Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want an electric car?

318 replies

Elevenfourteen · 04/04/2022 19:57

I know IABU for asking such a dull question, but my Dh wants to buy an electric car and I’m not convinced.
I guess they’re better for the environment so that’s one thing. But are we set up for them properly yet? Do all garages have charging points? Do you have to hang around the garage for ages while they charge? I just can’t imagine how they can be a practical option.
Driving to work and back and charging at night is fine, but what about going on holiday?

Do any of you have electric cars and can you reassure me?

OP posts:
BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 06/04/2022 13:48

Yes, add to the list “you can’t charge in the rain, or you’ll get electrocuted”
Grin

BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 06/04/2022 13:47

@Lunar27

No, but they're supposedly able to feel the vibrations of an engine. Allegedly.

Not being deaf it's hard to dispute but my MIL said exactly that when she found out I'd bought an EV.

I think she meant blind people but was too late and I had to bite my tongue. This would make more sense but neglects that drivers are not blind so can see when someone is in the way or crossing the road.

EV’s emit a sound at low speeds (so driving around car parks, pedestrianised areas, parking), which helps alert visually impaired pedestrians to their presence.

I know you’re a fellow EV driver and your list was meant as an illustration of the ‘stupid things people’ say).

FirewomanSam · 06/04/2022 13:45

@Lunar27 you forgot not being able to take your EV to the car wash because you’d get electrocuted Grin

Lunar27 · 06/04/2022 13:41

No, but they're supposedly able to feel the vibrations of an engine. Allegedly.

Not being deaf it's hard to dispute but my MIL said exactly that when she found out I'd bought an EV.

I think she meant blind people but was too late and I had to bite my tongue. This would make more sense but neglects that drivers are not blind so can see when someone is in the way or crossing the road.

woodhill · 06/04/2022 13:35

Hybrid sounds good but then there are thieves that steal the catalytic converter on Honda/Toyotas frequently

LetsGoCrazyPurpleBanana · 06/04/2022 13:23

@Lunar27

I've had:

You can't drive an EV through deep water as you'd get electrocuted.
I couldn't get an EV because it's impossible to charge while the power shower, cooker, tumble dryer, hair dryer and all other appliances are on at the same time.
The grid can't cope.
EV's catch fire a lot.
Deaf people will get run over in car parks.
I can't get an EV as I regularly do 1000 miles towing a caravan in winter without a break.

But deaf people can't hear any fucking car 🤦‍♀️🤣
Lunar27 · 06/04/2022 11:50

I've had:

You can't drive an EV through deep water as you'd get electrocuted.
I couldn't get an EV because it's impossible to charge while the power shower, cooker, tumble dryer, hair dryer and all other appliances are on at the same time.
The grid can't cope.
EV's catch fire a lot.
Deaf people will get run over in car parks.
I can't get an EV as I regularly do 1000 miles towing a caravan in winter without a break.

FirewomanSam · 06/04/2022 11:11

There seems to be a lot of misinformation out there!

I do find it interesting that a lot of EV discussions seem to involve people who don’t and have never owned EVs coming up with hypothetical scenarios that make EVs impractical, while actual EV owners explain that they’ve never actually encountered any such issues. Some people seem to think you have to just drive around the streets for hours desperately looking for a charger until you run out of battery!

They definitely aren’t for everyone but I do sometimes think there’s a knee-jerk resistance to them because they’re new and different and maybe because EV drivers are perceived as being smug? I think some people have already made up their minds that they don’t like them for whatever reason and then go looking for reasons why.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 06/04/2022 09:59

@AnastasiaRomanov

I don’t know a lot about electric cars, but I thought many of them are self charging now? I would really like one but assume starting cost was around £30,000.
Self charging Hybrid is a ridiculous piece of marketing bollockspeak started by Toyota. Their "self charging" Hybrids are the same as they ever were - they get some charge from using the motors as a generator when braking.

Hybrids have batteries but they still have a petrol or diesel engine too.

Actual electric cars can't charge themselves - they need a cable and a plug to charge.

Lunar27 · 06/04/2022 09:57

@C8H10N4O2.

You can't blame the industry and governments from trying and ultimately zero tailpipe emissions cannot be argued with really. However, nothing we do is green, when manufacturing is involved. It's just degrees of damage.

Honestly, my main drivers for buying an EV were:

Zero BIK
First year corporation tax write down (company car purchase)
Lower maintenance costs (covered by the company)
Much lower running costs
Zero tailpipe emissions

I would say that the majority of owners switch for financial reasons, much like we did with diesel. Yet why EV's seem to bring out the 'informed' and 'EV's aren't green' brigade is beyond me.

FloBot7 · 06/04/2022 09:55

Anyone who claims to be charging their car at home on totally renewable energy sourced from the grid has been greenwashed. You may feel good about it, but you are plain wrong.

I'm not greenwashed. I've been with ecotricity for about 10 years now and they've made a huuuge impact on renewable energy. I don't have the weather, funds or space to set up my own solar or wind farm, so the next best thing was to use a green energy supplier in the hope the market will continue to shift. I'm quite happy with my choice and yes, I feel good about it. Stop being so bitter.

C8H10N4O2 · 06/04/2022 09:33

[quote Lunar27]@daimbarsatemydogsbone

In fairness the greenest thing you can do is to not buy another car. It's the continuous cycle of buying that's ruining the planet so keeping your 17 year old car is a good thing.

I own an EV but am under no illusions that it's helping anything but the big corporations.[/quote]
This is the conclusion I've come after looking at EVs last year and a few years ago - its still largely green consumerism rather than green. I will keep reviewing every couple of years but there is some distance to go before they live up to the claimed green credentials.

I have had EVs as rental - fine to drive and I would be happy to drive one all the time but the charging infrastructure absolutely is a significant issue and the idea that its "entitled" to want to complete a long journey in a reasonable time is silly.

Frazzled2207 · 06/04/2022 09:21

@AnastasiaRomanov

I don’t know a lot about electric cars, but I thought many of them are self charging now? I would really like one but assume starting cost was around £30,000.
no they don't charge themselves! There are some hybrids out there where the petrol engine 'charges' the battery.
Otherpeoplesteens · 06/04/2022 09:19

Not missing the point. 95% of my charging is at home, on totally renewable energy.

and

Also not missing the point @WhenPushComesToShove. I charge at home, using electricity from a renewables-only supplier.

You may not have missed the point but you have not understood it. Unless you have your own solar or wind farm separate from the National Grid it is just not possible to claim you only use renewable electricity.

You may have a supplier which claims to source 100% renewable electricity for your tariff. It works like this: your supplier has a series of contracts with generators. It is possible that for every kWh of electricity they sell you they have contracted for a kWh of electricity from a renewable generator. But it is also quite legal for them to buy some, most or all of it all from a coal power generator, buy the equivalent in REGOs (Renewable Energy Guarantees of Origin - carbon credits) and sell it to you as 'renewable,' which is what most of them do. That's on the commercial side of things.

On the scientific side, while there is always a certain amount of genuine renewable energy being put into the system it varies during the course of a day, week etc. You know full well that on a still night there is no solar and almost no wind power. Your supplier contracts with a generator for the supply of wholesale electricity for, typically, 30 minutes' at a given time. If, during that window, your supplier's genuine renewable generator isn't producing electricity, then your 'green' supplier automatically sources it from the grid through a clearing system from other generators - a mix of gas, coal, nuclear, hydroelectric and imports. You get no choice in the matter, even on your '100% renewable' tariff.

Anyone who claims to be charging their car at home on totally renewable energy sourced from the grid has been greenwashed. You may feel good about it, but you are plain wrong.

AnastasiaRomanov · 06/04/2022 08:39

I don’t know a lot about electric cars, but I thought many of them are self charging now?
I would really like one but assume starting cost was around £30,000.

spaceman1 · 06/04/2022 08:24

I'm waiting for the range to improve, costs to come down and the infrastructure to be put in place, then I'll buy an EV.

AllLopsided · 05/04/2022 23:16

Of course it may not suit you, but they work for many of us. Like PP I have a Zoe and absolutely love it. I bought it second-hand last summer for €6,000 (2016, 60,000km) - a long way from £30,000! The range is only 100km but it's plenty for me. DH still has a petrol car which we use for longer trips. When it dies we will swap it for a hybrid or an EV with a bigger range. Holidays are 2 or 3 weeks a year - we will hire a car for that if necessary. I charge overnight in my garage on a household plug, no special equipment needed. There seems to be a lot of misinformation out there!

FloBot7 · 05/04/2022 21:19

My DH has a Tesla and I love it. I find it so much easier to drive than a normal car. We both live 14 miles from work. I get to/from work using 8% battery. He's more heavy footed and does it using 14%. Either way we don't worry about running out of charge. We don't do long distances often (and not at all for work) so don't mind if we need to stop and charge. That being said, we comfortably get to and from his parents house which is 2 hours away (roughly 70 miles) on a single charge.

XingMing · 05/04/2022 20:21

Friends in London have an EV, but hire an ICE vehicle if they are uncertain about long journeys to the wildernesses of the UK, like Exmoor.

Zooforhouse · 05/04/2022 20:13

I have one. Not a Tesla. Fantastic for my 50 mile a day commute. However trying to get from London to Devon with both kids and a dog in the back in winter not ideal!

Most places have a charge point. There is often a queue. It takes an hour. They are out of service a lot.

I’d like to think it will get better quickly but I suspect more cars are being produced than new charge points….

We now use our second car which is a 12 year old banger for long journeys.

NeedleNoodle3 · 05/04/2022 19:54

Instead of paying £60 a week on petrol we’re spending less than £20 on charging our car. We’re on quite a low electric rate that’s fixed until 2024. It will interesting to see what happens then.

Abraxan · 05/04/2022 19:49

@NeedAHoliday2021

My boss had one as his commute is huge and the amount they had to pay in charging it on their electric bill was much higher than they’d calculated. He replaced it with an Audi TT.
Very very unlikely an Audi TT was cheaper to run, re fuel/power, than any EV. He just wanted the TT.
Abraxan · 05/04/2022 19:47

@Fizbosshoes

Completely dumb question - what will happen with vehicle excise duty if a majority of people start driving hybrid or electric cars? If I understand properly it's a tax to maintain roads (which is obviously beneficial to all road users) but currently you pay it - at various levels - if you drive a ICE vehicle. What would happen if those vehicle owners didn't generate the required amount?
It's only the cheaper ECVs you don't pay it on. You pay it on ECVs above £40k. Even if you lease it's still paid, just as part of the lease payments.
Otherpeoplesteens · 05/04/2022 19:44

The problem with batteries is not just cobalt. It's lithium:

www.theguardian.com/news/2020/dec/08/the-curse-of-white-oil-electric-vehicles-dirty-secret-lithium

Lithium ion batteries degrade over time. Whilst they still have uses after they are no longer suitable for cars, and it is technically possible to recycle the lithium within batteries (see Graun article) we are going to be digging an awful lot of ground up to obtain enough lithium.

Hydrogen fuel cells, by the way, do not degrade over time like batteries, and they do not 'lose' their energy when sitting still like batteries do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread