Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When men say "I prefer women without make-up"...

711 replies

ThingThatIBring · 05/04/2022 18:10

AIBU to think that when men say "I prefer women without make-up" that they don't usually know what they're talking about (and don't usually have a clue that women ARE wearing it)?

The reality of this statement is usually:

  • I don't like it when women wear really obvious MAKE-UP make-up (loads of lippy and false eyelashes etc) or when it's badly applied (making it obvious);
  • I like really good-looking fresh-faced young women whose complexions, etc., look smooth without it;
  • I like to think of myself as very wholesome (and maybe a bit of a feminist).

What they DON'T mean (but don't realise they don't mean) is:

  • I prefer the look of the average woman of my own age without any make-up on.

I know so many men who say this, and it always mildly irritates me as it's said like it's a kind of virtue.

As a post-mating-phase human, it's not like it really affects my life. But it always makes me feel for all the women who are still in a position where they're affected by this nonsense...

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
IcedPurple · 06/04/2022 08:33

Heterosexual women generally want to attract men as partners.

But it's not like women are going around every day of their lives looking for a man. Many women spend most of their adult lives either already in a relationship or not bothered. Yet these women may still wear make up and pay attention to their appearance.

Women don't spend their lives looking for men. There are lots of them about, and most of them not up to much.

5128gap · 06/04/2022 08:32

@Emergency73

Surely as women we need to not buy into all this crap - and that will be a big step towards eradicating what you describe above?
If every single woman everywhere made a pact not to enhance their appearance, there would be a drop, for want of a better word (change, maybe better) in the beauty standards men expected, certainly. But it would not eradicate the inequalities arising from women's different levels of attractiveness. Amongst all the new 'natural only' women, some would be naturally better looking than others and would have greater opportunities because of it. Before too long, other women would look to emulate the physical characteristics of those naturally better looking women in order to increase their own opportunities. While men value looks, it will never be eradicated. So I think the best that can be hoped for is to understand it, navigate it yourself in accordance with your own cost benefit analysis, respect other women's rights to do the same, and offer some counterbalance by our own valuing of other women for reasons unrelated to looks.
Comedycook · 06/04/2022 08:32

when I encounter a woman in perfectly normal workaday circumstances who is heavily made-up and bright orange, it makes me think that she must have got out of bed an hour earlier to wallop it on

You could just as easily encounter a woman who has a full face of subtle make up which has taken hours to achieve but you barely notice. You probably don't judge them

stuckdownahole · 06/04/2022 08:31

@DrSbaitso

Extrapolating from one or two bad experiences, I have a theory that women who wear a lot of very heavy, very obvious, very unsubtle make-up are not the brightest.

Ironically, extrapolating this from one or two bad experiences isn't the brightest thing to do.

No, but we all do it, I reckon.
Changechangychange · 06/04/2022 08:31

To all the women saying you don’t do it for men, you do it for yourself, tell me, if you lived on a desert island would you bother to put on any slap?

Assuming this is some kind of full-service desert island with hot water, electricity and mirrors, and no humidity to make it instantly slide off my face, yes I would. Only mascara and foundation/tinted moisturiser, but that’s all I wear now.

It’s like saying “if you were on a desert island, would you really bother brushing your hair?” Most people would want to.

LowlyTheWorm · 06/04/2022 08:31

@Silverclocks

I sometimes think I live in an alternative universe.

Men might like a certain sort of women to look at in pictures, but genuinely, the men I know in real life like women who are fun and interesting. This applies to everyone from DH, my Dad, my sons, my friends, my friends" husbands and my colleagues.

These men are nothing particularly special to look at themselves and perhaps that makes a difference, but if any of them care much about looks they hide it well. They find their partners attractive, but they see something in them that others don't.

I love this. As someone who genuinely wears no make up, I just don’t understand people who do on a daily basis. The new heavier make up in particular is just so sad- those people who don’t look anything like themselves… why? Even that Reddit post with the four looks- the no make up woman looked fine to me and her makeup hid her ethnicity which was sad.

So yes the men in my life (adult son, young son and dh) love me for me and it’s nice for me to see DS has chosen girlfriends who are not the typical insta type made up.

Surely we need to look at why women are brought up to think it’s normal to hide what they look like and why they think that what they look like is so damned important. So may people say “oh but it is for ME” but that’s just not true is it? It’s so sad that people want this generic look so much and use filters- even on babies.

OutingHobby · 06/04/2022 08:29

Extrapolating from one or two bad experiences, I have a theory that women who wear a lot of very heavy, very obvious, very unsubtle make-up are not the brightest. It makes me wary of them in any professional setting. at least you are aware of your prejudice I guess.

Emergency73 · 06/04/2022 08:29

Yes we don’t need male approval - but how much of make up is about male approval. How much of this are we actually subconsciously accepting - whereas consciously we’d say no!! Every time we ‘plump up our lips’ or go for a silky youthful dewy glow.

DrSbaitso · 06/04/2022 08:28

Extrapolating from one or two bad experiences, I have a theory that women who wear a lot of very heavy, very obvious, very unsubtle make-up are not the brightest.

Ironically, extrapolating this from one or two bad experiences isn't the brightest thing to do.

Emergency73 · 06/04/2022 08:27

*male!! Not make

stuckdownahole · 06/04/2022 08:26

@OutingHobby

But having said that, when I encounter a woman in perfectly normal workaday circumstances who is heavily made-up and bright orange, it makes me think that she must have got out of bed an hour earlier to wallop it on, and I wonder about the priorities of anyone who would bother with that it's her choice though. You should spend less time focusing on what she looks like and more time on what she's saying.
I think you've hit the nail on the head.

Extrapolating from one or two bad experiences, I have a theory that women who wear a lot of very heavy, very obvious, very unsubtle make-up are not the brightest. It makes me wary of them in any professional setting.

They don't need my male approval of their appearance and they haven't missed out by not getting it. It's a prejudice about professional norms, not about attractiveness.

Emergency73 · 06/04/2022 08:26

@5128gap

Yes - and I do exactly the same! What you are saying is exactly how things are. BUT how much of this is as a result of sexist conditioning/marketing since I’ve been young. I think it’s really good to question WHY I do it - to challenge it. For my DD - I’d actually prefer things to be different. She’s nearly a teenager now. And I’d rather she didn’t see me pursuing ‘plump lips’ and ‘youthful glow’ over being ‘ready for action’ as my make deodorant advocates?

Lunar27 · 06/04/2022 08:23

@Emergency73

I’m a bit hmm about make up. Is it really necessary anyway? I wear it - but isn’t the whole premise about it to ‘make myself look better’ - and why should I need to look different to how I am? Why should women be ‘expected’/or generally do wear more make up then men? Why do I need to ‘minimise my wrinkles’, why do I need to make my lips look plumper? Why do I need to have longer eyelashes? How much make up is about trying to look more sexually attractive to men? So actually it depends on the reason a man says ‘I prefer no make up’. If it’s from a perspective of - be yourself, than I’d support that.
Short answer, you don't.

I'm a man and clearly you don't need my opinion but whilst I appreciate that men are dicks (who mostly grow up thinking women are on this planet solely for their pleasure) some of us see the overwhelming media and marketing pressure and think it sucks. We're happy to support our wives and importantly our daughters just being themselves and not fueling a multi billion pound industry that rams ideals of beauty down their throats.

OutingHobby · 06/04/2022 08:21

@stuckdownahole maybe she doesn't want to sleep. So not only does she have to look a certain way she has to spend her free time doing what you think she should be doing.

DrSbaitso · 06/04/2022 08:21

Sleeping!

And if she's a naturally early riser? If she goes to bed early because she wants an hour in the morning to do something else? If she doesn't start her shift until 10am? If she just bloody well chooses to rise early to style herself the way she wants?

Her "priorities" are wrong because she isn't lying in bed like you'd choose to do?

5128gap · 06/04/2022 08:20

[quote Emergency73]@5128gap

Ok so the whole marketing if ‘minimise wrinkles, plumper lips, luscious lashes, youthful glow’…what’s that all about - if not about sexual attraction.[/quote]
Well its obviously rooted in sexual attraction. I never said otherwise, did I? As in my post above, the more attractive a woman is, the more likely she will attract a man she wants to have sex with or form a partnership with. I didn't make those rules, and I'm not pretending they don't exist. There are nuances within that, as other people have said, women want to look a certain way for themselves too and for other women. Me, for example. I have a partner and am not after another, but do enjoy making myself look what I consider to be aesthetically pleasing (to me) as I prefer looking at things I find visually attractive, including my own reflection.

