Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When men say "I prefer women without make-up"...

711 replies

ThingThatIBring · 05/04/2022 18:10

AIBU to think that when men say "I prefer women without make-up" that they don't usually know what they're talking about (and don't usually have a clue that women ARE wearing it)?

The reality of this statement is usually:

  • I don't like it when women wear really obvious MAKE-UP make-up (loads of lippy and false eyelashes etc) or when it's badly applied (making it obvious);
  • I like really good-looking fresh-faced young women whose complexions, etc., look smooth without it;
  • I like to think of myself as very wholesome (and maybe a bit of a feminist).

What they DON'T mean (but don't realise they don't mean) is:

  • I prefer the look of the average woman of my own age without any make-up on.

I know so many men who say this, and it always mildly irritates me as it's said like it's a kind of virtue.

As a post-mating-phase human, it's not like it really affects my life. But it always makes me feel for all the women who are still in a position where they're affected by this nonsense...

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
MidnightMeltdown · 06/04/2022 00:31

@JulieBeds

I see your point to some extent but I don't think women wear makeup specifically for men. People are drawn to beauty, whether it's beautiful scenery, beautiful plants, beautiful art, beautiful people etc.

When I was a teenager my mother would ask me to put some makeup on before we went out because she wanted people to think that she had a beautiful daughter. Clearly the aim wasn't to attract men.

I once knew someone who disapproved of women wearing makeup, but that person had a very beautiful home with very expensive furniture etc. Surely the aim here is also to impress people? Is this any less shallow?

mathanxiety · 06/04/2022 00:31

@BoredZelda, men expressing a preference for women who don't wear makeup is such an established thing that it is worthy of comment here. It's not sexist to point out sexism and complain about sexists. They happen to be men and we're not obliged to pretend they're not.

Men who make remarks like this, either to women or to other men, are so blithely lacking in self awareness that they fail to appreciate how arrogant they are, and how faulty is their assumption that women wear makeup for their benefit.

Nobody asked their opinion. It's yet another example of men trying to tell women how they should live their lives, mansplaining to the nth degree.

Midlifemusings · 06/04/2022 00:29

I have never worn make-up and men don't care. They are fine with a natual look.

I also prefer men who don't wear make-up.

I don't think it is a big deal. Men, like women have preferences. Some prefer a natural look, others like a look that has a little make-up, others like a lot of make-up. A preference for no make-up doesn't make some misogynist. Many women don't wear make-up. It is okay for men to like us too!

BoredZelda · 06/04/2022 00:16

Like virtually everything else being flogged on the high street and in the supermarket and all over the internet then...

To be fair, the money spent on advertising in the beauty/fashion industry isn’t exactly equal to that of most other things we buy. Heinz aren’t playing on my insecurities when they try to convince me to buy their beanz.

BoredZelda · 06/04/2022 00:10

To all the women saying you don’t do it for men, you do it for yourself, tell me, if you lived on a desert island would you bother to put on any slap?

Probably not. Why? Because there’d be no one to see you.

Not even a desert island. I’ve often wondered if women who wear make up, do it in the house if they aren’t planning on going anywhere and if so, how does that sit with “I’m doing it for me”

mathanxiety · 06/04/2022 00:07

It tricks you into thinking you need it

Like virtually everything else being flogged on the high street and in the supermarket and all over the internet then...

BoredZelda · 06/04/2022 00:05

it was a reasonably sensible debate before. Thank goodness you’re here.

Oh my, your bar for that is really low

My point, if you bothered to think about it, is that men I reference couldn’t give one hoot what the woman in question wants. It’s not just a preference - which, of course, everyone is entitled to - it’s that, they want a woman to be only what they want her to be. It wouldn’t occur to them to find a woman who fits their ideals (probably because they don’t exist) - no, far easier to find a woman and make her conform. These aren’t cases where a man has a preference and keeps it to himself, it’s when he actively seeks to influence a woman’s choices. THAT’S what I have an issue with.

Which isn’t what the OP was talking about. And also isn’t just something men do either. How many times do we see posts about women complaining their husbands just aren’t what they want them to be? Off out too much at their “hobby” or workaholics or not doing housework etc. Women marry or have kids with men then complain they are essentially still the same as before they married them and why won’t they change. I guess the men you are referencing are just a bit more superficial about what they are looking for in a partner.

Fizbosshoes · 05/04/2022 23:50

I rarely wear makeup up because I'm pretty lazy and DH doesn't seem to mind, although I'm sure he thinks I look better with it on.

He hasn't the faintest idea about hair though and thinks every 40 or 50 something year old womens hair is its natural colour!! I'm not sure what he thinks all the hairdressers in our town do!

