Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers- be honest please - do you judge or make assumptions?

466 replies

BlingLoving · 04/04/2022 10:38

And if so, how often are you right?

eg when the kid turns up on day one with crazy curls, no hair tie (especially boys) do you immediately think, like I do, "oh no, this family is going to be a bit precious."

Or if the kid's clothes are consistently stained etc, do you chalk that up to parents having limited cash and taking view that school uniform is to be worn (my approach) or do you think they're just careless?

What about the ones who struggle to spend the time doing homework with their DC? Do you think they're just bad parents or are you sympathetic?

OP posts:
sashh · 04/04/2022 23:20

@BlingLoving

I don't know about your son's SEN but something I've done with some students who struggle to organise or are always looking for things (and are often dyslexic) is a 'desk map' basically a piece of paper with boxes that are marked with 'pencil case', 'calculator', 'exercise book' so things are kept in the same place.

Depending on the child it can be a scale 'map' or an actual A3 sheet that goes on the desk first.

Kanaloa · 04/04/2022 23:10

@MangyInseam

How much of that is because they’re then treated differently by their teachers though? Unconscious bias has a lot to answer for.

That's a theory but not actually one with a lot of evidence.

But as far as why kids who come from families that are struggling might not do as well, I can think of quite a few reasons that are pretty clearly going have significant effects on their ability to do well in school and life generally. Lack of help in school. Lack of the best medical care. Not as many interesting experiences - not travel, lessons, sports. Unstable home life. Addiction problems. Sometimes cultural issues that see doing well as something to look down on. Violence in the neighbourhood.

If all those reasons are true then that makes a teacher snickering about how a child named Ellie won’t get GCSEs even more despicable.
Pumperthepumper · 04/04/2022 23:06

@MangyInseam

How much of that is because they’re then treated differently by their teachers though? Unconscious bias has a lot to answer for.

That's a theory but not actually one with a lot of evidence.

But as far as why kids who come from families that are struggling might not do as well, I can think of quite a few reasons that are pretty clearly going have significant effects on their ability to do well in school and life generally. Lack of help in school. Lack of the best medical care. Not as many interesting experiences - not travel, lessons, sports. Unstable home life. Addiction problems. Sometimes cultural issues that see doing well as something to look down on. Violence in the neighbourhood.

Actually, there’s quite a lot of evidence. Here’s some:

scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?q=teacher+bias+and+attainment+gap&hl=en&as_sdt=0&as_vis=1&oi=scholart#d=gs_qabs&u=%23p%3D42JDeRbjnQMJ

scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?q=teacher+bias+and+attainment+gap&hl=en&as_sdt=0&as_vis=1&oi=scholart#d=gs_qabs&u=%23p%3DVkKUYnFkcJgJ

scholar.google.co.uk/scholar?q=teacher+bias+and+attainment+gap&hl=en&as_sdt=0&as_vis=1&oi=scholart#d=gs_qabs&u=%23p%3DW1FpOm0nDmEJ

MangyInseam · 04/04/2022 23:01

How much of that is because they’re then treated differently by their teachers though? Unconscious bias has a lot to answer for.

That's a theory but not actually one with a lot of evidence.

But as far as why kids who come from families that are struggling might not do as well, I can think of quite a few reasons that are pretty clearly going have significant effects on their ability to do well in school and life generally. Lack of help in school. Lack of the best medical care. Not as many interesting experiences - not travel, lessons, sports. Unstable home life. Addiction problems. Sometimes cultural issues that see doing well as something to look down on. Violence in the neighbourhood.

Kanaloa · 04/04/2022 22:57

But then all mine have always had short hair and now dd is 10 and has grown hers long she knows she needs to tie it for school so it’s neat and presentable. She does have gorgeous curls but no reason for them to be hanging all about her face/whipping round in PE etc. They’re just as gorgeous in a neat ponytail so she can concentrate and run round without her hair hanging in her face.

