Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think parents don't honestly behave like this...

169 replies

DumplingsAreRank · 05/04/2022 21:57

... ahead of the new serious of Waterloo Road (yes, I am that retro) I am rewatching some old series.

One of the kids, Scout, has witnessed her mother walk out with a new bloke for some "alone time" destroying her opportunity to get an education and leaving a 3 year old without a mum.

Parents wouldn't actually do this would they? It's make believe surely

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 06/04/2022 07:07

You probably don't want to know then, but Waterloo road is quite a sanitised version for teatime viewing. Many parents are horrible to their kids routinely. Nothing ever noticeable enough to be picked up or it is picked up and the children are in and out of care with it never really being resolved. Sad world.

As for it being fair for people to have children... That's one of those ideas that sounds sensible when you first think it but if you think more deeply about it you'd realise that it could never be implemented. Firstly who decides who is responsible enough to be allowed to have children? How do you make sure that viewpoint is fair and unbiased? What if somebody would be a great parent but they fall short of one of the markers? What happens if somebody gets pregnant anyway? Accidentally? Do you force them to have an abortion? That sounds horrific. Do you take the baby for adoption at birth? Babies are not puppies, so quite apart from the distress to the mother, bear in mind this causes harm to the baby. What if that baby would have been absolutely fine with their birth parent (s) if not ideal - would that definitely and absolutely be more than the harm caused by removing them? Where are all the new adopters and foster carers going to come from for these babies? What if they get stuck in foster care or children's homes for years? Would that definitely and absolutely be better than being with a slightly substandard parent? What about concealed pregnancies where somebody knows they are not "approved" to have a baby but goes and does it under the radar anyway. It is most important for the most vulnerable to receive antenatal care and support post birth. Those children would end up even more disadvantaged. And as said, children are not puppies and separating them from their parents, even bad parents, causes trauma and harm. That is why the bar is currently so high for removing children. Under the approved parents only system, what would happen with babies born abroad whose parents didn't meet the criteria when they arrive? Would you take those children away, even if they are being cared for? If not, why is there one rule for British parents and another for immigrants? What do you think angry and distressed parents who have had their children removed or their right to children refused would think about that?

You only have to look at atrocities in countries where indigenous people were deemed "unfit parents" (Canada, Australia etc) to see how such things can go badly wrong.

It's not about a right to have children, it's about basic rights of not treating people absolutely terribly, and making sure the most vulnerable children have access to support.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 06/04/2022 07:05

Of course some parents do.

There has been too many DC murdered or dying through neglect the past few years.

Battered to death, freezing on a door step waiting on DM, baby who's left starving till she passed. Another tossed in the river after a beating, stepmother killing babies.

There just the poor children who come to mind.

If those mother's left for a fun time those DX would have been safe.

Some mothers are like earth angels others are devil's.

Crimesean · 06/04/2022 07:04

I used to mentor a 2nd year university student - her parents fucked off to Pakistan for a holiday for 4 months, leaving her to look after her 3 younger (young primary age) siblings. It was only supposed to be for a couple of weeks initially. She went from a predicted 1st to struggling to even pass.

I judged those parents, harshly.

Donotgogentle · 06/04/2022 06:59

Flowers for those on this thread who had such terrible parents.

Sundancerintherain · 06/04/2022 06:55

I used to live in a very nice part of a very nice area and my very respectable ( outwardly) NDN would regularly keep her kids off school because she was pissed / hungover. She also liked to lock them outside as a punishment.
Dad worked abroad and was oblivious.

Wheniruletheworld · 06/04/2022 06:52

You are pretending to be naive for fun. Have you really led such a sheltered life, free from any kind of media/books/friends to show you how the world is, or are you just wilfully ignorant?

SpinningTheSeedsOfLove · 06/04/2022 06:47

@MaChienEstUnDick

Dads do it all the fucking time.
Well quite.

And then it’s unremarkable.

Fraaahnces · 06/04/2022 06:22

I’m a child of the 70’s. My birth bitch used to go out mid-morning after clobbering me, leaving me in charge of my younger, fucked up brother. She would trot back home about half an hour before Dad’s train was due in and be busily making dinner like a good mum when he walked in the door: I was about six (he was four) when the neighbours found me with yet another broken arm and took me to the hospital that she worked at and told them what they knew. Leaving us alone stopped. The broken bones didn’t.

Goldbar · 06/04/2022 06:18

Part of it as well might be the consequences of failing as a parent. If fathers walk out, the mothers will usually (but not always) pick up the pieces. If mothers walk out, it's far less obvious that fathers will necessarily step up. Often children will be cared for by relatives or go into foster care. I imagine it's easier to leave if your children have a stable other parent who you can abdicate responsibility to. It's interesting that when fathers go to prison, children are usually cared for by mothers. When mothers go to prison, only a few children are cared for by fathers... most are fostered, adopted or cared for by family, usually grandparents.

GreyCarpet · 06/04/2022 05:53

I do also think...and this is quite an unpopular opinion...that women have a stronger bond with their children usually. Due to carrying them in their bodies and being the only one able to breastfeed (though that's not always relevant)

Some women do.

I used to work in child protection and I can tell you that the woman who discharged herself from hospital the day her baby was born, left the baby there and went home did not feel bonded to that child.

My mother was open about the fact she didn't love me because she didn't feel that bond.

Some women...

FortunesFave · 06/04/2022 05:34

@GreyCarpet

Why is it so shocking when mums do it?

