Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SAHM for five years or so - AIBU?

160 replies

Whyisitsowet · 04/04/2022 07:46

I’m really not enjoying work at all and while there are advantages to my working most of these aren’t immediate - they are things we may benefit from in later life (pension) or when we retire.

Am really considering not going back after maternity leave second time around until school age so five / six years or so.

I can’t work out if sensible or not - what are your experiences?

OP posts:
Swayingpalmtrees · 04/04/2022 09:33

I genuinely feel sorry for you clymene You sound compromised, shall we say.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 04/04/2022 09:32

You need to both try it out and see if it works for you and your DH.
He will be the main earner and you the main care giver, so it has to be a mutual decision.
Talk about expectations straight away. If he doesn't expect you to provide financially, he might expect you to do most/all of the house work.
Resentment is the biggest thing I think, with both thinking the other has it easier.
If you're in a loving and mutually respectful marriage, then it works well.

Job wise, only you can decide, but it sounds like you don't like your job, so maybe a career change might help.

Clymene · 04/04/2022 09:29

@Swayingpalmtrees

I remember why I avoid threads like this now, it makes me so sad to think of the babies and children that have had such a negative childhood experience as their mothers seemed to hate being with them and couldn't wait to leave them. There is something so sad and damaging about some of these posts. It is one thing to have to work out of necessity, quite another to claim it was so awful being at home with your children, so utterly depressing that you couldn't wait to get away. Same people have more kids, unbelievable.

I am out op, I hope you choose something that makes you and your little ones happy, remember the regrets in life on deathbeds are very rarely about wishing to work more but regrets about not spending more time with families.

www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2012/feb/01/top-five-regrets-of-the-dying

Be happy op. All the best.

CRY! LAMENT ALL THE POOR BABIES WITH THE CRUEL MOTHERS WHO HATE THEM ENOUGH TO LEAVE THEM TO WORK

SadSadSadSadSadSadSadSadSadSadSadSad

Don't be so fucking melodramatic

NottheSAHP · 04/04/2022 09:26

Realise it's perhaps not the same when it's the man that has taken the career break. But DH - teacher - was the SAHP for ten years. He started when the oldest was nine months and my maternity leave finished. After about six months he picked up an hour or two of tutoring each week at a time that suited him. He did more or less tutoring each year depending on nap times and DC schedules. I think the most was around 15 lessons a week and that was a bit much! After eight years he picked up a very part time job in a school - two classes per week at first (though even that was a pain to fit around DC schedules) and built it up, doing extra curricular clubs and a bit of cover, until he had the confidence to apply for a full time role. He was ready to go back at that point and loved being a full time teacher again.

So I think, being a teacher, you're in an excellent position to try being the SAHP for a while if you want to. I hope you enjoy the experiment!

GuyDiamond · 04/04/2022 09:26

I did a sort of halfway house version of SAHM, where I mainly SAH and then took very part time jobs (for my own sanity and some extra money for fun stuff). I did this for 6 years and have just been offered a full time job, which I'm taking.

I loved it, but there were times I felt a bit crap about not having my own income and not paying any of the household bills etc.

Also, being at home with two very small children, was hard at times. I was quite glad to get some "me time" when I went to work.

SAHM would be lovely when dcs are primary age I think, as you'd have time to do lots in the house and still get a good amount of time with dcs. Obviously, financially, it wouldn't be the best though.

I think sahm with preschool children is pretty stressful. We only did it as it didn't make sense financially for us to send them both to nursery. It wasn't the easier going option for us and I did find it hard at times.

Pension contributions is an important one. I'd actually try to keep paying into a pension if you do decide to SAH. I didn't do this myself though, but I do regret it.

Swayingpalmtrees · 04/04/2022 09:26

I remember why I avoid threads like this now, it makes me so sad to think of the babies and children that have had such a negative childhood experience as their mothers seemed to hate being with them and couldn't wait to leave them. There is something so sad and damaging about some of these posts.
It is one thing to have to work out of necessity, quite another to claim it was so awful being at home with your children, so utterly depressing that you couldn't wait to get away. Same people have more kids, unbelievable.

I am out op, I hope you choose something that makes you and your little ones happy, remember the regrets in life on deathbeds are very rarely about wishing to work more but regrets about not spending more time with families.

www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2012/feb/01/top-five-regrets-of-the-dying

Be happy op. All the best.

dottydodah · 04/04/2022 09:25

Could you maybe register for a supply Teacher ? Maybe something like this may work .Otherwise a 4 day week .My friend is a primary Teacher and has 1 day a week off. TBH a pension is a way off ,maybe if you went back in 5 years ,you would still be able to get in maybe 10 or 15 years which would increase pension a lot .

Caramelcap · 04/04/2022 09:24

Can you either supply teach or job share?

My son's childminder teaches two days a week and child-minds the other three.

I also have a friend who is a qualified secondary school teacher but her husband is in the army so when they're posted somewhere away from friends/family she does supply so she can be there to pick up kids if needed.

Might be an idea so it's not too hard to get back into FT teaching when you're ready?

notanothertakeaway · 04/04/2022 09:23

I'd look at reducing to part time, rather than leave completely. That might be a good compromise. For many people, it's the best of both worlds

But I predict this thread will turn into a bunfight SAHM v WOHM

EmeraldShamrock1 · 04/04/2022 09:22

Oh missed you're a qualified teacher.

You'd be mad to give up work altogether.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 04/04/2022 09:21

If you are preparing to stay at home put a plan in place for yourself by studying while at home.

Do a degree.

It is very difficult to find decent work when you've had a break.

The winners in these situations are the ones who prepare to bounce back better once the DC start schools.

Changeee1546789 · 04/04/2022 09:20

I haven’t RTWT but I have posted about a similar thing before under a different name. Lots of people were saying hang in there as when the kids gets older you’ll regret leaving career etc. which is totally valid and yes you need to protect yourself for future. But. Ive worked part time to full time over the years in my (stressful) profession (my DCs are 5&8) and it has been bloody hard. If we’d had the money to I would have been off as a SAHM without a second thought. Having said that we’ve had the money to save and go on wonderful trips and my kids get to do v cool clubs etc. I’m still ploughing on with work despite having meltdowns every so often. Teaching would be easy enough to get back into compared to other professions. You’ll never get the time back.

Sandles12 · 04/04/2022 09:16

Hi, I'm a teacher on mat leave with similar thoughts to you. I'm going back 4 days a week with slightly later starts. My main concern is childcare logistics etc. Could you apply for a career break if 3 or 5 years then you can return to work. I'm considering this option further future. I also have two young children and childcare will be v costly.

Snoken · 04/04/2022 09:12

I think I would try it if I were you. You don't have to commit to being off for 5-6 years, just take it year by year to see how you get on financially and mentally.

Also, would you consider tutoring a few hours a week? That you could do in the evenings or weekends when your DH (might) be home to look after the kids so it doesn't incur any childcare costs. That way you are also making a bit of money and it would lessen the burden on your DH if that is a concern.

Brefugee · 04/04/2022 09:10

I don't know why it is considered a sin to want to look after and spend some time with your own children op!

Since nobody actually says that it must all be in your head.

Yes pension top ups

The thing is that when you are young and not scrabbling round to afford heating and/or eating when your 60+ it is easy to think that a pension isn't something worth mentioning. But if you ask women here, especially the ones who have been so badly treated (WASPI) then you might think differently.

extra money for tat you don't actually need is all well and good, but the ability to enjoy the children you have is to me worth more than anything else in the world.

I have yet to fathom why seemingly everyone thinks that as soon as basic needs have been met, mumsnetters immediately buy tat? I don't buy tat and never have. I think some things are tat that others love and want. And vice versa.

And, frankly, i was a SAHP for a while, it drove me bonkers. I couldn't wait to get back to work and it was the best thing for my family.

That is how these things should be judged: what is good for the family, and how will possibly unforseen but horribly regular disasters be handled?

Orangutanteddy · 04/04/2022 09:08

Don't know if it's an option in the UK but here in Ireland secondary teachers can jobshare assuming they're permanent. If you're doing 22 hours a week, you can do 6, for example, as long as the school can find someone to do the other 16. It means you keep your permanent job.
I would be extremely wary about giving up work, to be honest, for most of the reasons already given. I was never a deliberate sahp but due to a couple of moves we made, my work record was interrupted. It means I should be a point 19 on the scale but I'm on 15 here in ROI. It also means I have more years to work to get my full pension. I definitely wouldn't just dismiss these things. State pensions alone are shit. Plus, what would happen if you're suddenly a single parent? Financial independence is really important.

Isonthecase · 04/04/2022 09:04

Most teachers I know work part time, it's not really a career that works well with young kids. Apparently 2 days seems to be the sweet spot. Possibly worth an honest chat with the school saying it's part time or nothing?

