Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want an electric car?

318 replies

Elevenfourteen · 04/04/2022 19:57

I know IABU for asking such a dull question, but my Dh wants to buy an electric car and I’m not convinced.
I guess they’re better for the environment so that’s one thing. But are we set up for them properly yet? Do all garages have charging points? Do you have to hang around the garage for ages while they charge? I just can’t imagine how they can be a practical option.
Driving to work and back and charging at night is fine, but what about going on holiday?

Do any of you have electric cars and can you reassure me?

OP posts:
axolotlfloof · 05/04/2022 08:49

@NeedAHoliday2021

My boss had one as his commute is huge and the amount they had to pay in charging it on their electric bill was much higher than they’d calculated. He replaced it with an Audi TT.
With a huge commute he would make a huge saving. The cost of charging versus petrol is much, much lower.
Newuser82 · 05/04/2022 08:48

My husband has an electric car through work. It's fine for local journeys and would consider one if that was all I did but the charge doesn't last long enough to go long distance and if we are going a bit further we can't have the heating on or it drains the battery faster. It takes a while to charge although I have to admit I don't know how long the rapid chargers take on the motorways etc. I think once the technology improves and the batteries last longer then anyone would be silly not to have one with the price of petrol at the moment!

Coffeeonmytoffee · 05/04/2022 08:43

@NeedAHoliday2021

My boss had one as his commute is huge and the amount they had to pay in charging it on their electric bill was much higher than they’d calculated. He replaced it with an Audi TT.
I find this hard to believe. He just wanted a TT. Charging over night costs very little.
WalltoWallBtards · 05/04/2022 08:41

Get it. Why buy a car that’s going to be I delete soon?
We have a hybrid had it 12 years and have not had a single issue with it, not one, still going strong and has saved us a fortune in petrol. next one will be fully electric.
They’ve really come in and prices are dropping.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 05/04/2022 08:39

AFAIK VED just goes into the government pot, like VAT fuel duty etc. NI is ring fenced to some extent but it all goes to pay for the roads. Fuel duty is another one where the government will have to make up the shortfall so will have to wait and see how that one develops.

Actually VED is ring fenced for roads again since 2018.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 05/04/2022 08:38

My boss had one as his commute is huge and the amount they had to pay in charging it on their electric bill was much higher than they’d calculated. He replaced it with an Audi TT.

C8H10N4O2 · 05/04/2022 08:37

@FollowTheLizards

Could you rent an electric one for a few weeks to see how you get on with it?

I'm personally not going to get an EV anytime soon as I don't think the recycling infrastructure is where it needs to be to support a vast move of trying to get all drivers to go 'green'. What happens to all the batteries after they're used. I think only around half of the minerals used in batteries can be reused, so there currently seems little incentive to invest in these technologies. No doubt they'll all get flown over to South East Asia and China to sit with the billions of tons of plastic the world has already sent over under the guise of 'recycling'.

What happens to old EVs was another question I struggled to get clear answers on in terms of its overall green footprint. Certainly the dealers I spoke to could only speak in vague assumptions and platitudes rather than any actual facts.

It would be helpful to see more details on how the companies are reclaiming and recycling from EVs.

axolotlfloof · 05/04/2022 08:36

@Tumbleweed101

How long do they take to charge? If, for instance, you did need a top up on a long journey?
It depends on the charger. I think a Tesla supercharger does 100 miles in 7 mins. A standard charger in a supermarket car park does 100 miles in about 25 min. I find its rare to need to change away from home though as we have over 300 mile range.
Tumbleweed101 · 05/04/2022 08:31

How long do they take to charge? If, for instance, you did need a top up on a long journey?

axolotlfloof · 05/04/2022 08:26

@emmathedilemma

I’m with you, nothing appeals about them. I don’t even like driving automatic cars! I live in a flat so can’t install a charger and there’s no way I’m spending half my life hanging out at the local petrol station waiting for it to charge. None would get me to my parents without stopping to charge on the way whereas my current car gets there in half a tank of petrol. The infrastructure just isn’t good enough for me at the moment, let alone the cost of them.
What's the distance to your parents' house? Our EV range is similar to a 3/4 tank of petrol.
FollowTheLizards · 05/04/2022 08:21

Could you rent an electric one for a few weeks to see how you get on with it?