Society holds women to a much higher standard than men in pretty much every area of life unfortunately.

I do also think...and this is quite an unpopular opinion...that women have a stronger bond with their children usually. Due to carrying them in their bodies and being the only one able to breastfeed (though that's not always relevant)
ogorange · 06/04/2022 05:28

My sister walked out on her two young children and moved abroad for a man she met on the internet. She's highly educated, from a very nice middle class background (just to counteract the assumptions of this only happening with women of a certain class & situation). Her former husband now takes care of the children as a single father.

Do I judge her? Yes. Yes I do.

GreyCarpet · 06/04/2022 05:22

Why is it so shocking when mums do it?

Society holds women to a much higher standard than men in pretty much every area of life unfortunately.

Goldbar · 06/04/2022 05:20

@vicarc

My Dad was left with a brood of 5 children to raise alone as his ex walked out for a new bloke. The youngest was 2. They were probably not all genetically his as she was a serial cheat (all pre DNA testing) but he didn’t have the heart to split the sibling group so he soldiered on. He wrote to her to come and get the children at one point but she never came, in fact never responded. To add insult to injury he was ordered to pay her alimony in the way of pension contributions as part of the divorce settlement. It was incredibly hard, bankrupted him, was sectioned once for a complete mental breakdown from extreme stress and the eldest sister had to take up a parenting role as my Dad had to work all the hours he could to support them. The ex was a devout catholic and my dad even converted to marry her. What can I say really, women are no better or worse than men just society doesn’t wish to see it. A lifetime later, 6 months before my elderly Dad passed, a letter arrived from her apologising, I guess she was worried about her soul.
While I'm sorry for your dad's experience which sounds tough, I don't think it represents the norm. Statistically it's just not the case that women are 'no better or worse than men' as parents. The overwhelming majority of single parents are women and, even in relationships, women shoulder more of the parenting burden than men even when in full-time work. More anecdotally, men left with parenting responsibilities often look for a woman to push them onto...often a new, younger partner. In your case, you describe how the 'eldest sister' had to take on the parenting responsibilities.
Goldbar · 06/04/2022 05:13

Lots of parents walk out on their kids because they cba with family life.

Usually dads though. Society has no problem with that.

Why is it so shocking when mums do it?

DumplingsAreRank · 06/04/2022 04:54

Yes I am not talking about the big headline stories where there is rightly massive outcry (or what’s going on abroad with kids used as human shields), it’s more the utter low level wankery so many kids have to go through - and yet another thread merely asked the question if it was right she slightly judged when people had kids when the parents were obviously emotionally and financially out of their depths and she was rounded on that it was the parents ‘right’ to have those kids. How is any of this anyones right? To treat someone else, someone so vulnerable often so badly?

OP posts:
GreyCarpet · 06/04/2022 04:39

@TeddyTonks

Lucky you to think this.

Some people are absolute shits. And unfortunately, some of us have those for parents Confused

Yep...

Nice for you that you have no personal conept of something but I'm with the poster who wonders what else you don't believe happens because you can't imagine doing it.

orangeisthenewpuce · 06/04/2022 04:31

OP you're getting a hard time, but I think you must have led a lovely sheltered life where you don't come across or hear about the awful things that some parents do to their children.

WTF475878237NC · 06/04/2022 04:27

I find it odder that some PP don't know Harper Lee.

Turningpurple · 06/04/2022 04:24

If you are talking about women doing it, I think its less common than men doing it, but it happens. I know a couple of people whose mothers did it.

One of them left her 2 kids alone in the house for 2 days, as the dad worked away. So she left while he was working. She had 2 more kids with OM and then did the same to them

IstayedForTheFeminism · 06/04/2022 03:46

I bloody love waterloo road. When's it back?

Wasn't Scout a nickname? Is Scout the one who grew up to be Sinead in Corrie?

Josette77 · 06/04/2022 02:54

Many of us have abandonment stories. How are you unaware of this?

NotNotNotMyName · 06/04/2022 02:49

Dads abandon their kids all the time 🤷🏻‍♀️

Weatherwax13 · 06/04/2022 02:10

How on earth can you wonder for even a second whether parents really do things like this?
Feckless fathers vanish regularly. And that's the "normal" end of the scale. It's so common.
When I was divorced the stats were that 70% of non resident fathers lost contact with their children within two years. And that was only 20 odd years ago.
Far, far less usual, but certainly not unheard of, my mother walked out when i was 11 and left me with a useless father and two younger siblings.
Many, many children are abandoned by their parent(s)
Or worse.
How the hell haven't you noticed this?

vicarc · 06/04/2022 02:09

My Dad was left with a brood of 5 children to raise alone as his ex walked out for a new bloke. The youngest was 2. They were probably not all genetically his as she was a serial cheat (all pre DNA testing) but he didn’t have the heart to split the sibling group so he soldiered on. He wrote to her to come and get the children at one point but she never came, in fact never responded. To add insult to injury he was ordered to pay her alimony in the way of pension contributions as part of the divorce settlement. It was incredibly hard, bankrupted him, was sectioned once for a complete mental breakdown from extreme stress and the eldest sister had to take up a parenting role as my Dad had to work all the hours he could to support them. The ex was a devout catholic and my dad even converted to marry her. What can I say really, women are no better or worse than men just society doesn’t wish to see it. A lifetime later, 6 months before my elderly Dad passed, a letter arrived from her apologising, I guess she was worried about her soul.