Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers- be honest please - do you judge or make assumptions?

466 replies

BlingLoving · 04/04/2022 10:38

And if so, how often are you right?

eg when the kid turns up on day one with crazy curls, no hair tie (especially boys) do you immediately think, like I do, "oh no, this family is going to be a bit precious."

Or if the kid's clothes are consistently stained etc, do you chalk that up to parents having limited cash and taking view that school uniform is to be worn (my approach) or do you think they're just careless?

What about the ones who struggle to spend the time doing homework with their DC? Do you think they're just bad parents or are you sympathetic?

OP posts:
Myboypink · 04/04/2022 12:23

Primary teacher here- yes i do !
When I hear the names - Mason , Alfie , Billy , Dolly , Ellie-Mai, Demi- Jade - I am already thinking - help !

It is awful but of course I have re judgments . When i hear a parent saying - I ain’t got time to read with him , he does my head in ! I feel so sorry the child and immediately know the sort of parent I am dealing with !

Harsh but true .

WalltoWallBtards · 04/04/2022 12:23

All of the things you mentioned could be signs that a family is struggling, so yes of course teachers pick up on that, and often intervene but to help the child and family. Not to judge them for not being able to afford to wash clothes more often, or have spare uniform. And often the parents don’t have time to help with homework because they work long hours in tough jobs like building work or cleaners or in late night shops.
I’m more likely to judge the ‘nice’ MC parent who doesn’t help with the kids home learning because they don’t believe in homework…

PrivateHall · 04/04/2022 12:21

I think it is part of human nature to sometimes jump to conclusions based on what we see. Teachers are human and most are just doing their best for every child. However there are a few very worrying posts on here about judging based on ethnicity, names etc and that is really concerning. Maybe that small minority need to reflect on their actions and the impact it will have on those children. Maybe you think you are not showing your bias in the classroom, but I would say that is highly unlikely.

To the posters who think its ok to make statements such as all Nigerian families are lovely and polite. Did you ever think those people are having to try harder to 'fit in' and avoid racism? Did you ever think that building up a stereotype on these families about how polite they are might lead to a culture of some thinking they then cannot complain? It is really harmful to make stereotypes like this, eg some maternity staff claim that Black women cope well in labour; what does this lead to? Black women not being given pain relief when they ask for it because they don't 'need it'. Please think before creating stereotypes, even if you think they are positive.

Anorthernlass · 04/04/2022 12:19

The most judgemental teachers IMHO are the ones without children. Those with kids tend to be more laid back and inclusive. Had kids in schools for 16 years and it's very been rare to find a young teacher who truly gets kids. So thats me as a parent judging teachers lol!

TheFallenMadonna · 04/04/2022 12:17

I'm human and subject to biases and stereotyping like everyone else, but I've also been a teacher long enough to know that if you make assumptions about children and their families, you're going to get a lot of things wrong. Now I work with very vulnerable teenagers, and as a PP said, effective safeguarding requires noticing followed by support. Not judgement.

Pumperthepumper · 04/04/2022 12:16

@Enterthedragons

The comments about curls on the OP and subsequent posts are shocking and offensive. Curls are natural and beautiful and DO NOT denote naughtiness or carelessness.
They also lean towards a xenophobic attitude.
beattieedny · 04/04/2022 12:16

Only in obvious cases of neglect or abuse. That always breaks my heart. Otherwise, families are all different and have their own ways of doing things. Most parents are doing their best, often in hard circumstances given where I teach (deprived area). You learn to tell the difference between kids living in poverty and kids who are neglected.

Enterthedragons · 04/04/2022 12:16

The comments about curls on the OP and subsequent posts are shocking and offensive. Curls are natural and beautiful and DO NOT denote naughtiness or carelessness.

Branleuse · 04/04/2022 12:14

of course teachers judge. When you have to deal with teachers a lot, for instance if your child has SEN, you can absolutely tell which are the ones that think its all because of your terrible parenting, and sometimes you can feel that the whole team have these judgements and have discussed it. Other times you feel like theyre all on your side and want the same thing. Teachers are only human.

PlainJaneEyre · 04/04/2022 12:14

@ThatsNotMyMuffin

I judge the names and manners. We used to joke that on the first day you meet them you can generally rank them up for the by GCSEs they're going to get (I teach a core subject).

I don't ever judge on the looks, I know my own children often end up looking feral despite my best efforts.

