Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want an electric car?

318 replies

Elevenfourteen · 04/04/2022 19:57

I know IABU for asking such a dull question, but my Dh wants to buy an electric car and I’m not convinced.
I guess they’re better for the environment so that’s one thing. But are we set up for them properly yet? Do all garages have charging points? Do you have to hang around the garage for ages while they charge? I just can’t imagine how they can be a practical option.
Driving to work and back and charging at night is fine, but what about going on holiday?

Do any of you have electric cars and can you reassure me?

OP posts:
NandorTheRelentlessCleaner · 04/04/2022 21:44

DH bought a brand new one in Jan

It broke down after 1 month and is unfixable so far Confused

So I'm not impressed!

Like you say, you can't go on holiday with it etc

It's only good as a commuting/day trip car

A second car. If you will

Lunar27 · 04/04/2022 21:41

[quote Happyhappyday]@BalladOfBarryAndFreda but my petrol car has a starting range of 400 miles, versus 300 with a brand spanking new battery, which then rapidly loses range in the cold (we were experiencing -30%, most of our long distance driving is in the high mountains). Not a reason not to buy but important to be aware of, especially as charging stations are thinner on the ground in the literal wilderness.[/quote]
Definitely. Also people need to be aware that EV's generally use more battery on the motorway than around town, where they use barely any batter at all.

However, people just need to learn that EV's just have different range profiles to ICE, where your 400 mile starting range is also subject to equally large variations in mpg, depending on whether you drive round town or on a motorway.

myyellowcar · 04/04/2022 21:41

I would like one day to day but the idea of taking one down to France or whatever and frequently having to stop for a hour to charge back up sounds like a nightmare. We regularly do 600 plus mile journeys and it would add hours. Currently we swap drivers and stop once for fuel midway.

Lunar27 · 04/04/2022 21:36

[quote MurmuratingStarling]@Lunar27

Not everyone wanted or needed a mobile phone when they were first introduced but we barely think about it now. It'll be the same with EV's so if it doesn't work for you now then no worries. Just wait till one does.

Ridiculous comparison. Hmm People can live without a mobile phone, and shockingly, some people still don't have one. MANY people cannot live without a car for too many reasons to list.

Also, a mobile phone doesn't cost £30,000! Like an electric car does. Confused Your comparison is batshit.[/quote]
Not at all. It's a comparison of relative technologies where one infrastructure wasn't 100% for a long time and people were reluctant to transition due to the maturity of an existing network. Yet nowadays people rarely think about a landline in the same way that people will eventually forgot about petrol stations.

In any case, noone has to buy an EV and won't do for another 15-20 years. By which time the UK will be fully equipped to deal with all the charging issues etc etc. and there'll be plenty of 2nd hand cars. Even now you can buy a used EV for less than £10k and we're still in their infancy. People often talk about the cost of new cars but many people never buy new and have to wait for the used market. It'll come.

So how does this alter the fact that many people need to drive? It doesn't.

balalake · 04/04/2022 21:32

I don't have one. My first question was whether you actually could manage without a car at all.

Chersfrozenface · 04/04/2022 21:31

No home charging as terraced house, no charging available at workplaces, have one car that's rarely used for shopping and other errands so would have to factor in extra time to go elsewhere to charge it, mainly used for long journeys where range and dearth of working, unoccupied chargers become problems. Not really suitable for us.

AnotherDelphinium · 04/04/2022 21:28

I have an electric car (Leaf e+) and I absolutely adore it. I got it in October and wish I’d gotten one sooner!

Notice those in this thread who’ve got one and wouldn’t change it for the world… the ones who are negative about electric cars appear, crucially, to not actually own one, so I’d take their opinions with a pinch of the proverbial.

axolotlfloof · 04/04/2022 21:27

We love ours.
Easy to drive, charges at night. We have had it 6 months and only needed to charge away from home once as it has over 300 mile range.

Chocolatefreak · 04/04/2022 21:21

YANBU. We have one. We had the electrics done before it arrived and as soon as we plugged it in we had no power in the house for three days, not an easy repair. You need off street parking. The range is not what it boasts, as soon as you put on heating/air conditioning it reduces considerably.

The stress of wondering if you can drive long distance, get stuck in traffic etc and still find a charging point when you're desperate to get home and wait that additional 15 minutes isn't worth it for the eco-smugness, I feel.

All those heavy metals in that battery have to be mined from somewhere, and that electricity still has to be generated somehow. Clean and fast yes, but expensive. We had a hybrid before this and that was fine. This car is a bridge too far for me!

Happyhappyday · 04/04/2022 21:20

@BalladOfBarryAndFreda but my petrol car has a starting range of 400 miles, versus 300 with a brand spanking new battery, which then rapidly loses range in the cold (we were experiencing -30%, most of our long distance driving is in the high mountains). Not a reason not to buy but important to be aware of, especially as charging stations are thinner on the ground in the literal wilderness.

MurmuratingStarling · 04/04/2022 21:19

@Lunar27

Not everyone wanted or needed a mobile phone when they were first introduced but we barely think about it now. It'll be the same with EV's so if it doesn't work for you now then no worries. Just wait till one does.

Ridiculous comparison. Hmm People can live without a mobile phone, and shockingly, some people still don't have one. MANY people cannot live without a car for too many reasons to list.

Also, a mobile phone doesn't cost £30,000! Like an electric car does. Confused Your comparison is batshit.

Lunar27 · 04/04/2022 21:18

@SwanBuster.

Yes absolutely. Make the most of it while we can.

@BurscoughBooths

Free charging is the least of your worries. The taxpayer has already contributed to the £4500 EV grant, subsidised home chargers, BIK breaks, company car purchases, parking, congestion charges etc.

In some ways it can be seen as unfair but we've all likely benefitted from buying diesel when the government thought it was greener. Except this time there's more urgency to eliminate tailpipe emissions, hence the larger incentives. The trouble is, there are so many anti EV people around that change isn't happening quickly enough. Fine AFAIC as EV motoring will stay cheaper for longer.

SwanBuster · 04/04/2022 21:17

[quote BalladOfBarryAndFreda]@Happyhappyday, ICE cars have reduced range in colder weather too.[/quote]
Yeah, but petrol stations are everywhere. Until the general infrastructure improves, with an EV you need to know this - you can’t afford to be complacent. But once you do, its fine - also adjusting the way you drive makes a massive difference. I drive the Model S like the veritable grandparent sometimes and can eek out the range quite extraordinarily.

FlyingFlamingo · 04/04/2022 21:15

As Brrrrrrrrrrrrrrr (perfect username!) has reminded me - the preconditioning is worth it on its own! At 8:15 I press a button on my phone and at 8:30 I get into my warm, ice free car - I will never scrape ice again Grin

BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 04/04/2022 21:13

@Happyhappyday, ICE cars have reduced range in colder weather too.

Happyhappyday · 04/04/2022 21:09

That said, best thing is to run your existing car down and only replace with a new EV when you really need to. We got an e-assist bike to drastically reduce our car usage in the mean time without the massive environmental cost of building a whole new car.

Happyhappyday · 04/04/2022 21:06

I live in an area with a lot of Teslas (not UK) & charging infrastructure seems really good. Only annoying thing I discovered with a friend was the battery doesn’t last as long in the cold (obviously, I just hadn’t considered). So the almost 300 mile range when skiing wasn’t as good and we had to charge, but the charge only took 15 mins at a super charge station. And frankly the environmental benefits mean we all need to suck it up and be inconvenienced to help the chicken come before the egg with infrastructure.

SwanBuster · 04/04/2022 21:06

Obviously none of the above will last. But whilst those perks are there, I’ll use them!

BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 04/04/2022 21:06

YANBU, they won’t suit everyone’s needs but mine is great.

I’ve got a home charging point and charge overnight at home, it costs me 25% of what petrol used to. Zero road tax, saves me £490 a year and insurance is 1/3 less than my previous car. Longer service intervals. Thanks to the buoyant used car market, I sold my 2yr old car for more than I bought my brand new, factory ordered EV.

It has been brilliant for me but I did do a bit of reading first, checking that the range would suit me, year round and that the negatives wouldn’t really affect me. The main negative is the public charging network, which can be unreliable, expensive and sparse. I have only used it twice in the 8mo I’ve had my car, using my own wall box every other time. I’ve found it perfectly fine. I stuck to InstaVolt chargers, they were pricy (though still cheaper than petrol per mile) but are considered to be amongst the more reliable charging networks.

SwanBuster · 04/04/2022 21:04

@BurscoughBooths - it is indeed appalling. I

  • park in Tesco for 3 hours free charging and wander off to cinema
  • park in Aldi and use their free charging whilst doing my email
  • park in ikea and go for a mooch around and a cheap gravalax whilst free charging
  • park in the finest parts of London for 70p for half a day
  • pay no congestion charge on one of the widest cars you can buy
  • pay no Ulez
  • pay no road tax (VED)
  • charge for free at superchargers

It’s shocking. It shouldn’t be allowed. I couldn’t believe it either. So I bought one 🤷🏻‍♀️😂

Lunar27 · 04/04/2022 21:02

@MurmuratingStarling

100% this. ^ Brilliantly put. Such a stupid idea to phases out petrol and diesel cars, and force people to buy electric. There are sooooo many reasons against it.

Except the argument of course that petrol isn't going to last forever and we need to reduce emissions.

We're in a transitional period so EVs aren't ever going to work for everyone just now but ICE isn't going to be phased out until 2030 and even then you'll still be able to drive petrol/diesel for the foreseeable future. By which time all the issues you're thinking about will mostly be solved, including 2nd hand stock, which will be more readily available.

Not everyone wanted or needed a mobile phone when they were first introduced but we barely think about it now. It'll be the same with EV's so if it doesn't work for you now then no worries. Just wait till one does.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 04/04/2022 21:00

We got a Tesla Y. Gamechanger - it’s not a car, it’s a damn spaceship. No issues yet keeping it charged, it’s like having a petrol station at home. You get up and it’s ready to go. You can set it to warm up so it’s cosy to get into on a morning without an idling engine. And my god does it go. So fun !!

Jazzyjeffery · 04/04/2022 20:59

My tesla does over 300 miles on a single charge. Bloody love it. Unless you're regularly doing very long journeys you can just charge it when needed at home

ZenNudist · 04/04/2022 20:59

Work colleague has got one and it's made longer trips a nightmare by all accounts. And trips away from home where his PA now has to research parking/charging options. Stories about how he had to do diversions to charge up or plan his break around charging. I think he likes it but he's hasn't got much else to worry about so can afford to have some awkwardness about long journeys. My idea of too much faff.

PeachesToday · 04/04/2022 20:58

I have an electric car & absolutely love it. There’s so much more space inside & there’s a scheme through work that includes insurance, break down cover & a free charger setup at your home.

I charge overnight when needed and my car has around 270 miles between charges.