Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child begging to live with other parent, should I just let them go now?

89 replies

LetThemGoLetThemNot · 05/04/2022 16:40

DC is 7, school year 3.

They tell me, their teachers and anyone who will listen almost daily that they want to live with their dad (my ExH). I split with ExH due to violence and control.

Currently ExH has DC for 1 night EOWend, that’s it. There’s a CAO, which gives weeknight contact but ExH never ever wants to see DC.

I know if I offered ExH would have DC living with them though as they tell me they only get 2 days a fortnight off work – the weekend they have DC. ExH also moans about how little money he has since he has to send me a “fortune” every month – he pays less than 50p per day and knocks money off for the littlest thing, they go to a birthday party he knocks off the cost of the present and the fuel, they go out for lunch the cost of DDs meal gets knocked off etc,

It breaks my heart, though I never show it. I have offered the weeknight contact again and was met with a reply about something completely different. My messages about weeknight contact are either ignored or I get a reply about something completely irrelevant that I haven’t asked about like the football scores (I hate football).

ExH won’t see DC if DC is ill, doesn’t do medical appointments or school meetings (there’s a few due to SN), anything bad is my problem, and anything good is because of him.

I’ve told DC the truth about ExHs replies or lack of to messages about contact, DC excuses it “Maybe dad was busy” “Dad works hard maybe he didn’t know what you were asking” but I know in my heart n a few years’ time when they can decide for themselves they will choose him. I’ve known it since we split up.

I don’t suspect Parent Alienation, I don’t think ExH is putting words in their mouth or thoughts in their head because even school say DC speaks in a very expected way, we all think DC hasn’t accepted the split even though it’s been 5 years now.

I’m tempted to just let them go now and fight for contact, it’s so obviously what they want, I will never be good enough.

Very UR I know, but I just feel so sad by it all that I'll never be the correct parent no matter what I do

OP posts:
Gizacluethen · 05/04/2022 19:07

She desperately wants her dad to love her like you do and thinks that if they were together all the time then he might.

Just keep being there for her, she'll see through him eventually. Don't just throw her to the wolves.

Shelaydownunderthetable · 05/04/2022 19:07

OP I’m guessing you must be really hurting and at your wits end to even consider this. What other people have said is 100% true- they are seeking affirmation from their dad because they already know where they stand with you. That is real love, that will help a child build appropriate relationships and attachments. Not the EOW easy street fairy tale they get on weekends with their dad.

You know he’s abusive, you know the age of your child - you know all the reasons why this can’t happen.

Is there anything you can do to get some support for yourself? Therapy, or a workplace EAP, or your GP - anything?

Unsure33 · 05/04/2022 19:04

No . Your children are too young to understand this whole scenario.

You have to do the bigger thing unfortunately .

Never run him down , never bring him into arguments , say when they are older they will be free to make their own choice . But for now thier education and stability is paramount .
Let them know the door is never shut . Your problems do not become their problems .But for now things will not change .

GettingItOutThere · 05/04/2022 18:59

@Redwinestillfine

Seriously, he s violent and you want him to have more time with your child?
this

your child is 7. seven.

they are putting dad on a star and thinking hes wonderful, its possible only seeing someone once a week to think like this.

do not even consider handing residency to him!! your child will be gone

Embracelife · 05/04/2022 18:58

At 7 you decide
You tell dc they can have more say in the decision when they teenager.
Don't send a 7 Yr old to live with violent man

Carpy899 · 05/04/2022 18:52

Very easy to be a Hollywood dad when he only sees them for a day every other week.

Wedonttalkaboutrats · 05/04/2022 18:52

If you left your ExH because of violence and control, there’s no way you should allow you dc to live with him full time. Crazy idea. When dc grows up a bit they’ll realise. Kids can be short sighted. My ds used to say he wanted to live in the countryside and he’d rather go with Grandma, but I could always visit. Did it feel like I’d been punched? Absolutely, but I knew deep down it was because I was the one who made him tidy his room, do his homework, practice the piano etc…….and Grandma would just ask him if he wanted one slice of chocolate cake or two.
Just hang in there. Let dc grow up and appreciate the fact that you didn’t send them to live with a violent, controlling parent.

