Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hired a disabled woman in lockdown who I now have to fire

554 replies

Whatnextteletext · 05/04/2022 21:14

During the first lockdown I hired a physically disabled woman into an entry level role on my team. She’s in her mid 30’s but it’s her first job because pre-pandemic, she couldn’t work out of the home due to her disability and work from home opportunities were few and far between. She is a wheelchair user who lives with a full time carer who takes care of he personal needs (this is relevant to why she couldn’t work out of home) and prior to lockdown, she lived on her disability payments alone which from the sound of it was very hard going.

I hired her into an entry level web development role with on the job training and it turns out she’s wicked smart and a phenomenally fast learner. I’ve put her through some web development training and within 18 months she’s now a pretty decent developer and by far the most competent of the cohort I hired along side her. She’s also lovely and we get on really well.

Anyway, when I hired her, my company were committed to WFH and hybrid working long term. Now however, they’ve backtracked and everyone is back in the office 3 days a week mandated.

Today I had an email from the senior team asking why this employee hadn’t been back to the office so I explained that she’ll be working from home forever given the circumstances (that they’re very aware of!) and the reply I got was that she’s no longer suitable for the role now that the expectation is work from the office and I needed to let her go.

I hit the roof and went straight to HR who are looking into this now, but I’d like to know from here what is likely to happen??

If they come back and say she’s got to go and I have to fire her I’m handing my notice in on the spot, that’s a given. How likely is that though? Surely it’s discrimination?

It’s also really stupid. It costs a fortune to train new developers properly and I’ve invested a huge amount of my time into her. It’s a complete candidates market at the moment too - developer roles are everywhere, it’s really hard to find ones with the right training and she’s good enough that with a bit of off the record support she could freelance fairly easily.

Her contract doesn’t specify a place of work or working model and there is no reason on earth she couldn’t perform the role perfectly adequately from home. We all did for 2 years.

Does anyone know where we stand legally on this one? She’ll have 2 years service in June.

OP posts:
Elleherd · 06/04/2022 10:52

Awakened22

@Whatnextteletext it’s great that your fighting for your employee (and rightly so!) but there’s so much specific detail in here, if they were to be on mumsnet would they not realise it’s about them?! I’d hate to find out my job was potentially at risk on mumsnet and it also might put you in a difficult position. You’ve had some great advice but probably time to delete the thread…*

As wheelchair disabled literally struggling to make the rent weekly, I'd rather find out my job was at risk but that someone was fighting my corner on mumsnet, than when the cold harsh email telling me I was no longer wanted as my disability stopped me being part of an office culture, hit my inbox...

We're all different, but most seriously disabled people have had to fight bigger battles a lifetime and won't have a fit of the vaporous over the small stuff...

PerkingFaintly · 06/04/2022 10:51

BTW although she should get a big financial payout at ET, my guess would be that an attempt to sack her would still be devastating emotionally for her.

She's in her mid-30s and this is her first ever employment; she's had excellent reviews so knows she's capable and delivering; and her only ever employer STILL tries to shit on her, just because.

Soul-destroying doesn't begin to describe it.

If I were in the dev's position, I'd cope better if I were told I was being headhunted before I was told my current employer was trying to get rid of me. (I've no idea how that works legally with your position as her manager, and your own plans to possibly leave.)

yzed · 06/04/2022 10:48

Here here, Perking Faintly

SirSidneyRuffDiamond · 06/04/2022 10:47

@WinniesHunny bloody well said!

Crikeyalmighty · 06/04/2022 10:44

@Whatnextteletext. That’s very interesting OP- when I mentioned I left an HR role because of managements attitude to sticking to the law as regards HR— it was exactly same scenario as you are talking about— highly intelligent Oxbridge guys with a great ‘idea’ but bugger all idea of what you can/can’t do when you get to a certain size. Imagine having a bunch of Boris Johnson’s in charge going ‘oh bugger that- just do it’ — yep it was like that

WinniesHunny · 06/04/2022 10:43

I think the last three words of your post are superflouous, @perkingfaintly

PerkingFaintly · 06/04/2022 10:36

@Livelovebehappy

Was there always going to be a chance that people were going to be pulled back into the office though? Most people in lockdown were aware that wfh was temporary. And in that case I think it was a disservice employing her at all, as it sounds like you were well aware that working out of the home was was a no go for her, yet still employed her anyway, knowing there was every chance wfh was not permanent.
Thank you for this post, Livelovebehappy.

It's useful for folk to be reminded what we as disabled people are up against, and why we need legislation to protect us from people like you.

It's also an excellent demonstration for those who sweetly but naively believe that the mere existence of the legislation is a magic wand which has removed all barriers.

If it hadn't been for Covid, this developer would have been turned down at application on some spurious grounds and never been given the opportunity to prove she could do the work and successfully wfh. She then wouldn't have the track record that makes the employment tribunal such a likely win.

You've highlighted perfectly that employment involves two parties. It's all very well designating disabled people Fit To Work; doesn't buy squat unless employers actually make the reasonable adjustments and employ us.

The Livelovebehappy's of this world are thick on the ground.

yzed · 06/04/2022 10:33

If I've understood the dynamics of this company right, it's a typical example of a small group of people who started up a company and think they can do as they like with it. There are rules and laws to follow. Plus of course they've been emasculated by the larger company telling them what to do. They're trying to prove they're still in charge.