Judging on the names is just as bad as judging on looks.
shazzer1978 · 04/04/2022 12:13

@bluebaul

I tend to immediately make assumptions about families where the children have copious long curls, never tied back. I just know they're going to be all tinkly laughs and "oh so liberal" while their kids are probably hooligans!

This is fucking awful. Like seriously. WTF.

I agree! I have long hair and I don’t tie it back. It’s nothing to do with being “oh so liberal” and more that I hate it tied back.

I work with kids and some have untamed hair. I don’t judge them as my hair is hard to tame but I’m still nice I reckon.

I do judge the parents who don’t seem to have any respect for the people looking after their children all day, or who don’t show any joy whatsoever when collecting their children.

AppaTheSixLeggedFlyingBison · 04/04/2022 12:12

NO, I did not know that and frankly, that's GENIUS. As it's never come up because at primary everything is provided, I hadn't even thought of that. But it's a really good idea. Thank you. DS, bless him, told me that he thinks he'll just carry ALL his books for the school day as he knows he's going to struggle with getting Book A and Book B for periods 1 and 2 and then book C and D for Periods 3 and 4 after break etc.

I had to do this at school as there wasn't any lockers. And even if there was secondarys are so big I wouldn't have been organised enough to work out how to get them in time.
I'd recommend a proper backpack, as hiking backpack as you can get without it being "uncool". Key things to look for are proper back support and padding as well as padded straps. I used to cart everything around in a tote bag because "that's what the cool kids did", my back regrets that now

Pumperthepumper · 04/04/2022 12:12

Some of the comments on here are absolutely bonkers.

I can honestly say I don’t judge on any of these markers - but I truly believe that uniform and homework are a complete waste of time.

Shinyandnew1 · 04/04/2022 12:11

Long curly hair which isn’t tied back-I would strongly suspect are riddled with lice.

Otherwise clean polo shirts with whiteboard pen stains on that won’t come out, is one thing. Dirty clothes with 3 day old encrusted bolognese and a strong smell of urine is another.

Yes, I do think badly of parents that never hear their child read. Especially those who should at me because I have only heard them read once that week.

Gonnagetgoing · 04/04/2022 12:11

My DM used to be a primary school teacher in an inner city area and she was also a SENCO. I think she did judge sometimes but she looked deeper into the problems because she knew a lot of the children and their families had problems which required understanding and help.

I recall when I was a teenager and sometimes went to school to help her or on school trips some of the teachers were really quite nasty talking about young children and I think it can be easy to make sweeping statements about a child based on looks/scruffiness etc.

Some parents have more time and inclination to spend time with their children doing homework and some are too busy with working or family life.

PrivateHall · 04/04/2022 12:11

@ThatsNotMyMuffin

I judge the names and manners. We used to joke that on the first day you meet them you can generally rank them up for the by GCSEs they're going to get (I teach a core subject).

I don't ever judge on the looks, I know my own children often end up looking feral despite my best efforts.

Surely you understand the dangers of making assumptions like this and the impact your bias will have on the child - that your assumptions and the impact they have on how you interact with that child may well mean that your predictions come true?

Assume a child won't succeed at the very first meeting, that child doesn't stand a chance.

BlingLoving · 04/04/2022 12:10

Talk tot eh school and if they will let you put bright coloured tape on his books.

Another interesting suggestion, thank you. He's more concerned about popping to his locker between classes. But the higher year groups don't have lockers so I assume they give Year 7s lockers because they're smaller and might not want to carry as much. As he's tall, fit and strong, that's less of an issue. But yes, colour coding overall probably will be a helpful tip. Thank you.

He's good these days about looking for and putting out whatever he needs to wear the next day because he hated the stress when he couldn't find a PE shirt or whatever. And he does this independently with no input from us. So hopefully we can apply the same process for school equipment and books - it might just take a little time to get a routine in place.

OP posts:
LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 04/04/2022 12:09

@BlingLoving

Interesting. I guess it's different types of judgement, even in my OP, and in the answers... eg manners telling you something about a family where a judgement is just broadly negative vs dirty clothes telling you something else that is not so much judgement as figuring out how to support.

Like I said, I tend to immediately make assumptions about families where the children have copious long curls, never tied back. I just know they're going to be all tinkly laughs and "oh so liberal" while their kids are probably hooligans! Grin. x 100 if it's the boys who have these curls. So far I've been right every time but I look forward to being wrong at some point.

