Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want an electric car?

318 replies

Elevenfourteen · 04/04/2022 19:57

I know IABU for asking such a dull question, but my Dh wants to buy an electric car and I’m not convinced.
I guess they’re better for the environment so that’s one thing. But are we set up for them properly yet? Do all garages have charging points? Do you have to hang around the garage for ages while they charge? I just can’t imagine how they can be a practical option.
Driving to work and back and charging at night is fine, but what about going on holiday?

Do any of you have electric cars and can you reassure me?

OP posts:
Viviennemary · 04/04/2022 22:51

I wouldn't have one either. They are a bonkers idea IMHO.

SwanBuster · 04/04/2022 22:51

@Beercrispsandnuts

It’s not misinformation. It’s one hundred percent accurate. 100 percent.
So my 2016 Model S - coming up to 6 years - which is still on its original battery is a figment of my imagination?

And the 2014 one I met when the owner was charging yesterday is also somehow fake?

Give over 😂

Whetheryouthinkyoucan · 04/04/2022 22:50

@SwanBuster interestingly I haven’t used a Tesla charger yet- my husband has- I tend to use InstaVolt ones. It just happens that they seem to be on my routes. Also often near a Starbucks so I do some emails and have a coffee. Yesterday I charged for 27 mins, gained 98 miles. By the time I’d walked the dogs for a pee, bought my coffee and drunk it was done.

NaiceHamAndHugs · 04/04/2022 22:48

I do around 1k miles a week. I live remotely, I have a large family and need a lot of space in my car for stuff, I regularly tow 2t loads, I also recently went 8 days in an area cut off from civilisation without electricity after a storm.

Electric cars can absolutely fuck right off until someone produces something that’s actually fit for purpose.

Horrible, ugly, useless, silent little shit bins. 7 years to change the views of those who don’t live in urban and populated areas is going to be a challenge.

(And no need for anyone to take that personally, your car may be ugly but I didn’t say you were!)

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 04/04/2022 22:48

@Beercrispsandnuts

Don’t do it, there is a fire risk with the batteries over heating, don’t charge them in an integrated garage and battery replacement cost means you need to basically the car basically every three to five years. Cost of ownership is huge.

They burn so hot that the fire brigade can’t come near you and they will combust if you get in an accident and the battery is pierced.

Two things right now. Don’t ever charge it in integrated garage and have an escape route planned to get the hell out if you hit something.

Yanbu

This is total bollocks.
Coffeeonmytoffee · 04/04/2022 22:47

Today I drove into central london. Parked for four hours all for the grand total of….86p

Beercrispsandnuts · 04/04/2022 22:47

It’s not misinformation. It’s one hundred percent accurate. 100 percent.

SwanBuster · 04/04/2022 22:45

@Beercrispsandnuts

Don’t do it, there is a fire risk with the batteries over heating, don’t charge them in an integrated garage and battery replacement cost means you need to basically the car basically every three to five years. Cost of ownership is huge.

They burn so hot that the fire brigade can’t come near you and they will combust if you get in an accident and the battery is pierced.

Two things right now. Don’t ever charge it in integrated garage and have an escape route planned to get the hell out if you hit something.

Yanbu

Total misinformation regarding the batteries.

How many 2013 Model S’s are there that needed a battery swap?

Answer - a few, but there are plenty that haven’t.

How many have exceeded 250k miles out of a pack? - answer - quite a few worldwide.

Ljmumun · 04/04/2022 22:45

We had this discussion agreed on a hybrid with no external charge. Had it 3 months really like it . Filled it up twice. Most local journeys electric with longer if higher speeds petrol/ dual fuel. Only issue is the loss of boot space

LastInTheQueue · 04/04/2022 22:43

I was an early EV adopter, and got a Nissan Leaf 5-6yrs ago. I loved it, even if the mileage range was rubbish. Things have VASTLY improved since then - ranges are better, there are considerable more chargers, and I can’t imagine going back to petrol.

I replaced the Nissan with a kia Niro last year and I love this even more! We travel into London quite often, so no congestion charge (likely to change in a couple of years), no ulez, usually free parking while charging, which sometimes is also free.

Beercrispsandnuts · 04/04/2022 22:40

Don’t do it, there is a fire risk with the batteries over heating, don’t charge them in an integrated garage and battery replacement cost means you need to basically the car basically every three to five years. Cost of ownership is huge.

They burn so hot that the fire brigade can’t come near you and they will combust if you get in an accident and the battery is pierced.

Two things right now. Don’t ever charge it in integrated garage and have an escape route planned to get the hell out if you hit something.

Yanbu

jamie8 · 04/04/2022 22:39

Are there EVs suitable for towing a trailer yet?
We enquired about 2years ago, need a small trailer for garden waste and helping youth group camping. No cars were insurable because manufacturers did not recommend towing so no towbars designed for them.

SwanBuster · 04/04/2022 22:39

@toomuchfruit

Unless it’s a Tesla I wouldn’t bother just yet. The charging network in England is archaic and over complicated. The Tesla charging network works really well though.
We double posted 😂
SwanBuster · 04/04/2022 22:39

@Whetheryouthinkyoucan

I have a Tesla and have no problems charging it. Charging points need a bit more planning, but there’s plenty of them if you need them. I live rurally and still don’t have an issue. I do go on holiday with it too- don’t understand this “you can’t” business? Why not?
Tesla’s are a totally different breed to every other EV though - at least in mental comfort terms - because the supercharger network is a huge bail out even if you pay for it.

