Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers- be honest please - do you judge or make assumptions?

466 replies

BlingLoving · 04/04/2022 10:38

And if so, how often are you right?

eg when the kid turns up on day one with crazy curls, no hair tie (especially boys) do you immediately think, like I do, "oh no, this family is going to be a bit precious."

Or if the kid's clothes are consistently stained etc, do you chalk that up to parents having limited cash and taking view that school uniform is to be worn (my approach) or do you think they're just careless?

What about the ones who struggle to spend the time doing homework with their DC? Do you think they're just bad parents or are you sympathetic?

OP posts:
sweetbellyhigh · 04/04/2022 18:03

@Anorthernlass

The most judgemental teachers IMHO are the ones without children. Those with kids tend to be more laid back and inclusive. Had kids in schools for 16 years and it's very been rare to find a young teacher who truly gets kids. So thats me as a parent judging teachers lol!
I've met loads of young teachers who are fantastic at their jobs. And a fair few older teachers who are well past their best by dates.
Hutchy16 · 04/04/2022 17:56

You sound horrid! But at least you don’t mind people judging so won’t complain at me judging you

Fairislefandango · 04/04/2022 17:56

Why does a 4-year old need to wear a uniform - must their personality be whipped out of them at any cost?

I'm no fan of uniform, but I can assure you that it doesn't whip personality out of children. 'Don't judge a book by its cover' cuts both ways - clothes do not make personality, whether the clothes are uniform or the most eccentric outfit you can imagine. Some people might choose to express their personality through their clothes, but not doing so does not mean your personality is removed. I notice no lack of personality in the uniformed kids I teach Grin. And when I've been to non-uniform schools,I can't say I've noticed the children having more personality!

sweetbellyhigh · 04/04/2022 17:53

@FourChimneys

chillylizard that's interesting. A Nigerian mum whose child I taught would always pay double for everything with a note to say the extra was for someone who couldn't afford it. I assumed it was general loveliness but perhaps cultural as well?
Oh ffs like you would say this if they were Scottish
pollymere · 04/04/2022 17:52

I don't make assumptions. However, there are flags we need to check for. And certain types of abuse is more accepted in certain cultures so you keep an eye out for that too. Do you judge the parent who send their kids in with banned uniform items? Sometimes. There is an obvious difference between the kid in trainers because their parents haven't got the money for new shoes and the kid who's just in trainers. They do get treated differently.

Hertsgirl10 · 04/04/2022 17:52

@ThatsNotMyMuffin

I judge the names and manners. We used to joke that on the first day you meet them you can generally rank them up for the by GCSEs they're going to get (I teach a core subject).

I don't ever judge on the looks, I know my own children often end up looking feral despite my best efforts.

@ThatsNotMyMuffin

You can tell by a child’s name what their gcse results will be?

Bigblunder · 04/04/2022 17:51

I’m not a teacher but a parent and I’d love to know what teachers really think of the projects that most certainly have NOT been made by the child but by the parent!!! They are exceptionally good and stand out a mile! As a parent, I judge these people.

Shinyandnew1 · 04/04/2022 17:48

I have taught for 20+ years in primary and have never had any input over the children I have in my new class for the next year.

We split up and sort out our own classes for the next year and provide eg 3 class lists with a roughly equal number of boys/girls, PP/SEN, ability groupings etc but the head will decide on which new class teacher gets which class list.

SleepingStandingUp · 04/04/2022 17:47

Like I said, I tend to immediately make assumptions about families where the children have copious long curls, never tied back. I just know they're going to be all tinkly laughs and "oh so liberal" while their kids are probably hooligans! grin. x 100 if it's the boys who have these curls. So far I've been right every time but I look forward to being wrong at some point.
I guess I should be grateful my long haired, bobbleless son has straight hair so the teacher doesn't think he's a hooligan 🙄

winnieanddaisy · 04/04/2022 17:47

I had a terrible time at school being judged. I passed the 11 plus and went to a very posh grammar school in a posh part of a city. I lived on a large council estate and we were poor .
I could tell I was looked down on by some of the teachers especially my 2nd form maths teacher . She hardly looked at me and never tried to help me . She was shocked though when I came top on a test and moved up a set in maths . She was probably glad to be rid of me .
I did poorly at school even though many years later I found out that I had an IQ of 140 and if helped more should have done very well .

