Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel cheated by my doula

232 replies

Yumyumcakes · 05/04/2022 11:04

For my second 2 months old, dh and I made the decision to have a doula as my birth partner as we had no other childcare for our child at home. I didn’t want to go it alone as I was quite nervous of being mistreated, I didn’t have the best first labour.

So I hired a doula and I honestly feel robbed. Robbed not only of money (nearly £1k) but of that supportive presence during labour. I’m actually quite cross about it, of course I gave feedback on how I feel.

The woman I had, drove the wrong way to the hospital taking nearly triple the amount of time. Left me to walk from the carpark alone to the delivery unit whilst she parked the car in active labour, there were a few instances where I needed some extra advocacy when the midwife wasn’t really listening to me (nothing crazy, just preferences like my bum was facing the door and I wasn’t comfortable with being exposed to everyone in the corridor so just asked for a blanket) and nothing, no coachIng, no reminding of breathing techniques, no words of encouragement, no massage, pressure points, reminding to move around… literally nothing. She sat there on her phone and ate my snacks and drank my sports drinks. It was to the extent that the midwife even commented to leave some of the snacks for me and when the doula left 30 mins after birth on how little she did. My husband had one ask, just keep him updated. She didn’t, despite being on her phone

I feel cheated. She had good reviews but now I’m wondering if they were fake.

Was I just really unlucky? If you had a doula what was your experience like?

2 months later I still feel a bit narked about it. When I gave the feedback (said nicely but put across all the points I made above) it was oh ok, I’ll take it on board for next time. No explanation or apology. Feels like a grand wasted - aibu?

OP posts:
Yumyumcakes · 05/04/2022 12:27

[quote kinshasa]You met her twice and chatted on the phone? And then trusted her with your welfare?

Sorry, but I'm amazed that you didn't think to check her out more than that, just as you would someone claiming to be a therapist, or even a builder!

I'm glad that you are ok, but a tough lesson to learn as to how you go about finding a proper experienced doula. That wasn't the way!

Definitely complain and warn others, and small claims if necessary. Don't trust randoms you havent checked out properly, especially with your health!

A good doula is a great support. But if you a looking for one, best to start somewhere like this.
doula.org.uk/about-doula-uk/[/quote]
We had 2, 2 hour long ante natal sessions that came with her package. It was more than all the other local doulas offered. We did an initial ‘interview’ at a coffee shop too. Then chatted on the phone/ FaceTime several times. I left it quite late to get a doula 34 weeks so there wasn’t that much time left

OP posts:
Yumyumcakes · 05/04/2022 12:25

@Lady0racle

Did you sign any agreement with her? Is there anything in writing that shows what she agreed to do during labour to help you?

If there is, you’re on stronger ground with regard to a refund. I mean, I’d request one anyway but something in writing would be helpful as she clearly didn’t stick to her part of the agreement.

So we had an agreement/ contract but it didn’t directly list and specify all the things she’d do for me
OP posts:
NameChange30 · 05/04/2022 12:24

It wasnt a drip feed - OP didn't say at first because she didn't know, she hadn't checked whether the doula was a member. Hopefully the doula's membership can be revoked, she does sound terrible Sad

LBFseBrom · 05/04/2022 12:24

This is the definition of a doula from Web MD:
A doula is a person who provides emotional and physical support to you during your pregnancy and childbirth. Doulas are not medical professionals. They don't deliver babies or provide medical care.
.............
Seems a bit wishy washy to me, frankly. There were no 'doulas' when I gave birth, I just had my husband with me and that was sufficient.

It does seem an odd thing to do for a job; presumably they have some experience in giving birth but don't need much in the way of paper qualifications.

You're not likely to get your money back, op, you'll have to write it off but hopefully your experience will put others off from hiring someone like that - someone who, in effect, isn't paid to actually do very much.

Regardless, I hope your birth experience was a positive one.

kinshasa · 05/04/2022 12:22

Wow missed the post about doula uk.
You didn't say that, drip feed, indeed.
Complain.

kinshasa · 05/04/2022 12:21

You met her twice and chatted on the phone? And then trusted her with your welfare?

Sorry, but I'm amazed that you didn't think to check her out more than that, just as you would someone claiming to be a therapist, or even a builder!

I'm glad that you are ok, but a tough lesson to learn as to how you go about finding a proper experienced doula. That wasn't the way!

Definitely complain and warn others, and small claims if necessary. Don't trust randoms you havent checked out properly, especially with your health!

A good doula is a great support. But if you a looking for one, best to start somewhere like this.
doula.org.uk/about-doula-uk/

Roselilly36 · 05/04/2022 12:19

That sounds such a bad experience, so sorry, you should take this further, first complain to Doula UK, if they can’t mediate, money claim online. How did you pay for the “service”? Congrats on your baby OP Flowers

NameChange30 · 05/04/2022 12:19

@Yumyumcakes

She’s on doula uk
That's good, you can refer to their code of conduct and go through their complaints procedure. Links to both at doula.org.uk/about-doulas/
Lady0racle · 05/04/2022 12:17

Did you sign any agreement with her? Is there anything in writing that shows what she agreed to do during labour to help you?

