Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is a bit of a disconnect on Mumsnet nowadays between posters' experience of being a parent and that of being a child!

54 replies

Comeoninandclosethedoor · 04/04/2022 16:09

As someone who is coming to the end of my hands-on parenting days, and someone who has been on Mumsnet a lot over the years, I have noticed this of late.

It's not my intention to highlight or criticise any particular thread or poster and I admit to having had quite a few difficult years parenting teens myself, so I am certainly not claiming to be mother of the year myself, but this is something that seems to crop up a lot atm.

There are currently a lot of threads saying - understandably - how difficult, relentless, boring and frustrating it can be to be a mother sometimes (it is usually mothers posting) on one side of the boards, while at the same time, there are so many people (usually women) posting about how awful their parents are , particularly their mothers, on the other. How their mothers never cared enough, did enough, were too narcissistic, too selfish when they were DC, and how they don't help out enough with their GC now?

Disclaimer: Obviously I am not talking about neglectful or abusive mothers (and fathers) here who deserve every bit of negative criticism and condemnation they receive

But AIBU to suggest that we can try and join the dots a bit here? That mothers are often doing their best in very difficult circumstances, that many find parenting hard, and that parenting nowadays isn't easy, especially when so much is expected of women? That we could all cut one another some slack and be a bit more understanding of mothers, who are given a very hard time on here?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Comeoninandclosethedoor · 07/04/2022 13:08

And yes - sorry this was the main point - I so agree that "fathers seem to get away with murder. The bar on what constitutes a good father is incredibly low".

There have been some improvements but men , even fifty years on , still largely managed to side step blame! Unless they have been completely absent of course.

OP posts:
Comeoninandclosethedoor · 07/04/2022 13:02

@CatsArePeople

Hmm, we’ve just been through two years when the needs and well-being of children were completely disregarded, in a way they certainly never were for my generation, so I’m going to disagree with this very strongly.

I don't know which generation we're talking about. My both parents worked very demanding jobs so we could have a decent standard of living, and life was generally harder. They made sure we were safe, fed healthy, and doing well in school. Yes, they were not to invested into emotional well-being and I do have plenty of resentments, as it was borderline abuse at times. However, life was never properly hard for me.
Nowadays it seems like the pendulum has swung, and parents are supposed to be best mates, organize playdates, micromanage friendships, organize family time according to what the child wants, etc. And children seem to be less happy (then blame it on social media).

I'm not much help in this argument because I was a child of the sixties and seventies and I have teens of my own, so I can see both sides.

I think it's virtually impossible for my teens to understand what it was like growing up in the 60s and 70s with parents who were children during the war. The lack of Internet. The lack of information.
The level of poverty. The lack of money and indeed lack of shops and poor consumer choice as compared with now. The poor public infrastructure. The lack of good nutrition. Lack of central heating. The lack of material comforts. The strikes. (I grew up in the Midlands and it was grim.)

You can get a sense of it if you watch Netflix documentaries about the Yorkshire Ripper and Jimmy Savile. Cheery eh?

And children were raised very differently. It wasn't quite "be seen and not heard" but more "out of sight, out of mind".

It's all so different now that there isn't much point in even trying to explain to my dc but I do often find myself thinking "if only you knew how lucky you are".

At the same my teens and young adults have really suffered in the pandemic. And their experience is very much rooted in the here and now. Yes they have us to give them a broader perspective but if you say "compared to my day this isn't half bad" you also have to be careful not to be dismissive of their genuine upset and frustration. One of mine missed out on a lot of schooling. Important exams were disrupted. There was a lot of stress and uncertainty. Her school did not handle the pandemic well at all. Both missed out on very important milestone events and trips that were important to them. And both were confined to barracks when they should have been making exploratory forays outside of the home and gaining autonomy amd independence. And of course the academic and external pressures on them is huge.

In some ways, life without the Internet was freer and more fulfilling. And the world was more optimistic in our youth.

Swings and roundabouts! Smile

OP posts:
CatsArePeople · 07/04/2022 08:08

Hmm, we’ve just been through two years when the needs and well-being of children were completely disregarded, in a way they certainly never were for my generation, so I’m going to disagree with this very strongly.

I don't know which generation we're talking about. My both parents worked very demanding jobs so we could have a decent standard of living, and life was generally harder. They made sure we were safe, fed healthy, and doing well in school. Yes, they were not to invested into emotional well-being and I do have plenty of resentments, as it was borderline abuse at times. However, life was never properly hard for me.
Nowadays it seems like the pendulum has swung, and parents are supposed to be best mates, organize playdates, micromanage friendships, organize family time according to what the child wants, etc. And children seem to be less happy (then blame it on social media).

JohannSebastianBach · 07/04/2022 07:30

I think a lot of people like to blame their mothers for the way they are because its much easier and more comforting than examining your own behaviour and actions. This pretty much sums up my sister.

Yet fathers seem to get away with murder. The bar on what constitutes a good father is incredibly low.

My mum was difficult at times, often snappy and grumpy but when I looked back I have realised that my dad worked away a lot (by choice) and left her to deal with everything. He then came home like Disney dad. No wonder my mum was frustrated. My dad is a lovely man but was fairly useless in a lot of ways, yet my sister focuses on my mother's shortcomings.

The birds have come home to roost now though as my niece is very critical of my sister's parenting.

Comeoninandclosethedoor · 07/04/2022 00:52

No you are not derailing Rinatinabina. That's a very informative point that DC in abusive homes tend to blame themselves rather than their parents.

OP posts:
Darbs76 · 06/04/2022 22:53

Since I’ve learned to realise I was judging my mums mental health troubles on todays standards I’ve learned to let it go. If she had the same problem today she would have received so much more help, and I know she sought help for it, and didn’t really receive much.

Rinatinabina · 06/04/2022 22:48

Yeah maybe I mean that children always want their parents love and approval even while angry at them for something.

I think for children who are brought up by loving (if flawed) parents it’s often “safer” to moan at your parents than for children brought up in abusive ones. Children brought up in abusive homes often believe that there is something wrong with them not their parents until they get older. They may act out etc but always with fear. You see it again and agin, so many people seem to suffer from FOG. Those people invest a lot in placating horrible parents. Perhaps its a good thing if your kids aren’t as careful around you iyswim

Sorry I’m derailing, I know you said this wasn’t about abuse.

But yes I totally expect my DD will have a list of complaints when she’s older and I’m sure I’ll deserve some of them at the very least!

Obelisk · 06/04/2022 22:39

Now it seems the opposite extreme - at any cost, do not upset the kids

Hmm, we’ve just been through two years when the needs and well-being of children were completely disregarded, in a way they certainly never were for my generation, so I’m going to disagree with this very strongly.

CatsArePeople · 06/04/2022 22:30

The previous generations of parents weren't as kind to their children as we are now. They often saw them as not really human (speaking from experience w my own parents). Parents consider their children's feelings now don't they?

I thought so when I was younger. But i grew to realize that back in the day parents had much more pressing matters than kids feelings. Also kids learned to cope with the world. Now it seems the opposite extreme - at any cost, do not upset the kids. And as a result, kids think life is not worth living over most insignificant things.

GeidiPrimes · 06/04/2022 11:51

The previous generations of parents weren't as kind to their children as we are now. They often saw them as not really human (speaking from experience w my own parents). Parents consider their children's feelings now don't they?

Comeoninandclosethedoor · 06/04/2022 11:35

I forgot to add that there seems to be an on-line ATM among teens and young adults which encourages them to be dissatisfied with many aspects of their life: their clothes and accommodation have to be Instagram-friendly, as do their fitness regimes and healthy diets - just "normal" and " good enough" isn't acceptable any more - and I think us parents are perhaps expected to live up to the same perfectionist standards too.

Just scroll through You tube topics that teens and young adults look at and you will see all of it:
-Is my parent a narcissist?

  • Six signs your parent is a narcissist!
  • Narcissism in a parent; the signs you need to know
  • How to think about your narcissist parent!
And so on ...

I have no idea who is generating this type of content - people are making money out of it I assume - but when I was seventeen I was more interested in the psyches of my friends than of my parents.

Again, I am not talking about concrete abuse here and if a child was brought up by a true narcissist then they would have legitimate grounds for complaint.

I know that teens and young adults are understandably finding today's world hard to negotiate, especially post-pandemic, when they have had an utterly crap time, but there definitely seems to be a need to cast around and blame others, for what is perhaps mainly inner dissatisfaction?

OP posts:
Comeoninandclosethedoor · 06/04/2022 11:18

@HardbackWriter

I absolutely agree, and have said this on here before. If you post saying that you lost it and screamed at your three year old you'll be told that you're human, that they won't remember, that you're still an amazing mum. If you say you remember your own mum screaming at you when you were three then you were abused and she was probably a narcissist that you should go NC with.

