Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think teachers should be able to spell

367 replies

Brieandcamembert · 06/04/2022 09:20

I have increasingly noticed recently teachers (often of primary age) who make very basic spelling and grammar errors. Surely having excellent basic skills in this area is an essential criteria for teaching it?

I'm really concerned that we are raising a generation who will have appalling literacy skills.

I have seen the classic "of / have" confusion
I have seen "been" used instead of "being"
I have also seen phonetically similar words interchanged with one another.

OP posts:
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 06/04/2022 11:22

Unless you are comfortable with people being discriminated against because of a disability, then yes you must accept this.

Do you think I would be able to get a job at the BBC as a continuity announcer if I had that form of Tourette's that causes unexpected swearing?

Or work as an airline pilot if I was blind?

A teacher with dyslexia may be fine for a non-related subject, but for someone who is going to teach my child SPAG - it surely shouldn't be someone who can't manage SPAG for themselves?

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 06/04/2022 11:18

I don't need my children's teachers to have excellent grammar skills. I need them to be excellent learning facilitators, where my children are encouraged to learn and enjoy learning in a safe environment. As it happens my now teen dc both have excellent English language skills, which comes from the love of books and learning instilled in them by inspirational ks1 teachers.

takealettermsjones · 06/04/2022 11:18

@Thereisnolight Not a problem if the posters don’t work in a job where they have to teach SPAG to others.

It is when the sanctimonious tone comes out ("I just can't believe the state of education these days!" etc).

SpotALeopard · 06/04/2022 11:18

@takealettermsjones - I think SPAG is important, but am sure I make grammar and punctuation mistakes myself all the time. I’ve got the basics Spelling was prioritised when I was at school, but grammar wasn’t really taught. Punctuation was taught on a basic level only. I got a first in English from a good university, but it was only a few years after graduation that I learnt there was a difference between ‘less’ and ‘fewer’. I’d been merrily using ‘less’ in all contexts up until then. It’s our educational system that is at fault, not individuals.

BogRollBOGOF · 06/04/2022 11:17

There's a difference in a spontaneous brain-fart moment, e.g. in marking through a mountain of books, and in materials that are going to be printed off and distributed (worksheets/ letters) and have a better opportunity for proof reading. Accepting an error and turning it into a teaching point is vastly better than plain ignorance.

DH makes many classic dyslexia type errors (DS is diagnosed and strongly dyslexic), so he knows that he needs to get others to proofread critical documents. I had rearrange his PhD into English so that others could then proofread for the technical content.

Spellchecks have their uses, but you have to know the language you are using. The "LocalLive" news article this morning used sever instead of severe. Spell check doesn't care about the difference. Journalists are supposed to be excellent at English. It's a growing issue across all sectors.

The problem is that as grammar errors become endemic they become normal and harder to identify. Does it matter? When it distorts or corrupts meaning or the information given, then yes.

medicmummm · 06/04/2022 11:16

@twominutesmore

See where you are coming from but that is the same if not worse in a lot of fields. The NHS for example. Doctor pay rise after the pandemic was not for any junior staff (consulatants only) so we were in the direct line of fire and have no reward to speak of. We were suppose to get an extra day of annual leave but I switched contracts around then and missed out! Great, given that it nearly killed me Hmm

So I think gratitude is not proportionate to the risks taken. Look at the stick the NHS gets, I mean the system is broken but very individual tries their very best (mostly) can the same be said about teaching perhaps?

mbosnz · 06/04/2022 11:14

That teacher was very education for both DD and I. For all the wrong reasons!

PMSL, mea culpa, and most definitely hoist with my own petard!

frenchfancy81 · 06/04/2022 11:14

@PaddlingLikeADuck

My son’s primary teacher doesn’t know her six or seven times table.

He’s always coming home with the results of his multiplication tests and she ticks answers that are wrong.

It’s madness.

