Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult dc paying their way?

112 replies

poormee · 05/04/2022 08:11

Dh and I are working class we manage ok but do not have loads of spare cash. But we are lucky we can afford our bills. We have 3 dc, one is 8, one is 20 and at uni and the eldest is 22 and moved out this year. When we do anything together there's always an assumption that we pay so say we are having a meal out obviously we would pay for our self's and dc8 but the elder two expect us to pay for them which gets expensive. An example we went out for dh bday, both adult dc were drinking alcohol but did not offer to contribute (tbf we didn't ask) so we paid the lot. Next day we all took dc 8 to a soft play and we got everyone drinks. Older dc wanted lunch but we had eaten before (we did tell them we would be so they could too) I said they could get something if they want but we weren't. they didn't want to pay for themselves as not cheap but kept moaning they were Hungary. Dc20 is at uni, course and accom is covered by loan, we pay his food and he has a part time job for socialising etc. Dc22 works full time but is low wage she pays her own bills at her rented flat. They both have expensive tastes re clothes/lifestyle which is why they often don't have much money. When is it reasonable to stop paying for adult dc? If we were rich obviously it wouldn't be issue but we are at a point where we don't do as much as can't afford to take them too.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
user1471457751 · 06/04/2022 00:59

So you're happy for your parents to pay for you but don't want to pay for your children.

AbsentmindedWoman · 05/04/2022 19:03

[quote KELLOGSspeck]@AbsentmindedWoman true but for your own dad's birthday though... it does seem entitled. If your not going to pay any other time.[/quote]
You could be right, but I just wonder if it's carelessness and lack of emotional maturity, rather than real selfish entitled-ness.

But yes totally agree it would be much better if they were thoughtful enough to at least pay a token amount or show willing to chip in in some way!

Shinyandnew1 · 05/04/2022 18:48

They sound pretty cheeky, to be honest.

I don’t get this though…

They always expect a meal plus gifts on birthdays. I think this stems from lockdown when we would get a takeaway for bdays as we were all stuck in together.

If they’d got used to takeaways over lockdown for birthday, why don’t you do takeaways for their birthday now-they would be half the cost!

I wouldn’t go out for meals if we couldn’t afford it-we go out pretty sparingly. For birthdays, do takeaways or cook a nice meal and do cake.

I wouldn’t invite 20 year olds to soft play and I certainly wouldn’t buy them lunch especially if I’d specifically told them we weren’t eating there. That’s their look out if they couldn’t be arsed to feed themselves beforehand!

PlntLady · 05/04/2022 18:37

You 2 older DC are adults who make their own choices and have their own capacity for earning. They should be paying for themselves.
Tbh your probably not doing then any favours for continuing to pay for them. They need to learn that others want pay for them forever and to live within their means at some point.

alereal · 05/04/2022 18:20

My friend recently changed the rules with her adult niece and nephew. Suggested meeting up for dinner, range of venues/prices for them to choose from and noted it would mark a change where all couples paid for themselves. Cue no ordering of pricey cocktails.

dianthus101 · 05/04/2022 18:17

You need to have a conversation with them about it but they're probably not going to come out with you as much in future, particularly for trips to soft plays. They're likely to prioritise their money on going out with friends.

KELLOGSspeck · 05/04/2022 18:17

@AbsentmindedWoman true but for your own dad's birthday though... it does seem entitled. If your not going to pay any other time.

AbsentmindedWoman · 05/04/2022 18:07

Why would you assume though? Just because it is your mum/dad I don't get it tbh. You wouldn't assume your friend pays for everything so to assume you must lack awareness to some extent. I would feel uncomfortable and would offer purely on good manners.

This will be different in every family - the dynamics and the relationships with money and attitudes towards young people.

I know there are some parents for example who really don't want their kid to take paid jobs through A levels or at university, to concentrate on study. So they provide everything. Then the dynamic will have to change eventually, once their kid is out in the world independently.

Then there are kids who get little/ no help from family and are constantly pretty broke and maybe assume their parents are in a better position than them and don't realise if they're not. Not every parent is frank and open about family finances, though perhaps this is changing?

People get settled into their roles in the family dynamic and it can take time to shift perspectives.

Scout2016 · 05/04/2022 18:04

Not buying their dad a drink on his birthday at the very least is really off. If they went out for their mate's birthday I'm sure they'd either buy them a drink or get a round in.

Even if they are skint they try to make a contribution - pay for the taxi or a bottle of wine or something.

poormee · 05/04/2022 17:57

@AbsentmindedWoman 😂😂 I take your point. I think they couldn't be arsed to make anything, then when out felt hungry. It's quite a nice soft play on a farm so food is good but expensive.

OP posts:
PussGirl · 05/04/2022 17:56

My DS is a university student on a very limited income & even so will insist on buying me a coffee occasionally, & is always very appreciative of the money I spend on him.

It's more about the attitude than the actual sums involved.

JustOneMoreStep · 05/04/2022 17:49

My parents paid for me to go out for meals etc, but to be honest we only did it for special occasions. There was no expectation for me to pay at my siblings graduation for example. I think they viewed it as a 'family event' and they wanted me there. On the flip side, if we were out and stopped for a coffee or a McD or something I often pay. For my parents special occasions e.g. birthday I'd often pay for everyone (and I paid for my siblings to attend too).

mizzo · 05/04/2022 17:46

[quote poormee]@mizzo they had both come home for dh bday so then we felt obliged to invite them out as they said they didn't want to babysit and wouldn't have come home if they had known. The following day we said we were going soft play and they said they would come. We were clear it was coffee only but they obviously thought we might treat them while out so didn't eat before we left. [/quote]
Oh dear OP. This doesn't paint them in a very good light. I think you need to have a chat with them.

AbsentmindedWoman · 05/04/2022 17:40

Are the eldest two biologically yours and your husband's kids?

Or are either of you a step parent?

AbsentmindedWoman · 05/04/2022 17:39

[quote poormee]@mizzo they had both come home for dh bday so then we felt obliged to invite them out as they said they didn't want to babysit and wouldn't have come home if they had known. The following day we said we were going soft play and they said they would come. We were clear it was coffee only but they obviously thought we might treat them while out so didn't eat before we left. [/quote]
How much was travel home from uni or work?

Did they come home expecting to spend the birthday with you and your DH, and you expected that they would babysit so you and DH could go out just the two of you?

It sounds like lots of crossed wires...

I do find it bizarre you think they only went to soft play to cadge some crappy food Confused I'd never have done that as a student and nor would my friends! It sounds maybe like they wanted to spend more time hanging out together?

KELLOGSspeck · 05/04/2022 17:25

@mamabeeboo

I've been on the other end of that, as an adult child who did expect to be paid for. The only reason I felt like that was because my parents never said otherwise, so I just assumed they were okay with it.

Then a few months later, DM said that she would like us to agree who is paying for what before we went. So it was clear. I was happy to pay for myself, and that was the end of that. I think that's key in your OP that you're missing. You need to agree what the cost split will be before you agree to go for dinner or whatever. Then if they don't want to go, then that's their choice.

Why would you assume though? Just because it is your mum/dad I don't get it tbh. You wouldn't assume your friend pays for everything so to assume you must lack awareness to some extent. I would feel uncomfortable and would offer purely on good manners.
MissMaple82 · 05/04/2022 17:25

I could understand if they were late 20s or 30's they are still fairly young. I wouldn't begrudge paying for my children's meals out!

StaplesCorner · 05/04/2022 17:24

Lovely thread on here recently about how much MNetters appreciate the thoughtful things their parents do for them, some posters in their 60s too, somethings cost money some didn't. I was amazed as the usual stance on MN is one a child turns 16 they are entitled little shits what with all their free heating, food and accommodation etc. ... Hmm

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/_chat/4519477-Little-thoughtful-things-your-parents-still-do-for-you\

Ultimately can you afford to treat your DC? If you genuinely can't then they'll have to get used to it, but if you can and choose not to then I'd say that was pretty crap but I might be in the minority. Personally I love paying for things for my adult DDs.

mamabeeboo · 05/04/2022 17:22

I've been on the other end of that, as an adult child who did expect to be paid for. The only reason I felt like that was because my parents never said otherwise, so I just assumed they were okay with it.

Then a few months later, DM said that she would like us to agree who is paying for what before we went. So it was clear. I was happy to pay for myself, and that was the end of that. I think that's key in your OP that you're missing. You need to agree what the cost split will be before you agree to go for dinner or whatever. Then if they don't want to go, then that's their choice.

SixteenTwelve · 05/04/2022 17:22

I am the child in this situation. It’s super awkward partly because there are age gaps between me and my siblings which mean we have entered different life stages at different times.

I think it very much depends on where you are going and what you are doing and whether it is something your DC could reasonably afford to do/would choose to do without you.

Both my parents and DPs parents generally pay but we occasionally foot the bill as a gesture and if there are a lot of people (eg. Everyone’s partner and kids as well) we just agree who is paying for what in advance.

Blossom64265 · 05/04/2022 17:07

I would expect to be fully supporting a student at university. That doesn’t mean you are an unending cash machine. It’s perfectly fine to have a budget and stick to it. Drinks are not a necessity. Neither is eating out during every outing. Support means necessities like rent and groceries.

It’s nice to treat your kids in their 20s, but it’s ok to have a budget for that too. A home cooked meal is often really appreciated and likely is going to be much more affordable than a night out. I also never expected to drink if my parents took us out to dinner as it just made the meal too expensive.

We are in our late 40s and our parents still sometimes have us over for dinner. It’s not so much about the money at this point. We are likely to bring a bottle of wine or a contribution that covers the cost of our meal, it’s about the time to prep the home cooked meal which is something that is incredibly scarce for us, but that they have a good amount of since they are retired.

CatsArePeople · 05/04/2022 16:58

With adults, you should be able to communicate these things. Like, ok, today's treat is on us, but tomorrow you pay.

SalsaLove · 05/04/2022 16:58

My PIL always paid for me and DH until I told DH to man up and get his money out ahead of time. To ask for the bill. His parents were surprised the first couple of times but my DH was happy to do it and felt like an ‘adult’. Not working class or entitlement but more how his parents did things. They wanted to treat us but at 4 times a year in their retirement it seemed like a lot.

Horst · 05/04/2022 16:46

So they came back to visit dad on his birthday. Costing whatever from wherever they live, I’m guessing brought gifts for dad too. You had no plans, dad then decided hey let’s go for a meal for my birthday as a treat.

Certainly sounds like a parent paying trip to eat out tbh.

KELLOGSspeck · 05/04/2022 16:37

I'm not sure why a 20 and 22 year olds would want to cone along to a soft play. The 22 year-old I would advise her to flat share to save money...

I think you obviously need to have a word with your older kids and explain you won't be paying and you have your own plans to save.

Swipe left for the next trending thread