Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers- be honest please - do you judge or make assumptions?

466 replies

BlingLoving · 04/04/2022 10:38

And if so, how often are you right?

eg when the kid turns up on day one with crazy curls, no hair tie (especially boys) do you immediately think, like I do, "oh no, this family is going to be a bit precious."

Or if the kid's clothes are consistently stained etc, do you chalk that up to parents having limited cash and taking view that school uniform is to be worn (my approach) or do you think they're just careless?

What about the ones who struggle to spend the time doing homework with their DC? Do you think they're just bad parents or are you sympathetic?

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 04/04/2022 15:58

@Fairislefandango

England?

Yes. Various parts.

Yes. I think there is a different approach to education generally in Scotland.
BlingLoving · 04/04/2022 15:58

I just think it is such a weird, and such a specific thing to judge a family on, why would the OP focus on that to ask teachers about?

Well, in my defence, I didn't. It was one example I gave. I asked if there were things that teachers spot up front that immediately lead to them making assumptions. We've all just got rather bogged down on my personal example of where I make assumptions! Grin

OP posts:
FluffyDogMother · 04/04/2022 15:57

[quote hiredandsqueak]@Pumperthepumper No it's East Midlands, it seemingly works as children with behaviour that had them excluded lots of times don't feel the need to repeat it when the rigidity and consequences are gone.
@MsMarch All the children in dd's school have been damaged by the school process and frankly if they weren't in that school they would most likely be out of education altogether. None of them believe the world revolves around them I don't think but I do think that they learn to trust that adults can help, they deserve that help and they can learn with the right support in the right environment.[/quote]
I'm guessing these are specialist schools though with funding coming in that mainstream don't have access to?
And pupil to adult ratio is higher than mainstream in order to support these children's individual educational needs?

If so, not something that can be replicated in mainstream with 30 kids per class

SunshineCake1 · 04/04/2022 15:55

@ThatsNotMyMuffin

I judge the names and manners. We used to joke that on the first day you meet them you can generally rank them up for the by GCSEs they're going to get (I teach a core subject).

I don't ever judge on the looks, I know my own children often end up looking feral despite my best efforts.

Bit stupid to judge a child by their name since they didn't choose it. They were named by their parents. So thick of people to look down on, or criticise, someone by the name they have which was given to them by someone else...
Goodyetalso · 04/04/2022 15:55

It’s impossible not to make judgements especially as teachers always have to be alert to any signs of potential problems, but the judgements I automatically make aren’t necessarily the ones you’d assume that someone would make. If a child is often late and scruffy, I would automatically assume that the parent(s) have poor organisational skills. I would bear the lateness and scruffiness in mind and when interacting with the parents and chatting with the child throughout the school day you can often tell if this is the reason or if it’s something more concerning or that needs actioning. It’s not necessarily a red flag, more a small marker to check a bit further to see if our initial judgement is correct.

I’ve met loads of parents as a teacher and really liked the vast majority of them no matter what their circumstances were and what problems they had. The ones that persistently wind me up are a)” the ones who don’t listen to their child read and b) the over the top try hard ones who do their kids homework for them (always very obvious when the parents have done it) and are constantly pushing and pushing their poor kids who just need to chill out a bit.

mathanxiety · 04/04/2022 15:52

@BlingLoving, how nice for you that your DD would let you touch her hair.

Fairislefandango · 04/04/2022 15:49

England?

Yes. Various parts.

oakleaffy · 04/04/2022 15:48

What a bizarre thing to pre~judge a child on..''Curly hair?''

I do know someone who taught 'A' levels, and he said ''I can generally tell who will get an 'A' grade in the first week.
But that was on the basis of their first essays.
Another said ''You never have trouble with students who sit at the front bench -At the beginning of Autumn term.

Kennykenkencat · 04/04/2022 15:47

@AG1981

I am a teacher. I also have an autistic child. Those judging I'm on behaviour, make sure it isn't undiagnosed SEN rather than poor parenting.

I used to judge behaviour and blame parents entirely for it, as a young teacher. I was wrong to do that and I've learned that the hard way!

Ds would go into school looking like he had been dragged through a hedge backwards. Dirty finger nails hair a mess, clothes a mess.