KellsBells77 · 05/04/2022 18:44

@DinkyDiggies

It’s hard, but actually you are the correct person, you know it, and so does your child. You are getting the pushback back because you are the safe place, they know your love and acceptance is assured- but dad’s is not. That’s why they work so hard for his approval. They may also get an ‘easier’ time there- If no one cares enough to have a bed time, read with them do homework and just let them do whatever they want. Just keep doing what you do, acknowledge their feelings, but don’t let it get to you.
Great post. Sums up the situation precisely.

You’re the good parent OP, unfortunately he’s not been good enough.

Booboobibles · 05/04/2022 18:33

I think a lot of abusive men take their ex to court for residency. It’s a control thing.

Also he’s violent and he won’t look after your child properly.

You say you’d give him as much money as you could afford. I can assure you that the money would not be spent on your child,

It’s hard but you can’t take offence at something a small child says. Think ten years into the future….your child will be so thankful that you didn’t let your hurt feelings influence your decision. What if you let them live with dad and they go off the rails? You’d never forgive yourself.

Electriq · 05/04/2022 18:30

If you were push for anything push for 50/50.

Although the reasons you left him, I would not be pushing for any more than he has, its hard to hear, but your the one being a parent, and he gets all the fun, thats all the child sees, but in years time, when they understand more, it will make sense to them.

whynotwhatknot · 05/04/2022 18:20

First if all you need to g through cms if he keeps deducting money for things-he cant basically

at 7 your dc just wants the fun bit probably the attention from him

my friend went through this unfrtunately the dc was older so she had to let them go but at 7 a court wont hear of it

RandomMess · 05/04/2022 18:19

It's likely that your DC SEN play a role in this too that their emotional maturity and understanding is younger than most 7 year olds and they are speaking out a fantasy in the same way as wanting a unicorn.

4thtimethecharm · 05/04/2022 18:13

You may not be the parent your DC want. But you are the one they need.

Parenting is not a popularity contest, certainly not when the contest is run by a 7 year old! Please don't feel defeated by their preferences. You know being with you is better for them in the long term.

Dixiechickonhols · 05/04/2022 18:10

He's not begging to live with him he's begging for his attention. The play example he's looking for him as there's no guarantee he's there whereas you are always there.
He's got court ordered contact he's not utilising.
I wouldn't get into contacting ex. The order is there if he messages to arrange then abide by order but don't chase him. Don't set DS up for disappointment if he doesn't reply.

Ash2956 · 05/04/2022 18:05

I feel for you as I have been in this position. I can only tell you what I did. No one knows the true situation except you. My son was 15 and my daughter was 10. My son wanted to live with his dad and eventually he did. My daughter wanted to live with her dad at first and he had her to stay every other weekend. It used to break my heart when she would come back and say she hated me and wanted to live with her Dad. This went on for a couple of years until in the end I agreed that as she was 12 and determined to live there it wasn’t right to continue as we were.
I can tell you I had the most miserable 4 months of my life. Continual excuses from my ex why I couldn’t see her. Anyhow, long story short, I had a phone call one evening asking me to come and pick her up from her dads. After living there for a while she made her own decision to come home to me.

Your kids are much younger and only you know what’s best for them. I just wanted to let you know that you are not alone and that this situation will pass in time. Love and hugs to you and stay strong xx

GoodnightJude1 · 05/04/2022 18:03

The grass is always greener OP!

My DS would probably live with his dad given the choice….when he goes to his dads EOW there’s no set bedtime, they get McDonald’s for dinner and play Fifa all day. It’s like he views his dad as a mate.
That novelty would soon wear off when there was no available money for the school trip, no home cooked meal on the table, no clean, ironed school shirts.
At 7 your DC is probably thinking every day would be like EOW with dad…he’d soon realise it’s not.

Like PP said, he looks for his dad in the crowd because he already KNOWS you’ll be there. You’re the constant. Sadly, it’ll take a few more years before he really acknowledges that.
Hang on in there though. If your Exh was violent what will stop him being violent with your DC?

moofolk · 05/04/2022 18:00

As PP have said, kids of that age don't know what they want.

It is upsetting to feel rejected, but you are strong. You are his mum, and you do know what's best.

