Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult dc paying their way?

112 replies

poormee · 05/04/2022 08:11

Dh and I are working class we manage ok but do not have loads of spare cash. But we are lucky we can afford our bills. We have 3 dc, one is 8, one is 20 and at uni and the eldest is 22 and moved out this year. When we do anything together there's always an assumption that we pay so say we are having a meal out obviously we would pay for our self's and dc8 but the elder two expect us to pay for them which gets expensive. An example we went out for dh bday, both adult dc were drinking alcohol but did not offer to contribute (tbf we didn't ask) so we paid the lot. Next day we all took dc 8 to a soft play and we got everyone drinks. Older dc wanted lunch but we had eaten before (we did tell them we would be so they could too) I said they could get something if they want but we weren't. they didn't want to pay for themselves as not cheap but kept moaning they were Hungary. Dc20 is at uni, course and accom is covered by loan, we pay his food and he has a part time job for socialising etc. Dc22 works full time but is low wage she pays her own bills at her rented flat. They both have expensive tastes re clothes/lifestyle which is why they often don't have much money. When is it reasonable to stop paying for adult dc? If we were rich obviously it wouldn't be issue but we are at a point where we don't do as much as can't afford to take them too.

OP posts:
Swayingpalmtrees · 05/04/2022 11:05

This can be easily fixed, but in a gentle way they need to be reminded that adults contribute, pay their way and they are expected to at least offer once in a while. Otherwise I think you are setting yourself up for a lifetime of handouts and expectation. Everything from free meals to full childcare. Set your stall out now, and be open and talk about it. "Dad and I are finding money is tight atm. Next time we go out for dinner it would be great if you can chip in" or we won't be going out, money is tricky can everyone bring some food on Sunday and we will eat at home instead.

It is okay to live within your means, and for your children to get into the habit of helping out/paying their way or you will end up with entitled adult children looking to you for everything, they need to understand the value of money and independence.

Beautiful3 · 05/04/2022 10:47

This is a difficult one. The only way around it is to cook a dinner and have everyone over. Ask the grown up children to bring alcohol/puddings. If you tell one grown up child, to pay for their own, they probably won't come. I do think that if you're inviting your children somewhere, to celebrate then, then you should pay. Unless you all agreed beforehand, that adult children pay for themselves.

Horst · 05/04/2022 10:47

So who was originally going to watching the younger one during the meal? As that reads that just you and dh where going to go out?

LadyGardenersQuestionTime · 05/04/2022 10:44

In my experience, they will carry on acting like kids and assuming you will pay until you explicitly tell them you expect them to pay their way. My two still assume I'm paying unless I tell them I'm not and that I expect them to pay.

Weirdly, I discovered that when we went out for lunch with PIL DH was paying every time - I assumed MIL was paying Blush. But then it was her saying 'let's go out' and booking the restaurant. I've sorted their finances now and realised they are extremely comfortably off so have told them it's their turn to pay next time!

billy1966 · 05/04/2022 10:43

[quote poormee]@mizzo they had both come home for dh bday so then we felt obliged to invite them out as they said they didn't want to babysit and wouldn't have come home if they had known. The following day we said we were going soft play and they said they would come. We were clear it was coffee only but they obviously thought we might treat them while out so didn't eat before we left. [/quote]
This reads as so rude OP.

Your standards and expectations of your children are very low if they have been taught to speak to you that way.

They don't sound like nice kids.

The sound spoiled and rude.

I would be so firmly shutting my purse in the face of what you have just written.

I would also feel embarrassed that my children were that way and that I was tolerating such rudeness.

mjf981 · 05/04/2022 10:37

They're your children. Just tell them.
For the soft play example - I'd just say 'no I'm not paying for your lunch. We can't afford it. You can make a sandwich when we get home.' If they moan, say 'well you buy your own if you like.' End of. Its not rude, its factual. Stop being so British and skirting around the issue!

00100001 · 05/04/2022 10:34

[quote StrawberryPot]@00100001 -

"I'd say the uni kid is in the same situation as my DS...."

If you think that then you're both in for a shock if your ds goes to uni.
[/quote]
They're the same, in that both DS18 and OP20 are both having bills and food paid for (so are both "living for free" and both have part time jobs solely to fund socialising.

