Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want an electric car?

318 replies

Elevenfourteen · 04/04/2022 19:57

I know IABU for asking such a dull question, but my Dh wants to buy an electric car and I’m not convinced.
I guess they’re better for the environment so that’s one thing. But are we set up for them properly yet? Do all garages have charging points? Do you have to hang around the garage for ages while they charge? I just can’t imagine how they can be a practical option.
Driving to work and back and charging at night is fine, but what about going on holiday?

Do any of you have electric cars and can you reassure me?

OP posts:
Coffeeonmytoffee · 05/04/2022 06:30

Throw a car away? Do people do that? I sold my car because I’d had it 15 years and it couldn’t go in the ULEZ zone. I decided to replace it with an electric car because I live in london and the ULEZ is only going to get bigger and I don’t want to have to buy another car - ever!!
I sold it to a lady who lives in Sussex and only does a few thousand miles a year.

I’m not sure I could have thrown it away it wouldn’t go in my bin. Why are some people so weird about electric cars? No one is saying they’re perfect but they’re the best we have at the moment.
I also don’t fly or eat meat if that helps.

Keladrythesaviour · 05/04/2022 00:50

I've had my i3 two years now and I'll never go back to a non electric. I absolutely love it. Only once have I got into a slight range concern but I've done that in a petrol car too! We've got a drive way and gone charger, plus on Octopus Go so cheap night charging. Rarely use mid route chargers except when we travel to my in-laws caravan in west Wales.. the Welsh infrastructure is somewhat lacking still so we usually charge in Shropshire before heading over, but as a mid point in a 4 hour trip it comes as a perfect toilet stop. We usually use morrisons - get a coffee and use the loo etc.
DH has a plug in hybrid (vw Passat) as we needed one bigger car. It only has a 30mile range but it's perfect for his commute. We want to swap it for a full EV eventually but need one with a big range as we like to do driving holidays across Europe. They've got an excellent infrastructure so that isn't the concern, just the distance we want to cover between stops. The i3 has about 120-150 depending on weather so absolutely fine for UK journeys.
When visiting family or friends overnight we often put the grannycharger through a window and bung them a tenner whilst it charges over night (they offer, we will use public chargers otherwise).
There's a reason the vast majority of people who have EVs evangalise about them. They really are fabulous. Plus the i3 has a real kick to it!

Blossomtoes · 05/04/2022 00:35

@SwanBuster

Ah *@Blossomtoes! Have a read - if only those buy to let landlord parasites on the other thread read this, they’ll see that I wasn’t bullshitting when I said I can more than* afford to do what they do but don’t 😂
😉😂😂😂
SwanBuster · 05/04/2022 00:29

[quote Lunar27]@SwanBuster

If business was going well enough I'd happily go for a taycan but sadly I could only afford the BMW!

Not that it's the booby prize by any means, as it's a great (albeit expensive) hatch but the taycan is in another league!

Haha. I remember the Mondeo.[/quote]
The i3 is a fab car and immensely fun 👍

Re the Taycan: I’d only get one if my work started offering the salary sacrifice EV deal that some do. If they did - I’d get (a cross turismo) for the 4 years and keep the Tesla for after.

Go drive one though anyway if you haven’t had a chance and can swing it! You just have to pretend very very solemnly you’re interested 😂 Though I did it last year and god knows if any dealer has a demonstrator available any more.

AlwaysLatte · 05/04/2022 00:28

We've had one for about 18 months now and absolutely love it. The acceleration and braking is brilliant, very responsive. And we charge it at home overnight at cheap rate. I zip about all the time on school runs and parent help so clock up about 100 miles a day. But we also have a diesel estate which we use for longer journeys so we've never had to test the ecv on charging stops (in fact never charged it anywhere other than home). Still not quite confident enough to trade in the estate but when the range is longer or charging en route more reliable we'll trade that in for a second electric.

SwanBuster · 05/04/2022 00:22

Mind you, I guess I’m a bit of a parasite when it comes to the EV freebies and perks currently available 😂🤦‍♀️

Lunar27 · 05/04/2022 00:20

@SwanBuster

If business was going well enough I'd happily go for a taycan but sadly I could only afford the BMW!

Not that it's the booby prize by any means, as it's a great (albeit expensive) hatch but the taycan is in another league!