Your ex sounds awful and it doesn't seem like your kids would be better off with him, and in the long run might feel rejected by you.

But if he's a shit dad, and they don't see him very often, it's unlikely he makes them do homework, wash the dishes, get dressed and brush their teeth by 8am, and other horribly mean, unfair things that you make them do.

That makes dad seem like a fun option, but it's not realistic.

Menora · 05/04/2022 17:57

@WonderfulYou

I personally would let him go, if you think he’ll be safe.

Right now his dad is a Disney dad so of course he’s going to want to live there if he thinks his entire week is going to be fun doing whatever he wants to.

They’ll both soon realise that it’s not as fun as they think.

I’d have him live there for a 2 month trial.
Ex can have him mon-fri and you have him weekends.
Tell your son that he can change his mind at any time.

In reality this will teach the child nothing at all. It will just mean the child is confused and possibly both child and ex miserable to try to prove some kind of point. Kids don’t always want to go to school, you don’t just say ‘oh ok you don’t have to go’. Children who fantasise about living with their other parent fanatically like this are displaying their feelings of missing the parent and not having their emotional needs met by them. They want them because they are at a distance and feel insecure. Clearly OP has outlined that dad doesn’t meet their needs so handing a child over would be awful
Wish44 · 05/04/2022 17:57

So hard OP. Just remember you are playing the long game. Your child will thank you when they are older and can see him for what he really is.

WonderfulYou · 05/04/2022 17:52

I personally would let him go, if you think he’ll be safe.

Right now his dad is a Disney dad so of course he’s going to want to live there if he thinks his entire week is going to be fun doing whatever he wants to.

They’ll both soon realise that it’s not as fun as they think.

I’d have him live there for a 2 month trial.
Ex can have him mon-fri and you have him weekends.
Tell your son that he can change his mind at any time.

Menora · 05/04/2022 17:52

I will add that mine is now an adult and has had a very slow painful realisation as to what a crap dad he is. She spent her whole childhood wishing she was with him more and he didn’t wish for it back. He did his bare minimum. I just felt sorry for her and stayed close and she grew out of the fantasy

Theunamedcat · 05/04/2022 17:51

My son witnessed violence and recieved it from his father he is desperate for his attention and approval its a sting in the tail when he says well we can always ask daddy for money if we can't afford the heating on much I did tell him dad has been paying less than half what he is is supposed to (child maintenance are useless) and is now unemployed again gently son what makes you think he will give us money? He said true true but dad said he will play with me online today! He will text you.....has he text yet? Has he text yet? Has he text yet? Not that YOU would tell me if he did (I did challenge that one told him he couldn't take his dad's poor behaviour out on me he apologised)

So I get its hard and at age 7/8/9 he was very Very challenging about it he even "left home" at one point he stood outside the door saying his dad would "know" he needed him and he would show up he never did

I got him counselling through the school it helped a little but I won't lie about my ex if he says he isnt coming for no reason I literally tell ds the truth

Menora · 05/04/2022 17:49

I had this for years and it was a very rose tinted wishful thinking from my DD and actually very tragic and sad. It was what she thought she wanted because she could not have it and he didn’t want her. You need to ride this out and it will pass. It doesn’t feel that way but it is because she feels that she doesn’t have enough of him, and that’s not even your fault is it. Sometimes kids want the things they can’t have and it is very sad but giving it to them might not be good for them anyway

Walkingalot · 05/04/2022 17:42

Don't let him go. You kinda know what sort of life you'll be letting him in for. You're the parent that knows him best and you need to protect him. I agree with PP, that he maybe needs some counselling to help him get over the split and maybe get to the root of why he wants to live with his DF (I'm assuming you've tried talking to him). Basically, he's too young to make this decision.
Also agree that the DF doesn't get to deduct money spent on him when he takes him out! Go through CMS.

Icecreamclub0 · 05/04/2022 17:41

If your child was 13 I'd say you didn't have a choice as they were old enough to make up their own minds. A 7 year old is not gilick competent and therefore it is your duty to safeguard them. A 7 year old who is stating they don't want to see a parent wouldn't be listened to either.

Swipe left for the next trending thread