JulieBeds · 05/04/2022 23:46

To all the women saying you don’t do it for men, you do it for yourself, tell me, if you lived on a desert island would you bother to put on any slap?

Probably not. Why? Because there’d be no one to see you.

It’s other people’s opinions of you that you care about, be they men or women. You’re not doing it for yourself. You have a sense of identity about how you wish to present yourself to the world, and that may consist of some make up. But don’t pretend it’s for yourself, it’s for everyone else to perceive you in the way you wish to be perceived.

As for men primping and preening, how do you think that whole male beauty thing took off?

The beauty brands saw how fucking gullible women were and decided to unpick the male ego in exactly the same way. It’s taken the best part of two decades but they’ve succeeded. But when I was growing up, men really didn’t care about their hair etc

The beauty industry plays in our biggest human truth:

Everyone, yes everyone feels like they aren’t good enough, just as they are. everyone has something they’d change. Even supermodels and fit blokes, underneath, somewhere, something niggles. It’s a universal human truth to not feel good enough. We all feel it and the beauty industry is living proof that if they tried hard enough eventually they’d crack men and add 50% extra market share to their bottom line.

And as for trickery, yes, make up can be a form of trickery. It tricks you into thinking you need it. It tricks you into thinking you’re somehow “less” without it. It tricks you into thinking that women wearing it are somehow better than you, more worthy than you.

And as for it being an investment, my time spent getting to know someone/anyone is a form of investment. Time and money are somewhat synonymous for me. I’m not going to insult anyone with some weird plumped up, preened up version of myself only to at some stage present a different less coloured in version. Why would I do that? Take me as I am.

Think of Kim Kardashian. There’s a cost, mental, physical and emotional, to looking that way and she’s free to take that choice but it looks exhausting, unhealthy and a strange road to travel. Not one I’d want. It’s not real life for most women and she sets a ridiculous impossible unhealthy standard that others follow who haven’t had time to mature and grow and truly understand the nature of what real female beauty is. She’s extremely wealthy, but she’s made her money by playing into all the same insecurities that the same media playbook uses over and over again: You’re Not Good Enough As You Are and my Spanx will save you from your hellish rotten body.

You could call her a genius for actually using the existing beauty industries’ playbook at us women once again. She’s made the money instead of a group of pale, stale executive males.

But woman to woman I’d say she’s betrayed us.

I wish her no ill but I find her abhorrent for what she’s done to so many many women.

worriedatthistime · 05/04/2022 23:45

@HesterShaw1 nowhere did it say random man walks uo to a woman and says this , people to people they know and yes I will of said to men I prefer clean shaven etc even if they have a beard as thats my preference , I have said it to my dh as well because its the truth I do prefer a clean shaven man when going by appearance
Im not walking up to a stranger in the street and saying it but in conversations with men and women and general chit chat

worriedatthistime · 05/04/2022 23:41

@BoredZelda exactly this is actually one of the most sexist sites I know by people who want equality but clearly they don't as they can't see how wrong some of the things they are saying are

MidnightMeltdown · 05/04/2022 23:39

@TheVillageOfUpperDenture

One of my exes is now an Academic. He never liked me wearing make up said 'it's like women are wearing fake mask'. I asked him why? because his Mum wears it and he said 'I know, it's tarty'. I wore eyeshadow, mascara and lipstick fairly muted colours. no blusher ot foundation or bright colours. No other blokes commented or gave me a disapproving look when i wore it.

Never approved of me wearing it. I was 17 when we went out for a few years. He married someone who never wears makeup.

I felt free when i could wear it again.

I've had a similar experience with male academics. It's because academia is male dominated, and many (not all) successful female academics look and behave like men. They have to if they want to be taken seriously.

I wear make up and once worked with a male academic who used to complain about women wearing makeup. It made me feel really uncomfortable. A few months later he started coming on to me, despite the fact that he was 20 years older than me. Clearly he didn't dislike makeup that much....

BoredZelda · 05/04/2022 23:38

I imagine you tell men who are wearing a beard that you would "prefer" them if they shaved it off?

No? Why not? Is it because it's nothing to do with you and you realise it would be really rude, and they wouldn't give a shit what you, a random woman, thinks?

Nowhere in the OP, did they speak about men going up to women wearing makeup and telling them not to wear makeup.

But crack on with the imaginary situations.

Idriveelectric · 05/04/2022 23:29

I never wear makeup, never have. DH perfectly happy with me, together 42 years. DIL often over made up. Such a shame, on the odd time we've seen her without we both agree she looks much better. Ah well, each to their own!

HesterShaw1 · 05/04/2022 23:25

@BoredZelda

Frankly any sentence that starts with 'I prefer women with/without/who...' is a bit shit.

