Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have you ever had to leave a job you love because of a manager?

82 replies

BlossomLake · 04/04/2022 16:18

Aibu to leave a job I love and pays me well because my manger is awful. He constantly finds fault in everything I do. Nothing is ever good enough. I'm exhausted.

Words of wisdom and advice appreciated

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thepollonator · 05/04/2022 22:38

I posted my story up thread but I would just like to add that the manager who first employed me was excellent, we had a few little ups and downs but nothing ever lingered or got in the way of work. She got a promotion after I'd been there 10 yrs and that's when the new manager took over and our problems began! Now about 8 years after my first manager left we are still the best of friends and she is always there to support my with anything! Sooo now Pete you horrid little man I wish you nothing but bad luck in everything that you do!!!!

Terfydactyl · 05/04/2022 15:54

@malificent7

I always feel that certain types become bad managers....those who were bullies at school seem to thrive on the power.

That said, some managers are great...the difference is I WANT to do well for good managers.

Yes indeed, I posted a page or so back that I now have the best manager ever. And because the manager is so good, I do more, happily. And the whole team is good. We know our backs are covered, we know and have seen the manager go to bat for us all. There is very little bitching within the team, which is unusual imho. I also posted that I have to move on, I want to go into management and I will model myself on current boss. That's how good they are. I will never make a staff member cry at the thought of coming in to work.
EleanorDeCleaner · 05/04/2022 14:28

Yes, 9 years ago now. I absolutely loved it - it was the dream job I landed out of nowhere. Me and my manager (who I knew personally) got along famously and laughed all day every day, my own team was small and experienced and no trouble, really nice people. There was always something new and exciting to deal with every day, it was brilliant.

Then just as I was feeling warm and valued and worthy and like I'd finally arrived, the manager I laughed and shared annoying "in-jokes" with daily suddenly turned on me.

It was so sudden I was reeling - it was something really trivial but he ripped into me, out of the blue, in front of another team member. Ridiculed something I'd done, getting increasingly nasty until I was backing out of the room. I actually cried (in private), I was so humiliated.

And that was how the pattern went - he'd build you up, making out you were the best at everything and utterly irreplaceable so your ego was well-stroked, and then come and tear it all down again when he wanted to entertain himself. He did it over and over until my confidence was so broken that I could barely make a decision, and then he'd ridicule me and call me jelly-spine in front of my team. He even had nasty spiteful "prizes" at the Christmas party to shame people.

I reached my limit when he talked me into a "promotion", which meant a lot more responsibility for no more pay but with a lot of kudos attached. He promised that he would support me in the new role.

Not only did it turn out that I was expected to do the new job AND my existing one simultaneously - 2 for the pay of one - but the first time I went to him needing help with one of the new projects, he told me I was weak and had to stop leaning on him, and refused to help me at all.

That was quite enough for me, it still upsets me because that was a great job if he hadn't been such a massive bellend.

MrsFatArse · 05/04/2022 13:17

I had finished ALevels and was working in a pub i had worked in since I was a teenager waitressing. I used to be holiday cover to manage it, absolutley loved it, then we got new landlords who decided my face didn't fit ad they wanted to be in full control and know more than anyone else.

They were fuckibg awful, bullying and belittling me, putying me on a zero hour contract and givibg me random shifts, I was in tears most days. I was 18 and didn't know what to do.

The wife was a bitch, the husband facing a court casecregarding being acvused of rape.

So, Debbie and Paul, you worthless pair of shits, I hope your lives have gone right down the toilet.

Motnight · 05/04/2022 13:00

I did. I grew to hate the job (loved it for 5 years) because my line manager micromanaged me, wouldn't listen to my requests for support and didn't have my back.

It took her 6 months to make me really unhappy. About the only thing that she ever did for me 😬

SAB10 · 05/04/2022 12:56

Yes. It was a really interesting role in a brilliant company that was pretty much one of a kind (especially in the area I had just moved to).

My manager (there were only two of us on the team) refused to give me any training even though she knew that a large part of the role was completely new to me. She would send me into really important meetings with senior colleagues at a moment's notice and without any context, then would delight in giving me feedback that I seemed 'underprepared'. Even worse, she would attend the meetings with me but get me to lead, then repeatedly sigh, pointedly correct me and undermine me in front of everyone.

