Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want an electric car?

318 replies

Elevenfourteen · 04/04/2022 19:57

I know IABU for asking such a dull question, but my Dh wants to buy an electric car and I’m not convinced.
I guess they’re better for the environment so that’s one thing. But are we set up for them properly yet? Do all garages have charging points? Do you have to hang around the garage for ages while they charge? I just can’t imagine how they can be a practical option.
Driving to work and back and charging at night is fine, but what about going on holiday?

Do any of you have electric cars and can you reassure me?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MissyB1 · 06/04/2022 21:29

@FlyingFlamingo

Be careful with the NHS lease scheme though if anyone is considering it - I looked into it but decided against it because it would have reduced my pension contributions - if I did it for 10 years when I retired I would have been £1000 a year worse off. There is the option to offset this and pay more in to make up the difference of course but in terms of monthly outgoings PCP worked out cheaper and provided I pay it off I will own the car at the end - not so with lease schemes.
It depends on your personal circumstances. We’ve just gone for it on the NHS salary sacrifice. Dh is only 5 years from retirement, and pcp would not work out cheaper for us. We looked at the numbers very carefully.
SwanBuster · 06/04/2022 20:05

@FlyingFlamingo

Be careful with the NHS lease scheme though if anyone is considering it - I looked into it but decided against it because it would have reduced my pension contributions - if I did it for 10 years when I retired I would have been £1000 a year worse off. There is the option to offset this and pay more in to make up the difference of course but in terms of monthly outgoings PCP worked out cheaper and provided I pay it off I will own the car at the end - not so with lease schemes.
Yeah the devil is in the detail with the NHS scheme. At my workplace, all salary sacrifices are calculated and cumulative from the gross - so for instance pension comes off - and they give us the employer amount based off full. .

There would be nothing to stop someone doing the following - technically - all they need to do is stay above minimum wage on a monthly basis.

Sacrifice enough to put 40k in pension (it’ll likely take between 20-32k to do that, once employers contribs are taken into account)

Sacrifice say 12k for a cycle

Sacrifice 12k for an EV

Perhaps doing the above gets yourself down to minimum wage and then you can claim universal credit.

In no way financial advice - but by my reading of the rules - that’s all allowed. But do your own research. It’s In-flipping-sane.

FlyingFlamingo · 06/04/2022 19:55

Be careful with the NHS lease scheme though if anyone is considering it - I looked into it but decided against it because it would have reduced my pension contributions - if I did it for 10 years when I retired I would have been £1000 a year worse off. There is the option to offset this and pay more in to make up the difference of course but in terms of monthly outgoings PCP worked out cheaper and provided I pay it off I will own the car at the end - not so with lease schemes.

SwanBuster · 06/04/2022 19:44

www.gov.uk/hmrc-internal-manuals/tax-credits-manual/tcm0260120

Just in case anyone thinks I’m talking rubbish that you could get a cheap Tesla on tax credits 😂

SwanBuster · 06/04/2022 19:37

Oh - I forgot now that BIK is back though on those Sal sac deals, so it wouldn’t quite work.

But still - on a cheaper car, yeah those schemes are amazing. Another sweet spot could be if you earn between 50-60k and are having your child benefit tapered away - or 100-125k and having the personal allowance tapered. All have big marginal rates that you could sacrifice for an EV instead ….

SwanBuster · 06/04/2022 19:34

[quote Lunar27]@lampygirl.

Yes definitely. It is rather skewed towards business but then I have a friend who works for the NHS and their car scheme is ludicrous. Not long ago she could have a Jaguar iPace for around £350/month or Audi eTron for £400. When you consider that everything is included except electricity, it's a no brainer.

It's always business though and think it's a real kicker that they've scrapped the EV grant when BIK is zero.[/quote]
Indeed. The EV salary sacrifice schemes are nuts. The savings are totally dependent on your marginal tax rate.

Hypothetically - someone still qualifying for tax credits could sacrifice say 12k per year for a taycan. Totally legal.

That 12k would cost them ~3k net as they have an effective marginal rate of 73% with the taper. So 250 p/m for a Taycan, fully insured etc.😂

I'd do it for sure 😁

Pilatesteacheruk · 06/04/2022 19:20

Thank you @lunar27 @FloBot7 Smile

Lunar27 · 06/04/2022 19:04

@lampygirl.

Yes definitely. It is rather skewed towards business but then I have a friend who works for the NHS and their car scheme is ludicrous. Not long ago she could have a Jaguar iPace for around £350/month or Audi eTron for £400. When you consider that everything is included except electricity, it's a no brainer.

It's always business though and think it's a real kicker that they've scrapped the EV grant when BIK is zero.

lampygirl · 06/04/2022 18:25

@Lunar27 interesting what you say about BIK. EVs seem to be way more appealing as a corporate purchase. When you do the Tesla compared with the standard ICE car on a £48k car the savings to a business purchase are somewhere about £23k over 5 years, but as a private purchase the savings to the individual diminish to under £4k over 5 years based on an average deal. Yes that is savings to business vs savings to an individual so not necessarily like for like, but lots of people don’t get company cars but generally these people have the pick of the market rather than something from the fleet, so maybe more of that saving could be moved away from fleet and into private ownership.

FloBot7 · 06/04/2022 17:47

Ours isn't coming until May. We have to get some sort of update to our wiring and then the charger will be fitted the day after. Cost is around £900 all-in. At the moment we charge DH's Tesla overnight using a regular plug in our porch. It's only every 4 or 5 days and the lowest the battery has been since delivery is 60%. To be honest, we don't really need the charger but it's not a huge stretch financially so we've kept the appointment. Who knows, the next owners of our house might be more inclined to get an electric vehicle because of it. I debated a Zoe about 4 years ago but didn't understand how charging worked.

NeedleNoodle3 · 06/04/2022 17:10

Those of you who have a charging point at home, how much was it and who did it? Thank you!
It was free, we got a government grant of £350 and Audi paid the rest.

Frazzled2207 · 06/04/2022 16:23

to echo what @Lunar27 said - bear in mind that you might not actually need one at all.
At the moment we are just charging it happily via a 3 pin plug in the garage (cable runs outside the garage) having moved to house without a charge point.
This means it takes 12 hours i.e. overnight from empty to full as opposed to 3 ish with a charge point but we never actually charge from empty. Trick is to just plug it in every few days overnight at home to keep it topped up. We intend to get a chargepoint fitted for when we need it charged more quickly but are coping just fine as it is and have no rush.

Lunar27 · 06/04/2022 15:59

@Pilatesteacheruk

Those of you who have a charging point at home, how much was it and who did it? Thank you!
Prices vary depending on what charger you go for and what features you want e.g. solar panel and battery storage compatibility etc. but something basic will cost about £700 all in. Sadly the government have now ended the £350 grant so you'll have to pay the full amount. It's been a while since I had mine installed so there may be cheaper ones available.

The supplier of the charger will normally organise an electrician to install it. All you'd need to do is to provide some basic info on the location of your consumer unit, where you'd like the charger and whether you have any spare fuse capacity.

Of course, if you know an electrician you can buy a charger direct and have it installed yourself. This may be cheaper still.

Lunar27 · 06/04/2022 15:49

@C8H10N4O2

I have an appreciation as an engineer, of course.

My comments relate to the type of person you often hear pontificating that the grid can't possibly cope, yet has no actual interest in buying an EV until there's no other option i.e. in 10-20 years time. This is despite the national grid saying there isn't a problem.

So yes, it's unwise for Joe public to worry about stuff today when it's not going to affect them for aeons.

It's definitely something for the relevant organisations to think about but something tells me that they've been thinking about it for some time now.

Pilatesteacheruk · 06/04/2022 15:23

Those of you who have a charging point at home, how much was it and who did it? Thank you!

C8H10N4O2 · 06/04/2022 15:18

Therefore worrying about a theoretical scenario today, when mass EV uptake is 10-20 years away, is unwise

Do you have any idea how long it takes to roll out this kind of infrastructure and how much investment? Or the kind of distribution bottlenecks and problems in the current, aging UK grid? These programmes take decades, not a few months in the run up to 2030.

Even in my urban road about half the houses could not be upgraded without significant cabling changes due to the age of the local infrastructure. Then there is the carbon footprint of all that civil engineering and infrastructure work in itself, let alone the carbon footprint of replacing any car less than 10-15 years old.

It absolutely needs worrying about now if you want EVs to achieve mass roll out but in the short term replacing relatively recent cars with EVs is more about green consumerism for the middle classes than reducing carbon footprint.

If you want to reduce your carbon footprint then start with your day to day life, reducing consumption, insulating where you can, reducing car journeys where you can, reducing imported food - these all reduce carbon footprint without adding to it further up the line. If your car is over ten years old then look at EV or hybrid when you need to replace rather than when you fancy a new car.

Lunar27 · 06/04/2022 15:07

@Otherpeoplesteens

Every article I've read, including the national grid's says that the grid can cope, and that was my original comment.

Whether the local distribution can, is another matter and would imagine is highly dependent on locale, as well as the number of people charging.

It's a common misconception that everyone will be charging simultaneously as the just don't and the grid will likely evolve currently overnight tariffs to suit generation and load profiles.

But I'll repeat. Infrastructures evolve so I very much doubt local networks will stay the same when EV ownership increases I the areas you're talking about.

Otherpeoplesteens · 06/04/2022 14:56

@Lunar27

I'm not so sure it's a myth or that it has been debunked. In a previous job I had to negotiate with electricity distributors (the operators of the infrastructure between the substations and the home or business end user) when looking to install linear accelerators in cancer treatment centres. The national transmission infrastructure might be OK but trust me, it is a very, very real issue at local distribution level.

Lunar27 · 06/04/2022 14:50

@Otherpeoplesteens

I believe the grid myth has been debunked by people who work in the field. I've watched interviews with experts who have no worries that it can cope (in the UK anyway).

I would imagine there may well be areas of the UK where mass charging may be difficult but engineering and infrastructures evolve. Therefore worrying about a theoretical scenario today, when mass EV uptake is 10-20 years away, is unwise.

I studied renewable energy production at uni over 20 years ago, when we generated barely any at all. Now over 40% is generated. Things change as demand/necessity dictates.

The beauty of EV's is that I can also stick solar panels on my roof and alleviate the grid for 8-9 months of the year. Perhaps not 100% but some is better than none.

Lunar27 · 06/04/2022 14:40

@Horst. Apologies, couldn't help myself.

It's a tricky one really as it depends on the speed of the vehicle. Under 12mph EVs are as quiet as many ICE vehicles (not diesel obviously). Above 12mph tyre/road and wind noise dominate, hence why modern EV noise is limited.

If you have the time/inclination, this report is really interesting and covers a lot of research into relative vehicle noise.

Although on a camp site I can imagine vehicle noise and emissions to be more of a nuisance but we're so normalised to accept it.

<a class="break-all" href="https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/4486/PPR525-assessing-the-perceived-safety-risk-from-quiet-electric-and-hybrid-vehicles.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjO7uboxf_2AhVBlFwKHeyVDgcQFnoECAMQAQ&usg=AOvVaw3astwND3A7vqXBLd2BYRUr" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/4486/PPR525-assessing-the-perceived-safety-risk-from-quiet-electric-and-hybrid-vehicles.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjO7uboxf_2AhVBlFwKHeyVDgcQFnoECAMQAQ&usg=AOvVaw3astwND3A7vqXBLd2BYRUr

Otherpeoplesteens · 06/04/2022 14:40

Just looked up the warning noise thing. AVAS (Acoustic Vehicle Alerting Systems) became law in the EU in 2019 for all new approvals, and production of older designs from 2021. It is not required to be retrofitted to older vehicles.

The issue with Tesla is that the ability to play loud fart noises at will (yes, this is apparently a factory fit capability) through the 'Boombox' external speaker was deemed to be capable of drowning out the mandatory warning sound, and thus illegal.

Otherpeoplesteens · 06/04/2022 14:12

I understand Tesla has an option to change the sound of the low speed warning. It hit the news recently because one of the alternative options - a repeating fart sound - didn't meet the regulations in one US state.

In all seriousness, sure there are a lot of BS 'reasons' given for not having an EV but the grid argument is currently quite true in many places. The odd charger here and there isn't a problem, but a wholesale move to EV charging at every home in Britain would be impossible nearly everywhere with current capacity. UPS has a depot in Kentish Town with electric vans and they can only charge more than 20 vans at a time with the help of their own battery storage facility, or the lights go out.

There are also a whole range of places near military bases where, although charging itself is not a problem, smart meters for overnight charging tariffs are not permitted because they interfere with radar installations, even up to 20 miles from the base. According to Smart Meter GB this is being worked on and should have a solution this year, but it is a real problem for some people.

Horst · 06/04/2022 14:11

Very funny. It turned from behind a wind breaker so yeah it was in no line of sight then was right in front of the tent pretty much silently. And the driver electric or not wouldn’t of been able to see is any children where there but if it had of been noisy they would at least hear it coming.

It wasnt a dig at electric cars just saying they don’t all make a noise at low speeds only the newer ones seems too.

Lunar27 · 06/04/2022 14:01

@Horst

Unfortunately that'll be the cloaking device that comes standard with most EV's. One minute you can't see them and the suddenly, poof, it's running over women, children, dogs and old people.

Horst · 06/04/2022 13:55

All evs don’t make a sound when going slow.

When we where camping no music just chatting and throwing a frisbe next thing there was a car right there no sound at all. That one was pretty dangerous on a camp site none for allowing children to run free. It wasn’t on a designated road just driving though a tent field.