Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers- be honest please - do you judge or make assumptions?

466 replies

BlingLoving · 04/04/2022 10:38

And if so, how often are you right?

eg when the kid turns up on day one with crazy curls, no hair tie (especially boys) do you immediately think, like I do, "oh no, this family is going to be a bit precious."

Or if the kid's clothes are consistently stained etc, do you chalk that up to parents having limited cash and taking view that school uniform is to be worn (my approach) or do you think they're just careless?

What about the ones who struggle to spend the time doing homework with their DC? Do you think they're just bad parents or are you sympathetic?

OP posts:
Valeriekat · 06/04/2022 06:17

@Invasionofthegutsnatchers

And actually I think binning uniform would increase inequality. At least within a uniform policy there's limited scope for elitism. Remove the uniform entirely and the label-rich (not necessarily cash rich) families would show off their Nike etc.

The best scenario would be to ban labelled uniform so that all families would shop at Asda, M&S or wherever to buy plain coloured uniform. No logos

Agree! All schools should also have a 2nd hand uniform shop.
ohfook · 06/04/2022 06:14

Oh and yes on a more lighthearted note if your kid is called Jude and has beautiful blonde curly hair I know exactly what type of person you'll be (but that's probably because I love the name Jude and want my kid to grow his hair but it's so thick he ends up looking like a mushroom, so they're probably the type of person I wish I was but am stuck here with my bad temper and a mushroom headed feral kid instead).

ohfook · 06/04/2022 06:10

We have to. Because anything that seems not right we have to report in case it's part of a bigger picture and I'd expect/hope that my kid's teachers are doing it to them too. I've reported a lot of things over my career that have looked a bit off but amounted to nothing (suspicious bruises, kids saying they have to share a tooth brush) but I don't care because I've also seen fairly innocuous things turn out to be the disclosure that revealed something serious. So I'd rather make 100 mistakes that turn out to be nothing than relax and miss something serious.

When teachers say report though they don't mean call social services and have your kids taken off you until you agree to put a bobble in their hair. It's just an online system where we type up anything that doesn't look right, so a lot of small things that don't look right are all kept in one place in case they start to add up.

On a personal note unruly hair or recurring nits are not something I would give a second thought too. Matted hair would raise alarm bells though and I do judge people whose kids and their homework smell of smoke and who don't give their kid a toothbrush.

Valeriekat · 06/04/2022 06:07

@Tidy2018

In Scotland here. We have restorative justice. In secondary this mostly consists of restorative conversations, early involvement of parents/carers, campus cops with good relationships with older kids.

Primary is very much nurture and wellbeing.

No detentions. Punishment, when necessary, takes place within school hours.

Restorative justice...where the bully gets a second go and the victim is overreacting?
Ericaequites · 06/04/2022 06:03

Hair that touches the collar should be fully tied back at all times in school. If you won’t follow the rule, cut your child’s hair short. How hard is this?
As for names, it’s the first thing people learn about you. Choosing something sensible that isn’t trendy or illiterate will save a child many explanations over a lifetime.

Ajay96 · 06/04/2022 05:44

We're all human, we all judge, this is our first impression, the difference is wether this is fluid of fixed.
As a teacher, starting the school year, im standing in front of 20 to 30 children, I'm looking around wondering what kind of year we will have. Luckily I'm in the same school every year, so I have an awareness of the children moving up, but I'm teaching primary 1, so some of the little faces are very new to us. I do agree that we judge based on looks, mannerisms, actions, etc, this helps us build a picture of each little child. They are all very unique and it's important to take that into consideration when planning and implementing learning experiences. These initial judgements can turn out to be true or false, for example, a very small little boy, looks quiet, angelic, like butter won't melt, but in reality he's ac cheeky happy, a very loud little boy. I think it's important not to let personal judgement stand in the way, it's important to allow children to grow and develop with confidence, creating there own little personality. The same goes with judgements on outfits, cleanliness, parental behaviours etc. I've had parents I initially thought were going to be hard work because of our first interactions, but ended up the most supportive and helpful parents.
There's nothing wrong with first impressions and judging someone, but it's how you use this moving forward, it's not fixed and you need to be aware of that.

Valeriekat · 06/04/2022 05:35

@INeedNewShoes

copious long curls, never tied back. I just know they're going to be all tinkly laughs and "oh so liberal" while their kids are probably hooligans!

Have you ever tried to tie curly hair back?

I had thick curly hair as a child. Shy, low self-esteem, academic, well-behaved.

DD has wild hair that looks like she's been dragged through a hedge backwards within 5 minutes of me doing it in the mornings: shy, well-behaved, quiet.

