Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask regarding COVID - what does 'we just have to live with it' look like in real life?

427 replies

Fay2121 · 04/04/2022 17:26

I keep hearing the phrase.

What is the reality of 'we just have to live with it'.

OP posts:
carefullycourageous · 05/04/2022 17:43

@SilverGlitterBaubles

I spent yesterday in a meeting with a group at work of in a small poorly ventilated room. 2 of the group clearly had 'colds' but said they had tested negative so you just have to trust in this. We shall see how many have the cold next week. It is actually amazing to think only 12 months ago the idea of being anywhere near a work colleague was considered risky.
Our work have asked anyone with cold symptoms to stay away, and people are following this.

I think it is annoying that a window can not be opened more often tbh, it woudl help with so many minor illnesses.

MangyInseam · 05/04/2022 17:40

@Cornettoninja

It's very reasonable if you have norovirus or the flu to avoid visiting an elderly person in a nursing home, or for that matter going anywhere you don't have to

I’m seeing a disconnect between these statements…

That is in no way comparable to telling people they cannot have visitors, or go out, for six months, or even three months. Even if it is to "protect others"

It only works if you don’t think covid is actually as much of a concern to this group as norovirus or flu?

Largely restrictions are in place, in nursing homes certainly, to protect residents, not others. The frequency of this happening will depend on the circulation in the wider community, when one resident has covid symptomatically its impossible to ignore it.

Essentially this is one of the last groups to Come out of the pandemic and we’re crossing fingers that circulation in the community drops drastically so it isn’t an ongoing issue and becomes something that is encountered as often as norovirus or flu.

The rest of the country may have made a conscious decision that we’re happy living with covid but there’s still sections of society where that’s essentially a death wish and not a freedom anyone with a duty of care can facilitate.

I have some personal stake in this, my df is currently eol with heart failure and other diagnoses and a DNR in place and resident in a nursing home meaning my face to face contact with has been and continues to affected by covid restrictions. He’s had it twice, once he was completely asymptomatic and once he was miserably ill but not enough to be any closer to death. It’s beyond shit but I don’t know if he could comprehend what the decision to opt out of restrictions actually might mean, he’s making his peace with dying but everyone’s focussed on that being a good death not one where he’s surrounded by people in full on PPE and experiencing unnecessary pain and fear. Truthfully there’s very little that can be offered to this group even in terms of palliative care, no one is under any illusion that antivirals or interventions will even be offered. Those with responsibility for their care shouldn’t be asked to not do what their job is, caring for and protecting their clients.

No, there is no disconnect and I am honestly not sure why you think there is.

If you are actively ill with something more serious like a flu, it may be best not to visit someone vulnerable. Certainly you should ask them, in any case. If they live in a place like a senior's center they may choose to be more careful than they would in their own home, and everyone understands that.

This is quite different than telling adult people that they are not allowed to have any visitors, or telling them they cannot leave their institutional facilities, for fear they may come in contact with an illness from out in the world.

If someone told you, in your own home, that you were not allowed to leave or have guests, in case you might spread illness, that would be considered some kind of coercive control.

Older people still have all the normal rights of other adults. Being cared for in a facility does not mean that they are now sub-human people who can have others dictate their movements.

We have had seniors restricted in their facilities now for two years of covid. In some of these places, people's average stay is 18 months, pre-covid. Not because they get better and move out, but because they die. They have spent the last years of their lives locked in, and died relatively alone, in order to protect them from dying from covid.

I really don't understand how people think that is ok, or how it is ok to tell people in their home - because it is their home - that they can't go out or see their loved ones. If there are people who want complete isolation there needs to be other arrangements for them - there should be no question of them inflicting that on others.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 05/04/2022 17:27

I spent yesterday in a meeting with a group at work of in a small poorly ventilated room. 2 of the group clearly had 'colds' but said they had tested negative so you just have to trust in this. We shall see how many have the cold next week. It is actually amazing to think only 12 months ago the idea of being anywhere near a work colleague was considered risky.

HardyBuckette · 05/04/2022 17:12

@BoredZelda

Possibly the 'properly followed' is a nod to measures that perform better in controlled conditions than they do in the big wide world with actual humans being normal and inconvenient.

Mainly I meant properly followed i.e proper ventilation being used, offices being set up properly. But yes, also people understanding that a mask goes over your nose too.

I'm all up for proper ventilation, but meanwhile, do you think people just putting low grade masks over their noses too, in the face of something as contagious as Omicron actually qualifies as 'could really help' and if so what's the evidence?
TheKeatingFive · 05/04/2022 17:02

Mainly I meant properly followed i.e proper ventilation being used, offices being set up properly.

I'd still love to know what these measures are, given than full on lockdown is not achieving that much in China

BoredZelda · 05/04/2022 17:01

Possibly the 'properly followed' is a nod to measures that perform better in controlled conditions than they do in the big wide world with actual humans being normal and inconvenient.

Mainly I meant properly followed i.e proper ventilation being used, offices being set up properly. But yes, also people understanding that a mask goes over your nose too.

TheKeatingFive · 05/04/2022 17:00

And how is it looking for them? How will it look when Omicron sub variant hits? There is also a different mindset certainly in the likes of Sweden.

It's true of Norway, Denmark and ROI too, all of whom have been held up on here as much superior to the U.K. in their handling of covid

TheKeatingFive · 05/04/2022 16:58

I was expecting the country not to be stupid enough to leave the house with covid.

But what was 'all for nothing' is specifically what I'm asking. What was the 'all'?

BoredZelda · 05/04/2022 16:58

Correct me if I'm wrong, but haven't some of the Scandinavian countries lifted pretty much all restrictions?

And how is it looking for them? How will it look when Omicron sub variant hits? There is also a different mindset certainly in the likes of Sweden. They didn't have to be told to be careful, they were just told it would be a good idea and they did it.

TheKeatingFive · 05/04/2022 16:57

Thursday 24th of February was when mandatory isolation ended. It was impossible to get LFT's for weeks before then.

Guidance and policies in most public places didn't change until 1st April and your point about lfts isnt true.

Thatsplentyjack · 05/04/2022 16:55

@Invasionofthegutsnatchers

Teachers with no access to LFTs unless they pay for them out of their own pockets, coming to work with a temperature and flu symptoms, battling through 10-12 hours of a highly stressful day because apparently it doesn't spread in schools, only hospitals and prisons
Well if you're really unwell you just take time off surely? You know, like any other illness. Teachers get sick days just like any other employees.
likemindedarseholes · 05/04/2022 16:54

@TheKeatingFive I was expecting the country not to be stupid enough to leave the house with covid. But with no sickpay or government funds to pay for people to isolate those people had no choice.

Eyedropeyeflop · 05/04/2022 16:53

@likemindedarseholes

Ahh I see. It could make them unwell coming off their meds.

It could also be argued that covid restrictions in general are just as damaging to people who suffer from severe and enduring psychotic Illnesses.

I know the people in my family who suffer from psychosis certainly suffered the most during the height of the pandemic.

They are managing their mental health a lot better now restrictions have eased somewhat so it really isn’t as black and white as what you’re suggesting.

Have you ever thought the reason why they’ve potentially relapsed and ended up as an inpatient is because of covid restrictions? Certainly was the case with my auntie.

likemindedarseholes · 05/04/2022 16:53

Thursday 24th of February was when mandatory isolation ended. It was impossible to get LFT's for weeks before then.

TheKeatingFive · 05/04/2022 16:50

the rates were nowhere near as bad as before the idiotic decision to stop mandatory isolation and free testing.

Those things have just stopped a few days ago. So rates aren't reflective of that change.

All of this seems to have been for nothing

What has been for nothing? Covid measures? What were you expecting them to achieve?

HardyBuckette · 05/04/2022 16:50

Yes, people not going to Morrisons after testing positive is the only thing that's important here, and also if people didn't go to Morrison's after testing positive nobody would ever get covid again. That's a full solution to the entire pandemic.

likemindedarseholes · 05/04/2022 16:48

@Eyedropeyeflop if you test positive and are on certain medications then you might have to stop them due to abnormal blood results. Look up the research.

Eyedropeyeflop · 05/04/2022 16:46

@likemindedarseholes

Why would someone else’s anti psychotic medication have to be stopped due to someone testing positive on a psychiatric ward? Something doesn’t add up tnere. That’s ethically wrong and I’m very suspicious. You cannot simply prioritise a covid infection over someone’s MH meds.

My auntie is not long home from an inpatient stay and not once did she have her meds stopped and she was in there for months. I’m certain they wouldn’t have escaped covid on the ward, we are a large city.

likemindedarseholes · 05/04/2022 16:45

@TheKeatingFive the rates were nowhere near as bad as before the idiotic decision to stop mandatory isolation and free testing. Our hospital is the worst, staffing and moralwise, that it has ever been. I don't see many of my team still being in the NHS in a years time. All of this seems to have been for nothing, and you know who suffers the most, the patients.

TheKeatingFive · 05/04/2022 16:39

And for what? So Sheila can go to Morrisons after testing positive?

Being very dismissive of the impact restrictions have on society doesn't actually help this discussion.

We were isolating for 16 days as a family in a very small house, with big impacts on both our businesses, our children's education, their mental health.

That's before we get into the actual efficacy of these measures.

likemindedarseholes · 05/04/2022 16:29

In my line of work (long term psychiatric hospital, 'getting on with it' means that if someone catches covid we have to shut that ward down, no one can have leave, no transfers, no one can be discharged. It can mean they at very often antipsychotic medication must be stopped due to it causing alarming abnormalities to their blood results. This causes them to sometimes become unwell or it delays their discharge, at a time when we still have less substantive staff than ever before!
We are still very much in a pandemic with staff not being able to work whilst covid positive nor if a family member has tested positive. There's a very good reason for that!
Imagine you have a family member who is mentally unwell and they can't leave the ward for nearly a month as patient after patient tests positive for covid. Imagine that all regular staff are wiped out and you constantly have agency staff who don't know the patients. Imagine their consultant is off, their social worker, psychologist, activities team etc etc. This has been going on for over two years and it seems worse than ever! Their quality of life is so poor compared to before. And for what? So Sheila can go to Morrisons after testing positive?

WeddingFavour · 05/04/2022 16:22

@Nicholethejewellery We've just spent 2 years trying to solve/avoid it. We've tried. No we can't 'solve' a virus, obviously, but we can try to develop effective vaccines and treatments. And yes, 60 million people's right to live freely is more important than thousands of extra deaths a year. It's a balance and a risk/benefit. We can't limit millions of people for the sake of thousands.

TheKeatingFive · 05/04/2022 16:10

That's all it is. It's an admission that we can't "solve" Covid and we're not even going to try.

We can't solve covid, no. But what are you saying? Should we do lots of costly things (from a social and psychological POV as well as economic) even though we know that they won't make a difference?

Nicholethejewellery · 05/04/2022 16:07

"Living with Covid" just means "the economy/my right to do what I like is more important than several to many thousands extra deaths every year".

That's all it is. It's an admission that we can't "solve" Covid and we're not even going to try.

Frannyhy · 05/04/2022 16:02

I’ve just developed it for the first time. I’m triple vaccinated.

It means my Airbnb guest has had to move for the rest of the week. She is an NHS worker on placement and didn’t need the inconvenience.

My weekend guest was coming to run the Brighton Marathon - all other cheap accommodation is booked. She’s been forced to pay extortionate money for a hotel. If I could I’d pay the difference but I can’t afford it - Airbnb say it’s not down to them.

My next two week’s bookings have cancelled and I have to pay for a deep clean.