Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers- be honest please - do you judge or make assumptions?

466 replies

BlingLoving · 04/04/2022 10:38

And if so, how often are you right?

eg when the kid turns up on day one with crazy curls, no hair tie (especially boys) do you immediately think, like I do, "oh no, this family is going to be a bit precious."

Or if the kid's clothes are consistently stained etc, do you chalk that up to parents having limited cash and taking view that school uniform is to be worn (my approach) or do you think they're just careless?

What about the ones who struggle to spend the time doing homework with their DC? Do you think they're just bad parents or are you sympathetic?

OP posts:
yellowsuninthesky · 04/04/2022 17:14

[quote Letmethinkidontknow]@Anorthernlass
Unfortunately I agree. I observed that the colleagues with children usually have more perspective and understanding than those who are child free by choice.[/quote]
That's interesting because I often felt the ones with kids were more judgey and I wondered how their kids always managed to be so perfect. A lot of the younger teachers have been more realistic in their expectations in my experience. But it depends, there are the ones that buck the trend - his Y1 teacher had kids and was amazing. Had the kids where she wanted them and seemed to be one of those teachers who could quell any thoughts of dissent by a look.

cansu · 04/04/2022 17:14

Context is important.
Dirty clothes consistently - yes I worry about the child. Stains on otherwise clean clothes - no. Clothes that are a bit worn out or on the small side - no. Kids grow out of stuff and not everyone can afford to replace stuff all the time. Homework it depends again on context. Some parents have too much on to be doing much at home. I think that when kids are young and need to be reading that is important.

FancyAnOlive · 04/04/2022 17:14

I'm a teacher and I don't judge on the basis of hair etc - that's awful. I keep an eye out for signs of neglect or other safeguarding issues, obviously, as that's part of my job but judging pupils and their parents on the basis of hair/class/ethnicity is revolting and completely goes against any kind of equality, fairness or inclusion. I also never judge on the basis of behaviour as have two children with SEND myself and know how often it happens that people make assumptions and judge your parenting when its neurodiversity that is the issue.

Tidy2018 · 04/04/2022 17:11

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Duracellbunnywannabe · 04/04/2022 17:05

@BlingLoving

I’m sure you know but lots of parents in this situation have a pencil case at home for homework and a school one which never leaves their bag outside of the classroom.

NO, I did not know that and frankly, that's GENIUS. As it's never come up because at primary everything is provided, I hadn't even thought of that. But it's a really good idea. Thank you. DS, bless him, told me that he thinks he'll just carry ALL his books for the school day as he knows he's going to struggle with getting Book A and Book B for periods 1 and 2 and then book C and D for Periods 3 and 4 after break etc.

I’m trying to think of other things I used to recommend, I left a while ago so I can’t remember everything
  • multiple time tables, in their pocket, planner, fridge door, spares. Colour code the same colour as class book.
  • put loose homework sheets straight into hmk folder
  • pile of spare stationery at home
  • get into a set routine of sorting out bag the night before. Create a visual checklist.

At GCSE stage get GCP revision guide for each subject (check exam board) for when they start their course.

thegreylady · 04/04/2022 17:02

I was a teacher for 40 years and judged rudeness and bullying but not appearance. I have never seen him, do not know his name I judge the boy who asked hhis teacher,”Who do you think you are talking to?” when she asked him to stop sending paper aeroplanes across the room during an exam. She dealt with it by getting SM to remove him. I judge parents who are quick to criticise teachers when their child refuses to do homework, is insolent and idle in school yet mummy and daddy think they deserve A* for everything.
I loved my job but couldn’t recommend teaching to anyone these days.

BlingLoving · 04/04/2022 16:59

Her daughter has curly hair and likes to wear it down. She wants to know if she'll be judged if she sends her in like that.

Nope, keeping DD's hair clean and vaguely knot-free is a massive chore for me. People can judge me on how successfully i do that all they like. But her hair is never in her eyes for school. So perhaps I'm less sympathetic to others because I go through such hell to stick with the very limited guidelines our school provides (ie no hair in eyes). But mostly, I stand by my point - there's a certain type of long hair, often on boys, that is a clear indicator the parents are going to be the type who believe their little darling is always 100% perfect and can and should do whatever he likes.

OP posts:
DogsAndGin · 04/04/2022 16:55

I am a primary school teacher.
Tbh I have no idea what you’re referencing with ‘crazy curls’ - I’ve never judged anyone for having curly hair, or not having a hair tie.

Stained clothes because they’ve just spilt their lunch on themselves is one thing, but smelly, unwashed children are a big issue - we have to call home and tell the parents their children need a wash. It’s neglect - so we have to deal with it as a safeguarding concern.

I am not sympathetic to parents who don't make time to help their children, no. Again, it’s neglect. I can’t stand parents who think it’s acceptable to never talk to their kids. I am referring to the parents who send their kids to their rooms with an iPad every night, or even allow the kids to eat in their room! I’ve got children whose parents shut themselves away in their own bedroom, door locked, to play on the PlayStation undisturbed! It’s disgraceful parenting and I feel very sorry for children who get no attention at home. It’s a huge set back for them - teachers can only do so much. The vast majority of a a young child’s learning comes from home.

Orangutanteddy · 04/04/2022 16:55

I don't judge kids. I do judge parents who swear and shout at teachers at ptm. And then they have the nerve to ask you to ring them a few months later? Nah, you'll get a professional, polite email as it's in the remit of my job but I'll never be seeking out verbal contact with you again.

Fairislefandango · 04/04/2022 16:52

My year 1 COULD read Harry Potter and tell you everything that happened in those books. And read fluently with expression. Some kids can do these things and it’s equally as frustrating as a parent when you’re not listened to and told you’re being precious…

Mine too. I didn't let her read beyond no.4 until she was a couple of years older though. Starting in yr1 she talked about the books all the time, and it was clear from her conversations that she wasn't 'just decoding'.

I was the same at her age apparently. My reception primary teacher refused to believe my mother when she said I could read, and refused to move me up to harder reading books. I'm not teacher-bashing btw - I am a teacher and I know parents can sometimes be difficult.

Skelligsfeathers · 04/04/2022 16:46

@BorsetshireBanality

My DD’s reception teacher was very judgemental. She was moving up to be a year 1 teacher and had kept all the middle class boys in her new class and imported in the middle-class girls while the lower socio-ecomomic group children were put in the other year 1 classes. Luckily DD’s new Y1 teacher was lovely and kind as well as a brilliant teacher and had a really good calming influence on the children. If she was judging the patents she hid it very well, unlike the reception teacher. No very naughty, ethnic, or outside of school-gate—parent clique children left languishing to the last weeks of summer term to get their turn to have the class bear or not get a star of the week either.
Do you honestly think that teachers have ANY say or influence on their classes? That teacher did not CHOOSE who she had in her class! The headteacher makes those decisions and the teacher just lumps it!

I can't believe the things that people think about schools.

Mumofsend · 04/04/2022 16:44

@FairyCakeWings

The only thing I would judge parents on is reading, and that can only be done after at least a term of knowing them.

The ones who never read with their children are doing their children a huge disservice and are actively preventing their children from achieving their potential across the whole curriculum. I have little sympathy with the parents who complain that their children won’t read at home because it’s usually their fault that they don’t like reading at home. If it had been put in place as an expectation at the start of reception and presented as something rewarding then it wouldn’t be an issue.

The parents who insist that their Y1 child has read Harry Potter are equally as bad. They seem to think that decoding is the only thing that matters and it’s irrelevant if the child hasn’t understood or retained any of it.

My children have been raised from the earliest days to love stories.

DD is dyslexic and it wasn't until we could ditch phonics and switch to sight words she got over her fear of books. In December (Y2) she was at a reception level for reading/phonics. Now, at the end of March she was at ARE because following the phonics screen we finally were OK to embrace whole word reading. She absolutely categorically read to me at home. I kept reading to her and made sure she loved listening to and discussing stories but her actually reading them? Whole other ballgame.

Children who see themselves as not as good as others in their class tend to be more resistant. Other children are very much school is school, home is home.

Its frustrating knowing you are being judged when it isn't always the parents laziness

baffledcoconut · 04/04/2022 16:43

@FairyCakeWings

My year 1 COULD read Harry Potter and tell you everything that happened in those books. And read fluently with expression. Some kids can do these things and it’s equally as frustrating as a parent when you’re not listened to and told you’re being precious…

BlueOverYellow · 04/04/2022 16:42

@ToughLoveLDN

This is so interesting to read.

For the teachers, if you notice something with a child in their behaviour that could be a sign of something they may need some help with at what point do you contact the parents? Or is there like a special channel that you have to go through?

Or say for example if the child coming in is smelly or dirty etc and this is noticed on a regular basis, how is this kind of thing handled?

It's logged as a neglect concern. If it happens frequently, it will be followed up on by safeguarding team.
Bootothegoose · 04/04/2022 16:37

[quote DarcyBlue]@BlingLoving Why do you have a fixation about children with curls? Reads as really odd. I do judge that.[/quote]
Her daughter has curly hair and likes to wear it down. She wants to know if she'll be judged if she sends her in like that.

DarcyBlue · 04/04/2022 16:34

@BlingLoving Why do you have a fixation about children with curls? Reads as really odd. I do judge that.

FairyCakeWings · 04/04/2022 16:32

The only thing I would judge parents on is reading, and that can only be done after at least a term of knowing them.

The ones who never read with their children are doing their children a huge disservice and are actively preventing their children from achieving their potential across the whole curriculum. I have little sympathy with the parents who complain that their children won’t read at home because it’s usually their fault that they don’t like reading at home. If it had been put in place as an expectation at the start of reception and presented as something rewarding then it wouldn’t be an issue.

The parents who insist that their Y1 child has read Harry Potter are equally as bad. They seem to think that decoding is the only thing that matters and it’s irrelevant if the child hasn’t understood or retained any of it.

username78383733333 · 04/04/2022 16:20

Stupid to judge a parent on homework. My DC with Sen has always refused to do homework, it's very rare she'll do it. The school do get annoyed but it's not because I can't be bothered i spend a hour with her each week trying to make her do it even follow with punishments.

That said no teacher should be judging on stained clothes right now, parents don't have a money tree!

Bootothegoose · 04/04/2022 16:17

@Kennykenkencat

That hit me right in the feels. I was very similar to your son as a child, boundless energy, looked like I'd been dragged through a hedge, covered in stains, scruffy etc and as an adult I was diagnosed with varying forms of Autism and Dyspraxia.

I was always tarnished as lazy and a bit feral. So happy your son got the diagnosis and support he needed.

ldontWanna · 04/04/2022 16:16

I judge..

Neglect
Abuse
Disinterest
Preciousness/refusal to accept there is a problem (be that academical,SEN, behavioural etc)

Otherwise I take the kids and the parents as they come. It seems to work. I manage to build trust,bonds and good relationships even when it's not exactly straight forward.

Bootothegoose · 04/04/2022 16:14

They're bound to judge they're human, however whether this judgement influences their job is a mark of the person and their capacity.

My sister is a wonderful teacher and has always taught in extremely deprived areas. She has come home will an array of stories and has often judged the parents, especially where social services are involved however this has never influenced her opinion of the children.

She has been physically assaulted innumerable times by children at a third of her height at 4 years old to boys who are taller than her at 11 and has had a number of stand offs with the parents when police have had to be called. She has packed lunches for kids who go without. If she knows kits won't get washed she'll bring them home so the children don't miss out. She brings home half a dozen swimming bags weekly and always has a boot full of dirty PE kits over the holidays or if it's been particularly muddy. She has a team of staff who do the same. During lockdown we would ring one another during our hour's exercise and often I'd speak to her and she would say she hadn't slept because she was up worrying about certain class members.

Teachers break their backs but there are also rotten apples who are just not suitable for the role. We all judge and it's what we do with that judgement that really is a mark of the person.

TracyMosby · 04/04/2022 16:12

Then we have others who seem to not be very interested in their child's well-being. Things like not taking library books from the bag the whole week, never taking artwork out of their bags so it's still in there the next day. I understand that things get missed (I've done the same) but when it's every day, you start to wonder

My children have books at home they are reading. Im not going to also add a school reading book and a random library book they took out as someone LSA’s CPD target to give children library experience. We visit actual libraries.

And the school sends home rubbish for us to bin rather than art work so you can keep it.

Mariposista · 04/04/2022 16:09

@Anorthernlass

We moved from Asia and my DS teacher said "yeah right" after he told her he'd ridden an elephant (in front of his classmates). Set the stage for a perfect year of primary (not). Also, made similar gagging noises when he was telling the kids about how delicious dim sum is. Kids from overseas get judged as though there is an assumption that because (British) parents dared choose to live abroad that they look down on UK. That is not the case, but we get judged. All. The. Time. I also lived abroad as a kid and had the same experiences.
Oh that’s a real shame. I’d be going out of my way to include all those fascinating experiences into class time/show and tell etc. Kids who have had life experience need to be celebrated!
grapewines · 04/04/2022 16:07

One little lad was in grey sleeves (white shirt), constantly filthy, so I organised spare shirts and to wash his uniform and dry it while he had PE so it wasn’t obvious.

That's so kind, @cherrysoup. I'm a bit emotional today anyway, but this touched me.

Fritilleries · 04/04/2022 16:02

@Goodyetalso

It’s impossible not to make judgements especially as teachers always have to be alert to any signs of potential problems, but the judgements I automatically make aren’t necessarily the ones you’d assume that someone would make. If a child is often late and scruffy, I would automatically assume that the parent(s) have poor organisational skills. I would bear the lateness and scruffiness in mind and when interacting with the parents and chatting with the child throughout the school day you can often tell if this is the reason or if it’s something more concerning or that needs actioning. It’s not necessarily a red flag, more a small marker to check a bit further to see if our initial judgement is correct.

I’ve met loads of parents as a teacher and really liked the vast majority of them no matter what their circumstances were and what problems they had. The ones that persistently wind me up are a)” the ones who don’t listen to their child read and b) the over the top try hard ones who do their kids homework for them (always very obvious when the parents have done it) and are constantly pushing and pushing their poor kids who just need to chill out a bit.

Agree. 5 minutes a day is nothing. It is vital and yet 'I don't have the time.' Find it. Parent!