Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is a bit of a disconnect on Mumsnet nowadays between posters' experience of being a parent and that of being a child!

54 replies

Comeoninandclosethedoor · 04/04/2022 16:09

As someone who is coming to the end of my hands-on parenting days, and someone who has been on Mumsnet a lot over the years, I have noticed this of late.

It's not my intention to highlight or criticise any particular thread or poster and I admit to having had quite a few difficult years parenting teens myself, so I am certainly not claiming to be mother of the year myself, but this is something that seems to crop up a lot atm.

There are currently a lot of threads saying - understandably - how difficult, relentless, boring and frustrating it can be to be a mother sometimes (it is usually mothers posting) on one side of the boards, while at the same time, there are so many people (usually women) posting about how awful their parents are , particularly their mothers, on the other. How their mothers never cared enough, did enough, were too narcissistic, too selfish when they were DC, and how they don't help out enough with their GC now?

Disclaimer: Obviously I am not talking about neglectful or abusive mothers (and fathers) here who deserve every bit of negative criticism and condemnation they receive

But AIBU to suggest that we can try and join the dots a bit here? That mothers are often doing their best in very difficult circumstances, that many find parenting hard, and that parenting nowadays isn't easy, especially when so much is expected of women? That we could all cut one another some slack and be a bit more understanding of mothers, who are given a very hard time on here?

OP posts:
Lunar27 · 04/04/2022 16:28

I think there's a difference between the trials and tribulations of parenting and people's personalities, that have negative impacts on their children.

For insurance, my MIL is controlling, argumentative and never praises my wife for anything she's done or achieved. But wants everything back in return. She's been like this since my wife was a child.

Unpleasant people are usually unpleasant irrespective of whether they have kids. My mum was similar.

All we can do is not to recycle the shitty personality traits and minimise the BS that gets passed down. I'm sure it'll never quite be enough but I want my kids to be able to talk about us in more positive terms than how we talk about our parents.

BrieAndChilli · 04/04/2022 16:16

The problem is (and this happens with everything) is that we judge the past by todays standards.
Now obviously we can look at the past and realise that the way things were done were awful or unsafe, but we have the benefit of time and studies and the fact that society has moved on so like you said bar actual abuse and neglect a lot of things like leaving kids in car while you went to the shop or smoking in the house or letting kids go out to play out of sight for the day etc were just the way tings were back then. parenting advice changes, we no longer leave babies in prams outsite shops or the front door, that seems shocking now but years ago it was what everyone did. Years and years ago 11 year olds worked down the mines etc etc.

JenniferBarkley · 04/04/2022 16:16

YANBU at all. I've been on here donkeys but have only really realised in the past year or two how hard MN is on mothers. It's not a particularly supportive place for women who are struggling.

Mumoblue · 04/04/2022 16:13

I couldn’t really compare this to my own experience of being a child, as my parents definitely came under things covered in your disclaimer.

I found it personally helpful when going through therapy to examine their side of things and what they might have been struggling with, meanwhile understanding that their struggles did not excuse their behaviour.

I think it’s the same for anybody though. We can try and understand our parents, all the while knowing that they were adults with the responsibility of raising us- and as parents we can struggle with things and do our best with the knowledge that if our children feel that we failed them, they aren’t obligated to forgive us.

Certainly something to think on.