Kanaloa · 04/04/2022 22:55

@Cait33

My DS started school with a positive mane of flowing blond curls past his shoulders (never tied back). I've very definitely never been accused of being liberal though - a little bit right wing on some topics if truth be told! I'm a strict parent who expects my kids to behave and toe my line at all times. I'd definitely prove you wrong OP! DS had long luscious hair because it was just too pretty to cut. DH and peer pressure eventually led to the chop and it's been bitterly regretted since. I still get random semi-strangers coming up to me and asking why we cut his beautiful hair (it's been 2 years).
This seems to be really common amongst these boy mums too. Oh his beautiful luscious curls are simply too delicious to cut or tie back.

I never ever see girls with their hair left lying all around and mums saying ‘oh her gorgeous curls are just toooooo pretty to tie up.’

I think it just looks messy.

ItsAlwaysThere · 04/04/2022 22:42

I work in school. I find it awful that you judge based on loose curly hair. What a bloody cheek! I have loose curly hair. This judgement is why so many curly hair people straighten for years and years - the assumption that it equals a certain persona and as adults, that it isn't professional enough. Yes you're talking about children but this is where it starts.

Re my own judgements, yes I consider children's wellbeing all. the. time. Consistently dirty (not just now and again - kids get dirty), smelly, attitude, behaviour etc is always at least mentally noted. It is our job to look out for children.

But your hair judgement, you can stick that where the sun don't shine.

ldontWanna · 04/04/2022 22:34

[quote sweetbellyhigh]@ldontWanna

That wasn't my list, you have tagged the wrong poster[/quote]
I know. I quoted a poster who tagged you in their reply to you , hence you getting a notification I presume.

wanttomarryamillionaire · 04/04/2022 22:34

Oh yes they judge! I was judged as a single parent who obviously couldn't cope because my child was having frequent meltdowns, aggressive behaviour, refusing to wear anything but the same clothes everyday. All the while i begged them to have my son assessed for SEN but was told no, its my parenting etc. Even went to the extreme of calling social services on me, saying i was an unfit parent ( social worker visited us at home and decided there was no reason for them to be involved and actually bollocked the headteacher of ds school for wasting her time) school eventually expelled ds age 9, he was in his new school only a few weeks and they started process for EHCP and referred to camhs. Ds was diagnosed with ASD, ADHD, ODD and SPD as well as bilateral deafness by the time he was 10! I kept saying to his previous headteacher i think he has problems hearing but was told no he chooses when he will listen. So yes they definitely do judge and sometimes very wrongly.

Cait33 · 04/04/2022 22:31

My DS started school with a positive mane of flowing blond curls past his shoulders (never tied back). I've very definitely never been accused of being liberal though - a little bit right wing on some topics if truth be told! I'm a strict parent who expects my kids to behave and toe my line at all times. I'd definitely prove you wrong OP! DS had long luscious hair because it was just too pretty to cut. DH and peer pressure eventually led to the chop and it's been bitterly regretted since. I still get random semi-strangers coming up to me and asking why we cut his beautiful hair (it's been 2 years).

sweetbellyhigh · 04/04/2022 22:29

@ldontWanna

That wasn't my list, you have tagged the wrong poster

ldontWanna · 04/04/2022 22:28

@CasZekey sweet f all as I don't make judgements based on names. I might try to engage you in conversation though as a fellow Supernatural fan.Grin

Pumperthepumper · 04/04/2022 22:26

@MangyInseam

I knew a student called Philistine. I always thought that was a rather bad choice. I'm not sure why the parents chose it.

The thing about names though - there is a correlation between names and success on testing and career and such. It's because names are correlated to class and class as a child correlates to school outcomes and their consequences.

So while it would be wrong to assume any individual child will or won't do well based on name, it is possible to make better guesses than chance for groups of kids.

How much of that is because they’re then treated differently by their teachers though? Unconscious bias has a lot to answer for.
ldontWanna · 04/04/2022 22:26

[quote Myboypink]@sweetbellyhigh

My favourite names have been
Markus-Jon
Betty-Blue
Beyoncé
Armarni
Aleeeyesha
Riley
Rileee
Rhileye

Jayden / Tyler and Bailey ! - also always makes me shudder .

Hahaha!

I won’t do anymore or I could
Out myself ! Hahahaha[/quote]
Once again on that list are names of some of the kids I bonded the most with. Really lovely kids, even if their behaviour wasn't always, but always think of them with fondness and a smile.

MangyInseam · 04/04/2022 22:23

I knew a student called Philistine. I always thought that was a rather bad choice. I'm not sure why the parents chose it.

The thing about names though - there is a correlation between names and success on testing and career and such. It's because names are correlated to class and class as a child correlates to school outcomes and their consequences.

So while it would be wrong to assume any individual child will or won't do well based on name, it is possible to make better guesses than chance for groups of kids.

Invasionofthegutsnatchers · 04/04/2022 22:21

I shall also make sure I won't go above and beyond in any way in future. If your child needs a special resource made or a bit of extra time explaining something, or some TLC because they feel sad that day, I won't have a chat with them. Wouldn't want to be a martyr.

Hadehahaha · 04/04/2022 22:19

Secondary teacher and parent; genuinely never judge, every child is an individual and I am observing with interest all children as I get to know them. Never judging even once I know the child, just reporting any safeguarding issues as is my responsibility. For the record these issues arise across class, nationality and circumstance.

sweetbellyhigh · 04/04/2022 22:16

Cutest was a class of new entrants which included children named

Milo
Coco
Sugar

Teacher held a breakfast party and they all brought their favourite cereal or drink

sweetbellyhigh · 04/04/2022 22:14

*Parker
Harrison
Coke
Scout
*
🤔
Are these the most common names? They seem pretty average to me.

Pumperthepumper · 04/04/2022 22:12

Oh god, more xenophobia with the name shit. Im embarrassed for you.

sweetbellyhigh · 04/04/2022 22:11

[quote Myboypink]@sweetbellyhigh

My favourite names have been
Markus-Jon
Betty-Blue
Beyoncé
Armarni
Aleeeyesha
Riley
Rileee
Rhileye

Jayden / Tyler and Bailey ! - also always makes me shudder .

Hahaha!

I won’t do anymore or I could
Out myself ! Hahahaha[/quote]
Mine have been

JackDaniels
Chirs (they meant Chris but didn't know how to spell it)
Big John and his brother Lil John

Pumperthepumper · 04/04/2022 22:09

@RazzlePuff

We can conclude that our children are suffering through a deeply flawed education system, and being taught by angry judgmental teachers who instead of educating children complain they work harder than anyone else and seem to hate most children based on name, hair type, make assumptions about parents politics, income, parenting style, etc. let me tell you teachers - your names suck, your hairstyle also sucks, I don’t like your clothes, your hygiene could be improved, your roots need a touch up, your shoes are cheap, you are not as smart as you think you are, and my child will succeed regardless of how you feel about his gorgeous long curls. Bah!!
Quite a lot of this is true. The education system is deeply flawed and teachers as a rule are not good at voting with their feet. And, my roots do need a touch up.
Myboypink · 04/04/2022 22:09

@sweetbellyhigh
Marky-Jon

Damn auto correct!

Harri-Bo ! Also made me laugh !

Parker
Harrison
Cole
Scout

Also very telling !

sweetbellyhigh · 04/04/2022 22:08

@Giraffesandbottoms

Uniforms aren’t only there because of equality; wearing a different and specific set of clothing to a school environment has an effect on learning. The same way that many people working from home work more productively wearing actual clothes rather than pyjamas. It’s also smarter, makes children easier to identify on school trips and stops people from sending their children in in godawful outfits like head to toe Burberry etc.

An oft-repeated myth.

The children of the many countries who do not subscribe to uniform madness can testify to this.

There is no school uniform at local primary schools where I live and you know what? It's not an issue. Not one bit. Kids get up, put on their clothes and go to school. End of story.

Myboypink · 04/04/2022 22:06

@sweetbellyhigh

My favourite names have been
Markus-Jon
Betty-Blue
Beyoncé
Armarni
Aleeeyesha
Riley
Rileee
Rhileye

Jayden / Tyler and Bailey ! - also always makes me shudder .

Hahaha!

I won’t do anymore or I could
Out myself ! Hahahaha