Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers- be honest please - do you judge or make assumptions?

466 replies

BlingLoving · 04/04/2022 10:38

And if so, how often are you right?

eg when the kid turns up on day one with crazy curls, no hair tie (especially boys) do you immediately think, like I do, "oh no, this family is going to be a bit precious."

Or if the kid's clothes are consistently stained etc, do you chalk that up to parents having limited cash and taking view that school uniform is to be worn (my approach) or do you think they're just careless?

What about the ones who struggle to spend the time doing homework with their DC? Do you think they're just bad parents or are you sympathetic?

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 05/04/2022 08:08

@Violinist64

What is amusing me on this thread is the number of people wringing their hands and telling us that of course they never judge the parents who choose such names as Riley, Bailey, Jayden, Chardonnay, Lacey-Mae etc. Of course we should treat each child as an individual and in that sense names really do not matter. However, MN, is predominantly a very middle class forum and I am wondering just how many people here, particularly teachers, chose those names for their own children as opposed to such names as Harry, George, Oliver, Olivia, Sophie, Isabel etc.
Hang on, you can’t notice xenophobia unless you’re appropriating that culture yourself?
Iwantthesummersun · 05/04/2022 07:48

@the80sweregreat

Of course they judge Most teachers I've ever met are not very pleasant people either.
Gosh that’s delightful. And it’s the teachers who are judgy? 🥴
Mamajunebugjones · 05/04/2022 07:47

Long curly locks on any gender sound beautiful- but it’s not doing a young child any favours if not tied back for work and play.

Mamajunebugjones · 05/04/2022 07:26

May be there’s something about teaching that wrings the humanity out of you following a number of years.

the80sweregreat · 05/04/2022 04:29

Of course they judge
Most teachers I've ever met are not very pleasant people either.

Marchitectmummy · 05/04/2022 03:06

Sounds like a lot of teachers need EDI training? Judging wealth, hair styles, nationality, clothes, first impressions are all unacceptable. I'm amazed people think vocalising their husbands prejudiced observations of Asian and Nigerian pupils is acceptable! Mind boggling that they are educating children.

Ericaequites · 05/04/2022 02:59

@FairyCakeWings- What do you want highly literate five and six year olds to read? Phonetic readers are deadly dull. Enid Blyton isn’t well written. Horrid Histories are highly inaccurate. Captain Underpants and Wimpy Kid contain poor grammar and promote antisocial behavior. Barbie and Disney Princess books promote the outdated idea that women are nothing without a man.

sashh · 05/04/2022 01:21

[quote ldontWanna]@CasZekey one of my Jaden's is at grammar school, so those posters can shove that up their pipe and smoke it.

As for foreign names, some teachers can't even be bothered to say them right and butcher them in English. That's another pet peeve of mine. No Andrii, is not a spelling mistake sneer sneer. No, Ioana is not eye oh na. No, Anoushka is not Annie or Ann or Anishka and no it doesn't sound like anus or whatever other bullshit. No, Isis and Ira aren't just terrorist organisations and Iris isn't just the part of the eye ... oh the horror. And so on.

Yes.. I have issues.Grin[/quote]
I'm awarding myself a chufty badge, doing supply I often butchered names on a register (I always said, sorry if I get your name wrong, please correct me before taking the register).

But I was proud of asking a student (phonetic English spelling) Is it Yonna or Eye oh na?

EmeraldShamrock1 · 05/04/2022 01:02

I have always wondered about this, my DC are always clean and punctual but DS tells his aid absolutely everything in detail with access to her all day.

Kanaloa · 05/04/2022 01:02

Yes it’s sad. You only need to look at how people will openly admit it on here. I don’t know how they get away with it though - no school I’ve worked in would accept or allow a teacher to go through the register snickering with their colleagues about how this child won’t get GCSEs because if they’re name.

I wonder why some people went into teaching in the first place.

Violinist64 · 05/04/2022 00:53

@Kanaloa, I hope l have explained my thoughts and l am in total agreement with you. The name should not matter. Unfortunately, not everyone thinks like you.

Violinist64 · 05/04/2022 00:50

I want to add to my post before I, too, am judged that I truly believe all children should be treated equally and fairly, whatever their names or backgrounds. However, in the real world with human nature as it is, this does not always happen. Even today, it is all too easy for teachers to see the youngest child of a large “problem family” and tar them with the same brush before they have even entered the school/class. I remember one boy in my class at school who was treated in just such a manner by some teachers. I think he was probably dyslexic but at that time dyslexia was only beginning to be recognised and it would not have been considered in his case. He reacted by becoming the class clown and left school at the earliest possible opportunity without taking any exams. However, he has worked hard all his life and now owns a business, is married and has two children who have both been to university. His strength of character has overcome the early adversity he faced but how many others were and are written off in life because they have the wrong name and/or background?

Kanaloa · 05/04/2022 00:41

@Violinist64

What is amusing me on this thread is the number of people wringing their hands and telling us that of course they never judge the parents who choose such names as Riley, Bailey, Jayden, Chardonnay, Lacey-Mae etc. Of course we should treat each child as an individual and in that sense names really do not matter. However, MN, is predominantly a very middle class forum and I am wondering just how many people here, particularly teachers, chose those names for their own children as opposed to such names as Harry, George, Oliver, Olivia, Sophie, Isabel etc.
Just because I wouldn’t choose a name doesn’t mean I’d find it funny to spend my break times ‘predicting what GCSEs children will get based on their names.’

Grotesque behaviour. There’s a huge difference between ‘judging the parent’ ie thinking hmm maybe Dick isn’t the best name for a child in 2022, and making nasty assumptions about the child because of their background or even just their first name.