DS earns around £350-400 a month, and finds £20-30 a month willingly to buy us a lunch or a small shop or whatever.

What's so different about OPs son and mine?

Fooshufflewickjbannanapants · 05/04/2022 10:34

We only go out for meals for special occasions, our oldest 3 are 19,20 and 22 and ALWAYS offer to pay their way. Sometimes we say no we'll pay then they'll get a round in. Younger ones are 17,15 and 9 and tbf even my 17 yo offers!

poormee · 05/04/2022 10:28

@mizzo they had both come home for dh bday so then we felt obliged to invite them out as they said they didn't want to babysit and wouldn't have come home if they had known. The following day we said we were going soft play and they said they would come. We were clear it was coffee only but they obviously thought we might treat them while out so didn't eat before we left.

OP posts:
Brainwave89 · 05/04/2022 10:27

We funded ours through University- Our decision and we could do it. We did not expect them to get PT jobs. We have been clear though that when they work we will help then get on the housing ladder, but we will not be funding them. I do have friends with children in their 30s where they as a matter of course are still paying rent and mobile phone bills. I do not think this is sustainable.

LadyT27 · 05/04/2022 10:17

YUNBU. My family are working class as I soon as I was in college/uni, I had a part time job, I paid for most things myself. My mum would buy me a 'food shop' every once and a while to help out or sometimes help out if I have a big utility bill etc buy I would never assume or expect help and was always grateful. If we went out for meals, I and my siblings paid for ourselves and would only have our meal paid for if it was our birthday. We would also do rounds for drinks and everyone paid their own way. Although my parents could pay their bills, we knew they didn't have a lot of money left over so never expected to be fully supported once we could get jobs etc.
When I went into full time work on a low pay, I treated my parents when I was able to.
We had a cousin that expected every thing to be paid for and always accepted drinks and never put their hand in their pocket. The rest of us stopped including them in rounds and surprise surprise they stopped attending family events shortly after!
I would be very disappointed if my my children were still assuming everything to paid for at their age and never give back. They are old enough to know now. I think you should have a 'chat' with them.

mizzo · 05/04/2022 10:05

@JaniieJones

'If you invite you pay. I’m not sure why the 20 or 22 year old would be at soft play again unless invited tbh. Even as a parent soft play is hell.'

This!

I can't get my head around the soft play thing either Confused I'd expect to have to bribe my older DC with drinks and lunch if I wanted them to come with me to a play barn!
SueSaid · 05/04/2022 09:53

'If you invite you pay. I’m not sure why the 20 or 22 year old would be at soft play again unless invited tbh. Even as a parent soft play is hell.'

This!

Seleniummillenium · 05/04/2022 09:51

We have totally the same issue. Our step son is 28. He has a good well paid job, has his own house. Whenever we suggest going out for tea, lunch etc, he always agrees and will often have an expensive thing off the menu, ie steak.

In all the years he’s been an adult and he's come out with us for meals or lunches, he’s never once offered to pay or even paid for his own meal. He’s always just assumed we would pay. The only time he’s ever been put in an embarrassing situation with it was when we went out for my husband’s birthday meal and his new girlfriend basically told him to get his hand in his pocket.

We have another adult son together and he offers to pay frequently.

It is annoying but it’s something that’s always happened. Like @ExConstance it’s the assumption that bothers me more than the actual paying.

girlmom21 · 05/04/2022 09:49

I've never been for a meal with my parents or DP's parents and not at least offered to pay my way since I've been working.

It's such an entitled attitude.

Tell them they're adults now. They need to pay their way unless you explicitly tell them you're paying. Set their expectations for birthdays and Christmas. You simply can't afford to treat them like children forever.

If you can't tell them now you're going to end up in all kinds of grief when they have their own families.

BlingLoving · 05/04/2022 09:48

I think this absolutely varies from family to family but that at some point each family needs to look at the way it's working and if it doesn't make certain members happy, then change it.

