Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hired a disabled woman in lockdown who I now have to fire

554 replies

Whatnextteletext · 05/04/2022 21:14

During the first lockdown I hired a physically disabled woman into an entry level role on my team. She’s in her mid 30’s but it’s her first job because pre-pandemic, she couldn’t work out of the home due to her disability and work from home opportunities were few and far between. She is a wheelchair user who lives with a full time carer who takes care of he personal needs (this is relevant to why she couldn’t work out of home) and prior to lockdown, she lived on her disability payments alone which from the sound of it was very hard going.

I hired her into an entry level web development role with on the job training and it turns out she’s wicked smart and a phenomenally fast learner. I’ve put her through some web development training and within 18 months she’s now a pretty decent developer and by far the most competent of the cohort I hired along side her. She’s also lovely and we get on really well.

Anyway, when I hired her, my company were committed to WFH and hybrid working long term. Now however, they’ve backtracked and everyone is back in the office 3 days a week mandated.

Today I had an email from the senior team asking why this employee hadn’t been back to the office so I explained that she’ll be working from home forever given the circumstances (that they’re very aware of!) and the reply I got was that she’s no longer suitable for the role now that the expectation is work from the office and I needed to let her go.

I hit the roof and went straight to HR who are looking into this now, but I’d like to know from here what is likely to happen??

If they come back and say she’s got to go and I have to fire her I’m handing my notice in on the spot, that’s a given. How likely is that though? Surely it’s discrimination?

It’s also really stupid. It costs a fortune to train new developers properly and I’ve invested a huge amount of my time into her. It’s a complete candidates market at the moment too - developer roles are everywhere, it’s really hard to find ones with the right training and she’s good enough that with a bit of off the record support she could freelance fairly easily.

Her contract doesn’t specify a place of work or working model and there is no reason on earth she couldn’t perform the role perfectly adequately from home. We all did for 2 years.

Does anyone know where we stand legally on this one? She’ll have 2 years service in June.

OP posts:
FairyLightPups · 05/04/2022 22:32

Please don't resign and leave her to deal with being fired by someone with no heart. Please fight for her. This is a clear case if discrimination.

Archepsych · 05/04/2022 22:32

Yes they can - being non disabled isn’t a protected characteristic. It doesn’t matter what rules apply to everyone else

thequeenoftarts · 05/04/2022 22:32

@Whatnextteletext

I’ve just logged on to download her reviews and I’ve got a reply from the HR director.

They have spoken to the leadership team this evening and would like to meet with me on zoom first thing tomorrow morning and have asked that I don’t pass the email onto my colleague or talk to her about this in the meantime. They’ll update me in the morning and thank you for bringing it to their attention.

It reads like a well considered place holding response - fingers crossed that’s a sign they’re on the ball.

Thanks all, I can go to the meeting in the morning knowing the legalities and likely outcomes now which is very helpful.

I’ve decided in my own mind that if the outcome is no further action, I’m not going to tell her. On balance, I don’t think it does any good and it’s likely to make her feel othered and ‘less than’ which serves no purpose other than to clear my conscience. We’ve had chats before about her feeling like she can’t do things or needs more help from me than the others which isn’t at all the case - I don’t want her knowing she’s being protected or shielded by me when she’s fought so hard to be independent in the first place and is here completely on merit. She’d feel like we were keeping her because we couldn’t sack her rather than because she’s brilliant. Her confidence would take a real knock and for no reason.

You are such a lovely person.
Whatnextteletext · 05/04/2022 22:31

@ThinWomansBrain

if she left/contract terminated, would you be able to employ her as a freelance consultant (on a more advantageous rate)
Actually, yes! I have full control over our freelancers (of which their are many!) and don’t have to get sign off on who we work for or what we pay them - if she’s fired (and it won’t be me doing it) this is 100% what I’m going to do Grin
OP posts:
stormswiftlysweetafton · 05/04/2022 22:30

Whatever the outcome is, at least you've helped her get her foot in the door with the training and work experience. It should make finding a new job easier for her, and I'm sure she'll appreciate that you've fought to keep her.

Roses1221 · 05/04/2022 22:30

Just in case the tide turns on you for not doing as they’ve asked, look into ‘discrimination by association’

You’re a brilliant manager and colleague Smile

StoneMap · 05/04/2022 22:29

www.scope.org.uk/

Whatnextteletext · 05/04/2022 22:29

I’ve just logged on to download her reviews and I’ve got a reply from the HR director.

They have spoken to the leadership team this evening and would like to meet with me on zoom first thing tomorrow morning and have asked that I don’t pass the email onto my colleague or talk to her about this in the meantime. They’ll update me in the morning and thank you for bringing it to their attention.

It reads like a well considered place holding response - fingers crossed that’s a sign they’re on the ball.

Thanks all, I can go to the meeting in the morning knowing the legalities and likely outcomes now which is very helpful.

I’ve decided in my own mind that if the outcome is no further action, I’m not going to tell her. On balance, I don’t think it does any good and it’s likely to make her feel othered and ‘less than’ which serves no purpose other than to clear my conscience. We’ve had chats before about her feeling like she can’t do things or needs more help from me than the others which isn’t at all the case - I don’t want her knowing she’s being protected or shielded by me when she’s fought so hard to be independent in the first place and is here completely on merit. She’d feel like we were keeping her because we couldn’t sack her rather than because she’s brilliant. Her confidence would take a real knock and for no reason.

