Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel cheated by my doula

232 replies

Yumyumcakes · 05/04/2022 11:04

For my second 2 months old, dh and I made the decision to have a doula as my birth partner as we had no other childcare for our child at home. I didn’t want to go it alone as I was quite nervous of being mistreated, I didn’t have the best first labour.

So I hired a doula and I honestly feel robbed. Robbed not only of money (nearly £1k) but of that supportive presence during labour. I’m actually quite cross about it, of course I gave feedback on how I feel.

The woman I had, drove the wrong way to the hospital taking nearly triple the amount of time. Left me to walk from the carpark alone to the delivery unit whilst she parked the car in active labour, there were a few instances where I needed some extra advocacy when the midwife wasn’t really listening to me (nothing crazy, just preferences like my bum was facing the door and I wasn’t comfortable with being exposed to everyone in the corridor so just asked for a blanket) and nothing, no coachIng, no reminding of breathing techniques, no words of encouragement, no massage, pressure points, reminding to move around… literally nothing. She sat there on her phone and ate my snacks and drank my sports drinks. It was to the extent that the midwife even commented to leave some of the snacks for me and when the doula left 30 mins after birth on how little she did. My husband had one ask, just keep him updated. She didn’t, despite being on her phone

I feel cheated. She had good reviews but now I’m wondering if they were fake.

Was I just really unlucky? If you had a doula what was your experience like?

2 months later I still feel a bit narked about it. When I gave the feedback (said nicely but put across all the points I made above) it was oh ok, I’ll take it on board for next time. No explanation or apology. Feels like a grand wasted - aibu?

OP posts:
TeaPacks · 05/04/2022 15:46

Well, my doula didn't bother turning up.
I went to hospital at 5am on a cold Sunday morning and I guess she didn't want to get out of bed.
Then she blocked me. Thankfully hadn't paid her yet.
You should demand a refund.

Yumyumcakes · 05/04/2022 15:44

@Responsiveroo

How many times had you met her before? Was she recommended personally to you?
Yes she was recommended to me, we met for an interview in a coffee shop and then had 2 x 2hr ante natal sessions and FT catch ups.

Not sure how the age of my first child is relevant though?

OP posts:
Responsiveroo · 05/04/2022 15:38

How old is your first?

Responsiveroo · 05/04/2022 15:37

How many times had you met her before?
Was she recommended personally to you?

Tortabella · 05/04/2022 15:35

I would write to her and say you need the money back as she was useless. And if she refuses say you have a journalist involved and will be talking to a paper as you'd hate other women to be scammed. It's cheaper than hiring a lawyer and works well in my experience.

BiBabbles · 05/04/2022 15:29

YANBU, it's awful that you had so little support from the doula, from the sounds of it, not enough from the midwives as well.

I think there is a need for non-medical support or 'chaperones' as some places still prefer to call them for many people in medical situations and births are a big one. Not everyone feels a need for it, and there may be a need for it to be better qualified and screened than doulas are now, but I think there can be lot of value in it.

Wtf is "burning sage and 'smudging'"?!
What on Earth is smudging?

Smudging is burning sage. There are a few other plants that can be used, often in proper practices multiple plants are used, but it's basically the same thing colloquially. It's a religious practice for lack of a better term in some American Indigenous nations, some Canadian and US hospitals will allow it certain rooms - some hospitals even provide a list of rooms, but really it's used for the same kind of thing in medical situations where someone of faiths with clergy might want those clergy involved.

It's also used by some to mock what they view as hippy, in part because it's a visible practice that's very different and because some hippy-types over the decades have taken and done some weird shite with it.

andysgirl22 · 05/04/2022 15:24

Op I'm so sorry that u went through this xxx

Yumyumcakes · 05/04/2022 15:03

To be honest @Patchbatch in the unlikely event I had more kids, a doula now would be bottom of my list. Wouldn’t waste my time or money, I’d just go it alone

OP posts:
Patchbatch · 05/04/2022 14:11

I’ve looked into it and pretty much any one can be a doula, the course is a few weeks long and not that expensive. My guess is it’s completely unregulated which means you can get some charlatans

Pretty much your answer. Sorry you had that experience OP, it's abhorrent that some are happy to take money and not even attempt to deliver what they promise, its shocking its as unregulated as it is. I only know after looking into it when a friend had a really terrible experience, I would have trusted one with good reviews prior to that same as you, wouldn't touch with a bargepole now.

