Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give DS calpol before nursery?

189 replies

CalpolDilemma · 05/04/2022 08:33

Our nursery has a policy that children can’t be given calpol before or at nursery in case it masks illness. They also send home any child who has a temperature over 37.5 degrees.

DS is teething. He could be unwell but he has all the classic signs of teething. His temperature is 37.6. He’s well in himself and happy and playing, but is slightly warm. WWYD?

He’s 18 months.

OP posts:
glitterelf · 05/04/2022 14:24

@feministqueen

If you hadn't taken the temperature would you say that your child is unwell?

I would and have given my child calpol if they've been a bit whingy and I've determined that they need it.

To the posters saying if they're I'll enough for calpol then they should stay home - do you take a sick day when you take a paracetamol?

Judging by this thread calpol is being misused by the majority anyway. Do you take paracetamol for every raised temperature you have ? I certainly do not but will do other things to try and reduce my temperature if it's slightly raised. I also do not administer calpol to children in my care with a raised temperature immediately instead I try other methods but would obviously administer if a child was clearly unwell or in pain.
Freddiefox · 05/04/2022 14:23

As someone who had to hold down a job and paid an exorbitant amount in nursery fees, it’s frustrating when nurseries make up ridiculous rules. What happened to common sense?

They’re not making it up though, 37.5 was the number picked by the GOV when they devised the action for covid info. You don’t just get to ignore the info even if you want to.

glitterelf · 05/04/2022 14:18

@GeorgieTheGorgeousGoat

Every single childcare provider has caught 'teething' at least once
This made me chuckle because it's so true.
Lipsandlashes · 05/04/2022 13:59

@Staryflight445

Lipsandlashes

Staryflight445
@Lipsandlashes everyone else at the nursery pays exactly the same as you do, why do you feel more entitled to take a poorly child there because you pay for the privilege of the service?
The service can’t run properly whilst parents behave like this, surely that’s understandable?

A bug for one child can land another in hospital, why is that fair? those parents pay the same.
I’m not talking about taking a poorly child in to nursery. I’m talking about giving pain relief to a child who is teething - as per the OP’s original point. HTH

Lol, the HTH is so patronising. If a child needs calpol they shouldn’t be at nursery.

Absolute rubbish and you know it. Do you call in sick to work after you’ve taken a couple of paracetamol? If not, why not? You’re obviously I’ll and could be passing your (completely non contagious) symptoms (pain!) on to someone else. Such double standards. HTH!
feministqueen · 05/04/2022 13:54

If you hadn't taken the temperature would you say that your child is unwell?

I would and have given my child calpol if they've been a bit whingy and I've determined that they need it.

To the posters saying if they're I'll enough for calpol then they should stay home - do you take a sick day when you take a paracetamol?

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 05/04/2022 13:39

Yawn my DS in nursery is ill at least once a month sometimes twice, just dose them up with calpol and send him in.
You'll only be shooting yourself in the foot as everyone else does it and realistically taking time off for every runny nose is impossible.

Iateallthechocolate · 05/04/2022 13:39

No, but I get full pay if I'm off, and am in a role that seems to have a lot of pointless busy work

GeorgieTheGorgeousGoat · 05/04/2022 13:33

Every single childcare provider has caught 'teething' at least once

ShadowPuppets · 05/04/2022 13:33

The last two years have turned everyone into raging hypochondriacs IMO. My daughter just got sent home from nursery with a temperature of 37.4. They’ve advised we get a PCR test, which considering we are in England now would cost £60+. We are relatively comfortable financially but there’s no way on earth I can spend that every time she has a normal temperature. And I’ll be much more up shit creek if I lose my job with frequent absences, which I will if they send her home every time she has a temperature starting with ‘37 point whatever’. And that’s assuming DH and I (who earn exactly the same and split childcare 50/50) take exactly half the absences each.

Toddlers spend the first couple of their lives with snotty noses, ‘‘twas ever thus. And she doesn’t even have a snotty nose for christs sake! She’s perfectly fine…

Vallmo47 · 05/04/2022 13:30

I’m with nursery on this, especially given the current ongoing covid situation. My first thought would be to also swab his nose, it would literally take you a second. Furthermore, if it isn’t teething and I worked in the nursery you’d be risking my chances of going to my niece’s wedding this weekend. Yes that sounds harsh but I’m really really peeved taking my kid to school this week with the amount of kids there with “just a sore throat”. That sore throat could risk so much more than just someone’s wedding plans.

Having said that, the situation is ridiculous in that schools fine you if your absence is too high, so it’s a catch 22. If I wasn’t home my husband would lose his job over the amount of absence we’ve had lately.
I do understand the other side of it.

