Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give DS calpol before nursery?

189 replies

CalpolDilemma · 05/04/2022 08:33

Our nursery has a policy that children can’t be given calpol before or at nursery in case it masks illness. They also send home any child who has a temperature over 37.5 degrees.

DS is teething. He could be unwell but he has all the classic signs of teething. His temperature is 37.6. He’s well in himself and happy and playing, but is slightly warm. WWYD?

He’s 18 months.

OP posts:
Thatsplentyjack · 05/04/2022 22:06

@Lipsandlashes

Yes I do hold parents responsible when I have to close due to them sending in their sick child even before covid as selfish parents are around long before covid Ah. So here is the crux of it *@glitterelf* You are acting out of a need to keep your childcare setting open and not threaten your livelihood. The child’s illness is secondary. It’s the consequence of you not being paid that matters to you. The thing is parents are also acting out of their need to go to work and make money and a nursery not admitting a child for a low temperature is preventing them from doing that. So what makes you think your need to ensure bills are paid trumps their need for the same? Interesting thought.
Lipsandlashes, childcare providers don't go into that career agreeing to look after sick children. Sick children should be at home with their parents. Of course childcare providers need to work trumps the parents need to work when it's their child who is ill. Not sure why that needs explaining. Bit stupid to bring it down to who needs to earn money.
Lipsandlashes · 05/04/2022 21:51

@Thatsplentyjack

So what makes you think your need to ensure bills are paid trumps their need for the same?

Hmm, let's see. Maybe because it's THEIR child and they are responsible for looking after them and taking care of them when they are ill no one else. If people aren't happy with that they should think twice about having children.

Jesus Christ! I’ve already said I’m not talking about an obviously ill child! It is in response to the OP, who’s child has a very slightly raised temperature caused by teething. No one is advocating sending a child in to a nursery setting with a bad dose of chicken pox
Thatsplentyjack · 05/04/2022 21:33

So what makes you think your need to ensure bills are paid trumps their need for the same?

Hmm, let's see. Maybe because it's THEIR child and they are responsible for looking after them and taking care of them when they are ill no one else. If people aren't happy with that they should think twice about having children.

Staryflight445 · 05/04/2022 19:17

AnonAnom940

Staryflight445
He’s hot for a reason, teething doesn’t cause a temperature.

Of course he shouldn’t be at nursery if he needs calpol.
You've obviously never had a child suffer badly with teething then. Every tooth my child gets a slight temperature. Nothing else wrong with her except the tooth coming through.
^

I don’t think most people have to be fair when they say very seriously that homeopathy cures it. (Ashtons and parsons, teething gels etc)
Look at the videos where people pretend to bang their babies head against a door, their ‘awwww’ reaction has kids screaming. I’d assume such sympathetic response to a child would lead to you believing they were in pain with teething when (as I’ve stated before, dentists disbelieve it’s not painful).

There’s also another comment on this thread where they’ve mentioned a baby teething and then getting unwell with a virus not long after… it’s common sense is it not? So many unwell children go without things they need because parents pass it off as teething.

You’ve only got to look at most peoples opinions of teething to realise that they actually don’t know what they’re talking about.

‘my baby has been teething since she was a week old and is now 8 months old and still hasn’t cut a tooth 🙄’

Roundeartheratchriatmas · 05/04/2022 18:42

Good Lord they’d have loved me as a child. Always ran hot.

Even now as an adult normal body temperature for me can be up to 38.4 !

EV117 · 05/04/2022 18:32

YANBU. If a child is genuinely very ill then Calpol won’t ‘mask’ it. It will bring a high temp down slightly it doesn’t magically make them seem completely well.

felineweird · 05/04/2022 18:09

Bloody hell, find a different nursery!

Whattodoniw · 05/04/2022 17:18

[quote Staryflight445]@Lipsandlashes everyone else at the nursery pays exactly the same as you do, why do you feel more entitled to take a poorly child there because you pay for the privilege of the service?
The service can’t run properly whilst parents behave like this, surely that’s understandable?

A bug for one child can land another in hospital, why is that fair? those parents pay the same.[/quote]

Yep... but it seems lipsamdeyebrows is very entitled and no one else really does matter.....

LittleBearPad · 05/04/2022 17:17

I’d find another nursery. Those policies are absurd.

And depending on how many days that £1,900 covers I’d consider a nanny or nanny share instead of the nursery.

glitterelf · 05/04/2022 17:08

@Lipsandlashes

Yes I do hold parents responsible when I have to close due to them sending in their sick child even before covid as selfish parents are around long before covid Ah. So here is the crux of it *@glitterelf* You are acting out of a need to keep your childcare setting open and not threaten your livelihood. The child’s illness is secondary. It’s the consequence of you not being paid that matters to you. The thing is parents are also acting out of their need to go to work and make money and a nursery not admitting a child for a low temperature is preventing them from doing that. So what makes you think your need to ensure bills are paid trumps their need for the same? Interesting thought.
Nice assumption there the impact of closure doesn't just affect me financially it affects multiple families why is it so hard for you to understand that ? It also affects the selfish parents who sent their sick child in because I will send home a child who is that poorly they can't take part in activities or carry out our normal routine and in turn when my family have caught what their child brings in and I close that's a double whammy for them!! I also have a CV DH and care for CEV children so yes I expect parents to be honest and upfront regarding Illnesses as I am if anyone in my family is I'll it's called common courtesy.