Thankfully you're not her teacher Hmm

HEADBAND?
Valeriekat · 06/04/2022 05:29

@Kanaloa

As for homework whenever I’ve supported in reception/year one (and even preschools sometimes!!) I couldn’t give a monkeys about homework. I don’t think young kids should even have homework.
Yes, way too much homework (other than reading spelling and tables).
Valeriekat · 06/04/2022 04:37

@Enterthedragons

The comments about curls on the OP and subsequent posts are shocking and offensive. Curls are natural and beautiful and DO NOT denote naughtiness or carelessness.
Don't be so precious. That is not what was said or implied. You must be easily shocked!
Valeriekat · 06/04/2022 04:28

@bluebaul

I tend to immediately make assumptions about families where the children have copious long curls, never tied back. I just know they're going to be all tinkly laughs and "oh so liberal" while their kids are probably hooligans!

This is fucking awful. Like seriously. WTF.

I think it is the "never tied back" bit. Why do you think it is awful. Does it describe your child?
Kanaloa · 06/04/2022 00:39

@RazzlePuff

The Teachers Union should organise for teachers to chat with pregnant mums about what to name children for academic success. Properly named children will make teacher more efficient as they won’t need to spend time snarking, laughing and doling out bias.
Yes 😂 maybe then teachers could concentrate instead of nastily laughing at kids and predicting they won’t get GCSEs because they’re named Ellie.
worriedaboutmoney2022 · 05/04/2022 20:28

The school my kids are at is quite judgemental
We live in quite a nice area but we rent our house and there are a lot of very wealthy parents around here clearly with a lot more disposable income

It's a state school but 2 main fundraisers every year are the school summer and Christmas ball, at a local hotel - tickets being £50 each but you have to book 10 tickets for a full table - thankfully this stopped during COVID but it's scheduled again for July.

The rich parents all go and buy tickets, donate expensive raffle prizes etc and then Their kids often get lead roles in plays, assemblies, selected for class reps and mini school council etc - the PTA is ran by mums who don't work and have tonnes of money!!

It's the school I went to and I wanted my kids to go to that school as it's in a nice area but the attitude of some of the teachers isn't great

My daughter had a dirty jumper in her bag and went to School then felt cold so got the dirty jumper out and put it on

The head rang me to ask "if we were managing" which was extremely patronising and said in a rude way not a "would you like any help" approach and now I feel she looks down her nose at me

It's a very difficult situation

Longcovid21 · 05/04/2022 20:03

Yes but evaluation of hair length and type is not a safeguarding issue!

Hesma · 05/04/2022 19:33

It’s not being judgy, it’s being observant to safeguarding issues. If my being judgy saves a child’s life then I’ll judge away

Longcovid21 · 05/04/2022 18:45

Surely teachers are being paid to get the best out of children, regardless of their hair type and political persuasion of the parents. No 4 year old should be judged Sad

RazzlePuff · 05/04/2022 18:20

The Teachers Union should organise for teachers to chat with pregnant mums about what to name children for academic success. Properly named children will make teacher more efficient as they won’t need to spend time snarking, laughing and doling out bias.

Reindeer897 · 05/04/2022 16:26

I don't judge names, wouldn't judge breakfast on the school uniform, or the odd bit of uniform that got a bit small.

I don't judge behaviour, but I massively judge when the parents are given support and time by the school but continue to make their children's lives harder and learning impossible (as well as disrupting the education of 28 other children). I judge the parents who try and kill aspiration in their children (unfortunately common at my school). I also judge parents who won't put the time in on things like spelling or learning the times tables (unless SEN is involved of course).

Mostly I judge parents at my child's own school - parents who are very well-resourced professionals but put zero time or effort into their children and allow some pretty shocking behaviour.

sweetbellyhigh · 05/04/2022 16:02

@Tsuni

What kind of dick judges someone for having curly hair? Hmm
Isn't it amazing? Yet there are schools who "ban" afros, long hair etc, essentially criminalising some ethnicities.
VelvetChairGirl · 05/04/2022 14:38

@Keepingmytoeswarm

Homework at primary school? Hmm I struggled to show enthusiasm for this myself (beyond reading & spellings).

My kids HATED these mega projects and it made years 5 & 6 pretty unhappy - around the weeks homework was set anyway.

I guess it set them up for year 7 and having homework?? But still we thought it was ridiculous.

The idea of giving a 9 year old a large, weeks-long project without breaking it down always seemed like setting students up to fail and an awful lot of stress. Plus - lots of parents doing the homework to teach the desired standard. Pointless really. Your kid - who did everything themselves / just felt shit about their work…

oh god the projects, my son is fixated on cars, always has been, he was fine in primary doing maths etc but all the big "fun" building projects like make a rainforrest in a box, I had to do them because he had no interest in arts and crafts unless it involved cars, and even then if he'd made a land rover to crash thru the trees I still would have had to make the trees.
VelvetChairGirl · 05/04/2022 13:07

Ah yes this happened to me when DS started making dramatic improvements. Apparently I'd been coaching him. This was repeated over and over in a sort of mixture of sympathy and fake gratitude....except I genuinely hadn't coached him!!

my my how this thread has grown over night.

thats not the case with mine he maybe Sen with behavioural problems but he was top in the primary school in maths and tired top for reading comprehension. he only started secondary in septemer, since then I have had the science teacher asking if he can get medicated to calm him down and the maths teacher seems to think I do his homework.

