Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

When men say "I prefer women without make-up"...

711 replies

ThingThatIBring · 05/04/2022 18:10

AIBU to think that when men say "I prefer women without make-up" that they don't usually know what they're talking about (and don't usually have a clue that women ARE wearing it)?

The reality of this statement is usually:

  • I don't like it when women wear really obvious MAKE-UP make-up (loads of lippy and false eyelashes etc) or when it's badly applied (making it obvious);
  • I like really good-looking fresh-faced young women whose complexions, etc., look smooth without it;
  • I like to think of myself as very wholesome (and maybe a bit of a feminist).

What they DON'T mean (but don't realise they don't mean) is:

  • I prefer the look of the average woman of my own age without any make-up on.

I know so many men who say this, and it always mildly irritates me as it's said like it's a kind of virtue.

As a post-mating-phase human, it's not like it really affects my life. But it always makes me feel for all the women who are still in a position where they're affected by this nonsense...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
18
MarshmallowSwede · 12/04/2022 18:36

I’m amused at the man coming all the way to mumsnet to argue with women about makeup.

So many other activities, yet they always come!

They just can’t help themselves can they.

Again.. this is a situation where the only response is “who the fuck asked you?!”

No one is asking for men’s opinions on makeup, and women should wear it if they want pr don’t wear it if they don’t.

I’ve yet to see women going out of our way to campaign for all women to wear makeup. Do what you want.

Do men ever have a day where unsolicited opinions are off? I can’t imagine what it feels like to go around telling men my opinions on how they look.

Yet they always go out of their way.. take entire detours to make sure women know we somehow some way need to live up to their likes.

Who tf cares if they like it or not? Men still will come if you’re barefaced. The fact that we are all alive and makeup didn’t exist for our hominid ancestors shows makeup or no makeup some sexing is going to happen.

It would happen more if men shut the f-k up. But here we are. Not sure if it’s hormones or what.. but I’m sick of hearing about what men like.

Blackmagicqueen · 12/04/2022 18:19

"They honestly think I'm lying when I say I don't apply any moisturiser, or creams."

I would advise a minimal of moisturiser with spf protection for summer.

aurynne · 12/04/2022 09:21

@5128gap that could be, if I ever actually mentioned makeup or the fact I don't wear it. Thing is, I can't recall a single time that makeup enters my conversation because for me it is a non issue. It only gets mentioned when someone else does. In fact this thread is the only time I remember talking about makeup. The cases in which other women are in disbelief often starts because someone else starts asking about foundation/creams/etc and someone asks me, I say "I have no idea, I don't use any", and the shock and horror of it starts there. Not because my face is particularly beautiful or my skin perfect... their disbelief originates in the fact I don't use any product apart from water and soap and that apparently is as rare as to require some kind of proof.

5128gap · 11/04/2022 11:09

@aurynne

"Sounds like you are very lucky to have the kind of skin where people think you are wearing make up. And to have had the experience of life whereby you can consider that the skin problems of people who wear make up tend to be caused by the make up itself. Lucky you."

I don't look like I wear makeup at all, my skin is very average. But many women honestly do not believe other women do not, genuinely, wear makeup or foundation or "at least something!". They honestly think I'm lying when I say I don't apply any moisturiser, or creams. They are THAT conditioned to think that no woman would dare to show their face unless it is somehow "improved".

I would say it's more likely they're just trying to compliment you with exaggerated disbelief. A bit like when someone proudly announces they're 55 or whatever, and people pretend not to believe them. Its a reasonably predictable, polite response to someone saying they don't use products. Social convention would mean most wouldn't say 'Yes, I can tell'. Given loads of women don't wear make up, I think its a reach to suggest they really can't conceive of one who doesn't.
aurynne · 11/04/2022 01:25

"Sounds like you are very lucky to have the kind of skin where people think you are wearing make up. And to have had the experience of life whereby you can consider that the skin problems of people who wear make up tend to be caused by the make up itself. Lucky you."

I don't look like I wear makeup at all, my skin is very average. But many women honestly do not believe other women do not, genuinely, wear makeup or foundation or "at least something!". They honestly think I'm lying when I say I don't apply any moisturiser, or creams. They are THAT conditioned to think that no woman would dare to show their face unless it is somehow "improved".

TurquoiseDragon · 10/04/2022 10:41

I'm 53 and really just beginning to learn about makeup and how to apply it. I don't want much; a bit of mascara, eyeliner, lipstick and I use a BB cream that just evens out the tone a little. And not every day. I have roseacea and found products that work for me.

I had an abusive ex who was always banging on about preferring the natural look. Even the merest hint of eyeliner and it was "Oooh, panda eyes" or "who are you trying to impress?", and so on. So I gave up trying to wear makeup and didn't for 30 years. I've never even curled my eyelashes until this year.

He was a control freak, and his reasoning was that by not wearing makeup, I was less likely to be attractive to other men, so I wouldn't get them even thinking about trying to get closer to me. I can see he was a hotbed of insecurities, and I certainly wouldn't put up with that shit now.

So I will continue to experiment with makeup and enjoy doing so.

CoalCraft · 10/04/2022 10:35

That should be "never wear makeup", not " never wake up" Blush

CoalCraft · 10/04/2022 10:34

Of course men know what women look like without makeup on - they'll have seen their mother and sisters, and if they've ever been in a serious relationship they'll have seen their partner without it. There are also women who never wake up - me for instance - who still go out in public and are seen by men, so there's plenty of opportunities for them to get a point of comparison.

I'm sure it's true for some men. Others might just be saying it to sound progressive.

rainbowmash · 10/04/2022 10:33

[quote Porcupineintherough]@Comedycook and do you have no feelings about make up on men? I prefer my men without make up.[/quote]
Cute that you think this is a "gotcha" moment, but no, women don't frequently and publicly say these kinds of things about men's makeup choices, and then treat it as a vain virtue-signal.

Jeez, the type of mental gymnastics some people will do to defend men from criticism here is fascinating.

Nomoreusernames1244 · 10/04/2022 10:26

It should just be a personal choice. I don't like it so don't wear it

I agree. I don’t shave on a regular basis either, and if it were truly a choice I would never bother.

However I am also aware, as we see on this thread, that societally it’s not acceptable. So I keep the hairiness covered up, or if on holiday, swimming, heatwave, etc I will shave rather than have the looks and judgement when I’m in public. I’m even very conscious that I’m the exception when going for smears etc.

Same with make up. I choose not to, but again am aware that it’s expected, especially in certain social situations. Like pp have said, there’s the link with looking “better”, having “made an effort” so for things like job interviews not wearing make up may imply you aren’t bothered about presenting your best self, or not having prepared properly.

Xenia · 10/04/2022 10:16

It should just be a personal choice. I don't like it so don't wear it.

Other women like to do a lot of beauty things. Each to their own. If you want to do it if not don't.
I use soap on my face and twice a day a moisturiser. I clean my teeth with tooth paste and dental floss them once a day. One shower a day with soap. Don't shave my legs or under arms these days ever. I don't use deoderant. I comb my hair once a day when I get up. I dye it myself at home to ensure it is not grey when it needs doing. I don't currently cut it at all ever. I bite off a finger nail if it gets long. I use nail clippers on my toes. I use nivea lypsyl/lip balm which is by my desk here in my home office as needed.

I don't drink or smoke or have tea/coffee and drink a lot of water.

OneTC · 10/04/2022 09:23

Part of the reason my oh did wear make up when she was younger was having eczema and scarring on her face which she wanted to cover up. She's dark skinned Asian so scars and marks show up alot

The eczma cleared, the scars faded and she carried on wearing makeup but she started to develop non exma skin problems, she tried 11 million different products and brands but always ultimately with the same result so she stopped using it and her skin got better. For some people cleaning it off at the end of the day is sufficient but for some people it isn't. Or maybe she wasn't very good at cleaning it but that seems unlikely

5128gap · 10/04/2022 08:58

@aurynne

I am 45. I never use makeup, and I have had several male (and female) friends commenting on it positively. Several female friends did not believe I didn't use any makeup, any foundation, any mascara until they rubbed a tissue on my face. A couple of flings I have had commented on how nice it is to kiss a face with no paint/lipstick/mascara on it, and waking up to someone who looks the same as she did the previous night. Some people, men and women, genuinely do like unpainted faces.

I do have the theory that people who use makeup regularly have worse skin (as it cannot breathe properly), so they reason they look worse without it is precisely because using it every day has ruined their skin.

And I do look healthy and sporty without makeup... because I am healthy and sporty.

Some men do mean what they say, and even though they may not be able to tell if a woman has light or "natural" makeup, they still do like makeup-less faces when they get the chance to get close to them. I have the strong impression that some of the women commenting here feel the need to defend the fact they don't dare to go out in the street without makeup. There really is no need.

How odd. I don't wear foundation either and have never had to prove it by letting someone rub a tissue on my face! It must be very important to you to prove how good your skins looks to allow that. Personally I wouldn't care less if they believed me or not, given good skin is not a virtue or achievement. As far as your theory goes, I understand it to be the opposite. Foundation and BB type creams actually form an additional protective layer between the skin and sun/pollutants. Just like a moisturiser, but coloured. As long as they are properly removed they don't cause issues. I've worn lipstick all my life and have none of the age related lip lines or shrinkage that can sometimes occur so I think that has been some protection from that.
DrSbaitso · 10/04/2022 08:50

And to clarify: I've no trouble believing some random Internet person is prettier than I am. Lots of people are. That's fine.