Yumyumcakes · 05/04/2022 14:06

I’m not saying she’s a fake per se, i mean she’s on doula UK and it’s hardly doctorate levels of accreditation, but good reviews can be faked

OP posts:
Ava50x · 05/04/2022 14:01

OP, I'm so sorry to hear you've had such a horrible experience- when you were at your most vulnerable. Because you asked, I will say I have used 2 different doulas and they were both awesome. Supportive, encouraging, warm, empathetic, caring- I can go on and on! At my last birth in August, my midwife and doula were working together as a real team- each of them holding one of my arms as I pushed, and the midwife told me she loves the births where there is a doula- its such wonderful teamwork for them.
Its a crying shame that your sham of a doula is giving the industry such a bad name. I know with a newborn you probably don't have much energy or time to fight it- but its so important that she's exposed for who she is.
Congrats on your baby!

kinshasa · 05/04/2022 14:00

@Yumyumcakes

Not spoken to doula uk about her, didn’t realise that was a thing. Didn’t ask for certificates, she’s got the badges of her training online though

I’m looking at her website now and the testimonies that seem so good as so all easily faked now, it’s just text and a name and location

It really is a thing, rather than a taken down google review. I think they would take your complaint very seriously indeed. You would be helping other women who might book her, especially if you believe that she is fake.
DoNotStayCalm · 05/04/2022 13:54

Wondering if it’s the same person

Mine quit working as a Doula so it seems unlikely. She is in her early 50's if that helps to confirm it wasn't the same person.

I have many friends who have had positive experiences with Doulas so don't let it put you off if you need one for another birth.

NameChange30 · 05/04/2022 13:44

"It’s a shame a few bad eggs could put women off."

Agree.

Some midwives are awful but no one says that makes all midwives pointless!

Worldgonecrazy · 05/04/2022 13:41

So sorry.

My doula was amazing, as soon as she was with me, everything went more smoothly. Unfortunately I ended up needing medical intervention but she and I had planned for that. It’s a shame a few bad eggs could put women off.

Yumyumcakes · 05/04/2022 13:36

Not spoken to doula uk about her, didn’t realise that was a thing. Didn’t ask for certificates, she’s got the badges of her training online though

I’m looking at her website now and the testimonies that seem so good as so all easily faked now, it’s just text and a name and location

OP posts:
Yumyumcakes · 05/04/2022 13:34

@flopseyR72

Seems like she didn’t do anything though but she charged £1K. I can’t see the point tbh unless you needed a lift. The midwife sounded more attentive than the doula so that is my point.
This is also my point, but she didn’t declare she’d be as useful as a chocolate fire guard prior to hiring her or I might have gone in a different direction…
OP posts:
flopseyR72 · 05/04/2022 13:31

Seems like she didn’t do anything though but she charged £1K. I can’t see the point tbh unless you needed a lift. The midwife sounded more attentive than the doula so that is my point.

hearmywomanlyroar · 05/04/2022 13:30

So sorry to hear about your experience. How awful for you. I've no advice but just wanted to send sympathy. I looked into a doula for my first and my impression was that it was a vocation where the money barely covered their costs and really they just wanted to support women. That all feels a bit naive now hearing your story Sad I just can't understand how any birth partner would be so unhelpful, let alone one who made promises to support you.

kinshasa · 05/04/2022 13:28

@sheildmaiden

I am a doula and so sorry she treated you like this. Did she show you her certificate to prove her training?
Yes, I'd like to know that. And what they were.

Have you spoken directly to doula.uk about this? Seeing as you have found she is listed with them.
I think it's really important that you tell them about this woman given what has happened.

Yumyumcakes · 05/04/2022 13:25

@sheildmaiden

I am a doula and so sorry she treated you like this. Did she show you her certificate to prove her training?
No :( I didn’t think to ask as she came so highly recommended
OP posts:
Yumyumcakes · 05/04/2022 13:24

@Dinoasaurme

On the basis of this thread if I ever have any more children I will never use a doula. What an awful traumatic experience for you OP.

Definitely take this further, and this time do not word your complaint "nicely", but state exactly what happened in no uncertain terms. Go to the Doula UK management and write a very strongly worded letter.

Where did you post the review that has been deleted? I would go to the regulators / admin if that site too. Service providers shouldnt be able to simply delete reviews they don't like the look of. Post another review.

I had no idea doulas aren't regulated. How completely shit.

I didn’t mean to put you off, but now looking back she was so clever with her words ‘how many births did you attend?’ ‘I’ve supported hundreds of women, I’ve done this for over 10 years’ never directly said I’ve been at 100 births etc.

Review was on google

OP posts:
sheildmaiden · 05/04/2022 13:23

I am a doula and so sorry she treated you like this. Did she show you her certificate to prove her training?

Dinoasaurme · 05/04/2022 13:18

On the basis of this thread if I ever have any more children I will never use a doula. What an awful traumatic experience for you OP.

Definitely take this further, and this time do not word your complaint "nicely", but state exactly what happened in no uncertain terms. Go to the Doula UK management and write a very strongly worded letter.

Where did you post the review that has been deleted? I would go to the regulators / admin if that site too. Service providers shouldnt be able to simply delete reviews they don't like the look of. Post another review.

I had no idea doulas aren't regulated. How completely shit.

Yumyumcakes · 05/04/2022 13:16

Also someone asked where did I leave the review, I left it on google and now it’s gone a few have actually now it just says 1 5* google review but before she had about 15/20

OP posts: