Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers- be honest please - do you judge or make assumptions?

466 replies

BlingLoving · 04/04/2022 10:38

And if so, how often are you right?

eg when the kid turns up on day one with crazy curls, no hair tie (especially boys) do you immediately think, like I do, "oh no, this family is going to be a bit precious."

Or if the kid's clothes are consistently stained etc, do you chalk that up to parents having limited cash and taking view that school uniform is to be worn (my approach) or do you think they're just careless?

What about the ones who struggle to spend the time doing homework with their DC? Do you think they're just bad parents or are you sympathetic?

OP posts:
SpiderinaWingMirror · 04/04/2022 15:03

I'm my experience, teachers ditch a whole load of judgement when they have their own kids!

Mumofsend · 04/04/2022 15:02

I have two children. One always looks like she has been in an argument with a tornado. The other likes to eat mud on the way in.

DS absolutely won't drink water, he gets flavoured water.

I read with both but I'm awful for signing the bloody books.

I feel I would probably be the most judged mum ConfusedBlush

TerraNovaTwo · 04/04/2022 15:01

I know my DC's teachers judge me. As a lone parent with next to zero support and exH who's an absentee father, I couldn't care less what they think.

BlingLoving · 04/04/2022 15:00

@Anorthernlass

We moved from Asia and my DS teacher said "yeah right" after he told her he'd ridden an elephant (in front of his classmates). Set the stage for a perfect year of primary (not). Also, made similar gagging noises when he was telling the kids about how delicious dim sum is. Kids from overseas get judged as though there is an assumption that because (British) parents dared choose to live abroad that they look down on UK. That is not the case, but we get judged. All. The. Time. I also lived abroad as a kid and had the same experiences.
That's really sad. Definitely falls into the judgement (wrong) part of my post vs assumptions made.
OP posts:
BlackeyedSusan · 04/04/2022 14:58

@PhileasPhilby

No I don’t judge. I do get to know the children and their families really well and I do learn about them and their home lives. I try to support them.

Sometimes I get frustrated when I know a child would really benefit from something that - for whatever reason - their families aren’t able to provide. But I also try to understand why families aren’t able to do that.

I also check my privilege so eg if my own dc have toothpaste on their uniform I know no-one is going to make assumptions about me not caring for them properly (because the proper school shoes, Boden coat, smiggle bag, ‘posh’ accent etc etc), unlike the single mum on a v. tight income. Because all sorts of people are making judgments all the time.

Yes, some people get a free pass for something others would not.
MsMarch · 04/04/2022 14:58

@hiredandsqueak I can sort of see the appeal of that process and why it might be helpful in some circumstances but I'd be very worried children are being taught that things can always be adjusted to suit them which just isn't true.

Bewilderbeest · 04/04/2022 14:57

@ToughLoveLDN You raise it in writing with the member of staff who is the “designated safeguarding lead” in your school. As a classroom teacher you don’t contact the parents directly - doing that could in certain circumstances put a child at risk.

Pumperthepumper · 04/04/2022 14:57

@hiredandsqueak was that in Scotland? I’m only asking because I don’t think anti-punishment schools are that unusual up here. I can’t think of any who still have a punishment system. I only know of two with a reward system, actually,

Anorthernlass · 04/04/2022 14:57

We moved from Asia and my DS teacher said "yeah right" after he told her he'd ridden an elephant (in front of his classmates). Set the stage for a perfect year of primary (not). Also, made similar gagging noises when he was telling the kids about how delicious dim sum is. Kids from overseas get judged as though there is an assumption that because (British) parents dared choose to live abroad that they look down on UK. That is not the case, but we get judged. All. The. Time. I also lived abroad as a kid and had the same experiences.

hiredandsqueak · 04/04/2022 14:54

@SockFluffInTheBath my dd attends an independent specialist school where there are no punishments/ detentions/ behaviour points etc. Every action is considered communication and so the school would look at the reason behind the behaviour and establish what they could alter so the young person didn't have to repeat the behaviour to be heard.
Children in her school have often been excluded from other schools (sometimes multiple times) or had school refusal due to high anxiety (like dd)
It seems to work alongside no uniforms, staff use first names and an awful lot of flexibility on the school's part. So one day last term dd's teacher phoned to say d was refusing the planned lesson as was her friend. We discussed why, alternative lesson offered, teacher for lesson later in day alerted that they wouldn't manage that lesson (reason for refusal in first place was because they were anxious about later lesson and were trying to save themselves for later stress) later lesson altered too. D and friend did both alternative lessons, planned lessons will be reworked to make them accessible at another time.

BlingLoving · 04/04/2022 14:54

@Kanaloa

It’s also just a hazard during PE generally - hair should be tied back so it doesn’t catch other children/get caught by other children.
DD has long curly hair. If we've just washed it and brushed it she sometimes likes to wear it in a half ponytail - so it's off her face (as per school requirements) but loose at the back. But she knows she can only do this on a normal day, not a PE day as her teacher makes it clear that hair flying around during PE is a safety issue. She's also old enough now that she can retie it or get it off her face alone so often has a spare hair tie in her back. It's not neat, that's for sure, but it does mean she can make sure to have hair that works for whatever activity she's doing!

I took it less well when the school took it on themselves to give her a massive headband of the style the Duchess of Cambridge wears to formal events for school photos once..I assume because it was a bit frizzy that day!

OP posts:
WalltoWallBtards · 04/04/2022 14:53

PS Theo will drink water, does drink water once the sugary crap is taken away as an option.
They all drink water, all the live long day without a peep!

Pumperthepumper · 04/04/2022 14:52

[quote SockFluffInTheBath]@Pumperthepumper sorry I forgot what you said about your school. I agree about nipping things in the bud but I’m interested in your experience of that being a whole school policy with no official punishment. Are the students ‘fixed’ before they get the point of warranting a detention (in other schools) or does the lack of deterrent ‘encourage’ the students with challenging behaviour? Sorry for all the questions, I’m genuinely interested. I’ve worked in schools with a general ethos to support not punish, but there’s still always been an official line with detention at the end.[/quote]
No, if by ‘fixed’ you mean ‘never misbehave’ then of course not. It’s obviously difficult to go into too much detail anonymously but the general kid in my school acts out because of something fairly major going on at home. So the school culture is no punishments, because 1) they don’t work and 2) they would just make that kid’s life extra shit for a bit of time. But it’s not a perfect system - the staff have to be of the same mindset for it to work, and I know one of my colleagues is miserable and looking for a new job, because they feel unsupported. I can appreciate that, but I still think our school ethos is necessary for the sake of the kids we teach.

WalltoWallBtards · 04/04/2022 14:51

I sure as hell wouldn’t judge a child for having long curly hair, tho if you don’t want nits on your kid TIE IT back!
The parents who get on my tits are the ‘i don’t believe in homework, my Emmy is too creative to wear the uniform properly she just HAS to put her spin on it, Theo HAS to have a (banned) juice in his lunch box because he just won’t drink water’ mob.
Basically the ones who send their kid to a school with strict discipline rules then complain the whole time that it’s too restricted…

SockFluffInTheBath · 04/04/2022 14:51

I don’t think OP, or anyone else, said curly hair automatically infers all the negative qualities as if it’s The Problem- it was part of the package on a type of student. There’s really no need for the outrage from mums of curly boys who behave like decent human beings, maybe rtft?

Anorthernlass · 04/04/2022 14:49

@GregBrawlsInDogJail

Is it important to sign the flaming reading diary? I do read with, or to, the DC every day but frankly I prioritise the doing over the writing it in the diary. DC are reading ahead of age so am sure there are no concerns on that front, but I only do the diary every so often when guilt strikes I have the time.
Lol we never sign the diary. DS is free reader and was since year 4 anyway and it's ridiculous. He also likes to research a lot amd read magazines, articles, etc., but his teacher used to say that didn't count. Same teacher who never acknowledged how many books he read so he never received his reward - 50 in a year when he was aiming for it. I wonder if she had judged him 🤔??
ToughLoveLDN · 04/04/2022 14:48

This is so interesting to read.

For the teachers, if you notice something with a child in their behaviour that could be a sign of something they may need some help with at what point do you contact the parents? Or is there like a special channel that you have to go through?

Or say for example if the child coming in is smelly or dirty etc and this is noticed on a regular basis, how is this kind of thing handled?

Kanaloa · 04/04/2022 14:45

It’s also just a hazard during PE generally - hair should be tied back so it doesn’t catch other children/get caught by other children.

Kanaloa · 04/04/2022 14:44

@mam0918

Kanaloa - I never tie up my hair and didn't as a child either as I hated it and I have always had long hair, my hair is mega fine and bobbles tear it apart and leave severe damage and bald spots - my son has the same hair as me.

I have NEVER had lice, my hair doesn't bother me at all, doesn't get 'sweaty' any more than anyone else's and of course it's not dirty/unhygienic any more than tied up hair (what a bizarre assumption to make - and neither me nor my 4-year-old work as a chef so no food prep issues lol).

What magic do you think is contained within a ring of elastic that repeals parasites, stops sweat and cleans hair?

Obviously I don’t think hair ties are magic. And of course your child doesn’t work in food prep - they will presumably do home ec at a certain age and probably baking at primary.

Having hair all over the face while doing sports/active play can definitely contribute to the child getting sweatier than if it’s tied back. And of course it’s more likely to get dirty when it’s swinging all around as it’s more likely to touch the face, paints being used, messy play substances etc. Same with lice, if it’s neatly tied back it’s less likely to touch other people’s hair.

Bewilderbeest · 04/04/2022 14:43

@TheNameOfTheRoses Not sure why you took what I said so badly - if people act unpleasantly, is it a surprise if people judge them? I have no idea what issues you went through with your child and their teachers but attacking a random teacher on the internet for something I haven’t done suggests it must have been pretty awful. I’m sorry that’s been your experience of our profession.

Giraffesandbottoms · 04/04/2022 14:42

@MajesticallyAwkward

Well quite! Sometimes DS has beautiful ringlets just below his ears, and sometimes it looks like a bird’s nest. And sometimes it gets squashed somehow and looks lank and sad and less curly but longer, despite being washed and brushed daily! Never knew someone would be assuming i am some sort of feckless parent and he thinks he’s better than everyone else.

DelphiniumBlue · 04/04/2022 14:42

@hiredandsqueak

Dgs has a head of curls, it's not long hair as such as it only reaches his collar. Each time dd has it cut his hair gets bigger not shorter as without the length to pull the curls down the curls just get tighter. It's not long enough to tie back. I'm incredulous that dd and dgs could be judged purely because of hair they can do nothing about particularly as dd is completely opposite of the sort of parent who you assume have boys with long curls.
He sounds very sweet, but if it's collar length that is not really " long curls". I tell children with long hair that it needs to be tied back because of nits, and mostly they do tie it back. I'm not fussed about uniform really, although my school does have a fairly strict uniform policy, I'm more concerned that the children are appropriately dressed for the activities they will be doing - so shoes/trainers they can run in and do up themselves. You'd be surprised ( well, I was, as parent of boys) at the number of girls who come to school in ballet style shoes - that is within the uniform policy if they are flat and black, but they can't run properly in them and they provide very little protection against the weather. I judge those parents, and I judged the very few parents who sent in their children in dirty/grimy/smelly clothes ( I don't mean stained, I mean unwashed - , not even sponged down. )But then I found out that some of the families are living in conditions where they don't have facilities to wash clothes, some temporary accommodation is absolutely terrible. I recall one child who had the same (holey) socks on for more than a week, and when I chatted to her one day it turned out that her Mum was in hospital with a very sick younger sibling, and this girl and her 6 other siblings were staying with auntie, who also had a number of children, in a flat. Auntie was working miracles just housing, feeding and getting these children to school - replacing holey socks was a) not in her budget and b) way down her list of priorities. So I try not to judge, but to ask questions if I see something that was worrying, so that we can arrange support if possible.
Longcovid21 · 04/04/2022 14:42

I think id quite like the surfer dude with messy hair and his liberal parents. We are going to need free thinking people who challenge the status quo in the future. Obedience is something that can work against you in the world of work. I wonder if we are just teaching children to conform sometimes. Id probably dance with glee at a class of non conformists with cool names. But that's just me.

mam0918 · 04/04/2022 14:41

Kanaloa - I never tie up my hair and didn't as a child either as I hated it and I have always had long hair, my hair is mega fine and bobbles tear it apart and leave severe damage and bald spots - my son has the same hair as me.

I have NEVER had lice, my hair doesn't bother me at all, doesn't get 'sweaty' any more than anyone else's and of course it's not dirty/unhygienic any more than tied up hair (what a bizarre assumption to make - and neither me nor my 4-year-old work as a chef so no food prep issues lol).

What magic do you think is contained within a ring of elastic that repeals parasites, stops sweat and cleans hair?

Okaaaay · 04/04/2022 14:38

@WelshTiger I find some of what you write difficult to read (my issue - not yours for writing it).

I adore my children - they are well mannered and behaved, fed and looked after, have lots of experiences etc. They are not perfect (and I am clear about when they step over boundaries). However, my husband and I also have busy, full time jobs which are important to us too. My children have privilege and understand that the reason why they have that is because we work hard for it. It also means some sacrifices for them - which we talk about together. Evenings are really tough - time is limited and I don’t always have time to take art out of folders (or even realise it’s there), plant seeds, make costumes or listen to them read (we always read TO them but sometimes my 5 year old DD is too tired to read to me at 7.30pm (sometimes we forget). We probably listen to her read twice / thrice a week. It’s definitely not through lack of care of her wellbeing. Just pure survival in the midst of the juggle. Do I make them a healthy dinner or listen to them read. Do I do the washing or buy all the stuff to plant the sunflowers. It’s hard.

Swipe left for the next trending thread