What has she said when you've questioned/mentioned it? If it's a regular occurrence, then it's not on! Is she definitely marking them herself- not the kids peer-marking or a TA? The latter is also unacceptable, btw. One or two errors is forgivable- class of 30 and however many questions per child...but regular mistakes isn't.
whereshalligo · 06/04/2022 11:13

My son is a 2nd year primary education Uni student. He had to pass the government standard tests before he was accepted but as stated these have stopped but his uni now do their own tests. He only needed to have GCSEs at level 4 in both English and Maths. He has always been much weaker at English gained a 4 at language GCSE but 9 in Maths. He also has A level maths. Knowing this he chose a maths specialism for his primary education uni course. Obviously, he will still need to teach English but knows he has to work harder here. He's recently completed his school based training and had fantastic feedback. Yes in reality his English could be better and I'm sure he will make mistakes but he is young, male and committed to teaching.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 06/04/2022 11:13

@takealettermsjones

These threads are always amusing, just for the self-professed SPaG enthusiasts who then make SPaG mistakes in their own posts. There have been at least two already. Top work everyone 👍
This is my favourite so far: That teacher was very education for both DD and I. For all the wrong reasons!
medicmummm · 06/04/2022 11:12

Agree but maybe that’s what happens when everyone can get into university these days.

Surely though, to teach something you only have to be one step ahead of the student Wink

My grammar and spelling is awful- I try but i’m very dyslexic. Shouldn’t be a barrier to a career though- luckily I don’t need to write so much in my job (any more)

twominutesmore · 06/04/2022 11:12

@Arianya

If you can’t do the job then you shouldn’t be hired to do the job. That includes teachers who aren’t able to teach spelling because they don’t know how to spell themselves and aren’t capable of using tools such as dictionaries and spellcheckers to correct their mistakes.
I agree with you. But what to do when teachers are leaving in droves and the job isn't attractive enough to recruit trainees of a decent standard? Ten years of pay freezes and below-inflation increases, parents who treat us like staff and constant government tinkering, changes and interference.

During the pandemic these boards were full of people talking about the lazy teachers sitting at home while everyone I know worked every single day (including the Easter and May holidays that year) taught themselves new technology, delivered food parcels to vulnerable families, carried out welfare checks and goodness knows what else. Our reward for that was criticism from parents, the government and the media, followed by a pay freeze.

Thereisnolight · 06/04/2022 11:11

@takealettermsjones

These threads are always amusing, just for the self-professed SPaG enthusiasts who then make SPaG mistakes in their own posts. There have been at least two already. Top work everyone 👍
Not a problem if the posters don’t work in a job where they have to teach SPAG to others.
Thumpkin · 06/04/2022 11:09

I’ve worked as a proof reader and I still make mistakes when I’m exhausted and marking work! I agree that ideally our SPAG should be perfect but it’s very unlikely it will be when there’s a shortage of teachers and we can’t just pick only teachers with impeccable English. Plus, as I said, even those of us who are generally highly accurate have off days!

takealettermsjones · 06/04/2022 11:08

These threads are always amusing, just for the self-professed SPaG enthusiasts who then make SPaG mistakes in their own posts. There have been at least two already. Top work everyone 👍

WhenSheWasBad · 06/04/2022 11:07

Children deserve high quality teaching and if a person cannot provide that then they shouldn't be in the classroom

Children do deserve high quality teaching. But there’s not much incentivising highly skilled, well educated people to enter the profession.

I know the headteacher at my school is really struggling to recruit decent staff.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 06/04/2022 11:04

Yes, it’s appalling.

IMO teachers should be paid more, but there should also be a stringent SPAG test at the beginning of training, and any who are still shown to be lacking after compulsory remedial work should not be allowed to proceed.

Most basic mistakes are very easily explained and corrected - there is not some great mystique to them.

As for split infinitives, AFAIK it was the stickler 18th century grammarians who decreed that because you cannot split a Latin infinitive (and Latin was thought to be a ‘perfect’ language) therefore you should not be allowed to split an English one.

Which was always a rubbish reason, IMO, and should no longer apply. In any case, adhering strictly to that rule can result in some really clunky-sounding sentences.

