Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers- be honest please - do you judge or make assumptions?

466 replies

BlingLoving · 04/04/2022 10:38

And if so, how often are you right?

eg when the kid turns up on day one with crazy curls, no hair tie (especially boys) do you immediately think, like I do, "oh no, this family is going to be a bit precious."

Or if the kid's clothes are consistently stained etc, do you chalk that up to parents having limited cash and taking view that school uniform is to be worn (my approach) or do you think they're just careless?

What about the ones who struggle to spend the time doing homework with their DC? Do you think they're just bad parents or are you sympathetic?

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 04/04/2022 14:14

@Myboypink

Primary teacher here- yes i do ! When I hear the names - Mason , Alfie , Billy , Dolly , Ellie-Mai, Demi- Jade - I am already thinking - help !

It is awful but of course I have re judgments . When i hear a parent saying - I ain’t got time to read with him , he does my head in ! I feel so sorry the child and immediately know the sort of parent I am dealing with !

Harsh but true .

That's awful. Just awful - that you make judgments based on names. Which sound mostly completely usual to me, no idea what you are suggesting they signify.
Scottishnewmum · 04/04/2022 14:13

Of course we judge and make assumptions, but unless there is something really bad going on that puts a child at risk, I don't care at all about the family situation. I.e. I might think that a family are disorganised and messy, but I don't care about it if the kid is loved and looked after

Pumperthepumper · 04/04/2022 14:12

@SockFluffInTheBath

I think it’s just different mindsets though. I’d also refuse to allow a school to give my kids detentions and I’d argue that it’s our job to keep kids engaged in lessons. I’m not saying it’s not a complete pain in the arse to keep them on task, more that we should check our priorities. Does giving a detention change the behaviour? No. So work with it. Also, it’s not fair to say it’s the surf kids who seek attention in lessons, everyone has their moments. Long hair is not a symptom of this.

How, as a teacher, do you reconcile not supporting your own DCs’ school’s discipline system? I’ve given 2 detentions in my time- but like you say it’s much better to distract/avoid/entertain to avoid travelling so far down that road. I’ve never taught curly Surf Dude but have one living locally so I’m projecting him and his family into OP’s first post! The hardest kid I ever taught was completely average looking and had a mum at her wits end with him.

Because I don’t think punishments are fair or in any way a good use of time. I will say though, I’m in Scotland and I’ve never taught in a school that uses detentions.
carefullycourageous · 04/04/2022 14:11

On the main point of the thread, I guess judgemental people who go into teaching make judgemental teachers.

I think we are all prone to doing it with some things but only fools don't try to temper it because we are so often wrong.

AlistairCamel · 04/04/2022 14:10

SockFluffInTheBath

Thanks, I’m trying to. Smile

carefullycourageous · 04/04/2022 14:09

@chillylizard

Yes DH is a teacher and does. But his goes around manners more. For example, he says Nigerian families are the best - hard working, well mannered and a pleasure. Similar with Indian and other Asian families. Family culture has a lot to do with it.
You are saying your husband makes racist assumptions?
Anorthernlass · 04/04/2022 14:08

Omg I'm constantly forgetting stuff. I'm now post menopause. Plus I have thyroid disease, and am super stressed for other reasons. Would hate to think my DS teacher thought I was neglecting my kid but tbh I often think that and it makes the anxiety worse.

SockFluffInTheBath · 04/04/2022 14:07

His other teacher shrugs her shoulders at forgotten things.

Probably the one who has kids of their own or who has the common sense/experience to know that most ‘disasters’ have a simple workaround. Take your lead from this teacher @AlistairCamel and ignore other silly one.

AlistairCamel · 04/04/2022 14:03

I know my child’s teacher judged me for forgetting his water bottle a couple of times. She then mentioned something about how upset he was when I forgot his waterproof trousers the week before. I categorically knew I hadn’t. I argued back on it as I knew I hadn’t and she’s seemed less inclined to make judgmental comments since.

What she doesn’t know is I have ADHD and I really struggle to remember everything, no matter how hard I try. The reason I knew I had his waterproof trousers the week before was because I had been in tears trying to find them (ADHD guilt) and eventually got out some old ones which he hates, before finding the correct ones. The old ones were still out on the side a week later (ADHD struggles again!) which is how I was so sure she was mistaken.

