Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hired a disabled woman in lockdown who I now have to fire

554 replies

Whatnextteletext · 05/04/2022 21:14

During the first lockdown I hired a physically disabled woman into an entry level role on my team. She’s in her mid 30’s but it’s her first job because pre-pandemic, she couldn’t work out of the home due to her disability and work from home opportunities were few and far between. She is a wheelchair user who lives with a full time carer who takes care of he personal needs (this is relevant to why she couldn’t work out of home) and prior to lockdown, she lived on her disability payments alone which from the sound of it was very hard going.

I hired her into an entry level web development role with on the job training and it turns out she’s wicked smart and a phenomenally fast learner. I’ve put her through some web development training and within 18 months she’s now a pretty decent developer and by far the most competent of the cohort I hired along side her. She’s also lovely and we get on really well.

Anyway, when I hired her, my company were committed to WFH and hybrid working long term. Now however, they’ve backtracked and everyone is back in the office 3 days a week mandated.

Today I had an email from the senior team asking why this employee hadn’t been back to the office so I explained that she’ll be working from home forever given the circumstances (that they’re very aware of!) and the reply I got was that she’s no longer suitable for the role now that the expectation is work from the office and I needed to let her go.

I hit the roof and went straight to HR who are looking into this now, but I’d like to know from here what is likely to happen??

If they come back and say she’s got to go and I have to fire her I’m handing my notice in on the spot, that’s a given. How likely is that though? Surely it’s discrimination?

It’s also really stupid. It costs a fortune to train new developers properly and I’ve invested a huge amount of my time into her. It’s a complete candidates market at the moment too - developer roles are everywhere, it’s really hard to find ones with the right training and she’s good enough that with a bit of off the record support she could freelance fairly easily.

Her contract doesn’t specify a place of work or working model and there is no reason on earth she couldn’t perform the role perfectly adequately from home. We all did for 2 years.

Does anyone know where we stand legally on this one? She’ll have 2 years service in June.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WhyCantPeopleBeNice · 24/04/2022 07:33

You've won a great battle but the war is still on

It is rubbish that HR didn't have your back or your employees and it was down to you and Mumsnet to push hard with the Equality Act and reasonable adjustments.
Your HR team seem like they'd have let this happen had you not fought.
They need to be part of the SLT because right now they come across as mediators.

Your employee is lucky to have you as their manager, you're clearly a decent, competent person who knows right from wrong...but what about the other managers? Are their team members as protected?
Managers need diversity and inclusion training. It doesn't just protect employee rights but also saves the company legal and reputational damages.

If the company isn't willing to take ongoing action to learn and grow, someone else will be fighting this soon

marcopront · 24/04/2022 07:10

Boredoutmymind · 24/04/2022 06:19

This is disability discrimination under the equality act. The employee can sue the company. Make sure you make the company and the employee know about it.
Employers have a duty to make reasonable adjustments for disabled workers. She will win.

Maybe read the entire thread or at least the OP comments before posting.

Boredoutmymind · 24/04/2022 06:19

This is disability discrimination under the equality act. The employee can sue the company. Make sure you make the company and the employee know about it.
Employers have a duty to make reasonable adjustments for disabled workers. She will win.

Gladioli23 · 23/04/2022 22:22

Ikeptgoing · 10/04/2022 09:26

There is a difference on the emphasis of 'long term', which basically means for an indeterminate, temporary length of time, to permanent.

Interestingly enough in social care 'long term' is phrase used for 'permanent' contracts (as long as needs stay same and that service remains contracted type caveats) unless there was further phrasing in same sentence (subject to review after ...), so I would hear "permanent" too for whilst I still had same role/ same company structure.

Pointing out costs of having to relocate office to make it accessible, for reasonable adjustments, for this worker to be able to access office (that they were insisting she attends), was spot on OP!!!

I'm so glad it is resolved and frustrated for you that you had to fight for such a great worker as this is how your SLT behave to their staff.

It's used similarly in my work - basically indefinite but with a change possible if circumstances changed substantially but with no particular expectation they will.

I would definitely have heard permanent if someone said long term - it just wouldn't occur to me it meant anything else.

mycatisannoying · 23/04/2022 22:17

Oh, the poor girl. It would be awful if they let her go Sad
You're bloody awesome though OP, and I'm so glad she's got you fighting her corner Star

BeerLoas · 23/04/2022 22:10

*poorly managed

BeerLoas · 23/04/2022 22:09

Well done OP although it’s sad your efforts were needed, but sadly not surprising. Having sat on an SLT and fought against (not the same but some equally) shitty opinions/decisions, it is shocking how in the weeds some SLT are willing to get. They should care about outcomes and performance to strategy leaving the detail to managers. Getting stuck on individual issues like this shows a) how discriminatory they and it won’t just be on disability and likely b) they’re not SLT level.

If you had handed your notice in you would also potentially have a claim against them. Sounds like a lot of evidence of what you felt was discrimination poorly left you no choice to resign.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 23/04/2022 20:52

Good for you OP. Thank goodness for manager who support their staff - there are not enough of them around.

Murdoch1949 · 23/04/2022 20:15

What a fabulous manager you are. Professional, knowledgeable, empathetic, any company would be lucky to have you. Chapeau.

Secondsop · 23/04/2022 12:56

Well done OP for sticking up for your team member’s employment rights! I can’t think of many clearer cases of WFH being a reasonable adjustment the employer should make. I hope your employee continues to thrive under your management.