Wow. How about a child with sensory needs who struggles to stand having their hair cut and can't stand anything tying it back? I hope none of my DCs teachers are judging like this. I spend countless hours trying to help him cope with basic things, Im certainly not liberal and my DS isn't a hooligan, never once has any tesvers had issues with his behaviour. All humans judge, but that isn't the same thing as being judgemental.
ComDummings · 04/04/2022 12:08

Everybody judges to a degree. Some much less than others but it’s human nature.

lanthanum · 04/04/2022 12:07

On the other hand, I suspect that for most teachers, seeing which homes have lots of books and which don't gives them useful information. Where they can see that there are no books at home, they know that what they send home is crucial, and they may also need to be alert to the possibility that there is nobody at home with enought confidence to hear the child read. (They should be careful about making too many assumptions from the living room, though - we have thousands of books but hardly any in the living room.)

Teachers will always joke about the patterns (I remember a colleague saying that Hayleys are always set 3), and yes, everyone needs to beware unconscious bias - but actually the first step is to recognise the assumptions that you tend to make.

On a liaison visit with a feeder school, a year 6 teacher told me that one child (from a rough family) "thinks you have to be posh to be clever". Interestingly, he had done better in his SATs than his teacher assessed level, and the child of our chair of governors had done worse in the SATs and better on the teacher assessment...

Princetopple · 04/04/2022 12:06

Curls are such an odd thing to make an assumption about though. I don't know why you'd think a child with curly hair which wasn't tied back was from a 'tinkly laugh liberal family' and would be hard work whereas a child with straight hair not tied back wouldn't be.

My son has long curly hair and it's just pretty wild. I imagine that the teachers at his current school would think he was neglected rather than having a precious mother. He's a teenage shower dodger now and I have to constantly nag him to actually comb and wash his hair. The only time he will willingly tie it back is when he's at army cadets because there are consequences if it's not tied up. They're pretty stern. The idea that anybody would think we were tinkly laugh liberals is quite funny. Not sure you get many of those around here.

Whattodoniw · 04/04/2022 12:06

@UsernameInTheTown

I judge my daughter's teacher, she's an utterly vile human being.

Interesting. In what way, if you don't mind me asking?

sashh · 04/04/2022 12:04

@BlingLoving

I judged the full time foster carer who wouldn’t make 5 mins every evening to ensure the lovely, bright but disorganised due SEN year 7 student packed the correct things in his bag.

DS and I are ALREADY talking about this. He has executive function difficulties and he'll be in year 7 next year and I've told him we'll have to make a real effort with ensuring he has the right school books for the day and then for each period etc.

For me, I spend so much time helping him with this sort of thing that sometimes the other things fall by the wayside, which frustrates me (homework, reading etc). eg I try with homework, but just getting him to sit down, with his notebook and pencil, computer loaded up to get the relevant homework etc, can take FOREVER. And that's before we even start. Bearing in mind I'm working full time and that DH works evenings so I'm usually alone in the evenings trying to feed kids, oversee homework, get younger DD to bed etc and often still finishing off work or taking calls/messages from clients in different time zones (run my own business)

On plus side, I think his teacher understands and we have a regular dialogue about what we're doing/not doing at home and what we're prioritising. But I do worry that she thinks I'm not doing enough (although, she was sympathetic when I was basically in tears on one occasion. As a result of that conversation though I do worry that she might think me and DH don' have a good relationship or that I expect too much or that he's a lazy dick. None of which is true!)

Talk tot eh school and if they will let you put bright coloured tape on his books.

So Monday - yellow
Tuesday - Blue etc

So if a book has a yellow and a blue strip you both know it is needed for Monday and Tuesday.

canonlydoblue · 04/04/2022 12:04

I definitely judged before I had my own children. Now I understand a bit more. My three year old has crazy curls. They get tied up before we leave the house and by the time we are at school they have all been pulled out. My children get a clean shirt each day but have usually spilt their breakfast or wiped toothpaste on it by the time we leave. Sometimes I do reading and homework with them - sometimes I ask my eldest to listen to a younger one read, sometimes they read to me in the car on the way to school and sometimes it doesn't happen for a fortnight. I don't consider myself a bad parent.

BlingLoving · 04/04/2022 12:03

I’d not judge the child but some names give you the heads up the parents will be interesting/original/quirky etc

I think this is the sort of thing I meant in my OP! Grin

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread