Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SAHM for five years or so - AIBU?

160 replies

Whyisitsowet · 04/04/2022 07:46

I’m really not enjoying work at all and while there are advantages to my working most of these aren’t immediate - they are things we may benefit from in later life (pension) or when we retire.

Am really considering not going back after maternity leave second time around until school age so five / six years or so.

I can’t work out if sensible or not - what are your experiences?

OP posts:
Rosser · 04/04/2022 10:24

I’m out the other side of this now. I was the only FT working Mum when my DC were little. Because my DH had some issues which meant I had to be the main earner. He also didn’t want to be a SAHP so my DC had full time nursery/childminders.

The preschool years are short and I tried my hardest to be as present a parent outside of working hours. I felt guilt, exacerbated by some of the horrible things other women said to me when they learned I worked FT with young kids. I am absolutely thrilled I did it now though, and the pension is one of the lower down the list reasons.

  1. I have progressed in my career and now both DC are in full time school we are much better off than I would be if I was trying to get back into work, lower down the ladder.
  1. My DH and I are both on an equal footing career-wise and are both used to school drop offs/pick ups. Looking after DC when ill etc… One of our jobs is not too important to dictate that the other needs to work a term time only, school hours only role.
  1. If DH leaves me then I am financially secure. Some of my friends are starting to split up now and some of these women are totally screwed financially. This is so so so important. No one can assume their marriage is going to last forever.
  1. My DH is a 50-50 parent and contributes equally to the housework/admin because he always has had to.
Brefugee · 04/04/2022 10:23

Spending more time with your children is a no brainer.

for you. For me? not so much. SAHM was never my plan beyond around 6 months. Circs, beyond our control, changed and i was home for 3 years in the end. it only became clear when 2nd DC arrived 18 months after the first (planned due to the circs, since we wanted 2) and my PND started that it became clear that it was good for none of us.

Hillarious · 04/04/2022 10:14

I was lucky to move into the area where I live when it was possible to afford the mortgage on one middle management salary. House prices have risen x6, but DH's salary hasn't. My close friends from then are still close 20 years later, and we've all gone back into work after, on average, six years as a SAHM. It's the best thing I could have done, and I have sympathy for parents who don't have the choice to be at home. It was difficult financially. I didn't buy tat, and my DC, now in their early 20s, continue to be cheap to entertain!

On the teaching front, all the primary school teachers I knew took time out, and then returned either part-time or as a TA. One is still a TA, another is her previous school's go-to for maternity/ill health cover, one is back in primary full-time and the other is head of a state nursery school.

ExerciseWoes · 04/04/2022 10:13

Oh and be confident your husband wouldn't use it against you or be "this is MY money" etc..

We pay bills from joint accounts but we also have individual accounts for spending and he splits his disposable in half and sends one half to me so we have exactly the same amount of money.

ExerciseWoes · 04/04/2022 10:10

Well it of course depends on your husbands POV as well. If it's something that everyone is on board and happy with then I would.

I'm currently a very PT working Mum. As in a few hours a week work and not because I have to but just because I'd be bored otherwise and wanted DC in nursery for some socialisation (and a break ha).

But I'm really happy with it. I worked in law before. It was high pressure, high stress and not really complimentary to family life. I know it's very sensible to think of your pension, your career progression and all the rest of it but honestly the thing that kept just repeating in my head was my baby / babies will only be small once and to be given the chance of spending so much time with them for this precious and quickly changing period of their lives was worth it to me.

Don't get me wrong it's mind numbingly boring some days and hard but I personally don't regret it.

You need to he okay financially though. I would hate to do it but be scraping by every month because of it. We're very fortunate that DH earns very well and loves his job (self employed) so we aren't under financial stress with me being out of work and he openly says there is no way he'd be able to stay at home with DC so there is no jealously!

Dixiechickonhols · 04/04/2022 10:09

I’m usually quite pro keep working but in your shoes I don’t think the risk is that great. You are married so have safety net if he dies or leaves. You are in an always in demand career, you don’t need to keep on top of registration or cpd etc like some jobs.
Obviously loss of pension, loss of career progression (scenario often is you end up working for less money in 5 years time meanwhile he’s on a lot more as he’s been able to work unhindered) and risk you become default carer making it harder to work when they are school age. Your return to work will be easier as you have all school hols off.
Not sure what you teach but tutoring can pay well and could fit around life now and keep hand in.