Alwayscheerful · 23/04/2022 12:50

F

DGRossetti · 11/04/2022 12:33

Thought this may interest dome on here

www.theregister.com/2022/04/11/4day_workweek/

particularly the comments ...

Jokie · 10/04/2022 13:16

OP- massive kudos to you for standing up for your colleague. I've had to reiterate some of the promises made during lockdown that are still relevant now (especially considering COVID rates). It's just not feasible.

DPotter · 10/04/2022 12:16

Money talks.

Sadly many businesses would happily act in a similar high handed way, unless there was law forcing them down the more moral, equitable route. Those companies with money would just go ahead anyway, eg P&O knew what they were doing was illegal and did it anyway.

I am delighted your employee was been protected

DGRossetti · 10/04/2022 10:34

Anyway, HR basically just firmly said ‘this is going to cost you a lot of money you don’t have if you pursue this’ and that was essentially that. Really disappointing it came down to money and not the morality of the thing but the outcome is the same.

I suspect this is the beginning, not the end Sad

I'd suggest your employee is incredibly careful about recording every interaction with the company for the next move they try.

Ikeptgoing · 10/04/2022 09:26

There is a difference on the emphasis of 'long term', which basically means for an indeterminate, temporary length of time, to permanent.

Interestingly enough in social care 'long term' is phrase used for 'permanent' contracts (as long as needs stay same and that service remains contracted type caveats) unless there was further phrasing in same sentence (subject to review after ...), so I would hear "permanent" too for whilst I still had same role/ same company structure.

Pointing out costs of having to relocate office to make it accessible, for reasonable adjustments, for this worker to be able to access office (that they were insisting she attends), was spot on OP!!!

I'm so glad it is resolved and frustrated for you that you had to fight for such a great worker as this is how your SLT behave to their staff.

Whatnextteletext · 10/04/2022 09:12

@HangingRock25

'That's fine, no issues with long term WFH. Proceed'

I would have clarified, PERMANENTLY? There is a difference on the emphasis of 'long term', which basically means for an indeterminate, temporary length of time, to permanent.

I think this should have been clarified when she was hired, that she would never be able to attend in person, and her wfh was permanent. The way they worded it, it seems they really didn't understand you meant that she would never, ever be able to go to the office. There should have been absolutely no ambiguity whatsoever. Communication was bad on both sides (yours and HRs) when you hired her in the first instance. "Long term" should never have ever been used, since her wfh was permanent, not just 'long term'.

I agree, lesson learned my side! From this whole thing I’ve decided absolutely every interaction with the SLT needs to be followed up in writing and very clearly stated. They’re clearly not good people and the only way to handle this level of incompetence above you is to cover your own back completely. My HR friend essentially said the same thing when we met for drinks on Friday night.

She wasn’t in the meeting with the SLT when HR told them to back off but apparently the head of HR came back from it and told her that the SLT argued for ages about ‘company cohesion’ and couldn’t get their heads around being told they couldn’t do something in ‘their own company’ - they’ve been watching too many American drama box sets..

Anyway, HR basically just firmly said ‘this is going to cost you a lot of money you don’t have if you pursue this’ and that was essentially that. Really disappointing it came down to money and not the morality of the thing but the outcome is the same.

OP posts:
soulinablackberrypie · 09/04/2022 17:22

What a lovely thread and outcome. I always thought I had the nicest boss in the world, but I'm very happy to say you sound even more awesome!

HangingRock25 · 08/04/2022 09:01

@DGRossetti

Please read ALL of the OP's posts, before responding

Isn't that a one week ban on MN ?
|
|
V

Grin

If it's not, it should be, lol. Smile
DGRossetti · 08/04/2022 08:37

Please read ALL of the OP's posts, before responding

Isn't that a one week ban on MN ?
|
|
V

Grin
HangingRock25 · 08/04/2022 08:17

@Flowersandjellybeans

What does her contract say? I think if you and your company hired her on the understanding she would and can only work from home it’s your problem not hers things have changed.

You can’t just fire her and if you do I sincerely hope she takes you to a tribunal.

@Flowersandjellybeans Please read ALL of the OP's posts, before responding. Not just the Opening post. It was resolved awhile ago.
Flowersandjellybeans · 08/04/2022 08:11

What does her contract say? I think if you and your company hired her on the understanding she would and can only work from home it’s your problem not hers things have changed.

You can’t just fire her and if you do I sincerely hope she takes you to a tribunal.

DGRossetti · 08/04/2022 07:44

I'm baffled why a tech company are going down the road of forcing ppl back into the office.

My reading was this isn't "an IT company". It's a regular old (fashioned and oriented) company that bought an IT company (like some people buy racehorses) and now it's being "harmonized" with the mothership.

BTDTGTTS.

It's hard to understate the power of the the "it's all about me" gene - especially when it's paired up with the "it's not faaaaaaaaaiiiiiiiiir" gene. But usually the reason for not progressing will be a combination of them.

DrDreReturns · 08/04/2022 07:18

@PintLady I think the op said the management had no, or very little, experience in IT. So it doesn't surprise me.

PlntLady · 07/04/2022 22:43

I'm baffled why a tech company are going down the road of forcing ppl back into the office.
I work for a large civils company. They did a survey and determined that from how the staff want to work they only require 40% of the office space. So they have decided to offload 60% of the office space and reinvest money saved into the company & staff with an additional few percent on the original proposed cost of living, better training and IT infrastructure to keep us all hybrid working.
Surely if a civils company can do this, an IT company can allow 1 disabled exemplary member of staff to wfh.