His other teacher shrugs her shoulders at forgotten things.

I hope the school know I’m a supportive parent overall. I volunteer to help out with things, always have him there as the gates open or before so I hope they can look beyond my forgetfulness.

BlingLoving · 04/04/2022 14:02

To clarify: it's totally true - I have opinions about the parents, not the child. I say, "child thinks he's better than everyone else" but what I absolutely mean is "when a child has been taught he can do what he likes" or similar ie my rather negative comments about such parents in the OP.

And to the poster who asked if I have ever tried to tie back curly hair.... If there was a emoticon, I'd be using it now. It's not that I have an issue with curly hair it's that the parents I make assumptions about (ie that we will NOT be becoming best friends, by any stretch of the imagination!) are the ones with boys with curly hair they can't bring themselves to DO anything with (well, with one exception where a mum thought her boy's hair was so gorgeous, used loads of products and it just looked dirty!).

Having said that, there is the family at our school whose son has poker straight, extraordinarily thick hair and it was kept long and with nothing to keep it out of things for a long time.... until I noticed the school sent a note round and I did wonder if it was aimed at them! Grin

OP posts:
DarkShade · 04/04/2022 14:00

Honestly OP this sounds like sexism. It annoys you when boys have long curly hair and you think the parents who have let these boys choose their own hair styles are hippies.

Why should they cut it just because they're boys? Why shouldn't their hair be long? They're at school, not prison. Mad to me that you think parents should force kids to conform to how you want them to look, and to afford them the basic right of choosing their own hair is "oh so liberal" and "tinkly laugh". I don't even know what a tinkly laugh is, or why how someone laughs is a stain on their character.

RosesAndHellebores · 04/04/2022 13:59

When my dc were at state primary in a leafy suburb the scruffiest dc belonged to teachers. DH belonged to one and consequently became very pernickety about his clothes when he reached adult hood.

Knockdown43 · 04/04/2022 13:58

@Cherrysoup

We judge constantly. If a child’s clothes are stained and he/she looks uncared for, I’d speak to the head of year, see if the child needs spare uniform. One little lad was in grey sleeves (white shirt), constantly filthy, so I organised spare shirts and to wash his uniform and dry it while he had PE so it wasn’t obvious.

I perfectly understand that some parents don’t have time to do homework, so we make homework easy to complete (links, learning only, offering use of the tablets at lunch)

I hope that most teachers ‘judge’ as we pick up issues that way. I don’t mean look down on parents/children, but notice so we can support.

What a lovely person you are to care for that boy in that way ❤️
Rinatinabina · 04/04/2022 13:56

@FourChimneys

chillylizard that's interesting. A Nigerian mum whose child I taught would always pay double for everything with a note to say the extra was for someone who couldn't afford it. I assumed it was general loveliness but perhaps cultural as well?
Thats seriously lovely and thoughtful.
SockFluffInTheBath · 04/04/2022 13:53

I think it’s just different mindsets though. I’d also refuse to allow a school to give my kids detentions and I’d argue that it’s our job to keep kids engaged in lessons. I’m not saying it’s not a complete pain in the arse to keep them on task, more that we should check our priorities. Does giving a detention change the behaviour? No. So work with it. Also, it’s not fair to say it’s the surf kids who seek attention in lessons, everyone has their moments. Long hair is not a symptom of this.

How, as a teacher, do you reconcile not supporting your own DCs’ school’s discipline system? I’ve given 2 detentions in my time- but like you say it’s much better to distract/avoid/entertain to avoid travelling so far down that road. I’ve never taught curly Surf Dude but have one living locally so I’m projecting him and his family into OP’s first post! The hardest kid I ever taught was completely average looking and had a mum at her wits end with him.

Backtomyoldname · 04/04/2022 13:53

We all make judgments - but for the most part keep them inside and don’t let them affect how we react with others.

Teachers are no different.

There are some, whose behaviour/attitude prized the lid off my calm outerself. Usually it was easier once I’d met the parents and realised why they were like they are.

However the above paragraph only related to 1% The other 99% were fine.

