Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When men say "I prefer women without make-up"...

711 replies

ThingThatIBring · 05/04/2022 18:10

AIBU to think that when men say "I prefer women without make-up" that they don't usually know what they're talking about (and don't usually have a clue that women ARE wearing it)?

The reality of this statement is usually:

  • I don't like it when women wear really obvious MAKE-UP make-up (loads of lippy and false eyelashes etc) or when it's badly applied (making it obvious);
  • I like really good-looking fresh-faced young women whose complexions, etc., look smooth without it;
  • I like to think of myself as very wholesome (and maybe a bit of a feminist).

What they DON'T mean (but don't realise they don't mean) is:

  • I prefer the look of the average woman of my own age without any make-up on.

I know so many men who say this, and it always mildly irritates me as it's said like it's a kind of virtue.

As a post-mating-phase human, it's not like it really affects my life. But it always makes me feel for all the women who are still in a position where they're affected by this nonsense...

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
AmberLynn1536 · 06/04/2022 17:23

I’ve seen plenty of men with red noses and they don’t feel the need to cover it.

Some men would want to cover it though, but it’s not really mainstream for men to wear make up. If women are socially conditioned to wear it, it is the opposite for men, in that way women are pretty fortunate, we can cover things we don’t like generally (apart from on this thread) without judgement. I do think things are changing though, the male grooming market is booming, I think the make up best seller for men is concealer and brow gel.

Blossomtoes · 06/04/2022 17:22

At least when its men, we know what we're up against. Attacking, policing and trying to control other women in the name of feminism is the own goal we're not expecting

Totally. I’m so pleased you said that @5128gap.

stripeyflowers · 06/04/2022 17:22

I feel I look cleaner, brighter and fresher and with make up. I've become slightly darker around the eyes and concealer makes a huge difference. I find if I look brighter I feel brighter.

As for what men want, I couldn't give a flying.

gogohm · 06/04/2022 17:20

Neither my dp nor my exh liked makeup. I don't wear much anyway but when I put it on (for myself) I get a you look pretty without it comment

skybluee · 06/04/2022 17:18

Maybe you weren't responding to me but the implication by saying 'Uneven skin tone is a hop, skip & jump away from pigmentation is bad' was that there may be a racial element to it which is what I objected to as there isn't.

No, the reason I feel self conscious is that locally in the past I've had a lot of people make comments which makes me apprehensive about it happening again as I do not want that. I agree that society heavily values women based on looks which is wrong IMO.

However, the reason I apply make-up is because I want to and I feel better and happier that way. I don't apply it because I care what stupid kids (who make comments) or random people who make comments think, just like I wouldn't not apply it because of what someone on this thread said.

5128, what you say is really interesting. I'm glad you don't think being barefaced would've made you a better feminist because I strongly identify as a feminist and hate the thought that wearing make-up would affect that. To me it should be irrelevant really.

AmberLynn, I think Cameron Diaz is stunning. Yes, I've been shocked by some of the comments on this thread! Thanks for what you said. To me feminism should be about making your own choice and I think I find the negative comments from other women about women ironic/sad in the same way you do.

Interestingly, I've seen there's a massive increase in the amount of men wearing make-up and ranges for men being brought out. I wonder if people feel the same way about that?

5128gap · 06/04/2022 17:13

@Stravaig

I wasn't responding to you *@skybluee*.

One of the reasons you feel so self-conscious is that society values women based on their looks, and teaches all of us that we're not acceptable unless we look a certain way! Do whatever makes you feel more comfortable, but be very clear as where the source of oppression is.

I think most if us are very clear about oppression by men. What is far more insidious is when certain women with their 'don't do what the men tell you, do what I tell you instead' approach grasp the baton. At least when its men, we know what we're up against. Attacking, policing and trying to control other women in the name of feminism is the own goal we're not expecting.
lightisnotwhite · 06/04/2022 17:07

@skybluee I’ve seen plenty of men with red noses and they don’t feel the need to cover it.

Look it’s easy to cover a “flaw” with makeup and I totally understand why you would feel better being flawless. I think yours is less make up and more akin to wearing a loose top to cover a fat tummy or only wearing jeans to cover veiny legs. I do get it.
But ultimately we have to remember it’s everyone else’s problem not yours. Perceptions can be changed.

Blossomtoes · 06/04/2022 17:02

but be very clear as where the source of oppression is

Indeed. Hitler was very clear about his love of the unadorned female face. When the camps were liberated it was the lipsticks sent by mistake that all the women fell on. That tells me everything I need to know about make up and oppression.

AmberLynn1536 · 06/04/2022 17:01

Yes @skybluee some of the comments about women who wear make up have been awful, and the fact that those particular posters think they are supporting the sisterhood and railing against the patriarchy whilst insulting women who wear make up is laughable. Make up of some form or other has been used for around 6,000 years, it’s not going anywhere! Don’t let these posters upset you, there are loads of us who love make up, pretty much every single famous beautiful woman and probably a lot of the men too enhance their appearance in some form. Cameron Diaz does not have the best skin and she wears make up, you are in good company.

When men say "I prefer women without make-up"...
5128gap · 06/04/2022 17:00

Skybluee, I have spent the last 30+ years supporting women, campaigning for improvements to the lives of women, and challenging discrimination against women, both professionally and in my own time. The majority of the time, I manage to somehow skillfully combine this with wearing lipstick and mascara, without that detracting in the least from the benefits of my work. Had I sat barefaced at my keyboard telling other women they were shallow and brainwashed by the patriarchy because they wear make up, I don't think that would have made me a better feminist or improved the life of one single woman.