That job (and that utter bitch) destroyed my confidence and when I finally walked out, three months in, I was practically skipping down the road.

iklboo · 05/04/2022 12:55

Yes - I'd been seconded to another team full time for six months. Boss (new to the team) decided to put me on a performance review and set my end of year as 'failure to comply' because I'd not met my full year working target and that I'd 'return to probation'.

When I argued I hadn't been working in my target team for half the year she said I should have pulled it up in the remaining six months.

I went to the other team boss & HR to ask for a permanent transfer. Even with other boss & HR telling her she was wrong she wouldn't accept it. Head of Section over-ruled her end of year mark for a higher one and told her that I wouldn't be working my notice / handover in her team and would transfer with immediate effect.

She left about three months later. Loads of staff complaints.

Wexone · 05/04/2022 12:53

yep at the time it was horrible. It was near me, very nice team, rest of the factory was lovely too. Good nights out aswell. When i started we had no director of the department, was there nearly 5 years. Had three directors nd three direct managers during that time. I think one year we lost 80 people out 350, 8 of them were senior managers. My last manager was horrific, made me loads of promises turned out lies, moved me forcibly to another department with a person i though was my friend, she turned out to be a bully, brought my team leaders wife into do my job ( she did a terrible job) ,My team leader quit went for her job didn't get it new person external brought in trained him and then he quit too. Came back after a death in the family, he promised me a pay rise - Turned out of months asking he had lied, had a blazing row. Handed my notice in a month later with no job to go too. He was told by many people at time he was loosing his one of his best people, a month later after i handed my notice in ( had to give three months) he announced he was leaving too. By then it was too late for me, had made my mind up. Didnt work for a few months after i left then temped before i got this job and now ma happy. No job is perfect but especially during covid this nobs has been good. My old job was terrible during covid, didn't allow working from home etc so am glad am out of it. Am a lot better in my self mentality and work life balance is good most of time. As people say you dont leave bad jobs you leave bad managers

Eyedropeyeflop · 05/04/2022 12:49

@malificent7

Absolutely. I work very hard for good managers.

Poor ones drain me and my productivity. I simply cannot work under poor management it’s a deal breaker.

malificent7 · 05/04/2022 12:39

I always feel that certain types become bad managers....those who were bullies at school seem to thrive on the power.

That said, some managers are great...the difference is I WANT to do well for good managers.

YNK · 05/04/2022 12:39

The decision was taken from me, but I wish I had.
We had a connection from decades before and I knew she had a very colourful past. Although I maintained total discretion I guess it made me a particular target, although she bullied and manipulated most of the staff with the exception of her 'favourites' over whom she would gush shamelessly.
She put me in dangerous situations a few times and inevitably I was injured and had to retire early with compensation.
In the period leading to my retirement it was clear her senior managers were not supporting her after several other formal complaints were made by staff and her emotional instability led to her taking extended sick leave herself. It was still a shock to learn of her suicide though.

She was promoted above her emotional capabilities which turned out to be a calamity for the staff and a fatal outcome for her.

As I see it, senior managers created a monster, then eliminated it when they couldn't control it, leaving other casualties along the way.

PinkAndViolet · 05/04/2022 12:25

I never loved mine but am now hating it because of this exact scenario. I'm on lunch break now and want to cry at the thought of going back in.

BlossomLake · 05/04/2022 12:25

I'm genuinely concerned that they're right and I'm not performing

OP posts:
jay55 · 05/04/2022 12:23

I did. I was crying in the shower in the morning before work.
It just couldn't go on.

It worked out in the end, took a sideways move for three years got my confidence back, added new skills and now I earn heaps more and don't take any shit.

Eyedropeyeflop · 05/04/2022 12:03

Oh absolutely and more than once.

I leave because of bad managers not bad jobs.

PeeAche2 · 05/04/2022 11:58

People mostly leave jobs because of bad management.

If you've told yourself you've left because of pay that's bad management.
If it's because of company culture... that's bad management.
If it's because of a poor work life balance... bad management.

Someone once told me that people don't leave jobs, they leave managers. And I think that with obvious exceptions (leaving because you want to become a SAHP, you're relocating, you're sick etc) it's almost always true.

Sorry your manager is such a tool. You deserve better!xxx

TitoMojito · 05/04/2022 11:57

@CoralPaperweight

Yes many times. You need to leave before you believe you are crap at everything and you have no confidence to get a new job. A fair proportion of managers spend their time slagging off everyone else to make themselves look great
Agree^ it's been over a year for me and I still think I'm at risk of getting sacked for being useless all because of one boss who made me feel like the most pathetic person ever
TitoMojito · 05/04/2022 11:56

Yes. Enjoyed my work but my boss was an egomaniac and all around unhinged. I held on as long as I could but it was hell and I was miserable.

ZeroFsKarma · 05/04/2022 11:53

I have. I worked at a University and left without a job because I was so mentally done I couldn't possibly sit in an interview and speak positively about the job. I eventually got a part time job 5 months later but now am not fit to work due to health - I believe all my health problems were triggered by the stress of what happened in the job I left. I took out a grievance which made things 100% worse as then I had to deal with my manager's incompetent manager and HR who were useless. It went from bullying to mobbing. No one cared, they just piled on. Some days I regret it and wish I had just gone on sick leave then left, other days I wish I had fought even harder. It was 6 years ago and I'm still not over it. I was offered a small pay out (3 months wages tax free) but refused it as I had to sign a gagging order and there was no way they were going to prevent me from talking about my experience. I remember going to the job centre for a meeting about my CV and telling the woman a few minor details and she told me the story deserved to be on panorama or dispatches! I had told her about 5% of it but felt so validated for the first time since it had all started.

OP do everything you can to take care of yourself while you figure out what you are going to do.

Shopboughtmeatballs · 05/04/2022 11:44

Yes. Best job I ever had with the best prospects. I know this sounds big headed, but truthfully, I did it so well 😕, it still makes me sad...
My, manager was having an affair with her/our 'big' boss, (only 5 people in dept'). Their had been financial mismanagement and extraordinary levels of corruption as well as breath-taking laziness on her part and abuse of her position over me. Once she knew I knew where the bodies were buried, and he knew I knew I knew too, they did their absolute best to slander me and manage me out. For about a year it made me physically sick- even my kids were begging me to leave. I managed to get a position sideways in the wider institution, not a good fit, but somewhere to go, and left. They even approached my new boss to say he shouldn't employ me and when that didn't work, the big, BIG boss to try and bar me from even coming on site. That didn't work either, because, as I knew, I had done. nothing. wrong.
It was excruciating and tbh, I hung on for a couple of years but it truly crushed me. I've never really recovered.

CoralPaperweight · 05/04/2022 11:40

Yes many times. You need to leave before you believe you are crap at everything and you have no confidence to get a new job. A fair proportion of managers spend their time slagging off everyone else to make themselves look great

Fraaahnces · 05/04/2022 11:40

There is a great book available on Amazon called “The Pocket Psychopath.” It’s tiny, and a really informative read that will help crystallize your intention. It makes you decide if it’s worth the battle or not.

confuzzzzzled · 05/04/2022 11:36

I’m in this position at the moment. I feel my manager picks on me. She’s constantly correcting me on things the rest of the team get away with, other team members are often congratulated for things and I’m never. It doesn’t really constitute as bullying per se but it’s very very obvious she doesn’t like me, even though I know I’m good at my job. I’m going to have to leave because it’s affecting my mental health so badly, sometimes she makes me feel like a schoolchild with the way I’m talked down to. Because I’m in the civil service I can quite easily move to another team though so it shouldn’t feel like a massive upheaval but I find the whole recruitment process very overwhelming and have been putting it off for months now.

Keladrythesaviour · 05/04/2022 11:18

Yep. He was an absolute bully but other people had made complaints and had nothing back in response / actually out themselves in the firing line so it became clear that the company approved of his methods and ethos and so I decided it was no longer tenable to work there.

Frenziedandfurious · 05/04/2022 11:10

Yes have done it twice. Last role the she was an ok person I think but just a nightmare at managing people really patronising and condescending. Also due to her inexperience she resorted to micromanagement. I think as a manager as much as you have a style you have to adapt and flex it according to the situation/person. Certain situations require a level of autocracy and others more collaborative decision making. I do think she was doing the bidding of the manager above her who was a bitch which is why although I felt sorry for her I didn't dislike her.

I had one manager who was great, however the actual job was awful. We both left as the working conditions were intolerable.