Haha. I remember the Mondeo.

SwanBuster · 05/04/2022 00:12

Ah @Blossomtoes! Have a read - if only those buy to let landlord parasites on the other thread read this, they’ll see that I wasn’t bullshitting when I said I can more than afford to do what they do but don’t 😂

SwanBuster · 05/04/2022 00:08

@Lunar27 - if you can blag it somehow, try a Taycan 👍

I haven’t tried the Model S Plaid yet obvs because they aren’t available here, but the Taycan is very good as a drivers car. Nowhere near as good as my personal favourite drivers car though ….

…. My dads old Mondeo was an absolute beautiful feedback through the wheel monster 😂

wardrobewarrior · 05/04/2022 00:08

Not sure why some people are saying they cost 30 k ? That's not the only option at all. You can pick up second hand ones really cheap. Or buy on finance to spread the cost. I would never put down cash for any depreciating asset like a car.

Blossomtoes · 05/04/2022 00:06

@FuzzyPuffling

I've never driven an automatic in my long life. I'm not sure I want to learn that now.
Easy as can be. And once you’ve done it there’s no going back. I’ve been driving an automatic for 12 years now, I doubt I could drive a manual any more. We have a hybrid and it’s a joy to drive. We’re considering fully electric when we replace it.
Lunar27 · 05/04/2022 00:03

@MobLife

Aren't they really incredibly dull to drive? I love driving and hate automatics 😂
I think it'll be a while before the really driver oriented EV's arrive as they need to sell the bread/butter first.

Having said that, my i3s is a hoot. I came from a hot hatch so was worried but all's well. Sure it's not a driver's car but is fun in different ways and I'm no longer crying when I thrash the thing and the mpg falls off a cliff.

I do miss the noise of a straight six but nowadays so much fake exhaust noise is pumped through the stereo that I'd rather silence to fakery.

SwanBuster · 04/04/2022 23:59

[quote Lunar27]@SwanBuster

Absolutely not denying your experience and probably is the case for your Model S. I think the Model S is 2.2 tonnes, whereas my i3s is 1.3 so would explain a lot. EV motors are supposed to be about 97% efficient (vs about 20% for ICE) but accelerating all that weight is still a big ask for any motor.

Love that you have a bike though and I'd quite like a GR Yaris too. Terrible time to buy a new car though so am waiting and hoping that lead times/availability improves![/quote]
The good thing about owning a luxury car is it gives you the possibility of taking test drives in other very exotic cars, where the dealer definitely takes you more seriously if you rock up in a car that originally cost £120k.

I’m saying no more - we’ll, ok I will - I can get my fix occasionally for free 😂😂😂

SwanBuster · 04/04/2022 23:56

[quote MobLife]@SwanBuster this is reassuring as I was wondering! 😆[/quote]
😂👍

Actually - it is possible to watch something whilst driving because there is a workaround by using the built in browser and dodgy streaming sites, but I only briefly confirmed that to myself out of technical curiosity as a passenger whilst I told my partner to ignore what I was doing and keep their eyes on the road!

The (well, my) car does have the capability supposedly to one day drive itself - I’ll believe it when I see it - so who knows in future 😳

Anyway, for now hopefully Tesla will fix that stupid possibility in a firmware update.

MobLife · 04/04/2022 23:49

@SwanBuster this is reassuring as I was wondering! 😆

Lunar27 · 04/04/2022 23:48

@SwanBuster

Absolutely not denying your experience and probably is the case for your Model S. I think the Model S is 2.2 tonnes, whereas my i3s is 1.3 so would explain a lot. EV motors are supposed to be about 97% efficient (vs about 20% for ICE) but accelerating all that weight is still a big ask for any motor.

Love that you have a bike though and I'd quite like a GR Yaris too. Terrible time to buy a new car though so am waiting and hoping that lead times/availability improves!

TheBigPeach · 04/04/2022 23:43

Husband has one. Our electric bill was sky high when he was working from home, I’m so glad he charges at work now. He went to charge it at a service station recently and all the points were broken, there was a guy there who hadn’t that factored in and didn’t have enough of a charge to get him to the next point. I would hate worrying about that. Husband loves his car though. My dad has a hybrid not plug in and he loves it. Drove 50 miles round trip last week and the needle didn’t move on the petrol gauge.

whynotwhatknot · 04/04/2022 23:42

I cant justify it either yet

i still dont think the infrastructur eis there ther ewere three charging points at service i sto0pped at on m1 and m6 thats pathetic

so you have to wait then what another couple of hours of charge if youre on a long journey compared to two minutes fill up of fuel

i also dont have a drive where do i charge go and sit in the shops every few days and wait?

SwanBuster · 04/04/2022 23:41

[quote MobLife]@SwanBuster
I'm not sure I follow with the Netflix thing-are you joking?![/quote]
When I stop to charge - the infotainment system has a Netflix app and YouTube with the underlying internet connection being completely free. Very useful when camping in the car too. The only downside is on older cars you have a portrait rather than landscape screen, but it’s fine - and the sound system is awesome.

I don’t watch it whilst driving 😂

Lunar27 · 04/04/2022 23:40

@Flatbrokefornow

Exactly. I have a BMW with 120 miles of range, which is paltry compared to most but it's fine and I've now covered over 50k miles.

There's lots of negativity but IME I love not having to visit a petrol station and putting in £60 to travel 300 miles. On an overnight tariff, I pay around £4 to travel the same distance. For me, this more than makes up for an occasional inconvenience of stopping on a long journey to recharge and so what if I have to stop at the services for 30 minutes instead of 10 for a comfort break.

I think people will need to adjust their habits as you can charge when shopping, eating out, gym, at the cinema or anywhere else where you'd normally spend time doing something. Sure in the winter the range drops but I've happy traded this for having to scrape and defrost a car in winter. Simple precondition and step inside a nice warm car. This can also be done when doing any of the above activities. Alternatively in the summer there's no need to get inside a scalding hot car as the Aircon sorts that out.

I'm a petrol head so am looking to buy a last hurrah car for fun but for everything else, the EV is quiet, relaxing, faster at junctions and superb for A to B driving.

MobLife · 04/04/2022 23:36

@SwanBuster
I'm not sure I follow with the Netflix thing-are you joking?!

SwanBuster · 04/04/2022 23:33

@MobLife

Aren't they really incredibly dull to drive? I love driving and hate automatics 😂
Depends. I will freely admit - I miss having a manual car sometimes and the involvement it gave me.

What I like is how incredibly easy the car is to drive long distances and the ridiculous acceleration - I have a Model with ludicrous mode, so it’s 0-60 in 2.6s. But I rarely do that - I usually drive it sedately - listening to podcasts and classic FM, and then pluggiing in and watching a few random YouTube videos or Netflix shows (again - the internet connection is totally free on the older models).

It’s a totally different way of driving. I have a motorbike for the thrills, but yeah - if I had the parking space, I’d buy a GR Yaris as well.

NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 04/04/2022 23:30

People will be able to drive their old cars.

But there will come a point where petrol stations become unviable and it becomes as hard to fill up with petrol as it was to charge electric vehicles 4 or 5 years ago.

SwanBuster · 04/04/2022 23:29

[quote Lunar27]@SwanBuster

I think it's generally true that most EVs are more efficient around town. Rationale being that you make best use of regenerative braking and wind resistance is minimal.

I see you have a Model S, which is pretty heavy so it's possible that the shifting all that weight is the problem but I'd imagine it's more efficient round town than doing 70-80mph on the motorway.

I have an i3s and can exceed the quoted range if I'm only round town. I've seen videos of the same for the Mini, Zoe, Leaf etc.[/quote]
I find it’s most efficient as I said when doing a constant speed - usually between 30-60 mph. Regen is all well and good but there’s an efficiency loss there. In town, you are inevitably accelerating and slowing down a lot. It doesn’t like it - my watt hours per mile figure in town driving is around 350 - which would equate to below rated range.

The most efficient journeys I’ve done have been doing about 55 constantly for 90 mins. There I’ve smashed the wh/mi figure down to 230. This would equate to a range of about 320 miles - and I well believe I could get that if I went on a long run fully charged.

As you can tell, I monitor all sorts of crap 😂

MobLife · 04/04/2022 23:28

Aren't they really incredibly dull to drive? I love driving and hate automatics 😂