I myself never went to school my parents never sent me and I didnt learn to write until I went to college, so the accusation is insane, he surpassed my maths ability when he was about 7 or 8 years old as I said its all greek to me.

TimeForTeaAndMe · 05/04/2022 09:57

[quote ldontWanna]@TimeForTeaAndMe if you get nowhere, can you look at changing schools?
It sounds heartbreaking for your poor kid, but tbh you can't make a school or TA/teacher behave in a certain way if they're not willing to. Some even do it on purpose to weed out "undesirable " children. While it's not your child's fault, and you have every right to fight and complain and expect/demand better the time is passing and his self esteem and interest/enthusiasm for school and learning can severely wane. You might get somewhere,you might not but by then might be too late.

It's not fair,and it's not right but please consider whether that school is the right environment for your son.[/quote]
Thankyou for your concern and replying to my rant.
We have put a few things in place now and complaints have been lodged.
The school have been given a set amount of time to meet his needs.
Or yes I will have to pull him out,
He really is a overly sensitive child so things can very easily upset him.
But there are no excuses for a TA shouting at him for his stuttering when trying to explain himself.
I'm also trying my best not to be so judgemental however his main teachers are littrally just out of school themselves,have no life experience with children and don't have children of their own..
While they may be kind. They haven't had enough time or training to understand the complex needs of some of these children.
We shall see what the new term brings I suppose. Love to see his confidence come back and that happy big hearted boy we have at home..starts to enjoy school again.

Frlrlrubert · 05/04/2022 09:52

Not RTFT

I was secondary so slightly different. I didn't judge hair as such, but always had spare scrunchies for science experiments and would judge if any of them made a fuss about tying it back. Whether that judgement was 'this child may have additional needs' or 'this child is stubborn' would depend on the exact nature of the interaction.

I tried to keep an open mind but after a few years your brain spots trends so you have to be aware of unconscious bias, mine were things like:

Ellie-Mai, Rosa-May, name. Probably going to have a low opinion of 'science' and a less confidence in her own ability than she should have, needs lots of encouragement. Much more confident in English and Drama.

Short red-haired boy with diamond earring. Reluctant to put pen to paper, sanctions tend not to work well, constant battle on effort, unlikely to complete homework.

Tall boy with floppy hair walks into first lesson with 'what up Miss?'. Socially confident, attitude in class could go either way depending on mix of peers. Studious peers will result in him working well and offering good answers, struggling peers will result in him causing disruption every time my back is turned.

BlingLoving · 05/04/2022 09:30

[quote sashh]@BlingLoving

I don't know about your son's SEN but something I've done with some students who struggle to organise or are always looking for things (and are often dyslexic) is a 'desk map' basically a piece of paper with boxes that are marked with 'pencil case', 'calculator', 'exercise book' so things are kept in the same place.

Depending on the child it can be a scale 'map' or an actual A3 sheet that goes on the desk first.[/quote]
Thanks. We don't think he's dyslexic but he is being assessed in May by an ed psychologist and she's going to look at dyslexia - not least because his cousin is dyslexic and we suspect my dad and/or brother/s are too (undiagnosed).

He's also got many dyspraxia markers but, oddly, none of the really big ones - he can ride a bike, has no problem with zips and buttons etc (although did take longer to master these skills than peers) so she's going to take another look at that too (he was assessed by an OT age 6 previously).

He struggles to organise in preparation - hence my concern about getting books/bags etc. But once he's in place, he does okay. The challenge is going to be getting him to the right place at the right time with the right tools. But he can and does learn routines so it's hopefully just about taking the time in the beginning.

OP posts:
ldontWanna · 05/04/2022 08:57

@Violinist64

What is amusing me on this thread is the number of people wringing their hands and telling us that of course they never judge the parents who choose such names as Riley, Bailey, Jayden, Chardonnay, Lacey-Mae etc. Of course we should treat each child as an individual and in that sense names really do not matter. However, MN, is predominantly a very middle class forum and I am wondering just how many people here, particularly teachers, chose those names for their own children as opposed to such names as Harry, George, Oliver, Olivia, Sophie, Isabel etc.
Actually there are some teachers at my school that have kids with names from the "list". Just how some of the wc class parents have Harry,Olivia,Isabel,Oliver etc. and not one single child is actually called Chardonnay.

Aren't assumptions funny?

Fairislefandango · 05/04/2022 08:40

However, MN, is predominantly a very middle class forum and I am wondering just how many people here, particularly teachers, chose those names for their own children as opposed to such names as Harry, George, Oliver, Olivia, Sophie, Isabel etc.

What's that got to do with anything though? Are you saying it's somehow hypocritical to try not to judge people dissimilar to yourself? Or that in order to prove that you're trying to be non-judgmental, you should deliberately choose names for your children on the basis of which names are popular with socio-economic, or perhaps even racial, groups different from your own?

Swipe left for the next trending thread