If there is, you’re on stronger ground with regard to a refund. I mean, I’d request one anyway but something in writing would be helpful as she clearly didn’t stick to her part of the agreement.

Yumyumcakes · 05/04/2022 12:15

She’s on doula uk

OP posts:
Marvellousmadness · 05/04/2022 12:15

Scammer*

Or just the worst doula in the world perhaps.

Marvellousmadness · 05/04/2022 12:15

She wasnt a doula. Just a spammer
Sorry this happened to you

starfishmummy · 05/04/2022 12:14

@Oriunda

My doula was amazing. I’d be reporting yours, but first I’d be attempting to get some sort of refund.
And exactly who would she report it to? Anyone can call themselves a doula - there's no formal training, no regulation and I assume this one is self
Yumyumcakes · 05/04/2022 12:13

@NameChange30

So she wasn't a member of Doula UK, then. You didn't answer my question about whether there was a written agreement? Doula UK has a code of conduct and a complaints procedure. Sorry but I think it was an error to choose a doula who was not a member.
Sorry, yes there was a contract. Admittedly I didn’t check if she was on doula UK, I’ll go and have a look now actually. The other doula definitely was and that doula said she used this woman as her back up doula and they work together lots
OP posts:
thinkfast · 05/04/2022 12:12

I had a doula at my dd's birth. She was a former midwife who no longer wanted to work for the nhs. She:
Brought healthy snacks for me
Chatted / distracted me when I wanted
Walked with me
Massaged
Advocated for me strongly. She was able to ask questions and where appropriate challenge doctors' midwives' suggestions with her knowledge of recent studies. One doctor was very junior. She told him to stop talking and wait as I was having a contraction and couldn't hear him
Explained what the doctors were telling me in a way that I could understand.
Took a photo of me, DH and dd.
After the birth, She also submitted a complaint on my behalf regarding one aspect of my care.

Sorry you had a bad experience OP. I think you should request a refund.

Movetothebeat · 05/04/2022 12:10

Was this woman actually listed on Doula UK though?

It sounds like you’ve been scammed. The doula who recommended her may or not be aware of this.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 05/04/2022 12:10

Please take her to the small claims, this is disgraceful.

NameChange30 · 05/04/2022 12:08

So she wasn't a member of Doula UK, then.
You didn't answer my question about whether there was a written agreement?
Doula UK has a code of conduct and a complaints procedure.
Sorry but I think it was an error to choose a doula who was not a member.

Yumyumcakes · 05/04/2022 12:06

@Skydreams

Could you contact Doula UK for advice?

Where did you find this person?

Off a recommendation from another doula I found in doula UK
OP posts:
Stath · 05/04/2022 12:05

Bloody hell, you poor love.

I used to work as a doula (also qualified lactation consultant). All my actions and support were centred around the mother and her needs and wants.

I’ve had births where I’ve been pooed on as the (incredible strong) mum has wanting me to press on to her bottom of her back to help the pain so I was in the ‘action zone’ when natural events happened.

Doulas should be the birthing woman’s number one cheerleader/surrogate sister/advocate.
That has meant positive affirmations and physical support with some women and hands-off silent gate keeping for others.

So sorry you’ve had this experience. Definitely get a refund and make sure others know of her shitty ways.

Congratulations on your new baby Flowers

Yumyumcakes · 05/04/2022 12:05

Also couldn’t afford a private midwife that was £3k v 1k.

The intent here isn’t doula bashing, I think there are some really pushing the boundaries of good practice (ie sort of encouraging maybe some dangerous things or likening all medicine to abuse) and evidently some lazy AF ones but I think to have an advocate and someone basically coaching you and giving you all the positive vibes is a really powerful thing

OP posts:
Skydreams · 05/04/2022 12:04

Could you contact Doula UK for advice?

Where did you find this person?

Yumyumcakes · 05/04/2022 12:02

@LetHimHaveIt

Honestly, OP, you're clearly and understandably distressed, but I'm afraid I actually sniggered at your description. She sounds like a character from a Catherine Tate sketch show! But then - I have grace doubts re: the efficacy of 'doulas' anyway: I can't decide whether gulping Lucozade Sport is better or worse than burning sage and 'smudging'. A private midwife would've been better. One presumes.
What on Earth is smudging?

I’m not really into hippy stuff but I just really wanted someone there you know on team ‘yumyum’

OP posts:
NameChange30 · 05/04/2022 12:01

Wtf is "burning sage and 'smudging'"?!

That's not what doulas are about, not good ones anyway.

I don't like that this is turning into a doula-bashing thread. A good one is worth her weight in gold. This doula was obviously shit. But I don't think she is representative.

Gonnagetgoing · 05/04/2022 12:00

Sorry seen you’ve given birth. Maybe email her with a complaint but unlikely you’d be refunded.