WonderfulYou · 04/04/2022 17:45

I’ve come across many judgey teachers and I actually tried to quit my own teacher training over it.

Things like - going through the register to see which child is going to be a handful, it’s never George or Arthur always something like Axel, which actually is usually the opposite.

  • also assuming those who are PP or have low income families living on council estates are all work-shy and unintelligent.
  • how the black boys are not doing themselves any favours by messing around and it’s no wonder they have such a bad reputation, even though there are white kids whose behaviour is definitely worse.

As someone who lives in a council flat, been brought up in council houses, was a teenage parent etc I get very offended as it’s these sorts of views that stop some children reaching their full potential.

Fortunately these views are very rare and most teachers are less judgemental than most careers as they see a range of people and know you can’t judge a book by it’s cover.

BlueOverYellow · 04/04/2022 17:43

Do you honestly think that teachers have ANY say or influence on their classes? That teacher did not CHOOSE who she had in her class!
The headteacher makes those decisions and the teacher just lumps it!

I can't believe the things that people think about schools.

Um, primary school teachers absolutely DO have input into who goes into what classes as they move up the school. Who on earth do you think does the initial class proposals? We do! Heads just ask that the proposed splits be explained if there are questions and tweak/sign off, generally.

Bluesparkled · 04/04/2022 17:41

It almost seems the OP has a particular child with curly hair in mind tbh.

ldontWanna · 04/04/2022 17:36

@RazzlePuff

Helpful to know that there is a lot of judgement going on … about hair. How would any of you know why a child has long hair? What if child wants it long, doesn’t like haircuts, religion or cultural beliefs. Leave the kids alone.
Only issues I have with hair are 1.can the child see properly,and if not then a hair tie/clip/headband/whatever or hair cut is needed and 2. I do prefer it tied up,for their own sake because schools tend to be rife with lice.
FairyCakeWings · 04/04/2022 17:34

@Mumofsend

Its frustrating knowing you are being judged when it isn't always the parents laziness

There’s a big difference between the situations where a child is finding it difficult to learn to read but parents are supportive and another where the child is being denied the opportunity to practice their reading because the parents hardly ever open the book bag. I’d hope teachers can usually tell the difference so I’m sorry if you felt judged.

DemelzaandRoss · 04/04/2022 17:34

I used to be a TA & would worry about the children attending school with dirty clothes and sometimes they were far too small as well. The Form teacher would also be aware & these pupils would be monitored fairly closely.
Regarding names, it was fairly easy to predict challenging behaviour in both sexes!
Chardonnay would be a good example.
Finally, my own son was incredibly shy as a child. He found some work difficult unless extremely factual. At the age of 9 yrs we were told it would be unlikely for him to attain GCSEs.
He eventually passed 12 GCSEs, 3 A Levels & a degree. Spectacularly incorrect projection thankfully.

Makeitsoso · 04/04/2022 17:30

@Pigtailsandall

I'm reading this thread with a certain level of dread; I have a young child who will start school in 2023. I didn't grow up on Britain, and the schooling system to me seems draconian, from underpaid and undervalued teachers to school uniforms. Why does a 4-year old need to wear a uniform - must their personality be whipped out of them at any cost? Plus the constant testing and obsession with tests.

Anyhoo, my child will most likely be judged because they have big curls and a non-conforming, questioning mother.

Good for you. As a UK teacher myself, questioning the ‘system’ is wise.
Makeitsoso · 04/04/2022 17:27

@FiveForAPound

I find it incredibly frustrating that parents don't listen to their dc read.

It takes a TA pretty much a whole week to listen to every child once and the LA 20% every day.

I don't notice clothes except for shoes they can't tie themselves or that don't fit. I do t even notice if they are actually wearing uniform or not.

And I only notice hair that's in their faces. Some dc have to hold their hair when they work or when they are walking along or playing outside.