I know you must be very busy today, with the ongoing ridiculousness. But as soon as you can contact ACAS for definitive advice. Save every message back and forth and keep notes along the way (well done for getting the meeting recorded). Encourage your colleague to also contact ACAS, so she can put in her claim right away. Be wary of the advice not to leave, as Constructive Dismissal requires almost-instant leaving (but, obviously, check details first).

And finally, I wonder how big your whole team is? Might it be possible to follow the advice of a poster to "move on" and find work as a team? If these idiots aren't going to settle down and make a sensible decision soon, then they deserve to have the hassle of needing to employ a whole new team (or buy up a new company?) for "your" part of the work.

LaurieFairyCake · 06/04/2022 10:28

You're fantastic OP Thanks

She could easily motor on out of there and get a job in 5 minutes. I've loads of developer friends on £100-200k (or £2k a week freelance). Total employees market out there.

Herewegoagain84 · 06/04/2022 10:23

It’s unlikely you’ll be able to fire her on this basis, unless you’re ready for repercussions. If she can carry out her role competently working from home and has been for 18 months, management don’t have a leg to stand on. Be very careful.

Theo1756 · 06/04/2022 10:20

This is a shitty thing to happen and a crappy position for you to be put in. What does the contract say? If the company were committed at the time then should say it was a remote role. (I’ve been caught this way as I was hired and able to wfh but the contract said in office. If the contract does say remote then firing would also be a breach of contract. ACAS will be all over this one. Best of luck to you and to her.

ilovebrie8 · 06/04/2022 10:19

only plus for your colleague is the job market is booming so she will be snapped up...

WaterBottle123 · 06/04/2022 10:18

This is absolutely astonishing. Fingers crossed for the right outcome!

Enko · 06/04/2022 10:18

Hope it goes well op

BitOutOfPractice · 06/04/2022 10:17

I hope your colleague sues their arses off and goes and gets a much better and higher paid job with her hard won skills.

You don't have to be an experienced manager or know much about employment law to know that they are on very shaky ground

ilovebrie8 · 06/04/2022 10:02

that is shocking OP, I've seen this before and post lockdown some company's are insisting on an office presence....despite evidence that it is not needed. You are working for idiots! end of the day the company can dictate what the terms are as they are the employer/pay the wages...whether that is right in this case it's not but not sure much you can do...I wouldn't resign if I was you

forinborin · 06/04/2022 10:02

There’s also another overseas company who bought this one which is much older and bigger and that’s where the push to go back to the office is coming from
US by any chance?

BruceAndNosh · 06/04/2022 09:53

The overseas parent company need to be reminded that you are bound by UK employment and disability legislation.

Movinghouseatlast · 06/04/2022 09:49

Hope it goes well today. I think they really need some training on this as it seems they haven't got a clue. I worked in this area for 25 years and this scenario really is textbook.

PeterPomegranate · 06/04/2022 09:48

@RagamuffinCat

Could working from home permanently be considered a reasonable adjustment, given that she is currently doing this competently?
This would be my thought too. Why are they so adamant to get rid of her. She sounds like a diamond.
ZealAndArdour · 06/04/2022 09:41

@SenselessUbiquity The OP and her colleague appear to be coders/software developers. Where OP refers to languages she is meaning the different languages you can code in, E.g. python, Java, SQL, PHP, etc.

You can do a 12 week coding bootcamp with a company like North Coders, there’s even some government funded places for people in the north and midlands. Essentially you should be employable as a junior developer after these 12 week courses and they help you arrange interviews with potential employers. Lots of software developers are self taught, you don’t need a degree in computer sciences, and many developers teach themselves the new languages as and when needed on the job.

You can do some beginners exercises on freecodecamp to get a taste for it, the basic JavaScript course is a good start to see if you like it and your brain is suited to it.

Whatnextteletext · 06/04/2022 09:40

In terms of how they can be this stupid - you have no idea. The senior team haven’t been senior very long, have no management training or HR awareness at all and are very much in their roles through pure luck and over confidence in their own abilities.

They had a good idea straight from Uni, funded the concept with family money then somehow got investment from overseas, went on a mad buying/ hiring spree and now find themselves in charge of a fairly sizeable company. There’s also another overseas company who bought this one which is much older and bigger and that’s where the push to go back to the office is coming from. So although they paint themselves as this young, happening start up - the culture comes from the overseas company and they’re a bit hamstrung by that I think. I think fear of annoying that companies bosses is why this guy from the leadership team got a bit over enthusiastic.

OP posts:
EvilPea · 06/04/2022 09:37

I have a friend who could be this person (it’s not), I’m so glad your in her corner. Life is hard enough as it is, without this sort of shit panicking them.

BTW I’m another in the team that hopes you two set off into the sunset starting your own company taking all their clients with you.

yellowsuninthesky · 06/04/2022 09:36

I think their worry is if they agree my colleague can WFH, then they lose the argument as to why no one else can

they're a bit stupid if they can't tell the difference between someone with protected characteristics and someone without

yellowsuninthesky · 06/04/2022 09:35

I’ll update on my HR chat in a bit, they’re calling me back. I had to ask for the chat to be recorded in the end unfortunately as the immediate response wasn’t ‘disregard everything and we’re very sorry’ which is disappointing

unbelievable. Well actually it isn't. HR is, in my experience, usually pretty useless. But they usually want to protect the company, so you'd think they'd be all over avoiding a disability discrimination claim which they'd be 99% likely to lose.