He had walked through the front door 20 minutes before with clean and ironed clothes, clean fingers and combed hair. He would make it his purpose in life to stick his hands (and sometimes his head) in the soil of the flowerbeds each morning and roll around on the front lawn in his clean ironed uniform whilst giggling away.

With another slightly older child who couldn’t be trusted to not just run out in to the road so I always had to have a hand on Dd it was impossible to stop him.
Baby wipes and short nails for Ds to get most of the dirt off but he wasn’t exactly clean and tidy when he arrived at school.

The teachers were so busy judging me that when I asked about an assessment for dyslexia as Ds wasn’t making progress academically.
The impression I got was they thought I was just trying to find a deflection from ds’s issues and to them it was purely down to poor parenting.

Ds never did get a dyslexia assessment in school. He didn’t read properly until he was 12 years old

One of the children in his class who was very well behaved and very academic. Their mum approached me a few years later to apologise for thinking I was a very poor parent with no discipline.

She had gone on to have another child who was the opposite to the academically bright well behaved eldest child and suddenly getting down to the child’s level and explaining you don’t want to see certain behaviours and the child complying she realised was not about being an excellent parent and more about having a child who wasn't going to do anything naughty anyway.

Suddenly she was the one who people were talking about as a bad parent.

RazzlePuff · 04/04/2022 15:47

Judgmental about curly hair? Do you believe all curls are “crazy” & child is suffering bad parenting? Get over yourself. Curly hair is curly. Never occurred to me that people judge parenting skills on child having curls, yes even on a boy. Curls are lovely, boys / girls don’t need to be shorn or have hair restrained to please you curl haters. This is the weirdest thing I ever heard — judging kids with curls.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 04/04/2022 15:39

@bluebaul

I tend to immediately make assumptions about families where the children have copious long curls, never tied back. I just know they're going to be all tinkly laughs and "oh so liberal" while their kids are probably hooligans!

This is fucking awful. Like seriously. WTF.

I just think it is such a weird, and such a specific thing to judge a family on, why would the OP focus on that to ask teachers about?
Pumperthepumper · 04/04/2022 15:38

@Fairislefandango

I think it’s just different mindsets though. I’d also refuse to allow a school to give my kids detentions and I’d argue that it’s our job to keep kids engaged in lessons.

This sounds like a different world tbh. I've worked in quite a lot of secondary schools, and the only one which didn't use detentions was a very lovely, elite private girls' school.

Of course teachers try to keep students engaged in lessons. That doesn't mean it's always possible. Some of the behaviour we see (both in lessons and out of lessons) is frankly worthy of reporting to the police, never mind being given a measly detention. And that's in a pretty normal, standard state comprehensive in a nice area, not a sink school in a deprived or dangerous area. And the worst-behaved kids are by no means always those with mitigating issues at home. I think schools should have more powers to punish and exclude, not fewer. If my dc misbehaved I'd totally support them getting detentions.

England?
Fairislefandango · 04/04/2022 15:35

I think it’s just different mindsets though. I’d also refuse to allow a school to give my kids detentions and I’d argue that it’s our job to keep kids engaged in lessons.

This sounds like a different world tbh. I've worked in quite a lot of secondary schools, and the only one which didn't use detentions was a very lovely, elite private girls' school.

Of course teachers try to keep students engaged in lessons. That doesn't mean it's always possible. Some of the behaviour we see (both in lessons and out of lessons) is frankly worthy of reporting to the police, never mind being given a measly detention. And that's in a pretty normal, standard state comprehensive in a nice area, not a sink school in a deprived or dangerous area. And the worst-behaved kids are by no means always those with mitigating issues at home. I think schools should have more powers to punish and exclude, not fewer. If my dc misbehaved I'd totally support them getting detentions.

hiredandsqueak · 04/04/2022 15:33

[quote SockFluffInTheBath]**@MsMarch All the children in dd's school have been damaged by the school process and frankly if they weren't in that school they would most likely be out of education altogether. None of them believe the world revolves around them I don't think but I do think that they learn to trust that adults can help, they deserve that help and they can learn with the right support in the right environment.

