Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want an electric car?

318 replies

Elevenfourteen · 04/04/2022 19:57

I know IABU for asking such a dull question, but my Dh wants to buy an electric car and I’m not convinced.
I guess they’re better for the environment so that’s one thing. But are we set up for them properly yet? Do all garages have charging points? Do you have to hang around the garage for ages while they charge? I just can’t imagine how they can be a practical option.
Driving to work and back and charging at night is fine, but what about going on holiday?

Do any of you have electric cars and can you reassure me?

OP posts:
Abraxan · 05/04/2022 19:40

@Beercrispsandnuts

It’s not misinformation. It’s one hundred percent accurate. 100 percent.
And yet there are many ecvs that are older than 5 years which are still running happily in the same battery.

And I've yet to see the tons of news reports of people perishing inside burnt out ECVs.

Abraxan · 05/04/2022 19:27

@MurmuratingStarling

YANBU. Hell will freeze over before I get an electric car. And no WAY will everyone in the UK have one by 2030. Stupid, unrealistic goal that is.

Do the Government not realise that the VAST majority of UK citizens do NOT have £30,000 to buy a bloody electric car?! Hmm

Also, having an electric car as your main/only car is untenable long-term. And the infrastructure is not even 10% of the way to being ready for it.

We have two electric cars, so it is totally doable to live with just electric cars.

We've used the bigger car to do several long journeys, including Yorkshire to Cornwall and back on a holiday. If using motorways and large roads with services then the charging isn't an issue tbh. We also have home charging so no issues day to day either.

It becomes more challenging if off the beaten track or in more remote areas. Though we have discovered lots of hotels now have charging stations and many pubs/restaurants too.

The infrastructure does still need improving a lot, but depending on the types of journeys you undertake in your life then it can be easy to have only ECVs.

Lunar27 · 05/04/2022 19:15

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

In fairness the greenest thing you can do is to not buy another car. It's the continuous cycle of buying that's ruining the planet so keeping your 17 year old car is a good thing.

I own an EV but am under no illusions that it's helping anything but the big corporations.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 05/04/2022 18:57

@FuzzyPuffling

I just looked up the price of a two year old Tesla. Just short of £45,000.

Impossible for so many people.

My car is 17 years old. I have a zero budget for replacement so electric is going to have to wait. Current car car can tow our 28 year old caravan for an occasional break - although I suppose we could rent a tow car for those occasions. I know we aren't the greenest but at least we are maximising use of the CO2 and raw materials used to construct them by keeping them going.

I don't object to electric cars but for most people they will need to be cheaper to buy before adoption is widespread.

I do see that for our use our car is sort of overkill - just because we could do a 400 mile plus trip in it doesn't mean we do and it is true it mainly does shorter trips for which an electric one would be ideal.

angela99999 · 05/04/2022 18:42

We seriously considered it, but regularly drive 150 miles to a place with few charging points and no possibility of charging where we stay. Completely impossible to do this journey, we checked the local supermarket charging points, not many of them, regularly half out of order and usually the rest in use. Hopeless.

Bickles · 05/04/2022 18:33

Oh and I drove a 4 year old VW Golf R before. Total gas guzzler. I got 2k back on the part ex, my monthly payments are £100 cheaper, my insurance is 1/4 cheaper and I pay no road tax. So for me it’s very good value.

Bickles · 05/04/2022 18:31

Just got an ID3 and love it! It drives really nicely. However I only do short journeys- school run, work run and errands. It needs charging once a week at the moment.
DH has a Volvo and that’s a funny sort of hybrid which takes fuel but has a small battery that charges as it goes. If we go on any longer journeys we will take that due to range anxiety.
We love the ID3 but don’t think the infrastructure is there yet for 2 wholly electric cars.

Arsewangry · 05/04/2022 18:01

We have just ordered a Hyundai Santa Fe hybrid and it's not going to be delivered until bloody January '23!

FuzzyPuffling · 05/04/2022 17:56

I just looked up the price of a two year old Tesla.
Just short of £45,000.

Impossible for so many people.

BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 05/04/2022 17:55

Also not missing the point @WhenPushComesToShove. I charge at home, using electricity from a renewables-only supplier.

Whetheryouthinkyoucan · 05/04/2022 17:51

@WhenPushComesToShove

Not missing the point. 95% of my charging is at home, on totally renewable energy.

stayingaliveisawayoflife · 05/04/2022 17:49

We have a Tesla which has free supercharging plus no road tax etc. We also have solar panels at home so never pay for home charging. It has been totally free for a few years now and hopefully will last quite a while.

Ours was a return so we didn't pay full price for it.

jenkel · 05/04/2022 17:36

Actually meant to add, really not sure how good for environment it is over petrol, actually don’t think it’s much better. I’m more curious about hydrogen as a safer alternative some time down the ,line.

jenkel · 05/04/2022 17:33

Plug in hybrid, we bought one as a little experiment and we love it, give us the security on long trips, short trips are on the battery. No way yet would I buy a fully electric car.

WhenPushComesToShove · 05/04/2022 17:28

People always seem to miss the point that a large percentage of our electricity in this country is still a fossil fuel.

ivykaty44 · 05/04/2022 17:27

I think that’s appalling. Council tax should be for the benefit of the community, not to pay the motoring costs of someone who can afford a Tesla.

In my local area we have some of the worst pollution, if electric cars are being charged for free then thats a benefit to the community as they are not polluting with petrol and diesel fumes and shortening my life span

BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 05/04/2022 17:18

[quote NightmareSlashDelightful]**@BalladOfBarryAndFreda* @FirewomanSam* This Graun article from November has some stuff on it.

Here's a Forbes piece on the same subject albeit from 2020 and another from Nature.

As I mentioned in my post, the whole situation is actually pretty complicated and more nuanced than 'cobalt bad' although there are undeniable abuses within the supply chain, especially regarding mining in DRC, that shouldn't go unacknowledged.[/quote]
Thanks, I’ll have a look.

I absolutely agree re the issue being Li-ion batteries which are much more widely used than in EV’s but it is still a concern to be taken into account by EV owners (such as myself).

Lunar27 · 05/04/2022 17:18

@NightmareSlashDelightful

The highest demand for cobalt is, and continues to be the consumer electronics market, for which we're all guilty. As you say, we should all consider where our products come from but is really just hypocrisy IMHO. Like the oil industry is an ethical business!

Fortunately engineers are working around cobalt as it's not 100% necessary and the whole child slavery thing has pushed manufacturers to use more ethical suppliers.

Still, it won't satisfy the anti EV brigade.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 05/04/2022 16:58

@BalladOfBarryAndFreda @FirewomanSam This Graun article from November has some stuff on it.

Here's a Forbes piece on the same subject albeit from 2020 and another from Nature.

As I mentioned in my post, the whole situation is actually pretty complicated and more nuanced than 'cobalt bad' although there are undeniable abuses within the supply chain, especially regarding mining in DRC, that shouldn't go unacknowledged.

FirewomanSam · 05/04/2022 16:57

@daimbarsatemydogsbone cross posted, it’s the pollution point that I was interested in hearing more about since 2Gen said they had to do a lot of digging to find out about that.

FirewomanSam · 05/04/2022 16:56

@2Gen sorry, to be clear, I know about the cobalt mining in the DRC and the pressure on manufacturers to ensure their supply chains are clear. I hadn’t heard about cobalt mining causing more pollution than petrol cars though and am interested in reading more on that.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 05/04/2022 16:56

It's not hard to find -

[[https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2017/11/industry-giants-fail-to-tackle-child-labour-allegations-in-cobalt-battery-supply-chains/#:~:text=Amnesty%20International's%20previous%20research%20exposed,to%20cleaning%20up%20their%20batteries.][

FirewomanSam · 05/04/2022 16:46

@2Gen I’m also interested in reading more about this. Could you share the results of your digging please?

NightmareSlashDelightful · 05/04/2022 16:46

The cobalt question is interesting, and complex.

Yes, the majority of the cobalt used for EV batteries is mined in DRC. And there are definitely human rights and child labour abuses going on there.

Being aware that an EV could well contain a big chunk of cobalt that was scraped out of the ground by an eight-year-old on a chain gang is definitely something anyone who owns, or is considering, an EV should bear in mind.

But of course like everything else, it isn't that simple.

There's cobalt in anything with a lithium-ion battery. The laptop or phone you typed that response on will have an amount of cobalt in it. So no one gets away without blood on their hands for that one. (At least, no one who owns a smartphone, computer, tablet or gaming console.)

Also, technological developments are apace which will first reduce, and ultimately eliminate, the need for cobalt in EV batteries.

So yes, it's a consideration I think. But it's also something that (hopefully) should be addressed within the next few years.

BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 05/04/2022 16:39

@2Gen

YANBU. I don't want one either, for the reasons you state but also because of the way I've heard that the cobalt for the batteries is sourced. Child labour is used apparently and the conditions they work in are reported to be appalling! The reason I suspect we don't hear about it much because it would put too many people off. Furthermore, the cobalt mining allegedly causes more pollution than us driving our petrol cars, but again, we don't hear much about that either. I had to do a fair bit of digging to find this out and I'd advise anyone to look into this before they decide to buy one.
What are the sources for this please? I’d be interested to read them. Thank you.