Stravaig · 06/04/2022 16:59

I wasn't responding to you @skybluee.

One of the reasons you feel so self-conscious is that society values women based on their looks, and teaches all of us that we're not acceptable unless we look a certain way! Do whatever makes you feel more comfortable, but be very clear as where the source of oppression is.

skybluee · 06/04/2022 16:52

No it isn't Stravaig and I don't like that implication at all. You try living with the nose in the above pic and stupid comments from people and see if you wouldn't want to apply something so your nose is the same colour as the rest of your face and you can forget about it. There are different degrees of everything. I'm not talking about freckles or a bit of a flush, I'm talking about a neon nose. I personally think you're being ridiculous if you can't understand at least why I would want to feel good in myself and confident rather than self conscious and actually unhappy, when it can be fixed in a matter of minutes, but I shouldn't cover it for the sake of not wearing make-up?

MichaelAndEagle · 06/04/2022 16:48

My 'no make up, don't do anything to my face' friend has beautiful skin, nicely shaped eyebrows, dark eye lashes.
She also has very easy hair and is amazed at the fuss most women seem to go to.
I think actually its easier for some than others.

Stravaig · 06/04/2022 16:41

'Uneven skin tone' is a hop, skip & jump away from 'pigmentation is bad'. I have freckles and splotches and patches of pigment, I flush easily, I'm weathered by time and the elements. I have no idea what an 'even skin tone' is, or why I should find it interesting or desirable.

skybluee · 06/04/2022 16:34

Thank you so much for saying that AmberLynn. I really struggle without make-up and find it quite hard reading things that say people who like wearing it are being vain, vapid, all of the other insults, some of which are on this thread. That it's sad that women wear it and don't embrace themselves. I don't feel comfortable posting a picture of my own face (maybe later!) but I've found a picture on google that's the closest I can find to how my own is. I can cover this up in about two minutes and I feel so much better for it. I do not feel comfortable going into e.g. a shop without it and in the past have had quite bad comments. There is no amount of exercise or sleep that will get rid of it. I've had it since I was about 13.

People make statements about how you should embrace not wearing make-up, that you're anti-feminist if you wear make-up, so many different things. But for me the reality is that I feel bad if I don't wear it and I really wish people would understand, more than anything else, that their own experience of not wearing make-up is not transferable to everyone.

When men say "I prefer women without make-up"...
maddy68 · 06/04/2022 16:27

@PickAChew

I've never had a man say this to me.
Also this

Never ever ever have I heard a man say this

I have heard men and woman say they prefer a natural look which may mean the same, or it could refer to casual clothes or any number of preferences

maddy68 · 06/04/2022 16:25

Well I don't think women look great with too much make up on either. Surely everyone has a "looks" preference?

AmberLynn1536 · 06/04/2022 16:24

Looking tired is best addressed by sleep. Terrible skin by fresh air, exercise, healthy eating. Not by applying makeup to create the illusion of being well-rested or in good health

Fresh air won’t magically erase broken veins, uneven skin tone, they won’t suddenly become invisible to the naked eye because I’ve gone for a brisk walk or pumped some iron, I eat healthily, exercise daily but still have uneven skin tone and only make up will even that out. As for looking tired some women have dark circles no matter how many hours of sleep they get.

AmberLynn1536 · 06/04/2022 16:10

[quote MurmuratingStarling]@AmberLynn1536 Jen and Meg look beautiful up there. ^ Well they are beautiful anyway, but the make up enhances them, and brings out their best features. Smile[/quote]
Don’t they just! Both very beautiful women.

Stravaig · 06/04/2022 16:08

What's most noticeable to me in the before/after pics at 15:27 is her freckles have been obliterated! To create a bland, uniform complexion. In a supposedly ever more diverse society, are we really still saying that natural pigmentation is bad?

Looking tired is best addressed by sleep. Terrible skin by fresh air, exercise, healthy eating. Not by applying makeup to create the illusion of being well-rested or in good health.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 06/04/2022 16:07

Considering the amount of make up many women wear (orange foundation like a mask, vivid bronzer, huge false eyelashes, giant brows, sticky looking lipgloss) I can see why some men prefer the no makeup look.

They probably mean they prefer women who look natural (maybe they’re wearing light make up but it’s not noticeable as it blends into their skin and enhances rather than looks like paint?) Eg who can tell if a woman is wearing tinted moisturiser/concealer, discreet lipstick in a natural shade etc?

So many women seem to go for the false lashes, heavy liner, or clumpy mascara and clumsy contouring look it’s hard to see what they actually look like!

MurmuratingStarling · 06/04/2022 16:03

Not making any difference @5128gap (sorry!) BUT I agree the teeth are very similar, and the eyes too. So maybe it IS the same woman. Smile

As you (and someone else said,) make up can change someone dramatically!

SnackSizeRaisin · 06/04/2022 16:03

I rarely wear make up. 2 of my past boyfriends said they preferred no make up. One was always on at me to wear it. All 3 of them liked short skirts though.
Personally I think it looks nice in the evening but a bit try hard in the day. I don't think anyone looks more beautiful with make up though - they look like they have made an effort, which obviously can be a good thing. Beauty is to do with health and youth and bone structure and a good night's sleep and confidence - not darker eyelashes or a bit of powder on your skin.

MurmuratingStarling · 06/04/2022 16:01

@AmberLynn1536 Jen and Meg look beautiful up there. ^ Well they are beautiful anyway, but the make up enhances them, and brings out their best features. Smile

MurmuratingStarling · 06/04/2022 15:59

@5128gap

🤣

I will give it a go!!!