimes they write gobbledygook.