OutingHobby · 06/04/2022 08:19

But having said that, when I encounter a woman in perfectly normal workaday circumstances who is heavily made-up and bright orange, it makes me think that she must have got out of bed an hour earlier to wallop it on, and I wonder about the priorities of anyone who would bother with that it's her choice though. You should spend less time focusing on what she looks like and more time on what she's saying.

Emergency73 · 06/04/2022 08:19

Surely as women we need to not buy into all this crap - and that will be a big step towards eradicating what you describe above?

stuckdownahole · 06/04/2022 08:18

@DrSbaitso

when I encounter a woman in perfectly normal workaday circumstances who is heavily made-up and bright orange, it makes me think that she must have got out of bed an hour earlier to wallop it on, and I wonder about the priorities of anyone who would bother with that.

What should she have been doing instead?

Sleeping!
Emergency73 · 06/04/2022 08:17

@5128gap - yes, but why are we playing into cosmetic companies hands and paying a fortune for it. I just looked at my deodorant spray. I’ve got two - a mans cheaper one, a woman’s more expensive one. The mans one is 48hours and all about power, action, ready to go. The women’s one is 48 hours and all soft and gentle. And delicate pretty, pastel colours. I deliberately reached for the men’s one this morning.

DrSbaitso · 06/04/2022 08:16

when I encounter a woman in perfectly normal workaday circumstances who is heavily made-up and bright orange, it makes me think that she must have got out of bed an hour earlier to wallop it on, and I wonder about the priorities of anyone who would bother with that.

What should she have been doing instead?

DrSbaitso · 06/04/2022 08:16

Actually I saw ab eyeshadow tutorial the other day for a style I intend to try for an upcoming event. It's a fun aesthetic. Not male gaze sexy, just pretty and unusual looking. Some people enjoy playing with makeup. In fact, people who are really, really into it often see it as a kind of wearable, transient art. And some of their skills are incredible.

stuckdownahole · 06/04/2022 08:15

I'm male. I am ambivalent about make-up, as lots of PPs have said, it's part of an overall style. The current "fake" look with drawn-on eyebrows and obvious lip fillers is something I find bizarre, but I'm old now. The equivalent in my day was the Goth look.

But having said that, when I encounter a woman in perfectly normal workaday circumstances who is heavily made-up and bright orange, it makes me think that she must have got out of bed an hour earlier to wallop it on, and I wonder about the priorities of anyone who would bother with that.

DrSbaitso · 06/04/2022 08:06

To all the women saying you don’t do it for men, you do it for yourself, tell me, if you lived on a desert island would you bother to put on any slap?

Of course not. I'd be too busy hunting, fishing, starting fires and looking for buried treasure.

But the fact that I don't wear makeup or attractive clothes when I'm at home all day slobbing doesn't mean that I'm thinking about being sexy for men when I create a style and aesthetic that I like, that expresses myself, when I'm out and about.

It's fine not to like makeup or want to wear it, but being ludicrously puritanical about it suggests a different motivation.

5128gap · 06/04/2022 08:02

[quote JulieBeds]@MidnightMeltdown

In my earlier post on this thread the first line I wrote us is “women wear make-up for other women”. There’s more there, might be worth reading.

Your mum was looking for a raise in status and decided a beautiful daughter would give her access to greater status in your town.

Most people are on a hunt for status of some kind. It’s very normal.

Historically women have been objectified, unable to have equal status as men. We’ve gained it in other ways and there are other societal constructs about how women raise their status in society vs men.

I guess I think in a time when we no longer need to bark back to old archetypes and tropes about how to raise our status as women, the one thing we should not be doing is encouraging beauty for women as one of them. But it seems no one can think for themselves and the media is so loud these days and social media all powerful.

Objectification has never been more present and powerful.[/quote]
This is all very well as a theory. But it ignores a large slice of reality. Heterosexual women generally want to attract men as partners. A primary selection criteria for men when choosing a female partner is her looks. A woman who is perceived as attractive has far more options when selecting a partner than one who isn't. And the argument that some men ('the good ones') prefer other traits over looks, is based on the erroneous assumption that women can either be attractive OR have qualities such as intelligence, humour and so on, when in fact, they are not mutually exclusive. Women who are attractive have a huge advantage. Until this is no longer the case, which I predict will be never, women will be obliged to be interested in how attractive they are, unless they are not looking for a partner, or are prepared to accept a smaller pool from which to select. Accepting this unpalatable truth is not the same as an inability to think for oneself.

Swipe left for the next trending thread