I only once at most a week remember to write “we read the reading book” in the diary. I read with my child loads and listen to them read (also a primary teacher!). Don’t assume those who write in the book have and those who haven’t, haven’t. I think there is only a very loose correlation!
FairyCakeWings · 04/04/2022 17:27

[quote baffledcoconut]@FairyCakeWings

My year 1 COULD read Harry Potter and tell you everything that happened in those books. And read fluently with expression. Some kids can do these things and it’s equally as frustrating as a parent when you’re not listened to and told you’re being precious…[/quote]
Then I’d have to ask why on earth you’d give your year 1 child Harry Potter to read. I can believe the rare child is capable and still think it’s a bad idea.

You can’t possibly get the full benefit of everything Harry Potter has to offer if you read it with a 5/6 year old instead of waiting a few years until that child is old enough to get the best out of the whole series.

I’d have to write a whole essay to explain all my reasons for wishing my year 1 children didn’t read Harry Potter.

Keepingmytoeswarm · 04/04/2022 17:24

Homework at primary school? Hmm I struggled to show enthusiasm for this myself (beyond reading & spellings).

My kids HATED these mega projects and it made years 5 & 6 pretty unhappy - around the weeks homework was set anyway.

I guess it set them up for year 7 and having homework?? But still we thought it was ridiculous.

The idea of giving a 9 year old a large, weeks-long project without breaking it down always seemed like setting students up to fail and an awful lot of stress. Plus - lots of parents doing the homework to teach the desired standard. Pointless really. Your kid - who did everything themselves / just felt shit about their work…

GlitteryGreen · 04/04/2022 17:22

@Princetopple

Curls are such an odd thing to make an assumption about though. I don't know why you'd think a child with curly hair which wasn't tied back was from a 'tinkly laugh liberal family' and would be hard work whereas a child with straight hair not tied back wouldn't be.

My son has long curly hair and it's just pretty wild. I imagine that the teachers at his current school would think he was neglected rather than having a precious mother. He's a teenage shower dodger now and I have to constantly nag him to actually comb and wash his hair. The only time he will willingly tie it back is when he's at army cadets because there are consequences if it's not tied up. They're pretty stern. The idea that anybody would think we were tinkly laugh liberals is quite funny. Not sure you get many of those around here.

Completely agree with this. It's really hurtful to make this judgement on curly hair. Straight hair is not 'better'. It's just the way people are born.
Pigtailsandall · 04/04/2022 17:20

I'm reading this thread with a certain level of dread; I have a young child who will start school in 2023. I didn't grow up on Britain, and the schooling system to me seems draconian, from underpaid and undervalued teachers to school uniforms. Why does a 4-year old need to wear a uniform - must their personality be whipped out of them at any cost? Plus the constant testing and obsession with tests.

Anyhoo, my child will most likely be judged because they have big curls and a non-conforming, questioning mother.

RazzlePuff · 04/04/2022 17:19

Helpful to know that there is a lot of judgement going on … about hair. How would any of you know why a child has long hair? What if child wants it long, doesn’t like haircuts, religion or cultural beliefs. Leave the kids alone.

Mydogmylife · 04/04/2022 17:19

@bluebaul

I tend to immediately make assumptions about families where the children have copious long curls, never tied back. I just know they're going to be all tinkly laughs and "oh so liberal" while their kids are probably hooligans!

This is fucking awful. Like seriously. WTF.

I know - I hope this was a poorly judged joke
Invasionofthegutsnatchers · 04/04/2022 17:18

I see a lot of the results of poor parenting choices teaching in an infant school eg, a child with completely black, rotten teeth whose parent admits they have a baby bottle of coke at bedtime. Children age 7 with dummies in buggies being pushed to school. 4 year old children who won't eat anything at lunchtime because Mummy isn't feeding them. Children who have no idea how to hold a book and try to swipe at pages because they've only ever held an ipad. I teach in an affluent area too.

I don't judge the children at all, I give them everything I can to try to improve their life chances. I would never show judgement to the parents because in a lot of cases their choices are down to poverty and not being educated in parenting (bring back sure start!) I just feel upset that these children are at such a disadvantage.