Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult dc paying their way?

112 replies

poormee · 05/04/2022 08:11

Dh and I are working class we manage ok but do not have loads of spare cash. But we are lucky we can afford our bills. We have 3 dc, one is 8, one is 20 and at uni and the eldest is 22 and moved out this year. When we do anything together there's always an assumption that we pay so say we are having a meal out obviously we would pay for our self's and dc8 but the elder two expect us to pay for them which gets expensive. An example we went out for dh bday, both adult dc were drinking alcohol but did not offer to contribute (tbf we didn't ask) so we paid the lot. Next day we all took dc 8 to a soft play and we got everyone drinks. Older dc wanted lunch but we had eaten before (we did tell them we would be so they could too) I said they could get something if they want but we weren't. they didn't want to pay for themselves as not cheap but kept moaning they were Hungary. Dc20 is at uni, course and accom is covered by loan, we pay his food and he has a part time job for socialising etc. Dc22 works full time but is low wage she pays her own bills at her rented flat. They both have expensive tastes re clothes/lifestyle which is why they often don't have much money. When is it reasonable to stop paying for adult dc? If we were rich obviously it wouldn't be issue but we are at a point where we don't do as much as can't afford to take them too.

OP posts:
Swayingpalmtrees · 05/04/2022 09:24

I also don't think you should bankroll their birthday meals if you can't afford to, offer a cake and drinks at home instead.

phishy · 05/04/2022 09:24

@Swayingpalmtrees that’s sad, I can’t imagine not wanting to spend time with a decent parent, at any age.

Swayingpalmtrees · 05/04/2022 09:23

As a young adult the only time I would see my parents would be for a free lunch or dinner, as I enjoyed being with my friends at that age. I agree with horst one they have to pay you are unlikely to see them!

phishy · 05/04/2022 09:23

@Horst

If you invite you pay. I’m not sure why the 20 or 22 year old would be at soft play again unless invited tbh. Even as a parent soft play is hell.

If you want them to pay for their meals you need to make this clearly but highly expect they will stop coming as paying for a meal out with your little sibling and parents vs a meal out with friends or partner the friends or partner is going to be the more fun event.

But the 20yo and 22yo are expecting meals out and presents on their birthday.

So it’s not like they are being forced to attend these meals.

Norgie · 05/04/2022 09:22

Mine started paying their own way for everything as soon as they started earning their own money.

ArtVandalay · 05/04/2022 09:22

Ours are 23 and 19. Younger is at uni ft, older one is doing master’s around working ft.

We pay for everything. I wouldn’t feel happy asking them to contribute to meals out etc. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with wanting a contribution if you need the money. I also think the way your own parents were/are is a factor.

The eldest is saving for a deposit, so I’d rather his money went there.

They are both very generous with presents etc.

Cameleongirl · 05/04/2022 09:21

IMO, they’re at transition ages where parents would generally still pay for meals our, etc. But as PP’s have said, if you can’t, say so.

DH and I (late 40’s) both started paying for meals for our parents in our late 20’s and cover most things now. We’ve bought plane tickets for them in the past for holidays-I’d say we were covering everything by our mid-30’s.

Horst · 05/04/2022 09:21

If you invite you pay. I’m not sure why the 20 or 22 year old would be at soft play again unless invited tbh. Even as a parent soft play is hell.

If you want them to pay for their meals you need to make this clearly but highly expect they will stop coming as paying for a meal out with your little sibling and parents vs a meal out with friends or partner the friends or partner is going to be the more fun event.

phishy · 05/04/2022 09:19

It probably differs from family to family. I grew up working class and see meals out as a bit of a waste when the money could be saved towards a new car or house extension (we would never take out a loan).

Yet DH also grew up working class and would think nothing of blowing £200+ on a meal for 2.

I think money, or lack thereof, affects people differently.

LizzieMacQueen · 05/04/2022 09:17

I think it depends on the situation. If you invite them out to celebrate your birthday ( or your DH as in this scenario ) then I think you should pay.

notacooldad · 05/04/2022 09:15

My adult kids both have got a mortgage ( one is 22 and the other is 25, he started his mortgage for a year)
We don’t have a particularly large amount of money but I am happy to pick up the tab for them when we go to gigs, meals out, theatre etc.

The do offer to pay and every now and then I let them. I don’t want them to expect me to pay all the time but I remember what it was like when I first got my house and money was tight.

I’m also happy to pay for them to have odd weekends away and I have just payed DS1s car insurance and I’ve paid ds2s council tax for the year.
So to answer your question ‘ When is it reasonable to stop paying for adult dc?’ The answer is either when you want to ( which maybe never) or when you can’t afford to pay for things any more. There is also the other scenario which is when they become entitled and expect you to do it all the time. I would stop any handouts and treats there and then if I got wind they were taking advantage of me.

We are working class so never eat out or go to the pub
I’m a bit puzzled at this. Going to the pub is one of the most working class things that comes to mind when I think oaf what do working class people do. My local is full of Working class including me and DH!

Both are due a decent pay raise as this year so I’ll be able to ease off a bit.
I’m just glad that they have been in a position to buy their home so I don’t mind helping.

MichelleScarn · 05/04/2022 09:15

Did they want to come to the soft play to see younger sibling play about? How expensive are the restaurants you're going to?
Agree with @HappyGoDucky If you feel this way I'd stop inviting or accepting invites for meals out/activities as it's very clear you and your DC can't really afford it.

StrawberryPot · 05/04/2022 09:13

@00100001 -

"I'd say the uni kid is in the same situation as my DS...."