Arianya · 06/04/2022 11:03

If you can’t do the job then you shouldn’t be hired to do the job. That includes teachers who aren’t able to teach spelling because they don’t know how to spell themselves and aren’t capable of using tools such as dictionaries and spellcheckers to correct their mistakes.

MasterBeth · 06/04/2022 11:03

@CallmeHendricks

Your OP might have carried more weight with me had you not split an infinitive in the first sentence.
A split infinitive is perfectly acceptable in English.
MrsHamlet · 06/04/2022 11:03

@twominutesmore

"Ofsted grade, in part, on successful completion."

I didn't know that. It's so disheartening to see the decline.

Failed to recruit to your quota? Black mark. Too many trainees drop out? Black mark. Trainees fail? Black mark.

Solutions - recruit anyone who breathes. Keep them to the end. Pass them all.

okayigetit · 06/04/2022 11:01

I'm 27 now but I had a teacher for 2 years in primary school who my parents say was 'totally useless' I was a really shy kid and she had no clue what to do with me and didn't help me because and I quote 'she doesn't put her hand up and ask for help' anyway, my parents went to one parents evening once and my dad noticed on the board, Wednesday was spend 'wensday' 😳

twominutesmore · 06/04/2022 10:58

"Ofsted grade, in part, on successful completion."

I didn't know that. It's so disheartening to see the decline.

MiniatureHotdog · 06/04/2022 10:57

Some teachers have dyslexia- it doesn't mean that they shouldn't become a teacher

Not as a blanket rule no of course not, but I do think sometimes it should though. As a pp said, sometimes a job is not well suited to a person. One of my DC had a dyslexic teacher who had terrible spelling, grammar and English skills in general. I don't know how much was due to the dyslexia and how much was just that they were bad at those things.

We had spellings incorrectly marked wrong and vice versa nearly every week, frequent use of totally the wrong word in the context, terrible reading (I watched an online assembly where the teacher's reading was worse than my 9 year olds).

I'm sorry but I do not think they should be a teacher. Not all children have parents at home picking up on the teacher's errors and correcting them and plugging gaps. Children deserve high quality teaching and if a person cannot provide that then they shouldn't be in the classroom.

Puffalicious · 06/04/2022 10:57

@annabell22

Some teachers have dyslexia- it doesn't mean that they shouldn't become a teacher.
I'm sorry, but it does! They will have many other skills which will serve them well in another career, just not primary teaching. Teaching a secondary subject not English based, yes, but not primary.

I'm an English teacher and had to decline a reference for a lovely girl I taught last year. She's always struggled to spell. She's not dyslexic but it's one area she has a difficulty in. The course she applied for was primary teaching and I told her I couldn't approve that as it's of paramount importance to be able to spell perfectly and have an excellent command of syntax and grammar, which she also doesn't have.

I'm not a logical person at all, Science is NOT my thing, therefore I'm not an engineer/ science researcher. We all play to our strengths. Sorry it doesn't fit with inclusion but it's the truth.

SpotALeopard · 06/04/2022 10:57

@Debroglie

Teachers are massively overworked and make mistakes. I teach physics. I’m pretty academic and have a phd. I wrote on the board last week 2 x 3 = 5 My year 12s reacted with amusement and disgust in equal measure. (I do know that 2x3=/=5) I also spelt a word wrong in another lesson (forgotten what the word was now but the TA corrected me.) We’re not robots. We’re human. We’re tired. We can’t be perfect.
There is a difference between making mistakes because we’re tired or doing too many things at once or just because it inexplicably happens from time to time and ignorance. Your example is clearly in the former category, as are the comments about getting students to check their marks tally up correctly. And, yes, it’s good for kids to learn that everyone makes mistakes and it isn’t the end of the world.

A teacher refusing to accept that ‘passed’ is incorrect when it has been pointed out is another matter.

Not sure what the answer is, though, given that a decent grasp of SPAG has been undervalued for so long that you wouldn’t be able to fill vacancies if you insisted on it. As someone said on the first page, this just reflects a wider decline in SPAG standards.