Ain’t that the truth. These men never stop to think for one teeny moment what the woman wants, it’s aaaalllll about them.

Presumably people are allowed to have a preference on what they find attractive? I prefer men without facial hair. I’m sure men who have it, do it for themselves and not to attract women. I also don’t particularly like the ripped look, or a guy who is immaculately groomed. It’s ok for men to state a preference for the kind of woman they prefer. Women have the choice whether they date a guy or not too.

I imagine you tell men who are wearing a beard that you would "prefer" them if they shaved it off?

No? Why not? Is it because it's nothing to do with you and you realise it would be really rude, and they wouldn't give a shit what you, a random woman, thinks?

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 05/04/2022 23:24

I don't care what men think about women wearing make up.

GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 05/04/2022 23:19

Oh good, @BoredZelda, it was a reasonably sensible debate before. Thank goodness you’re here.

My point, if you bothered to think about it, is that men I reference couldn’t give one hoot what the woman in question wants. It’s not just a preference - which, of course, everyone is entitled to - it’s that, they want a woman to be only what they want her to be. It wouldn’t occur to them to find a woman who fits their ideals (probably because they don’t exist) - no, far easier to find a woman and make her conform. These aren’t cases where a man has a preference and keeps it to himself, it’s when he actively seeks to influence a woman’s choices. THAT’S what I have an issue with.

WeasilyPleased · 05/04/2022 23:14

My dh couldn't care less about the amount or lack of make-up I have on. Seriously couldn't give a monkeys. He says I look good with or without. He's delusional but I loves him I do.

TheVillageOfUpperDenture · 05/04/2022 23:12

One of my exes is now an Academic. He never liked me wearing make up said 'it's like women are wearing fake mask'. I asked him why? because his Mum wears it and he said 'I know, it's tarty'. I wore eyeshadow, mascara and lipstick fairly muted colours. no blusher ot foundation or bright colours. No other blokes commented or gave me a disapproving look when i wore it.

Never approved of me wearing it. I was 17 when we went out for a few years. He married someone who never wears makeup.

I felt free when i could wear it again.

BoredZelda · 05/04/2022 23:03

Frankly any sentence that starts with 'I prefer women with/without/who...' is a bit shit.

Ain’t that the truth. These men never stop to think for one teeny moment what the woman wants, it’s aaaalllll about them.

Presumably people are allowed to have a preference on what they find attractive? I prefer men without facial hair. I’m sure men who have it, do it for themselves and not to attract women. I also don’t particularly like the ripped look, or a guy who is immaculately groomed. It’s ok for men to state a preference for the kind of woman they prefer. Women have the choice whether they date a guy or not too.

BogRollBOGOF · 05/04/2022 23:01

Good job DH likes me without make-up, I've only put some on on 3 occasions in the past two years. Grin
I look slightly more polished with it on, but that's about it.
I don't go for heavier styles as I don't think it does my skin or features any favours anyway. Heavy for me is a tinted moisturiser.
I'm still looking decent 20+ years on, and we're aging naturally together.

BoredZelda · 05/04/2022 22:57

Jeez oh, the man hating on here is rife tonight.

If they say it they don’t mean it, they are too stupid to know when a woman is wearing makeup or not, or they are pretending to be a nice guy but are actually raging misogynists. Or both.

I haven’t worn makeup since my 20s. Can’t be arsed with the faff. My husband seems not to care that I don’t. I couldn’t care less what any other man thinks about it.

LittleMissUnreasonable · 05/04/2022 22:56

I've heard only one man say this before. He is completely overbearing with his partner and posts weird social media status' about 'his' beautiful GF like she's some sort of possession. Gives me the ick everytime I see his face. Incidentally she doesn't ever wear makeup so no idea why he has to make a song and dance about women who do wear makeup like their inferior or care at all what he thinks

breadfan1 · 05/04/2022 22:55

I am not daft enough to voice an opinion out loud. I know how long it takes Mrs breadfan to scrub up. But I do sometimes wake up and watch her asleep and see the lines that weren’t there 20 years ago and love that we have seen so much of life together. She’s still very discreet about my physical changes. 🙏

mathanxiety · 05/04/2022 22:54

Men don't bother with this level of pressure

Bless your naivete.

What do you think all those sweating men are doing at gyms all over the western world? Improving their cardiovascular function? 😂

The men buying exactly the right pair of jeans? Exactly the right car, which they lovingly work on all weekend?

All the men getting peaky blinders haircuts and expensive barber services? Buying beard oil by the gallon? And the market for hair regrowth serum is worth millions.

Men absolutely pay attention to markers of masculinity.