Ivyonafence · 05/04/2022 13:30

YABU.

If he's well he doesn't need calpol.

If he's unwell you should keep him home.

SuitcaseOfWhine · 05/04/2022 13:27

@Staryflight445

There’s absolutely no scientific evidence either that teething causes pain.

By the time mine had red cheeks their tooth had already erupted and both of them were fine.

How do they scientifically test for this on babies and toddlers? I'm intrigued.

Pain is quite subjective really, so one child may teethe without issues and others have a difficult time with it. Bit like birthing babies really. We have different pain thresholds and ways of managing pain.

gingercat02 · 05/04/2022 13:26

Everyone does it. If DS was a bit under the weather he got paracetamol and ibuprofen before nursery. Ours always asked if you said they had a cold so they knew when they could think about the next dose

JenniferBarkley · 05/04/2022 13:25

@Fleur405

The problem is what if he had a bug. Which he probably caught at nursery. Because someone else sent their child in when they had a bug (after giving them calpol to mask their temperature…)
I never understand this argument. If he caught the bug at nursery, then he was probably spreading it around yesterday before symptoms started. Other children will be spreading it around today, with or without symptoms. Every child in the room and indeed the adults will be exposed regardless, that's just the nature of the beast and if you can't accept that then don't use nursery.
Sartre · 05/04/2022 13:25

@Staryflight445

There’s absolutely no scientific evidence either that teething causes pain.

By the time mine had red cheeks their tooth had already erupted and both of them were fine.

Absolute bollocks. I know my wisdom teeth certainly hurt when they erupted so stands to reason babies and toddlers have pain too.

YANBU to give a teething toddler calpol at any point. Unless you have reason to believe it’s actually a virus then of course they can go to the CM.

Thehundredthnamechange · 05/04/2022 13:23

I would

Thatsplentyjack · 05/04/2022 13:21

@Glenthebattleostrich

Yes you are unreasonable. I say that as I sit here with my childminding business closed for the day because someone sent a 'teething' child. My 11 year old daughter caught 'teething'' and has been throwing up since 5. Their choice has cost me 2 days income and put my holiday on Thursday at risk.
Also a childminder, and yes "teething" is used for an excuse for everything. Vomiting, diarrhea, temperature, rashes.
Thehop · 05/04/2022 13:20

Theor temperature policy is stupid. A normal temp for each person is different!

I’m a childminder and take each child’s temperature a few times a week and log it. I know then if they really have a temp or not when they seem Ill. What’s normal for one os hot for another.

OutingHobby · 05/04/2022 13:19

No that's a disgusting thing to do. Your child could infect all the others and cause issues for their families. Follow the policy or find other childcare.

Fleur405 · 05/04/2022 13:19

The problem is what if he had a bug. Which he probably caught at nursery. Because someone else sent their child in when they had a bug (after giving them calpol to mask their temperature…)

JenniferBarkley · 05/04/2022 13:18

Our nursery being open to us (or them) giving Calpol meant we could be fully open with them - more than once we've said "She was a bit cranky this morning but temp is ok, think it's just teething or a bad night but we've given Calpol in the hopes she perks up a bit. If she goes downhill just call us and we'll be straight there."

Our nursery know that we are religious about covid testing (more than 30 PCRs as a family) and waiting 48 hours after vomiting (we've obeyed that even when it's been car sickness). That means that when we say "think they're just a bit under the weather and ok with Calpol but let us know if they're not", they know that we're not pulling a fast one. Similarly, because they're willing to keep a child who is a bit under the weather but mostly ok in themselves, then we know that if we get the call we really do need to get there sharpish to get the DC home.

There has to be give and take - nurseries are germ factories and everyone involved needs to acknowledge that and be a bit realistic about things.

SatinHeart · 05/04/2022 13:17

There’s absolutely no scientific evidence either that teething causes pain

And also no evidence that it doesn't cause pain, i.e. no-one's really done any studies on it at all.

OP, if they have a no calpol policy I wouldn't, simply in case there was some sort of emergency requiring medical intervention (e.g. paramedics) and the nursery didn't know that your DC had already had paracetamol. I know its massively unlikely, but still...

PatchworkElmer · 05/04/2022 13:15

@Staryflight445 of course it causes pain in most babies…

CorneliusVetch · 05/04/2022 13:09

@Staryflight445

There’s absolutely no scientific evidence either that teething causes pain.

By the time mine had red cheeks their tooth had already erupted and both of them were fine.

No evidence teething causes pain? I am rarely stunned by wow.
Staryflight445 · 05/04/2022 13:05

There’s absolutely no scientific evidence either that teething causes pain.

By the time mine had red cheeks their tooth had already erupted and both of them were fine.