Things are getting a lot better quite quickly with gridserve, shell and instavolt etc with regards to ‘open’ charging networks but until Tesla fully open up the superchargers to other makes, I’d say you have to know what you’re doing and be Ok with a bit of a leap into the unknown.

It’s definitely still doable, but Tesla’s charging network is what makes the car the best proposition. Otherwise I’d have a Porsche Taycan (over my Model S) or the Kia EV6 (over a 3). The Model Y is the best all round Tesla imho - but as there’s no free supercharging I’m not trading it in ever.

toomuchfruit · 04/04/2022 22:35

Unless it’s a Tesla I wouldn’t bother just yet. The charging network in England is archaic and over complicated. The Tesla charging network works really well though.

NotMeNoNo · 04/04/2022 22:35

I think people need to be less wedded to one car for everything. If 90% of usage is short journeys, commuting etc with a place to charge, you should go for it and hire a bigger/hybrid car for occasional holidays. People who drive all day or who need a commercial vehicle will need a different solution. But if all the school runners and short commuters went for EVs it would take a lot of petrol/diesel cars off the road.

lampygirl · 04/04/2022 22:34

@fourmagpies I’d do the 280 miles to Newcastle with just a quick wee, often have to come back same day as well, so if the location doesn’t have chargers then it’s not viable. We do to Zermatt with one or two quick stops (swapping drivers, not one person doing the whole journey). Having to have 2-3 hours of stops on that journey would probably put us over into having to have an overnight hotel which is a massive waste.

Some people just don’t want to spend time wallowing round service stations or eating a full sit down meal to kill time, or having to drive at 65 across Europe for max range when the speed limit is over 80. Time seems to be the overlooked commodity in the EV case.

Whetheryouthinkyoucan · 04/04/2022 22:31

I have a Tesla and have no problems charging it. Charging points need a bit more planning, but there’s plenty of them if you need them. I live rurally and still don’t have an issue. I do go on holiday with it too- don’t understand this “you can’t” business? Why not?

SwanBuster · 04/04/2022 22:29

@lampygirl - I get where you’re coming from with most of your post - but a 600 mile range is a strange thing to require imho. Doing 600 miles without stopping at all sounds torturous!

I know you might mean you don’t want to fill up too often, but it’s not really a big chore. I think any real range of over 200, provided there’s charging infrastructure is pretty acceptable. I dropped from a 500 mile range to 240, and it’s a bit annoying sometimes but 🤷🏻‍♀️

SwanBuster · 04/04/2022 22:25

@AnybodyAnywhere

Hmmm, reading this thread it seems that electric cars are ‘super great’ if you have a driveway and can afford a Tesla. Maybe not so great if you live in a tower block…….

I wonder if this will be how they eventually cut down the traffic, by making it just too difficult and inconvenient for many people.

This absolutely sums up the current state of affairs imho - honest opinion of an EV owner. If you haven’t got a Tesla which you don’t mind supercharging, and crucially you don’t have a way to charge at home - it’s not quite there yet.
SwanBuster · 04/04/2022 22:23

@Lunar27 - I dunno that saying the use barely any battery around town is a good idea. I dunno about your car, but mine definitely acts a bit like an ice on short start/stop journeys - especially when starting cold. It can use a lot of power - and I’m extremely careful with driving.

The optimum journey for range is driving on long clear roads at 30-58 mph. I can beat the official range doing that. I match the cars range figure if I’m cruising on a long road without too many hills at around 62 mph. Long journeys are what it feels my car was designed for - definitely not short ones with start/stops.

But yeah - different EVs have different optimisations. I’ve no doubt something more akin to a conventional city car might act differently.

Fourmagpies · 04/04/2022 21:55

My next car will be EV. DH has an audi e tron through work and I love it, it is heavier than a normal car due to the weight of the batteries but otherwise so easy to drive. We can do a trip from Midlands to other end of Kent without needing to charge. How far do people drive without stopping anyway? We plan the stops in advance, usually somewhere with a super fast charger and it's topped up enough while having a wee to get home.

AnybodyAnywhere · 04/04/2022 21:55

Hmmm, reading this thread it seems that electric cars are ‘super great’ if you have a driveway and can afford a Tesla. Maybe not so great if you live in a tower block…….

I wonder if this will be how they eventually cut down the traffic, by making it just too difficult and inconvenient for many people.

lampygirl · 04/04/2022 21:54

I'd actually like to be convinced into an electric car, but I want a bog standard premium estate not modelled around the starship enterprise, with a 600+ mile range and a decent loading and towing capacity, and be able to buy it second hand for sub £15k and not have to factor in replacing a battery at a cost that could to be honest buy another second hand ICE car. I know any car can fail and need a new engine but it's not expected in the same way that batteries are known to degrade.

The idea of the fast charger is OK if you turn up and the charger is free, but as more people have electric then what are the chances. You almost always have to wait for a car to move off from the petrol pump, only now the petrol pump is occupied for 25 minutes rather than 3, so could easily make a 10 minute stop into over an hour, and you have to repeat it every 200 miles.

I think they are great as city cars, where the home charge gets you to and from the local school and tescos for a week, but the long distance drive isn't there yet for the mass market for me.

emmathedilemma · 04/04/2022 21:54

I’m with you, nothing appeals about them. I don’t even like driving automatic cars! I live in a flat so can’t install a charger and there’s no way I’m spending half my life hanging out at the local petrol station waiting for it to charge. None would get me to my parents without stopping to charge on the way whereas my current car gets there in half a tank of petrol. The infrastructure just isn’t good enough for me at the moment, let alone the cost of them.