I also agree with the poster who says that a lot of people are going to be very surprised when their children find their own parenting wanting. I think there's a really dangerous streak - encouraged particularly by attachment parenting as a movement, but it's now also more widespread - of people thinking that we now 'get it right' with our children emotionally, unlike our own parents, and particularly that if you are martyrish enough when they're tiny that you'll be rewarded with perfectly emotionally healthy and flourishing adults. I think it's going to lead to both a lot of disappointed parents and, worse, a lot of parents who just won't believe that their children are normal, flawed human beings. I think 'you can't be depressed, we co-slept' will be the new 'but we took you to stately homes'.

Sorry for delay in coming back to this!

V. Interesting post Hardbackwriter

I'm afraid I agree that there are going to be some disappointed parents out there in the future who currently feel they are doing it all right. Partly because it's nature's design that children often find fault with their parents, as a catalyst for launching themselves off in to the world. And partly because the very focused and hands on parenting prevalent ATM seems to have contributed in part to DC who are far more anxious than they used to be. But that's for a different thread!

givethatbabyaname a classic! Grin

And I couldn't agree more about the unrealistic pressure on parents ATM, and it doesn't shock me at all that some DC are angry with their parents for not setting enough boundaries. I will probably be flamed for saying this but I saw some frankly dangerous parenting this weekend at an agricultural show caused by parents not being prepared to step in and deliver a firm "no".

Parents, of course, aren't always right by any means and I agree that this is a complex subject!

A bit of a trivial example but I confess to having experienced this with older teens and young adults myself who, when they were younger, were ferried about endlessly to extra-curricular activities but it took a lot of patience and many hours of cajoling, stress over lateness, general complaints and grumpiness to get them there week after week ( when in some cases they had begged me to to attend in the first place). And now they are older, some of them complain to me that I didn't make them carry on! Hmm

But that's more about personality responsibility I think which also ties in to this subject. We do live in a society I think where not enough people, both parents and young adults alike, do not take enough responsibility for their own actions, or lack of them!

Rinatinabina that's an interesting perspective. I tend to disagree that DC are very forgiving of their parents, but maybe that's because of the stage of parenting my friends and I are at ATM. Give it twenty years and things may be different! Smile. And yes, good point about the venting!

OP posts:
Ducksurprise · 04/04/2022 22:30

See also favourite child/golden child.

Fairislefandango · 04/04/2022 22:28

It's so difficult to generalise about this, because everyone is different, but your point doesn't chime with my experience. I'm 50 and had (still have!) nice, pretty well-balanced, good-natured parents. The dodgy/semi-neglectful stuff you hear aboit what parenting was like in the 70s and 80s didn't happen to me.

I don't think there's a huge difference in how I was parented compared with how I parent my dc (now teens). I haven't found parenting especially hard, and I don't think my parents did either. The one thing I could reproach them for is that they were smokers, but it was the norm then, and they did eventually give up.

I absolutely agree, and have said this on here before. If you post saying that you lost it and screamed at your three year old you'll be told that you're human, that they won't remember, that you're still an amazing mum. If you say you remember your own mum screaming at you when you were three then you were abused and she was probably a narcissist that you should go NC with.

But surely that has a lot to do with the perspective of being one step further removed from the person whose behaviour you're judging. You tend to be kind/lenient/understanding to the poster you're talking to. It's much easier and less confrontational to criticise a third party (e.g. the poster's mother) who you're not communicating with.

FarDownTheRiver · 04/04/2022 22:06

@Toloveandtowork

We're just not biologically or psychologically built to cope with living in small family units. Children can be so annoying and demanding that this needs to be spread out more among a tribe. Being a mother in this situation can destroy you. It carries on down the generations, shame being one of the social weapons to keep us quiet and inline with unrealistic, harsh and isolating expectations.
But with mandatory schooling, and sometimes free nursery hours etc that is a lot of time children spend away from their parents. Realistically what else should society be doing to ease the load?
Toloveandtowork · 04/04/2022 21:53

We're just not biologically or psychologically built to cope with living in small family units. Children can be so annoying and demanding that this needs to be spread out more among a tribe. Being a mother in this situation can destroy you. It carries on down the generations, shame being one of the social weapons to keep us quiet and inline with unrealistic, harsh and isolating expectations.

givethatbabyaname · 04/04/2022 21:44

This Be The Verse
BY PHILIP LARKIN

They fuck you up, your mum and dad.

They may not mean to, but they do.

They fill you with the faults they had
And add some extra, just for you.

But they were fucked up in their turn
By fools in old-style hats and coats,

Who half the time were soppy-stern
And half at one another’s throats.

Man hands on misery to man.
It deepens like a coastal shelf.
Get out as early as you can,
And don’t have any kids yourself.

———————————-

I don’t agree with the misery in the last verse, but you can’t deny the truth or logic 🤷‍♀️

TwoPenguins · 04/04/2022 21:41

@Cirelle

But do you not think that assuming you are a mum to young children now your own may look back on things you do now that are currently completely normal and socially acceptable, e.g. spending your money on Starbucks/driving a car/eating meat that in say twenty years time will seem unbelievable that you didn't have the foresight to understand that this was selfish. No because I make sure my child is provided for first before I do anything for myself. My mother said I couldn’t learn to play the violin because she wanted to use that money to smoke cigarettes. She put herself ahead of her child. I don’t do that.
You are missing my point (and thus kind of making my point). You are judging both your own and your mum's parenting based on current acceptable norms and values. What I was suggesting by picking a few things that have the potential for attitudes and perceptions of acceptability to change massively over the next few days. To the point that your own kids may look back and think: 'I would NEVER do sth like that. Look how it has shaped my life/the world we live in! How did she not realise how utterly not ok this is! I would never do sth like that to MY kids'.... Just like your mum at the time probably thought she was doing her best for you and cigarettes perhaps not being the best investment likely not remotely crossing her mind. But she was not doing XY horrific thing her own mother didn't have the foresight to know was absolutely NOT ok'... ad infinitum
Obelisk · 04/04/2022 21:30

@HardbackWriter Excellent post- I completely agree.

HardbackWriter · 04/04/2022 21:17

I absolutely agree, and have said this on here before. If you post saying that you lost it and screamed at your three year old you'll be told that you're human, that they won't remember, that you're still an amazing mum. If you say you remember your own mum screaming at you when you were three then you were abused and she was probably a narcissist that you should go NC with.

I also agree with the poster who says that a lot of people are going to be very surprised when their children find their own parenting wanting. I think there's a really dangerous streak - encouraged particularly by attachment parenting as a movement, but it's now also more widespread - of people thinking that we now 'get it right' with our children emotionally, unlike our own parents, and particularly that if you are martyrish enough when they're tiny that you'll be rewarded with perfectly emotionally healthy and flourishing adults. I think it's going to lead to both a lot of disappointed parents and, worse, a lot of parents who just won't believe that their children are normal, flawed human beings. I think 'you can't be depressed, we co-slept' will be the new 'but we took you to stately homes'.

Comeoninandclosethedoor · 04/04/2022 21:07

Some fascinating posts on here! Thank you to everyone who has responded and shared their insights. Unfortunately, I have to go to bed as I have a very early start tomorrow, but will catch up asap thereafter.

OP posts:
MichaelAndEagle · 04/04/2022 20:50

In turn, I think many of today's parents of young children will also find that many of their children grow into adults who are disappointed in their parenting, and yet, no one wants to accept that it will also happen to them, that they will also be condemned for their parenting choices, by their own children, until it does happen.

I think this is bang on.

AtomicBlondeRose · 04/04/2022 20:44

“If you were in their position” that should read

AtomicBlondeRose · 04/04/2022 20:44

One of the most useful things I’ve ever read - I think it’s from Philippa Perry - is “if you were in their positing, you’d do the same thing”. So you don’t think you’d act like your mother did, but if you were her, with her life and experiences and knowledge, you would. We’re all the product of our lives and those lives affect us, and it’s easy to sit back years later or miles away and say “well, I wouldn’t do that…” but it’s not true! You would do that. You’d think the same and act the same because you would have lived the same way to that point.

Cirelle · 04/04/2022 20:37

But do you not think that assuming you are a mum to young children now your own may look back on things you do now that are currently completely normal and socially acceptable, e.g. spending your money on Starbucks/driving a car/eating meat that in say twenty years time will seem unbelievable that you didn't have the foresight to understand that this was selfish.
No because I make sure my child is provided for first before I do anything for myself. My mother said I couldn’t learn to play the violin because she wanted to use that money to smoke cigarettes. She put herself ahead of her child. I don’t do that.