I'm personally not going to get an EV anytime soon as I don't think the recycling infrastructure is where it needs to be to support a vast move of trying to get all drivers to go 'green'. What happens to all the batteries after they're used. I think only around half of the minerals used in batteries can be reused, so there currently seems little incentive to invest in these technologies. No doubt they'll all get flown over to South East Asia and China to sit with the billions of tons of plastic the world has already sent over under the guise of 'recycling'.

bigbluebus · 05/04/2022 08:20

We went to a local exhibition of electric cars a few months ago. We came away concluding that we won't be buying one just yet. The range wouldn't get us to destinations we currently travel to to visit family/friends without having to stop and recharge and 2 lots of those friends don't have driveway parking so we couldn't recharge overnight there.
It was good to see what was on offer though and someone we know who works at one of the car dealerships told us the sold 6 EVs off the back if that 5 hour exhibition but we just didn't think it would meet our needs until technology improves.

thirstyformore · 05/04/2022 08:20

@oviraptor21 about £50k I think. We have the "cheap" one but we lease. Think it's about £500 a month with smallish deposit.

FirewomanSam · 05/04/2022 08:13

I have an electric car as my only car and I LOVE it. I find that a lot of people without electric cars get very worked up about charging and the practicalities of it all, but anyone who has one will tell you that in reality those aren’t actually serious concerns.

I mainly use mine for errands and short-ish journeys around town, so charging is a non-issue. I just charge at home when I need to, every week or two. It doesn’t occupy any brain space beyond ‘oh I’m at 30%, better plug in when I get home’. It’s no more stress than hypothetically running out of petrol would be.

Longer journeys require a bit more planning but nothing like as much as people seem to think. There are SO many chargers out there and plenty of apps to help you find them. You just have to stop at a service station for 20-30 mins or so. Not a massive deal.

If you have to do long journeys of hundreds of miles on a weekly basis then maybe I’d think twice but otherwise, as long as you can charge at home, then it really isn’t a hassle at all.

There are people who manage without chargers at home too but that sounds like a bit more of a faff. Still doable though!

C8H10N4O2 · 05/04/2022 08:12

@Elevenfourteen

I know IABU for asking such a dull question, but my Dh wants to buy an electric car and I’m not convinced. I guess they’re better for the environment so that’s one thing. But are we set up for them properly yet? Do all garages have charging points? Do you have to hang around the garage for ages while they charge? I just can’t imagine how they can be a practical option. Driving to work and back and charging at night is fine, but what about going on holiday? Do any of you have electric cars and can you reassure me?
How old is the car you would be replacing?

The biggest carbon footprint comes from manufacturing so the greenest thing you can do in most cases is keep your existing car running for as along as possible. Boring but still true when we looked last year. If your car is 10-15 years old and high mileage or on its last legs then consider hybrids or electric.

If you want to replace a perfectly functioning car with electric because its currently very in vogue then don't kid yourself it is automatically a green choice.

The public charging network is patchy and really not geared up for mass adoption yet, more saliently there is no rapid growth plan in place to match the targets for electric cars so unless you have your own home and off street parking then charging can be an issue.

Like PPs I have an issue with large subsidies for electric cars, home charge installation and council provided free charging. Its a tax payer subsidy which overwhelmingly puts money in the pockets of the middle classes and owners of larger homes. I would rather see that money put into better public transport which benefits everyone.

oviraptor21 · 05/04/2022 08:12

How much is the cheapest Tesla that everyone raves about and what is the range?

I have no plans to wait more than 15ish minutes for my car to charge. I can cover 2-300 miles with a 15 minute break and don't want to compromise that. Seems like the Tesla is the only car that would come close with its supercharging?

countrygirl99 · 05/04/2022 08:06

I'd love an electric car and my trips are suitable for one. But I live in a village.I have to park on the road so can't charge at home and the nearest public charge point is miles away at a place I've been to 3 times since it opened 6 years ago so there needs to be a big improvement in the public charging network before I can consider it.

Lunar27 · 05/04/2022 07:47

@Fizbosshoes

Completely dumb question - what will happen with vehicle excise duty if a majority of people start driving hybrid or electric cars? If I understand properly it's a tax to maintain roads (which is obviously beneficial to all road users) but currently you pay it - at various levels - if you drive a ICE vehicle. What would happen if those vehicle owners didn't generate the required amount?
My feeling is that it will change from being emissions based or they'll introduce an EV specific tax to plug the gap.

I don't think anyone is under the illusion that EV's will be cheap forever but just until they reach the tipping point and there are more EV's than ICE on the road.

AFAIK VED just goes into the government pot, like VAT fuel duty etc. NI is ring fenced to some extent but it all goes to pay for the roads. Fuel duty is another one where the government will have to make up the shortfall so will have to wait and see how that one develops.

We're still in a bit of a golden period so if people can make an EV work for them, there are savings to be made.

Grenlei · 05/04/2022 07:47

I agree, £7k is not really cheap.

My previous petrol car was £600. That is really cheap. I wouldn't even describe my current £1500 diesel car as really cheap.

However when an electric car can do what my current car does (400+ miles from a tank, tows a trailer, huge boot capacity), for the same price then I'd get one. Until then I'm sticking with this one. Unless that idiot Khan further expands the ULEZ into my area in the next year or so when I'll be forced to sell it - but hopefully that won't happen.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 05/04/2022 07:13

@wardrobewarrior

Not sure why some people are saying they cost 30 k ? That's not the only option at all. You can pick up second hand ones really cheap. Or buy on finance to spread the cost. I would never put down cash for any depreciating asset like a car.
I've never seen a second hand car that I would describe as "really cheap" Hmm

I had a quick look on Auto Trader. The cheapest electric car within 100 miles costs 7k and only has a range of 97 miles.

I paid less than 4k for my car - a second hand petrol and it does well over 400 miles per tank.

Yes, you would save money in the long run but only if you live somewhere with electric charge points (our town has one public point for a population of around 8k) or can charge at home, which is impossible for us.

I think it's you have to pretty fucking privileged to be able to say 7k for a car is "really cheap".

HomeprideSaucy · 05/04/2022 07:12

If that's ok they're selling by 2030, I wonder how on earth it's going to work in London where the majority of people live in terraced houses with only on-street parking? We are going to need a lot of charging points!

Randommother · 05/04/2022 07:04

I have a Tesla through work and I love it! So far I haven’t had an issue with charging. The longest trip I’ve done so far was from just north of Aberdeen to just south of Manchester, my charging stops were also coffee / lunch / loo stops so in the end It didn’t take any longer than if I’d been driving an ICE car. The key is the charging infrastructure which is getting better and better as more EV’s are being produced. You do need to be able to charge at home though, otherwise consider a hybrid instead for now.

ExplodingElephants · 05/04/2022 06:56

We’re getting one in a couple of months, we’re going for the Hyundai Ioniq. We’ll be able to charge it at home and, as we have solar panels and a battery, we’re hoping that it’ll be pretty much free motoring. If not, there’s several free charging points nearby 😆

Oblomov22 · 05/04/2022 06:52

Dh has a plug in hybrid Mitsubishi. I have a self charging hybrid Hyundai iconiq. Both bought 2nd hand. Fabulous.

Fizbosshoes · 05/04/2022 06:46

Completely dumb question - what will happen with vehicle excise duty if a majority of people start driving hybrid or electric cars? If I understand properly it's a tax to maintain roads (which is obviously beneficial to all road users) but currently you pay it - at various levels - if you drive a ICE vehicle. What would happen if those vehicle owners didn't generate the required amount?