Lou98 · 04/04/2022 09:03

I think you really need to have a serious discussion with your Husband and talk about it together. Just dreaming about "wouldn't it be nice" doesn't really let you know his thoughts on it. Ultimately, it's down to both of you to make the decision, being a SAHP only works if both parties are on board. It isn't fair to make one person fully responsible for the family financially if they're not comfortable with it, it can create a lot of stress and resentment so you need to find out where he stands. If he doesn't feel he can afford for you to stay at home, there isn't much point fantasising about it. You can of course look at different jobs etc if it's the job you hate.

Fwiw, my Son is 11 months and I was due back at work this month, I had really been looking forward to going back. My Partner was happy if I wanted to be a SAHM but I didn't, not full time. I was going back to work part time. However, when our Son was 6 months I found out I was pregnant with my second and I'm due in a few months so I'm now no longer going back because I'd be due off again in 2/3 months anyway and 2 lots of private nursery fees full time aren't worth it for us. My Partner works away from home so he's away 2/3 weeks at a time (then home for the same amount of time) but when he's away it's hard. I love being at home with my Son but honestly, I miss the part of my life where I got to go to work and socialise and be my own person for a while. The difference obviously is I enjoyed my job but it's definitely worth thinking about and being 100% sure it's what you want to do

Swayingpalmtrees · 04/04/2022 09:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Rememberitwell · 04/04/2022 09:01

I wouldn’t take too much time off but it depends how old you are.

I took five years out of teaching and tried to go back and found it hard as my references were out of date (previous headteachers retired etc.) The agencies found me supply work but it wasn’t as easy as you might think. However I am probably older than you as my dc are teenagers. Also in my area there has been a mass reorganisation and lots of redundancies.

I would say it’s a risk but if you plan to take 2-3 years off and you are still relatively young, then you might be able to pick your career back up.

Swayingpalmtrees · 04/04/2022 08:59

No one is talking about 10 years though clymene and if you are having children with someone that is likely to abuse you financially or otherwise then that is the problem no?

Women should be able to take a few years out to spend time with their children if they want to and have planned their finances accordingly, rather than paying someone else sky high rates to look after them instead. For low earners that is utter madness - just for a two bit pension and a foot hold. The loss obviously far outweighs any mediocre gains.

Many/most people I imagine are in stable marriages with decent loving husbands should not feel scared and forced back into work, with some imaginary fear that they will lose everything if they dare to stop for a while. Those that are married are entitled to half the assets in the worst case. Adding to qualifications or retraining might be an opportunity too.

A teaching career offers huge flexibility and a great set up for op to return in a heartbeat if she wants/needs to.

Bringonthebloodydrama · 04/04/2022 08:58

I've worked p/t with a baby, SAHM with young kids, a student with 3 kids and f/t (now) with 3 kids.

I wouldn't stay at home if you paid me. I fell into depression. I didn't cope well with the relentlessness of young kids, tantrums, nappies, incessant demands...the grind of housework and laundry and shopping, the rhyme times and the soft play etc....I hated never having time off; even on a major London commute I felt like I had more balance in my life.

My husband is a high earner and I didn't have to go back to work once my youngest started school. But I needed to. My life was as the above but without the little kid moments of fun...I felt like an unpaid slave.

Now in a different career, f/t and love it. It's demanding, stressful and tiring. But I am good at my job and I am respected and valued. I am someone else other than someone filling their days with mundane tasks or going to the gym. we outsource stuff that I hate - cleaning, laundry, changing beds...as well as stuff I quite like but have no time to do daily ...dog walking...get someone to help with the pick ups and drop offs...eat a lot of ready meals and yellow food....and I am much, much happier. The school stuff and home stuff have to be divided between me and my husband. I feel as though I am in an equal partnership rather than me doing everything, feeling put upon and resentful as well as bored, exhausted and empty. The grass is certainly not greener - it's often barren!

tkwal · 04/04/2022 08:57

If you go back to work sooner than that how much will childcare cost and how much will you and your children benefit from the experience ? If you don't go back until your DC are at school
Can you undertake online training to keep your skills, knowledge and understanding of innovation in your sector up to date and therefore prevent you from having to accept a less senior role ? How does your partner feel about your choice ?

passport123 · 04/04/2022 08:55

They still need you when at school and the best way to get PT is to already be in a job.

Clymene · 04/04/2022 08:51

The reason people aren't that enthusiastic about sahms on here is because it makes you extremely financially vulnerable. Obviously most men don't turn out to be arseholes but a large number do. If you haven't worked for 5 years, or 10, it's hard to get back the earning power you once had.

It's got sod all to do with the valuable role of raising children Hmm

That said OP, teaching is probably a better profession than most to take time out from.