So, your DC expect to be paid for. You feel this is not something your'e willing/able to do. In which case, the conversation should be, "right, we can all go out for dad's birthday but we can't afford to pay for 4 adult meals so either everyone chips in or let's get a cheaper takeaway/I'll cook at home".

These sort of informal conversations have happened with us regularly. We'll agree as a family if something is too expensive or not and what the alternatives are. Having said that, at least one of my siblings has form for never putting their hand in their pocket.....

phishy · 05/04/2022 09:47

@Swayingpalmtrees

No worries at all phishy I am grateful my teens seem to still enjoy seeing us, and I learnt a lot from my own experiences as a child, so i hope I have managed a better outcome for my own children. I was very poor as a young person, and only just affording the packet noodles once a day (great for the waist line) so any hope of a cooked meal was always an incentive to put up with my father! I hope op can find a way forward that makes her children feel welcome. I often think the foundations that go down now as an adult to adult relationship set the tone for the future. It is always better to have a warm and inclusive event, that brings everyone together even if it is a very cheap pasta dish and a few drinks to share, it does not have to be costly dinners out.
It sounds like you are doing well with your dc.

We (family of 8) were very poor growing up but had good parents, it seems we are shaped by our childhood experiences. I have to urge myself to loosen the purse strings now and then Wink

Renovationstation · 05/04/2022 09:45

I think on their birthdays make it clear they can either have a gift or you will pay for their meal out.

If you're inviting them out to celebrate someone else's birthday I think paying for the food and soft drinks but they buy their own alcohol is reasonable. If that's not affordable just go out you and DH then host a nice family meal at home for everyone.

I think transitioning them at this age is fine if money is tight, they're old enough to understand cost of living increases and no reason you have to scrimp or for the little one to miss out on the experiences they had as children.

negomi90 · 05/04/2022 09:43

I think it depends on the family. There is no right or wrong.
My parents split when I was young. When I was in uni if either went out to eat with me they'd pay. Now I'm working my dad still pays if we go somewhere and he wouldn't want me to. My mum and I tend to go more even but I often pay more overall (family holiday coming up and I'm paying for my own hotel room big enough to have my teenage siblings share with me). Neither parent is wrong but you need to talk to your kids about money and your concerns and set expectations in advance.

Horst · 05/04/2022 09:40

Just because they expect a meal out for birthdays doesn’t mean they get it but someone started that traditions that then become expected and again who actually books/arranges it. If it’s the op still then basically she’s the one inviting them again to a celebration meal for their birthday. If they are inviting their parents to somewhere they have booked then they are the inviter.

We let the children pick birthday dinner. As in home cooked or take away, my In laws do birthday meal out or take away. My parents do take away. Tends to be whatever your parents started that becomes the expected and tradition.

Swayingpalmtrees · 05/04/2022 09:38

No worries at all phishy I am grateful my teens seem to still enjoy seeing us, and I learnt a lot from my own experiences as a child, so i hope I have managed a better outcome for my own children. I was very poor as a young person, and only just affording the packet noodles once a day (great for the waist line) so any hope of a cooked meal was always an incentive to put up with my father!
I hope op can find a way forward that makes her children feel welcome. I often think the foundations that go down now as an adult to adult relationship set the tone for the future. It is always better to have a warm and inclusive event, that brings everyone together even if it is a very cheap pasta dish and a few drinks to share, it does not have to be costly dinners out.

Girlmum91 · 05/04/2022 09:37

Probably best to not go to restaurants when the eldest is home and if they ask why then explain that money is tight. Nothing wrong with being honest.

phishy · 05/04/2022 09:32

Fair point, sorry @Swayingpalmtrees

Swayingpalmtrees · 05/04/2022 09:31

I didn't have great parents phishy so I preferred the world outside of the family unit from a young age.
However, if money is tight most young people will choose to spend it on having fun, and not necessarily family meals with an 8 year old at soft play or family type restaurants, and that was the case with all of my friends.

billy1966 · 05/04/2022 09:26

Are you afraid of them?

I cannot imagine being silent in the face of such rudeness and entitled behaviour.

Your daughter including her boyfriend without running it past you.

Stop ALL celebrations and outings and tell them why.

This is not normal behaviour OP.

You have created this situation so you now need to kill it.