Violinist64 · 05/04/2022 00:23

What is amusing me on this thread is the number of people wringing their hands and telling us that of course they never judge the parents who choose such names as Riley, Bailey, Jayden, Chardonnay, Lacey-Mae etc. Of course we should treat each child as an individual and in that sense names really do not matter. However, MN, is predominantly a very middle class forum and I am wondering just how many people here, particularly teachers, chose those names for their own children as opposed to such names as Harry, George, Oliver, Olivia, Sophie, Isabel etc.

ldontWanna · 05/04/2022 00:20

@CasZekey one of my Jaden's is at grammar school, so those posters can shove that up their pipe and smoke it.

As for foreign names, some teachers can't even be bothered to say them right and butcher them in English. That's another pet peeve of mine. No Andrii, is not a spelling mistake sneer sneer. No, Ioana is not eye oh na. No, Anoushka is not Annie or Ann or Anishka and no it doesn't sound like anus or whatever other bullshit. No, Isis and Ira aren't just terrorist organisations and Iris isn't just the part of the eye ... oh the horror. And so on.

Yes.. I have issues.Grin

ldontWanna · 05/04/2022 00:11

@TimeForTeaAndMe if you get nowhere, can you look at changing schools?
It sounds heartbreaking for your poor kid, but tbh you can't make a school or TA/teacher behave in a certain way if they're not willing to. Some even do it on purpose to weed out "undesirable " children. While it's not your child's fault, and you have every right to fight and complain and expect/demand better the time is passing and his self esteem and interest/enthusiasm for school and learning can severely wane. You might get somewhere,you might not but by then might be too late.

It's not fair,and it's not right but please consider whether that school is the right environment for your son.

Tsuni · 05/04/2022 00:11

What kind of dick judges someone for having curly hair? Hmm

CasZekey · 05/04/2022 00:08

@ldontWanna

But then in a class like our school, where we're all working class, how does that work other than assuming they'll all fail because they're all wc? How do you seperate out the Nancy and the Elizabeth from the Romallo and the Xavier when they're all the same class?

They're all doomed ,doomed I tell you.Grin

But surely no Nancy could possibly be doomed???

I also wonder how this works for kids with none English names. I mean if an English name is unusual it's considered gutter name, kid will be kicked out of school by 4 but with a name like say Aradhya does she get a free pass to success because we can't judge it in the same way?

TimeForTeaAndMe · 05/04/2022 00:08

Ds not da sorry

TimeForTeaAndMe · 05/04/2022 00:06

@UsernameInTheTown

I judge my daughter's teacher, she's an utterly vile human being.
I was waiting for a comment like this. Da has a TA who seems to enjoy making him cry! Never gets noticed because she's left incharge of the entire class while the actual teacher leaves the room for most of the day. Da is 8yrs old and stopped smiling going into school after the first week of yr 3. He also struggles with SEN Rare life threatening illnesses. Spends his break and lunch times lonely. My heart is broken. When asked to help him buddy up..the school put him with bullies. I just want him to smile again..

School have now been given two weeks to sort out thoes issues as well as a few others. Before I report them.

I feel like screaming at her myself " hay Mrs COCKWOMBBLE you do realise the ear defenders my son are wearing are because he can not handle loud noises? So you might want to stop screaming at him every chance you get" (only when others aren't around)
Power mad bitch! .
Yep parents judge teacher too 😁

Apologies rant over..today was the last straw then I seen this thread. 🤦

ldontWanna · 05/04/2022 00:02

But then in a class like our school, where we're all working class, how does that work other than assuming they'll all fail because they're all wc? How do you seperate out the Nancy and the Elizabeth from the Romallo and the Xavier when they're all the same class?

They're all doomed ,doomed I tell you.Grin

CasZekey · 04/04/2022 23:52

@MangyInseam

I knew a student called Philistine. I always thought that was a rather bad choice. I'm not sure why the parents chose it.

The thing about names though - there is a correlation between names and success on testing and career and such. It's because names are correlated to class and class as a child correlates to school outcomes and their consequences.

So while it would be wrong to assume any individual child will or won't do well based on name, it is possible to make better guesses than chance for groups of kids.

But then in a class like our school, where we're all working class, how does that work other than assuming they'll all fail because they're all wc? How do you seperate out the Nancy and the Elizabeth from the Romallo and the Xavier when they're all the same class?
SleepingStandingUp · 04/04/2022 23:49

@Pumperthepumper

Oh god, more xenophobia with the name shit. Im embarrassed for you.
I don't think it's xenophobia, these threads are normally sagging off wc bits, not people from other countries
bellamountain · 04/04/2022 23:42

@Pumperthepumper

By far and away the best thing would be to ask kids to come to school in unbranded joggers, T-shirts and hoodies. Comfortable, can be worn at weekends, washes easily, warm.
Agree with this, I'd even say secondary school kids too. Not many professions require people to be suited and booted every day, even more so now with many working from home. A good proportion of kids in this country will go onto work in a trade or manufacturing. Why do they have to wear uncomfortable shirts, blazers and ties every day and be reprimanded for wearing trainers (aka comfy shoes). Completely outdated.
ldontWanna · 04/04/2022 23:26

@MangyInseam

How much of that is because they’re then treated differently by their teachers though? Unconscious bias has a lot to answer for.

That's a theory but not actually one with a lot of evidence.

But as far as why kids who come from families that are struggling might not do as well, I can think of quite a few reasons that are pretty clearly going have significant effects on their ability to do well in school and life generally. Lack of help in school. Lack of the best medical care. Not as many interesting experiences - not travel, lessons, sports. Unstable home life. Addiction problems. Sometimes cultural issues that see doing well as something to look down on. Violence in the neighbourhood.

That does not negate teacher bias also being a factor.