Kanaloa · 04/04/2022 13:52

Although the hair being curly is irrelevant whether it’s straight or curly long hair should be tied back/secured with a headband so it isn’t all over the place and the child is comfortable and not distracted, not sweaty and uncomfortable in pe etc.

danni0509 · 04/04/2022 13:52

@Longcovid21

Just wondering what teachers might think of a six year old boy with no socks? I have a battle with ds everyday when we try on 3 different pairs of socks and he pulls them off screaming. In the end I let him go in with no socks otherwise we would not get there on time. But what would a teacher make of a sockless child?
Is it the seams? Sensory issues? They sell seamless socks (M&S have an adaptive clothing range)

www.marksandspencer.com/3-pairs-of-ultimate-comfort-socks/p/clp22253633?color=GREY

Kanaloa · 04/04/2022 13:51

I think it’s part of a pattern though. It’s normally in uniform rules that hair over a certain length should be tied back - this is firstly for health and safety in gym lessons/playground and home economics/cookery. Secondly it allows the child to concentrate without hair all in their face.

FanFckingTastic · 04/04/2022 13:51

There seems to be a lot of feelings around curly hair. I'm not sure that having long curly hair means that you would be badly behaved, however as a parent I do wonder whether the kids who's hair clearly hasn't seen a brush in a while are more likely to be carrying around a nit-hotel.

knittingaddict · 04/04/2022 13:49

I don't understand the hair thing op. Crazy curly hair is an issue and indicates a problem family? My daughter had crazy curly hair that responded badly to standard hair brushing. Sometimes she wore it tied back and sometimes she didn't. This is a problem?

We are a white family, by the way, just in case the crazy, curly hair is code for something.

godmum56 · 04/04/2022 13:47

@BlingLoving

I reiterate, I have no comments to make on messy hair as that really would be a case of the pot calling the kettle black! Messy, difficult to manage hair is not the same as some kid with surfer style curls who thinks he's better than everyone else.

But then, DH watches a fair bit of rugby and I spend a lot of time exclaiming, "but how can he SEE the ball with all that hair in his face!?"

I think you should invert the statement.....the hair doesn't cause the kid to think he's better than everyone else.....better to say (and think) "some kid who has been taught to think he is better than everyone else and therefore thinks it ok to ignore hair rules at school"
INeedNewShoes · 04/04/2022 13:44

Ah, cross post OP. I see you're referring to a different style of curly hair. I still think you sound unpleasant.

TheNameOfTheRoses · 04/04/2022 13:44

@JudgeJ, tbf some teachers ARE awful.

My dcs have had a couple, one of them in particular was really bad.
The type that told me that if my dc was struggling in english (in reception) it was my fault because I was talking my own language at home Never mind they had a dad that was speaking english. And even so....
The one who told me that same dc was just lazy when actually he was struggling to understand what was going on (following year teacher picked up on that in less than a week. It was that obvious).
And still the same one who told me it wasnt ok for me to take notes during a meeting with her and the HT 'because you are not going to take note of the exact words I am using are you?!?'

That teacher didn't last long but she did a hell of a lot of harm to the children she taught. (And that's wo going into the xenophobia/prejudice she brought to the classroom)

Pumperthepumper · 04/04/2022 13:44

@SockFluffInTheBath

But even still, so what? These kids bring a different experience to a classroom, it should be encouraged. I can’t think of anything worse than teaching a room of identikit, obediently neat robots. It’s creepy.

To a point I’d agree. The trouble is the anti-school kids with anti-school parents are disruptive and time is already tight to fit in the entire syllabus and all the life learning. It’s not ‘interesting’ to the other students in the class to watch the teacher wasting time trying to keep the lesson on track while Surf Dude (and equivalents) does their best to constantly derail because it’s funny- hurr hurr- and if they get a detention Mom will refuse to allow it anyway.

I think it’s just different mindsets though. I’d also refuse to allow a school to give my kids detentions and I’d argue that it’s our job to keep kids engaged in lessons. I’m not saying it’s not a complete pain in the arse to keep them on task, more that we should check our priorities. Does giving a detention change the behaviour? No. So work with it. Also, it’s not fair to say it’s the surf kids who seek attention in lessons, everyone has their moments. Long hair is not a symptom of this.