I think it’s crucial to acknowledge this. We, as adults, are ‘allowed’ to have trust issues, to let experiences for us- but we don’t extend that to young people, they’re just supposed to behave and get on with it.[/quote]
On paper dd is the perfect student she had never misbehaved in school she always did exactly as she was told every time without question, she has an IQ of 162 so the academics aren't a challenge but school broke her. Her teacher and I silently cheered the day she refused because it signified that she had recognised her needs and for the first time in her life she didn't swallow down the anxiety and push through regardless.

SockFluffInTheBath · 04/04/2022 15:27

@NeverDropYourMooncup what an amazing post, thank you. I’m sorry for your childhood.

Those who aren't neglectful or abusive but just think normal expectations don't apply to them are a pain in the arse because they cloud the issue for children who are in horrible circumstances. Mrs Bohemian Free Spirit with her Surfer Boy and Mr We Practise Gentle Parenting, along with Ms Oh I'm such a Ditz or I'm Very Very Important with my Big Job You Know enable the utter bastards to operate unseen.

This is absolutely the problem- unnecessary diversion of time and resource.

BorsetshireBanality · 04/04/2022 15:21

My DD’s reception teacher was very judgemental. She was moving up to be a year 1 teacher and had kept all the middle class boys in her new class and imported in the middle-class girls while the lower socio-ecomomic group children were put in the other year 1 classes. Luckily DD’s new Y1 teacher was lovely and kind as well as a brilliant teacher and had a really good calming influence on the children. If she was judging the patents she hid it very well, unlike the reception teacher. No very naughty, ethnic, or outside of school-gate—parent clique children left languishing to the last weeks of summer term to get their turn to have the class bear or not get a star of the week either.

Lndnmummy · 04/04/2022 15:21

@ThatsNotMyMuffin

I judge the names and manners. We used to joke that on the first day you meet them you can generally rank them up for the by GCSEs they're going to get (I teach a core subject).

I don't ever judge on the looks, I know my own children often end up looking feral despite my best efforts.

This is awful. I am horrified. I despair that children have people like you as teachers.
Imtryingveryhard · 04/04/2022 15:16

@FourChimneys

chillylizard that's interesting. A Nigerian mum whose child I taught would always pay double for everything with a note to say the extra was for someone who couldn't afford it. I assumed it was general loveliness but perhaps cultural as well?
That’s a lovely thing for a parent to do.
NeverDropYourMooncup · 04/04/2022 15:15

@Lady089

Maybe teachers are judging the wrong things! How many teachers have failed to miss clear signs of abuse and neglect? This thread has made me think less of teachers to be honest!
That has context to it. You have to see all the tiny details and consider why.

If I see a lad whose 4C hair is in need of attention and his skin is very dry, I can see there could be something happening at home affecting the ability to care for him. Is his Mum or Dad working ridiculous hours? Has his big sister left home/had an argument/too stressed with exams to do what she would normally do for him? Is somebody unwell and the effort is impossible? Is it that they can't afford the skin and hair care they would normally use?

If another kid doesn't have clean clothes to the extent that it looks as though she's slept in them for a week, no books or PE kit and I've not seen her eat at lunch or breaktime, I'd be wondering in there are financial issues, a washing machine breakdown or whether something has happened that means they aren't at home (did they have to leave with only the clothes on their backs late at night? Has there been a house fire or roof damaged in a storm? Are both parents still living with them? Is there actually an adult there at all when they wake up in the morning?).

If another is extremely volatile all of a sudden or quiet and withdrawn, what's going on there?

Is this a change from normal? Is normal already less than optimal care? Is Mum or Dad very confrontational, disinterested, helicoptery, fond of the 'Bohemian' image? Do their smiles go all the way up to their eyes or is it more like they're baring their teeth at you? Is that fist forming movement at pickup or parents' evening them stretching a sore, arthritic hand, a subtle attempt to calm themselves because they're feeling stressed in a busy hall, or is it a subconscious expression of what they would do to that child if only they weren't in front of witnesses? Is the child getting a smile at the same time as a 'Just. You. Wait.' message telegraphed by the eyes?

One of the things that irritates me about the insistence upon wearing blazers all the time is that you can't see marks on the wrists/lower arms or an unwashed shirt easily and a makeshift bandage to deal with pain in the elbow following being grabbed and an arm twisted is invisible. Dangly hair is used to disguise where a blow could have caught a part of the face/side of the head where bruising would be visible. A pair of thick tights still being worn with holes in and unwashed for four days could be hiding bruising on the legs that would be visible with clean socks. Especially if the PE kit doesn't appear that week, either.

Is the homework being missed because the reaction to doing it at home is an utter meltdown (DD2's reaction - school work was for school, not for home, as far as she was concerned)? Is it because there's nowhere to do it? Does it require equipment they don't have and can't afford? Is the house a mess because a parent is a hoarder and they can't find anything once it's put down? Is it because there's not enough light or heat? Or are they keeping their heads down whilst somebody is being abused or the reaction to disturbing a parent/waking them up for help is worse than the teacher's reaction at school the next day?

Or is the being unkempt, disorganised and clumsy all part of an abusive parent's carefully crafted image to ensure that the kid never says anything, if they do, it's dismissed with a tinkly little laugh as 'oh, we just can't do a thing with it/she hates having it cut or brushed', and the child is being physically and emotionally abused and neglected under a veil of respectability?

I'm very alert to those possibilities because I was one of those abused children.

Those who aren't neglectful or abusive but just think normal expectations don't apply to them are a pain in the arse because they cloud the issue for children who are in horrible circumstances. Mrs Bohemian Free Spirit with her Surfer Boy and Mr We Practise Gentle Parenting, along with Ms Oh I'm such a Ditz or I'm Very Very Important with my Big Job You Know enable the utter bastards to operate unseen.

It might not be one big thing that leads to recognising a child is in trouble. It could be a culmination of tiny things all put together. So staff have to notice everything, including the stuff that's not 'important'. To notice is to judge in some people's eyes. Well, yeah, it's judging that this isn't what is expected, part of the rules, a standard behaviour, a disproportionate reaction - it's an anomaly. And it's the anomalies that can lead to discovering something massive.

SockFluffInTheBath · 04/04/2022 15:13

*Form us

SockFluffInTheBath · 04/04/2022 15:13

@MsMarch All the children in dd's school have been damaged by the school process and frankly if they weren't in that school they would most likely be out of education altogether. None of them believe the world revolves around them I don't think but I do think that they learn to trust that adults can help, they deserve that help and they can learn with the right support in the right environment.

I think it’s crucial to acknowledge this. We, as adults, are ‘allowed’ to have trust issues, to let experiences for us- but we don’t extend that to young people, they’re just supposed to behave and get on with it.

Nillynally · 04/04/2022 15:12

Yes of course we do but not necessarily about what you've described. Unkempt and dirty is nothing to do with money, it's quite often parents with little time. Children who are aggressive or nasty to others I judge to have parents that speak the same to them. Attention seekers are exactly that, they crave the attention they don't get at home. You can usually tell which children come from a warm and loving home and those that don't.

MsMarch · 04/04/2022 15:09

[quote hiredandsqueak]@Pumperthepumper No it's East Midlands, it seemingly works as children with behaviour that had them excluded lots of times don't feel the need to repeat it when the rigidity and consequences are gone.
@MsMarch All the children in dd's school have been damaged by the school process and frankly if they weren't in that school they would most likely be out of education altogether. None of them believe the world revolves around them I don't think but I do think that they learn to trust that adults can help, they deserve that help and they can learn with the right support in the right environment.[/quote]
Sounds like it's a very specific approach for vey specific children and is working, so that's great!

SockFluffInTheBath · 04/04/2022 15:06

@hiredandsqueak that sounds fantastic, I’m glad you were able to find that school for your daughter.

@Pumperthepumper thanks for coming back to me. Its great what a whole staff approach can do.

hiredandsqueak · 04/04/2022 15:06

@Pumperthepumper No it's East Midlands, it seemingly works as children with behaviour that had them excluded lots of times don't feel the need to repeat it when the rigidity and consequences are gone.
@MsMarch All the children in dd's school have been damaged by the school process and frankly if they weren't in that school they would most likely be out of education altogether. None of them believe the world revolves around them I don't think but I do think that they learn to trust that adults can help, they deserve that help and they can learn with the right support in the right environment.

Swipe left for the next trending thread