Just interesting that it's not enough to choose not to wear makeup because you prefer it. People who don't radiate like you do clearly aren't fit and active like you. People who wear makeup must have worse skin than you. Etc etc.

It's not the only post on here to do it, to be fair. There have been loads. Just interesting to see that so many people who see a moral value in not using makeup aren't above claiming to be prettier than people who do.

DrSbaitso · 10/04/2022 08:43

@lceni

She says she looks healthy and sporty. Not prettier than everyone else. Why can't some people accept some women don't wear makeup?
Eh? I accept it just fine. What, did you think I don't believe that some women don't wear it? I see women without it all the time. My boss doesn't wear it. I don't always wear it myself.

I'm just interested that some people, who place a moral value on it, are still not above telling us how much prettier they must be.

TurnOffTheHeating · 10/04/2022 08:36

@aurynne

I am 45. I never use makeup, and I have had several male (and female) friends commenting on it positively. Several female friends did not believe I didn't use any makeup, any foundation, any mascara until they rubbed a tissue on my face. A couple of flings I have had commented on how nice it is to kiss a face with no paint/lipstick/mascara on it, and waking up to someone who looks the same as she did the previous night. Some people, men and women, genuinely do like unpainted faces.

I do have the theory that people who use makeup regularly have worse skin (as it cannot breathe properly), so they reason they look worse without it is precisely because using it every day has ruined their skin.

And I do look healthy and sporty without makeup... because I am healthy and sporty.

Some men do mean what they say, and even though they may not be able to tell if a woman has light or "natural" makeup, they still do like makeup-less faces when they get the chance to get close to them. I have the strong impression that some of the women commenting here feel the need to defend the fact they don't dare to go out in the street without makeup. There really is no need.

Sounds like you are very lucky to have the kind of skin where people think you are wearing make up. And to have had the experience of life whereby you can consider that the skin problems of people who wear make up tend to be caused by the make up itself. Lucky you.
lceni · 10/04/2022 08:32

She says she looks healthy and sporty. Not prettier than everyone else. Why can't some people accept some women don't wear makeup?

DrSbaitso · 10/04/2022 07:26

It's always interesting when someone who claims not to use makeup because they're not vain also tries to claim they're much prettier than people who do.

aurynne · 10/04/2022 05:10

I am 45. I never use makeup, and I have had several male (and female) friends commenting on it positively. Several female friends did not believe I didn't use any makeup, any foundation, any mascara until they rubbed a tissue on my face. A couple of flings I have had commented on how nice it is to kiss a face with no paint/lipstick/mascara on it, and waking up to someone who looks the same as she did the previous night. Some people, men and women, genuinely do like unpainted faces.

I do have the theory that people who use makeup regularly have worse skin (as it cannot breathe properly), so they reason they look worse without it is precisely because using it every day has ruined their skin.

And I do look healthy and sporty without makeup... because I am healthy and sporty.

Some men do mean what they say, and even though they may not be able to tell if a woman has light or "natural" makeup, they still do like makeup-less faces when they get the chance to get close to them. I have the strong impression that some of the women commenting here feel the need to defend the fact they don't dare to go out in the street without makeup. There really is no need.

Newhousesad · 10/04/2022 03:47

I find it laughable that men think I care about their opinion on me wearing make up or not

lovelyweathertoday · 09/04/2022 20:15

Several have said everyone looks better with make up.

It's an interesting point of view. I don't like an excessively groomed look on either men or women.

I don't care if others think I would look "better" with makeup on. I like looking like myself as I am.

DrSbaitso · 09/04/2022 10:38

Women without makeup can look more sporty and less precious

I assure you I don't.

BadLad · 09/04/2022 06:50

Is it though?

It should be illegal to post this without Thor.

When men say "I prefer women without make-up"...
mathanxiety · 09/04/2022 01:41

It’s been fun but I am going to sign off with this. If your man expresses a preference about your appearance, take it for what it is… his preference. And it’s ok for him to have a view on how you look

Is it though?

lightisnotwhite · 08/04/2022 23:33

@Nomoreusernames1244

Some have said similar about themselves, others have said women look better in make up, but have not insulted anyone for not wearing it

Several have said everyone looks better with make up.

Which I do find insulting, as it is saying women who wear make up look better than those who don’t, and those choosing not do could do with “enhancing”, as they aren’t good enough au naturel.

I am interested to know though, if everyone looks better with make up, why men and children aren’t expected to wear it.

That’s the weird message I got too.

How are we defining better? To me everyone looks better happy in their own skin, even if they don’t look groomed or pretty. Obviously happy is the key word. If make up makes you happy wear it.