Funnily enough and didn't have to close throughout the pandemic until the last month but that was because everyone was on the same page and being considerate of each other but now that's waned and if the last month is anything to go by this learning to live with it is only going to get worse.

Something for you to think about, over the years I've seen threads on numerous sites where potentially new childcare providers have been testing the waters on opening up a setting purely for sick / poorly children because we all know the impact on parents when they have to take time off work to care for their children. However there has never been one of these settings open up because you wouldn't want to be mixing sick children together with an array of ailments so the consensus is it wouldn't work so why do you think it's acceptable for sick children to be in childcare settings infecting others ?

CalpolDilemma · 05/04/2022 16:35

Those policies are utterly stupid. I wouldn't be paying out of my arse so my child could go one week a month how ridiculous

We pay £1,900 a month too (we’re in London, zone 2)

OP posts:
Lipsandlashes · 05/04/2022 16:24

Yes I do hold parents responsible when I have to close due to them sending in their sick child even before covid as selfish parents are around long before covid
Ah. So here is the crux of it @glitterelf You are acting out of a need to keep your childcare setting open and not threaten your livelihood. The child’s illness is secondary. It’s the consequence of you not being paid that matters to you. The thing is parents are also acting out of their need to go to work and make money and a nursery not admitting a child for a low temperature is preventing them from doing that. So what makes you think your need to ensure bills are paid trumps their need for the same? Interesting thought.

DownWithTheBloodyRedQueen · 05/04/2022 16:22

@CalpolDilemma

Admittedly I gave him the calpol and sent him to nursery. The policy is also that if he has a temperature of 37.5 or above, he can’t come to nursery for 4 clear days after. So essentially, the rest of the week. If he’s given calpol, he also has to stay away for 48 hours after the last dose. All this makes it impossible for me to work. So in the past 6 months, he’s attended maybe a total of one week out of each month.

He is teething. His nursery worker spotted the signs on handover.

I wouldn’t send him if he was actually unwell. He had the classic teething signs, and was just very slightly warm. But warm enough to miss nursery for the rest of the week if they checked his temperature.

I think this thread has shown me I need to look at other nurseries in the area and see if I can send him to one with more common sense, as the situation we’re in is really unsustainable.

Those policies are utterly stupid. I wouldn't be paying out of my arse so my child could go one week a month how ridiculous.
CalpolDilemma · 05/04/2022 15:50

Admittedly I gave him the calpol and sent him to nursery. The policy is also that if he has a temperature of 37.5 or above, he can’t come to nursery for 4 clear days after. So essentially, the rest of the week. If he’s given calpol, he also has to stay away for 48 hours after the last dose. All this makes it impossible for me to work. So in the past 6 months, he’s attended maybe a total of one week out of each month.

He is teething. His nursery worker spotted the signs on handover.

I wouldn’t send him if he was actually unwell. He had the classic teething signs, and was just very slightly warm. But warm enough to miss nursery for the rest of the week if they checked his temperature.

I think this thread has shown me I need to look at other nurseries in the area and see if I can send him to one with more common sense, as the situation we’re in is really unsustainable.

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 05/04/2022 15:39

No I don’t but when the child clearly isn’t well, eg doesn’t join in with friends, doesn’t eat snack, lunch etc, child isn’t their usual self then it’s clear this child doesn’t have a minor cold. But parent claims I’ve topped them up with calpol as they have a slight temperature and I can’t afford to take time off work, It’s wrong.

Kids can go from zero to unwell really quickly. It’s not at all uncommon for a child to seem to be fine except for a temperature when you get them up, especially if they are teething and for it to turn out to be a throat infection by a couple of hours later. Equally, it can just be a wee cold or headache and calpol can sort it out. Unless you are psychic, you can’t tell which is which. Ridiculous to suggest children with any big should stay at home no matter what.

As someone else stated. A bug for one child could mean a very severe illness or even a trip to the hospital for another.

Meanwhile, elsewhere we are told we just have to live with covid and only be off if we are unwell.

AnonAnom940 · 05/04/2022 15:19

@Staryflight445

He’s hot for a reason, teething doesn’t cause a temperature.

Of course he shouldn’t be at nursery if he needs calpol.

You've obviously never had a child suffer badly with teething then. Every tooth my child gets a slight temperature. Nothing else wrong with her except the tooth coming through.
glitterelf · 05/04/2022 15:18

@Lipsandlashes It is a parent's responsibility to ensure that their child is well enough and able to function whilst in a childcare setting it's is not the responsibility of a childcare provider to be a sick nurse for a child who's clearly not well enough to attend. Masking symptoms with calpol isn't on nor is parents not sharing vital information on whether they have given calpol as this could lead to providers giving doses before they should.
Parents who send their children to providers who won't give calpol that's their choice if it's in their policies then the parents will have agreed to this and if unhappy should seek another provider.

Yes I do hold parents responsible when I have to close due to them sending in their sick child even before covid as selfish parents are around long before covid. The person sneezing on a bus I would assume are an adult and capable of using a tissue or at worst the crook of their elbow, how many babies and toddlers do you know that are capable of doing either ?

Would you be happy if your childcare provider attended work with D&V, covid, chicken pox or other infectious ailments ?

2anddone · 05/04/2022 14:55

Yes you would be unreasonable. If you dose him up on calpol he will have the 11am slump and all of the nursery staff will know you have given it to him!
@Glenthebattleostrich ThanksThanksI am also a childminder fed up with parents thinking they can make their own rules! Hope your dd is better soon my ds caught 'teething' last month and had to miss his gcse mock exams Angry

Staryflight445 · 05/04/2022 14:48

@Lipsandlashes - if parents are sending their kids in with stomach virus symptoms and the childcare setting has to close, why wouldn’t it be the parents fault?

It’s everybody’s responsibility when they’re using a childcare setting to ensure their children are healthy and well enough to attend.
They shouldn’t be taken in if they’ve been vomiting, had diarrhoea, or are unwell enough to need calpol/ not being themselves.

Anyone ignoring their child’s basic needs because they don’t want to keep their kid home is a shitty parent as well tbh.

Helendee · 05/04/2022 14:45

@Glenthebattleostrich

Same for me. It’s infuriating, some parents are very selfish.

Staryflight445 · 05/04/2022 14:43

That’s awful you’ve lost income because of selfish parental behaviour @glitterelf

We’ve also had attendance letters recently after my kids at school have constantly contracted norovirus, covid, chicken pox. It’s been never ending and very clear parents are just sending their children into school no matter the state they’re in so they don’t have to have them at home or take time off work.

It’s terrible.

Lipsandlashes · 05/04/2022 14:41

The piousness on this thread is ridiculous. When I go to work and come down with a cold a few days later I don’t start blaming work colleagues. I’ve had children in nursery who have caught everything under the sun. Eldest DD caught norovirus and spread it around the family - I was 3 months pregnant and thought I was going to die, I was so Ill. It took me two weeks to recover. I certainly didn’t blame the parents of the other children she was in nursery with. Illness and bugs happen. It isn’t other parents responsibility to ensure your child doesn’t get any illnesses - ever! Just like it isn’t the person on the bus’ responsibility if they sneeze and you get a cold. Unfortunately it’s life and all part of being a functioning member of society.
Of course you should keep your child off nursery if they are poorly and miserable and just want their parent but not for every bloody slightly raised temperature - just in case it turns into something else. How with their immune systems ever develop properly?

glitterelf · 05/04/2022 14:37

@Staryflight445

Yup, they always say treat the child not the fever *@glitterelf*

Which is why a child shouldn’t be at nursery if they need it, because it already means they’re not behaving normally.

Exactly over the years of being a childminder I've had an array of children arrive literally bouncing off the walls because parents have given them a special treat so they'd take their magic medicine only for children to be upchucking hours later or become lethargic within hours of the magic medicine wearing off. In the last month alone I've had Norovirus and covid close my setting because apparently the children were fine before drop off Hmm yet I'm the parent who's getting attendance letters because I point blank refuse to send my sick child into school where she has CEV peers.
Staryflight445 · 05/04/2022 14:27

Yup, they always say treat the child not the fever @glitterelf

Which is why a child shouldn’t be at nursery if they need it, because it already means they’re not behaving normally.

Staryflight445 · 05/04/2022 14:25

@Lipsandlashes

‘
Absolute rubbish and you know it. Do you call in sick to work after you’ve taken a couple of paracetamol? If not, why not? You’re obviously I’ll and could be passing your (completely non contagious) symptoms (pain!) on to someone else. Such double standards.
HTH!‘

Still being patronising I see.
Would I call in sick if I needed paracetamol? It depends I suppose, I’m an adult, can understand my body and communicate to myself how I feel. I’m not a child who cannot communicate that, and an adults work environment isn’t a germ breeding ground, I also have a fully developed immune system and can take measures to protect others such as not sneezing/coughing into mid air, clean my hands properly and travel home in the event I need to. I don’t spend all day touching everything other people touch as well.

Why are you even trying to compare the 2? HTH. 🙄