OP posts:
EngTech · 05/04/2022 22:26

Very short sighted of the company plus the media would have a field day if it got into the press 😳😳

needmorethanthis · 05/04/2022 22:26

Why does everyone need to come in 3 days a week!! Why? We all WFH just fine!

Echobelly · 05/04/2022 22:24

The argument that she can't collaborate if she can't come in and will be left behind is absurd because she will be even less included if fired. By that token she can't work anywhere, which is plain wrong.

Sneezesthrice · 05/04/2022 22:22

@sweeneytoddsrazor

I have no idea on any legalities but I think the key maybe you say hybrid working. To my mind that is a combination of home /office so not entirely wfh. I think you could push how competent and talented she is, but I suspect your employer will say that they can't let 1 person work entirely from home if everyone else has to spend sometime in the office.
It would be a faulty argument. Equality doesn’t mean EVERYONE has to be able access a reasonable adjustment or it’s unfair.

It means making access to something equitable to all. That means those who NEED adjustments to have equal access, get them (in this case to have equal access to employment and a job they are excellent at with an adjustment in place) and those who DONT need them don’t have the right to demand the same. They don’t need the adjustment that provides equitable access.

There is no ‘if we let one person do it we have to let all the people do it’ when it comes to accessibility. They don’t need it. They aren’t entitled to demand it.

ThinWomansBrain · 05/04/2022 22:22

if she left/contract terminated, would you be able to employ her as a freelance consultant (on a more advantageous rate)

Ballcactus · 05/04/2022 22:20

It’s direct discrimination and it’s illegal. I would advise them to join a union, and keep a record of all the direction from higher management as proof.

HoppingPavlova · 05/04/2022 22:20

I think you could push how competent and talented she is, but I suspect your employer will say that they can't let 1 person work entirely from home if everyone else has to spend sometime in the office.

WTAF. That’s like saying you can’t let one person be pushed in a wheelchair as it’s not fair to everyone else to have to walk and get sore legs!

What you have come out with is only correct if it’s a level playing field to begin with and no one has any disability, or everyone has exactly the same disability in the same way needing the same adjustments.

Chocolatetrifle · 05/04/2022 22:18

Has your company not ever heard of the Disability Disagreement Act, later replaced by the Equality Act 2010?

Think they need to become familiar with the above sharpish.

LittleBearPad · 05/04/2022 22:17

Seriously this. Yes, Web developer is a common job but how many Web developers in the UK do you think there are who are female, not just disabled but specifically disabled to a level that requires full time in home care and unable to work in the office, are in their 30s and who have been working for only two years??

Apart from the fact the OP could have changed them significantly. She seems unconcerned so let’s assume she has

NeverDropYourMooncup · 05/04/2022 22:16

This will cost them thousands and thousands of pounds.

And if they are in the slightest bit tetchy with you, now or in the future, it will cost them even more as it is also extremely expensive to victimise somebody for whistleblowing/supporting somebody with a Protected Characteristic who is being discriminated against. So if you left as a result of this, you could also file a claim.

The most important thing is to ensure that there is evidence. For example, if they decided to have an online meeting telling her she has to come in because 'we can't give you special treatment', or that she would just have to make the effort like a 'normal person' (you wouldn't believe some of the shit that's said in meetings where they think there won't be any evidence), somebody setting up the meeting and accidentally hitting 'record' would be very inconvenient for them.

Chouetted · 05/04/2022 22:16

@Breakfastofmilk I'm suspecting some details have been changed....

I'm reading this with some interest as I'm planning to enter the job market soonish with a disability myself - this would be pretty much my worst nightmare.

Gladioli23 · 05/04/2022 22:14

No no no - don't export anything out of the company, especially if they've got her details on. You don't need your lovely employers to come after you for data protection breaches

I agree I wouldn't want to copy it off the company drives as it's a root to a roasting but I would be tempted to make sure I had copies saved down on my own hard drive so things couldn't just be deleted from shared servers etc.

Crikeyalmighty · 05/04/2022 22:12

What a good friend/manager you are OP! I do know how you feel though as I once left a good HR role after 4 months as the guys I worked for were doing some things that were illegal in order to gain competitive advantage- things I felt were not good or safe for the 30 odd people there. I brought it up and made my point but they were adamant it was their way or the high way so I left.

Herejustforthisone · 05/04/2022 22:12

Those panicking about outing the woman in question, I think we can safely assume the OP is savvy enough to have changed a few details.

Yotrotro · 05/04/2022 22:11

HR professional here. This is disability discrimination and genuinely baffles me that people still have this thought process in 2022! She's been doing the role really well for almost 2 years from home, no concerns and in a sought after position when theirs a skills shortage. Just why??

From your perspective, keep copies of her reviews etc and the emails you have been sent asking to dismiss. You need to refuse to take any action, if you were to dismiss her you'd likely be the one having to attend the tribunal to defend the actions on behalf of the business!

Hopefully your HR team are decent and should shut this down immediately. If not, perhaps look to become a whistleblower so that you gain yourself some protection?

Cultureclub · 05/04/2022 22:11

Put your concerns in writing to your senior management team and keep a copy. If they proceed it would seem highly likely that this case will go to tribunal and you need to protect your reputation.

Chippingin2 · 05/04/2022 22:11

@Phascolarctos

Yes, she’s had a formal appraisal every 6 months, monthly check ins (all written up and documented in a central portal) and even had an email with glowing feedback 3 months ago for a specific bit of work from the guy now trying to sack her

That all needs to be copied somewhere secure.

No no no - don't export anything out of the company, especially if they've got her details on. You don't need your lovely employers to come after you for data protection breaches
Swipe left for the next trending thread