Opsiedaisy · 04/04/2022 10:07

I’ve been a sahm for five years. Before having our children I had a job in middle management with a good salary. Our plan was for me to have a year off on maternity leave then go back full time. I didn’t! Fortunately my husband was promoted while I was on maternity leave and after weighing up nursery costs (twins) we decided to see if we could manage on one salary. We did and it was fine, to be honest I think it would had been a real struggle going back to work, my job was very high pressured and often included working late (which would had been a problem with nursery hours). We have no family living near by and my husband often has to work away so it just made sense for me not to go back. Now my children are at school I am looking at going back to work but in a totally different field and am considering re-training (looking into teaching!)

latriciamcneal · 04/04/2022 10:03

Spending more time with your children is a no brainer. I had two years off and concentrated on my child. It was the best thing I could have done for both of us. I dedicated those two years to her and only her.

Ragwort · 04/04/2022 09:58

You need to think very carefully about how it will work for you and your family. I was a SAHM for 12 years ... at the time my DH earned a good salary, those 12 years were very comfortable for me, I had plenty of time to follow my own interests, do volunteering etc. We had a joint bank account and there was no question of me having 'to ask' to spend money or anything like that. I also made sure I kept my NI up to date for my pension.

However, it was hard to return to work when I wanted to, our financial situation changed (2007 recession) and although I found a job I love it pays about a third less than I was earning 25 years ago Shock ... not even allowing for inflation!!) But I guess being a teacher you wouldn't have that problem.

And, hate to say this ... but what if your marriage breaks down?

Also don't fall into the trap of doing all the housework and childcare, is your DH definitely the sort of man who pulls his weight? My DH loved being a Dad and never assumed I would be doing the bulk of the 'housewife and childcare stuff'. He fully appreciated that I needed time, space to do my own thing at weekends, evenings etc.

Is there a compromise? Part time teaching, tutoring etc?

thingymaboob · 04/04/2022 09:57

[quote Whyisitsowet]@Elpheba that’s definitely a problem and a similar thing happened to me. I returned FT because there weren’t PT ones available. And I do wonder if it’s that which is killing me. The problem is I’m just not enjoying it at all and that makes dropping off at nursery so hard.[/quote]
I think it's impossible to work FT and have a young family. I don't know how anyone does it! Obviously lots of people do but I returned 4 days a week after first mat leave and it killed me. My DH brilliant and does as much parenting as I do. I was able to move to 3 days a week and it made s HUGE difference!

Turningpurple · 04/04/2022 09:56

@Swayingpalmtrees

I am out of this thread, it is a toxic wasteland of people that seem very unkind.
Its not our responsibility or obligation to be kind. Especially to people who are rude and judgemental.
GizmosEveningBath · 04/04/2022 09:56

Oh and if not on a parenting forum, where else would it be appropriate for Mums to talk about PND and the more difficult aspects of parenthood? Or should us mums just dose ourselves up on valium and gin and be happy with our lot? If a mum is feeling depressed at home, what should she do @Swayingpalmtrees?

Brefugee · 04/04/2022 09:55

I remember why I avoid threads like this now, it makes me so sad to think of the babies and children that have had such a negative childhood experience as their mothers seemed to hate being with them and couldn't wait to leave them. There is something so sad and damaging about some of these posts.

what a load of bollocks. Women, working class women, have ALWAYS worked. The difference now is that we often live far from families, and our own mothers (or MILs) are also still working so no chance of doing extended family childcare which has been a stalwart feature of working class women's lives.
The cost of childcare is exhorbitant. And women fought long and hard not to be seen as "breeding machines" and should have the choice to work outside the home if that is what is good for them and their children. Why do you think "mother's little helpers" were a thing? and how many children were damaged by marriages staying together "for the sake of the children"? Plenty.

Women have choices, as do men (pity more men don't make the choice to cut hours and pick up more slack on the home front so that more women could work fewer than 40 hours and still have that SAHM-vibe) and the more of us make those choices, for the good of our own families, having given it serious thought the better.

