Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want an electric car?

318 replies

Elevenfourteen · 04/04/2022 19:57

I know IABU for asking such a dull question, but my Dh wants to buy an electric car and I’m not convinced.
I guess they’re better for the environment so that’s one thing. But are we set up for them properly yet? Do all garages have charging points? Do you have to hang around the garage for ages while they charge? I just can’t imagine how they can be a practical option.
Driving to work and back and charging at night is fine, but what about going on holiday?

Do any of you have electric cars and can you reassure me?

OP posts:
SwanBuster · 05/04/2022 09:55

@TokenGinger

The entitlement on this thread is astounding. It amazes me how many people are either completely unaware of the dire position the earth is in and the need for drastic change to enable the planet to live on, or they just don't care and only care about their own conveniences.

I say this as somebody who cannot afford an electric car right now, so it's not like I'm coming from a place of privilege. But the Earth is dying. And it's because of us. Our need to be somewhere quickly, our laziness to drive the school run, our habit of jumping in the car to go to the shop that's less than a mile away. Plastic bottles of water. Tumble dryers. All for convenience.

If we could look 50 years into the future and see our children and grandchildren suffering because of our greed and laziness, I'm sure many would wish they'd cut down on journeys or found more sustainable ways of travelling.

I'm not saying I'm innocent of these, because I'm not. I've been doing the same, but now is the time to open our eyes to what our consumption is doing and make changes where we can.

Countries around the world don't have a Net Zero target just because they fancy it, it's because drastic change is needed.

I agree - the thing I find astonishingly entitled is the ‘why should I wait to charge the car - I don’t want to have to stop’ bit.

Since getting the car I drive slower and look to minimise my energy usage as much as possible. And I don’t even pay for the energy! But it’s just about being concious. The incredible bit is the journeys don’t even take that much longer. The idiots blasting along at 85 on the motorway whilst I’m cruising at 60 end up getting stuck at the same traffic lights I do once they enter the urban zones.

Idriveelectric · 05/04/2022 09:55

I have an electric car. It's wonderful to drive, 0 to 60 in 4 seconds and handles like a dream. Well it's a Jaguar iPace, so it would! We charge for the most part at home, either purely for free on solar power from the panels on the roof of our house, or overnight on an EV tariff at 5p a kWh (though that will go up to 7.5p in May). Consequently it's a joy to drive and cheap to run. On the other hand, we do have a VW transporter van which we can use if we are going away and charging is not practical. We took the car to Anglesey in Feb as we could charge, but we will be going to The Isle of Skye in May and chargers are more difficult to find so we'll take the van.
It really is a case of looking at your circumstances and working out if you can charge at home. It becomes far more difficult if that is not practical. It can take about 10 hours to fully charge the Jag at home but we charged in Birmingham last week at a public "rapid charger" and took the battery from 20% to 90% in 1 hour - we had lunch while we waited.

CounsellorTroi · 05/04/2022 09:53

I have a low emission petrol car bought secondhand - £30 road tax - and as long as it keeps working I won’t be changing it for an electric one.

Silverclocks · 05/04/2022 09:50

I'm the same OP. For most of the driving I do, an electric car would be perfect, but a few times a year I do a longer journey where I think it would be a pain.

They seem good for a second car but not for the main car IMO, although a friend has a £££ Tesla, which does seem to work for them so maybe the time is coming.

TokenGinger · 05/04/2022 09:50

The entitlement on this thread is astounding. It amazes me how many people are either completely unaware of the dire position the earth is in and the need for drastic change to enable the planet to live on, or they just don't care and only care about their own conveniences.

I say this as somebody who cannot afford an electric car right now, so it's not like I'm coming from a place of privilege. But the Earth is dying. And it's because of us. Our need to be somewhere quickly, our laziness to drive the school run, our habit of jumping in the car to go to the shop that's less than a mile away. Plastic bottles of water. Tumble dryers. All for convenience.

If we could look 50 years into the future and see our children and grandchildren suffering because of our greed and laziness, I'm sure many would wish they'd cut down on journeys or found more sustainable ways of travelling.

I'm not saying I'm innocent of these, because I'm not. I've been doing the same, but now is the time to open our eyes to what our consumption is doing and make changes where we can.

Countries around the world don't have a Net Zero target just because they fancy it, it's because drastic change is needed.

SwanBuster · 05/04/2022 09:47

@yikesanotherbooboo

DH has had a plug in hybrid for a few years.It works really well, in a previous property he would plug into the garage and then where we live now plug through the window.On a day to day basis it runs off electricity as he does less than 30 miles a day .If we are travelling he fills it with petrol as needed. I now( 1year) have an electric car which I plug in over night about once every 10 days.We have had a proper plug installed at the front of the house.i love it and cannot now stand going to the petrol station if I have to fill up my DS's car or similar.We haven't yet used it for long journeys as we have the alternative.DH is apprehensive re having to hang around in a service station or Lidl or whatever ie infrastructure concerns.I am more patient and can see lots of people using the plugs around here , I think that that is probably a mindset and once we start to do it , it will cease to be a problem.
Why would he be apprehensive about having to hang around Lidl? 😂

They do superb fresh chocolate croissants for 49p.

yikesanotherbooboo · 05/04/2022 09:44

DH has had a plug in hybrid for a few years.It works really well, in a previous property he would plug into the garage and then where we live now plug through the window.On a day to day basis it runs off electricity as he does less than 30 miles a day .If we are travelling he fills it with petrol as needed.
I now( 1year) have an electric car which I plug in over night about once every 10 days.We have had a proper plug installed at the front of the house.i love it and cannot now stand going to the petrol station if I have to fill up my DS's car or similar.We haven't yet used it for long journeys as we have the alternative.DH is apprehensive re having to hang around in a service station or Lidl or whatever ie infrastructure concerns.I am more patient and can see lots of people using the plugs around here , I think that that is probably a mindset and once we start to do it , it will cease to be a problem.

sulalu · 05/04/2022 09:43

Once you have a electric car, you won’t believe you ever drove a petrol / diesel one. No noise, no exhaust smell or fumes. It’s like these days we can’t believe factories used to just emit all their waste and byproducts into the air and environment. We see documentaries about the Industrial Revolution and London smog and think Wtf! What were they thinking! When our children are adults, they won’t believe billions of people used to sit in traffic emitting and breathing in filth from exhausts. They won’t believe it. Once you have an electric car, you don’t believe it either. Change is coming folks. It’s not a choice.

SwanBuster · 05/04/2022 09:40

@Kukdoos

Why have you taken my comments personally SwanBuster. Why would I read your posts on landlords? What has that got to do with electric cars?
You were literally referencing things only I said - like charging at the cinema - in a post where I myself said the whole current situation is outrageous that I can do that sort of thing.
Kukdoos · 05/04/2022 09:36

Why have you taken my comments personally SwanBuster.
Why would I read your posts on landlords? What has that got to do with electric cars?

AndAsIfByMagic · 05/04/2022 09:35

DH says we'll hang on to petrol cars for as long as we can until you can drive long distances in an electric one without the need to waste time charging.

coffeeiwish · 05/04/2022 09:34

@jamie8

Are there EVs suitable for towing a trailer yet? We enquired about 2years ago, need a small trailer for garden waste and helping youth group camping. No cars were insurable because manufacturers did not recommend towing so no towbars designed for them.
A lot of the hybrids can tow. Not sure about the rest
coffeeiwish · 05/04/2022 09:33

Sorry but YABU, I have an electric car and absolutely bloody love it. It's such a fun car to drive and sooo much cheaper than our diesel car to run.

There are chargers absolutely everywhere. We're on holiday now and our cabin even has its own charging point, most hotels do too.

Really it'll be fine :)

SwanBuster · 05/04/2022 09:29

@Kukdoos

This is an interesting thread, and definitely highlights the privilege of many. I include myself in this, because I own (outright) a prestige car and also own a motorbike.

I think the initial outlay has to be considered. All very well saying you can get a 2nd hand for only £7k - but that's the privilege you have in thinking that's an affordable amount. For many people, all they can afford is a run down car for £1k, £1,500k etc. Many comments here of people having had multiple electric vehicles since they came out - again, how many people can actually afford to upgrade their cars?

Yes petrol is expensive, but with electricity rising by 50% now and again in October, people can't afford to pay that - where will they get the money to replace cars. Driving isn't a luxury, it's a necessity for most.

Another assumption, that people can change their cars for free when they're at the cinema, or eating out etc. Again, some might have that privilege and no money concerns, but there are plenty of people who will have to choose between heating and eating. There isn't spare money for a frivolous spend like that.

This is another way of creating the divide between the haves and have nots. Can't afford to fix your old car, can't afford the petrol but can't afford an electric vehicle? Oh well, you peasant, public transport for you (which is another joke).

Bloody hell. If you read into my posts you’ll work out that I am fully aware I both have exorbitant privilege and also real world experience of living very much within my means.

I have said on this thread numerous times that infrastructure and costs for electric cars for most people are nowhere near ready, and fully recommended people keep older cars.

Go read my posts on the thread about buy to let parasites if you want to see just how aware I am of the real world despite the fact I can afford a Tesla outright. It is entirely possible to be aware of the real world, empathise with the situation of other and be well off.

I’ve posted nothing but the real world current experience of EV ownership and even said how outrageous it is we get the perks!

SwanBuster · 05/04/2022 09:22

@Fizbosshoes

As with lots of things it's easier to make savings after a higher initial cost. People talking about free charging Teslas ignoring the fact that they are pretty expensive to start with. And yes you can buy second hand electric vehicles but often cheaper (using £7k as quoted by a pp) means a tiny car, or one that looked like a cross between a go-cart and a mobility scooter (Renault twizy) and not suitable for a family car. My own car is 15 years old and I am planning to replace soon as it has become unreliable, but will probably get another ICE as there is more options within budget.
Where the hell am I 'ignoring' the cost?! It's obviously a privilege of a person who can afford one to do it.

It's so implicit it doesn't need to be stated 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

Kukdoos · 05/04/2022 09:22

This is an interesting thread, and definitely highlights the privilege of many. I include myself in this, because I own (outright) a prestige car and also own a motorbike.

I think the initial outlay has to be considered. All very well saying you can get a 2nd hand for only £7k - but that's the privilege you have in thinking that's an affordable amount. For many people, all they can afford is a run down car for £1k, £1,500k etc. Many comments here of people having had multiple electric vehicles since they came out - again, how many people can actually afford to upgrade their cars?

Yes petrol is expensive, but with electricity rising by 50% now and again in October, people can't afford to pay that - where will they get the money to replace cars. Driving isn't a luxury, it's a necessity for most.

Another assumption, that people can change their cars for free when they're at the cinema, or eating out etc. Again, some might have that privilege and no money concerns, but there are plenty of people who will have to choose between heating and eating. There isn't spare money for a frivolous spend like that.

This is another way of creating the divide between the haves and have nots. Can't afford to fix your old car, can't afford the petrol but can't afford an electric vehicle? Oh well, you peasant, public transport for you (which is another joke).

Grenlei · 05/04/2022 09:18

@SwanBuster I do agree about used car prices - I bought mine 2 years ago, it was 10 years old and had done 110000 miles, it fitted the bill for me because I needed a cheap diesel for 3-5 years. I'd easily sell it for the same money or more now, even though it's now nearly 13 years old and has done nearly 130,000 miles.

My DS had a petrol car on PCP which finished last month, he sold it on to one of those 'we buy any car' type places and made nearly £3k profit after the balloon payment was deducted. That certainly wouldn't have been the case a couple of years ago.

I'm not anti electric cars per se, tbh I wish I had the budget for one!

Fizbosshoes · 05/04/2022 09:18

As with lots of things it's easier to make savings after a higher initial cost.
People talking about free charging Teslas ignoring the fact that they are pretty expensive to start with. And yes you can buy second hand electric vehicles but often cheaper (using £7k as quoted by a pp) means a tiny car, or one that looked like a cross between a go-cart and a mobility scooter (Renault twizy) and not suitable for a family car. My own car is 15 years old and I am planning to replace soon as it has become unreliable, but will probably get another ICE as there is more options within budget.

SwanBuster · 05/04/2022 09:11

@Grenlei

I agree, £7k is not really cheap.

My previous petrol car was £600. That is really cheap. I wouldn't even describe my current £1500 diesel car as really cheap.

However when an electric car can do what my current car does (400+ miles from a tank, tows a trailer, huge boot capacity), for the same price then I'd get one. Until then I'm sticking with this one. Unless that idiot Khan further expands the ULEZ into my area in the next year or so when I'll be forced to sell it - but hopefully that won't happen.

Agreed. But used car prices are crazy now. Relatively cheap motoring for me meant a ~£3k petrol estate car with 60k miles that I knew I could get at least 12 years out of, which was my previous car bought over a decade ago.

Now that same thing would have cost 13k. That's why I bought the Tesla. Over its life it's - fingers crossed - going to be cheaper than that 13k petrol car to run all in.

I think we are in a bubble for all used cars. Tesla offered me a trade in at what I paid for the car recently, having done 20k miles. And did I bite their hand off? No - the market says it's worth even more! And with free charging, I'll only bite if they give me a brand new Model S Plaid (100k) as a swap 😂.

Horst · 05/04/2022 09:09

See we camp and do say Norfolk to the coast in wales with only a quick 5 minute pee stop. I don’t think an electric car would be very good.

Also what about towing and roof racks etc we are a large family with a lot of kit when we camp also a lot of heavy work stuff to transport. Easier to send someone to fetch a can of petrol if you run out that find someone with their own genny if you run out of electric. Also hilarious at that point using petrol to power an electric car.

axolotlfloof · 05/04/2022 09:07

[quote SwanBuster]@axolotlfloof - the supercharger can deliver 100 miles in 7 minutes - in a Model 3 or Y - but not always as it's dependent on how much juice you have in the battery, the temperature and depending on the charging station whether others are using it. 7 minutes is perfect conditions.

My Model S maxes out at 135 KW/h charging and needs about 30 kWh for 100 miles. So it's at the very best going to be around 15 mins for 100 miles.

As far as supermarket chargers delivering 100 miles in 25 mins - I'd love to know what ones you're using! The usual 7/11 kWh posts they have at best could deliver 50-60 miles in about in a hour on a Model 3. You would need to find a rapid to get 100 miles in 25 mins - that's around 70-100 KW charging, car dependent.[/quote]
Tbh we have only needed to charge away from home once : supermarket charger, in Cornwall. It might have been a rapid one.
We are taking Tesla to France for Easter though so will get a bit more experience.
We charge every other night for 4 hrs with Octopus Go night tariff at 5p per kwh, and that does all our everyday driving.

SwanBuster · 05/04/2022 09:02

@axolotlfloof - the supercharger can deliver 100 miles in 7 minutes - in a Model 3 or Y - but not always as it's dependent on how much juice you have in the battery, the temperature and depending on the charging station whether others are using it. 7 minutes is perfect conditions.

My Model S maxes out at 135 KW/h charging and needs about 30 kWh for 100 miles. So it's at the very best going to be around 15 mins for 100 miles.

As far as supermarket chargers delivering 100 miles in 25 mins - I'd love to know what ones you're using! The usual 7/11 kWh posts they have at best could deliver 50-60 miles in about in a hour on a Model 3. You would need to find a rapid to get 100 miles in 25 mins - that's around 70-100 KW charging, car dependent.

SwanBuster · 05/04/2022 08:54

@oviraptor21

How much is the cheapest Tesla that everyone raves about and what is the range?

I have no plans to wait more than 15ish minutes for my car to charge. I can cover 2-300 miles with a 15 minute break and don't want to compromise that. Seems like the Tesla is the only car that would come close with its supercharging?

Honestly If those are your requirements - Probably only a Tesla Model 3 or Y or a Taycan or an EV6 combined with the extremely expensive Ionity chargers could do it under perfect conditions.

200 miles of range is at least 50kwh in the most efficient of cars, if you're driving at motorway speeds. That'd require you to get to where you were at the best position on the charging curve and get an average of 200kw charging to deliver it in 15 mins. Forget about 300 miles of range in practical terms in 15 mins yet.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 05/04/2022 08:51

I think the savings vs ICE cars will start to diminish as electricity continues to get more expensive. EV-specific tariffs will disappear in time — my SIL has already had hers doubled — and there will be some kind of road tax/VED type tax too. There has to be. Similarly, driving incentives will vanish as well — EVs are already going to be charged the Congestion Charge from Dec 2025.

So I think the incentivised case for EVs will shrink between now and 2030 — probably incrementally, but still.

FollowTheLizards · 05/04/2022 08:50

It would be helpful to see more details on how the companies are reclaiming and recycling from EVs. Quite. It feels like the Government and car manufacturers are somewhat infantilising people, by not providing full cradle to grave information for these vehicles, so that people can make a properly informed decision.

I remember in the early 2000s speaking to someone about recycling. He worked in the field, and was able to provide detailed evidence of how we were actually creating a larger carbon footprint by flying all this waste overseas. As a result I'm very skeptical when I see a Government try to quickly roll out a new 'green scheme' which is going to be the new way we combat climate change. Never say never, but let's see adequate evidence of the scheme being fully thought out before putting all our eggs in one basket.