If you think that then you're both in for a shock if your ds goes to uni.

ExConstance · 05/04/2022 09:12

I have two grown up sons, both live independently, the youngest with his girlfriend. They are all joining us for Easter, and to celebrate DS1's birthday. DS1 earns a lot more than me or DH. We will be going out for a family meal and cocktails and yes, you've guessed it, we will be expected to pay for everything, just because we always have. And of course we will. It is OK this year because we are both working and I have had a little Covid related bonus I have put on one side for this but year we will be retired and things will have to change. I feel sad in a way because I like treating them but a bit sad as they seem to take it for granted.

MatildaTheCat · 05/04/2022 09:11

I agree with @phishy. Make some changes but without saying much. Have a meal at home and ask the DC to do a pudding, go for a picnic etc and ask them to bring along a bottle of wine. If they complain just say times are tight for everyone which is true.

If and when you do go out again agree beforehand who pays for what. They’ll be earning soon and even then they won’t like paying unless you’ve already made changes. We still mostly end up paying for out 30 ish DC and their partners. It’s a habit that has to be broken at some point.

ThatsBullshirt · 05/04/2022 09:10

I am from working class parents with several siblings (youngest 24, oldest now 42). On the very rare occasion we go out for dinner (celebratory only) or all go on holiday together we all pay our own way. I know my parents struggled for money while we were all growing up and still don't have lots extra now so I wouldn't dream of expecting them to pay.

My in-laws, on the other hand, are more middle class (in terms of money now) pay for everything because they insist and they want to. We do occasionally pay for takeaway or drinks if we've gone out for dinner but they insist on paying for meals out, takeaways, going on holiday. That being said, all they would have to do is give us a heads up about needing to pay our share for a meal etc. and we would.

I think you just need to communicate to your adult children that now they are grown and presumably have their own money that they need to start paying their share as, if they don't, you can't afford to keep going for dinner etc.

00100001 · 05/04/2022 09:05

@StrawberryPot I'd say the uni kid is in the same situation as my DS. so there's literally no reason why OPs lad couldn't buy his mum a coffee once in a while. I'll bet he finds money to buy a round for his mates down the pub or a takeaway...

Swayingpalmtrees · 05/04/2022 09:05

In your position I would pay if you are inviting them to lunch or dinner, but make it clear this will not include alcohol and on this occasion no girlfriends or boyfriends. If they still order drinks, then I would ask the waiter to separate the bill from the drinks and they pay.

You are not a cash point, and it sounds like you are feeling used and abused.

I am of the view that if you invite others out, you pay. So perhaps stop inviting them? It is normal to pay for family birthday dinners, but not an extended guest list that they are directing. I would start to formalise things and put some boundaries in place or just take out your 8 year old and stop inviting the adult children? Or do a cheaper buffet at home with inexpensive drinks and ask them to bring a bottle of wine and join you.

They are not children, but they are still young and struggling so I would always try to be as generous as I could, funds allowing.

SueSaid · 05/04/2022 09:05

I wouldn't take my family out for dh's birthday if we couldn't afford to pay for our dc.

Just have a buffet at home or something next time?

I'm all for adult dc paying their way bills wise etc but family celebrations? No.

00100001 · 05/04/2022 09:03

@StrawberryPot

00100001 - that's nice. But your ds is presumably living rent and bill free? Unlike the op's dcs.
Hardly the point.... The uni child has a PT job with no other bills ...

The older child works full time and is spending money on luxuries.

Not like either of them are relying on food vouchers to feed their kids... Hmm

whatisforteamum · 05/04/2022 08:59

We are working class so never eat out or go to the pub.
Dcs paid some housekeeping as soon as they started working.
Ds is 23 and loves to eat out and treats himself a lot.
He does contribute to household and agreed to buy food shop once a month online.
Clothes, toiletries and driving lessons paid for by both dc.
They need to know the value of money.

phishy · 05/04/2022 08:57

Could you have a meal at home instead for the next year or so so they get out of the habit of expecting to be paid for?

And if a meal is too much when you and DH are busy, could you have a cake at home, with snacks?

Tell dd now that she can’t expect her boyfriend to be paid for, she needs to learn that lesson regardless.

What do they for you and DH when it’s your birthdays?

poormee · 05/04/2022 08:52

There just always seems like to be something like dh birthday, then it was dd birthday and we ended up paying for everyone plus her bf! Who works full time and lives at home rent free!! They always expect a meal plus gifts on birthdays. I think this stems from lockdown when we would get a takeaway for bdays as we were all stuck in together. Also was dd graduation so we paid for a meal out again. Just been a lot lately need to find a way to curb it abit. I think because when dd was at uni ds was still at school so if we did anything he wasn't working so would need to be paid for but seemed mean to ask dd to pay her self but now ds just says but you paid for dd when she was at uni. But they also do it if we are just hanging out, say nipping to shops will want coffee or lunch

OP posts:
TheSandgroper · 05/04/2022 08:51

Now is a good time. Decide going forward what you can manage and advise them of your expectations.

As mentioned on the current hen party thread, never apologise for saying you can’t afford it.

HappyGoDucky · 05/04/2022 08:46

If you feel this way I'd stop inviting or accepting invites for meals out/activities as it's very clear you and your DC can't really afford it.

I won't be asking my DC to pay their way for restaurant meals until I know they are financially comfortable- I'm hoping they will slowly be saving for house deposit and don't want to hinder that or make life completely miserable.