There is no "right way" of being a mother. The fact that being at home with children nearly broke my brain is neither here nor there in the terms that i love my children more than life itself - i just didn't love having to be with them 24/7.

And contrary to the toxic wasteland pp mentioned, i'm finding this thread refreshing in that is is less SAHM vs Working outside the home mum rather but is instead a lot of good advice and personal anecdotes about how people have made motherhood work for them and their families. It has been supportive, for the most part, and most of the toxicity (which has been mild) has come in the form of "ohhhhh the poooooor babies" with an undertone of horrible women who don't love their children. But even that has been restricted to only a few posts.

Have you any idea how damaging it is as a child to hear your mother actively hating spending time with you? Couldn't wait to leave you.

can't speak for anyone else but i never ever said that to my children and i don't know anyone who did (have met plenty of men who "work" late so they get home after the children are in bed though).

I wonder how women with children who feel they have no option but to work (lone parent, sole earner, two wages don't cut it etc) feel when the sanctimonious brigade castigate them for not wanting to spend every waking second with their offspring? or how women who have made a sometimes really difficult choice to be a SAHP (for whatever reason) feel when the sanctimonious "but think of your pension" brigade castigate them for that?

The reality is that we make choices for our families. But the decision to SAHP has to be taken with eyes wide open about what the financial implications may be, especially pensions, and how much robustness there is in the family budget for unforseen disasters. In that respect i have found this thread supportive and really good.

satelliteheart · 04/04/2022 09:55

Op, I've been a sahm since my first (now 4) was born and will be until at least my youngest starts school in several years. It's a very individual choice and no one can tell you what to do. I love being at home with my children and had a job that shouldn't be too hard to get back into. I also have the option to do some studying/retraining before I return to work if it's necessary. Dh earns enough to give us a nice life, not crazy rich, but we can afford days out as a family, holidays and the odd takeaway.

The main thing is financial security, I have a rental property in my name which brings in a small income and we're considering buying another one. We also have almost two years of dh's gross income in savings/investments in case he gets made redundant and dh pays into a pension for me so we shouldn't be up shit creek in retirement. And we are 100% equals in everything. All money is family money and I can spend as I wish, Dh would never dream of criticising me for buying myself new clothes/getting my hair done etc like you often see on here. He also more than pulls his weight with childcare and household tasks and does an equal share of night wakings and getting up with them in the morning

There are a lot of sahms on here who are stuck in very unequal, borderline abusive, relationships. You need to be very sure you wouldn't be getting yourself into a similar situation and that your husband will fully respect your role in the family and your contribution

Clymene · 04/04/2022 09:54

@Swayingpalmtrees

I genuinely feel sorry for you clymene You sound compromised, shall we say.
Compromised? I don't think you understand what that word means. I'm perfectly happy with my choices. My children are happy healthy teenagers and I feel no guilt or sadness about any of my choices.

I wonder why you're so insecure in yours that you feel the need to attack other mothers and try and give them anxiety about their children's well-being if they work? It's very unkind.

Not sIre this conversation is in any way helpful to the OP either!

girlmom21 · 04/04/2022 09:53

@Swayingpalmtrees

I am out of this thread, it is a toxic wasteland of people that seem very unkind.
You keep saying this and yet you're still here.

Shouldn't you be playing super mom somewhere?

ChloeHel · 04/04/2022 09:53

Hi,

I have been in a similar boat to you where I wasn’t going to go back after maternity and have 6 years off until the youngest went to primary school (currently pregnant with said youngest and DD is 18 months). But we decided it would be more beneficial for me to go back 1 day a week, that way I’m still paying into my pension, still on the career ladder and can buy things for DH and DD. It’s nice to have your own money and not rely on DH.

We don’t have to pay for any childcare and because it’s only 1 day a week I’m not taxed. The 1 day I do work we have family look after DD.

Maybe consider something similar to that :) I definitely wouldn’t completely pack in work, no matter how much I really, really want to haha.

MuchTooTired · 04/04/2022 09:52

I am a sahm, but if I’d had the choice I’d have carried on working. Turns out I’m not a natural at being a sahm, and have found the experience not great and I’m now even further behind than I would have been.

Yes, childcare is a shared cost, but as a household (all monies are shared here) we’d have been losing hundreds a month putting my DTs in nursery so it worked out much cheaper for me to stay home with them.

Obviously you’re a teacher so I’m assuming you’re much better at handling young children than I am (!) but it’s a fair few years of pension contributions and relying on your partner financially which I’ve discovered I’m not a fan of.

Would you consider leaving teaching for a few years and having a part time job doing something else just so there’s no gaps on your cv?

Turningpurple · 04/04/2022 09:50

@Swayingpalmtrees

emerald have you actually read the thread, lots of people saying that they could not wait to leave their kids, hated it, felt depressed and empty etc etc. I am not talking about the posts that love their jobs and dc but the ones that state they hated being with their children.

It is a very cruel thing to say.

Have you any idea how damaging it is as a child to hear your mother actively hating spending time with you? Couldn't wait to leave you. What that does to a child's mental health and well being. It will takes years of unpicking in terms of therapy, not to mention totally compromised or irreparable damage to the relationship.

I find it worrying that so many think it is okay, and don't seem to realise the damage they are doing.

Why are their kids on mumsnet?
GizmosEveningBath · 04/04/2022 09:49

Swayingpalmtrees

You sound overly defensive of your choices @Swayingpalmtrees

I loved being home with my babies, but women should consider thier financial position, there are few things more unhealthy for a child than being in an unhappy household with a DM who is trapped. You can also love your children and be a good mum but find the more monotonous side of being a SAHM hard.
As a former SAHM I have seen nothing disrespectful towards SAHM on this thread. Some of your comments towards working mums however have been vile.

Turningpurple · 04/04/2022 09:46

I remember why I avoid threads like this now, it makes me so sad to think of the babies and children that have had such a negative childhood experience as their mothers seemed to hate being with them and couldn't wait to leave them. There is something so sad and damaging about some of these posts.

Can you clutch your pearls and use them as a stress reliever. It will help.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 04/04/2022 09:46

@Swayingpalmtrees

I remember why I avoid threads like this now, it makes me so sad to think of the babies and children that have had such a negative childhood experience as their mothers seemed to hate being with them and couldn't wait to leave them. There is something so sad and damaging about some of these posts. It is one thing to have to work out of necessity, quite another to claim it was so awful being at home with your children, so utterly depressing that you couldn't wait to get away. Same people have more kids, unbelievable.

I am out op, I hope you choose something that makes you and your little ones happy, remember the regrets in life on deathbeds are very rarely about wishing to work more but regrets about not spending more time with families.

www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2012/feb/01/top-five-regrets-of-the-dying

Be happy op. All the best.

This is hilarious! Didn't take long for the parental judging to start. Page 2 no less.

I was raised as @Bringonthebloodydrama
did and turned out fine.

DM had no choice though and Had to work. Provided all 5 of a comfortable upbringing and still have lovely memories from when parents were home.

Depression is real, what if the 3rd child is what brought it on, who are you to judge?

Swayingpalmtrees · 04/04/2022 09:43

I am out of this thread, it is a toxic wasteland of people that seem very unkind.

Swayingpalmtrees · 04/04/2022 09:42

emerald have you actually read the thread, lots of people saying that they could not wait to leave their kids, hated it, felt depressed and empty etc etc. I am not talking about the posts that love their jobs and dc but the ones that state they hated being with their children.

It is a very cruel thing to say.

Have you any idea how damaging it is as a child to hear your mother actively hating spending time with you? Couldn't wait to leave you. What that does to a child's mental health and well being. It will takes years of unpicking in terms of therapy, not to mention totally compromised or irreparable damage to the relationship.

I find it worrying that so many think it is okay, and don't seem to realise the damage they are doing.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 04/04/2022 09:36

I remember why I avoid threads like this now, it makes me so sad to think of the babies and children that have had such a negative childhood experience as their mothers seemed to hate being with them and couldn't wait to leave them. There is something so sad and damaging about some of these posts.
Calm down.
It's possible to love your DC and enjoy your job.
It also shows DC from a young age working is part of life.
My Dsis works FT her DC definitely have better experiences than mine.
It is one thing to have to work out of necessity, quite another to claim it was so awful being at home with your children, so utterly depressing that you couldn't wait to get away. Same people have more kids, unbelievable.
Everyone needs to work, it isn't about getting away from the DC.
Staying at home isn't for everyone.