Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SAHM for five years or so - AIBU?

160 replies

Whyisitsowet · 04/04/2022 07:46

I’m really not enjoying work at all and while there are advantages to my working most of these aren’t immediate - they are things we may benefit from in later life (pension) or when we retire.

Am really considering not going back after maternity leave second time around until school age so five / six years or so.

I can’t work out if sensible or not - what are your experiences?

OP posts:
EthelsAuntie · 04/04/2022 11:47

I went back part time 3 days a week after maternity leave. It was the best for our family. I've kept up with new developments in work but still got lots of time with my girls.
When dd2 started school, I went up to 4 days a week. I still have one day off. On that day, I try to keep up-to-date with all the other stuff teachers have to do before or after school, planning, preparing, admin. This is my choice but it makes me feel less guilty about arriving a bit later and leaving a bit earlier on my days in school.
I do this so that I can ferry kids to activities after school etc. Other teachers often think I'm mad to work on my day off but they think nothing of coming 1.5hrs before school starts every day and the same at the other end of the day. I don't. I drop my children off and arrive about 30 minutes before the bell and leave usually by 4. This works for me and I can keep on top of everything.
You need to look at the family finances and work out what is best as a family. I, personally, hated the idea of not providing anything financially towards us even though my DH was earning well. I wanted to make some of my own money too.
The alternative is you look for something else instead of teaching. Our job is hard enough. If you don't love it, it must be extremely difficult. I am lucky in that I do still love it and have never considered doing anything else but it isn't for everyone. You would have lots of transferable skills that would make you a good candidate in a different role. Have that big conversation with your dh and make a plan.

Synchrony · 04/04/2022 11:39

Ps my experience is that I was lucky to go part-time ten years before I even had kids. I LOVE working part-time, it's awesome for me!

glowingcandle · 04/04/2022 11:36

I would definitely have considered this but unfortunately we can't really afford it. I work PT instead (2.5 days per week) which is a good compromise. I'm really enjoying being able to spend a more time with the kids whilst they're small.

My MIL died fairly recently just 18 months after retiring. She had an excellent pension which she barely had a chance to claim. It's definitely changed my view on this stuff - if you've been sensible to date and paid into a public sector pension for two decades, I don't think it's that crazy to stop for 5/6 years. Life is for living.

Synchrony · 04/04/2022 11:36

I think it's not all or nothing. You can quit and, if it turns out that sahm is not for you, go back. Or apply to work part-time and see how it goes. No need to commit to the decision for 5/6 years yet.

I have Mum friends all over the spectrum. Some thought they wanted to return to work but turns out they loved being at home. Others who thought they'd love being a sahm but found they needed what their work brought to their lives.

Good to test the waters before committing if you can, I'd say.

ThePlantsitter · 04/04/2022 11:35

Thank you @Chasingaftermidnight.

Chasingaftermidnight · 04/04/2022 11:34

@Mischance

*cons: -no money -too much time with kids -lose sense of self -drudgery -lack of respect from others about your role -have to be very careful you don't become SAHM to your H/P as well as your kids -pension and financial standing (couldn't get a credit card in my own name shock -difficulty getting back into work (maybe less tricky as a teacher?) -boredom and frustration and lack of structure -have to wait until H gets home to go out in the evening, which is a LOT more significant than you might be imagining now.*

Gosh!!

Well it just goes to show how different people can be!

  • too much time with kids - I am not even sure I can grasp this concept as I loved being with them!
  • Lose sense of self - I am not sure I even understand what that means .... I guess it might apply if you define yourself by your job,
  • drudgery - what does this mean? Does it refer to making a happy home?
  • lack of respect from others about your role - who are these others? I never experienced such a thing at all!
  • boredom and frustration and lack of structure - a SAMP has to create structure - nothing to stop this, if you choose to do so.
- have to wait until H gets home to go out in the evening. That would apply even if children were in nursery.

It makes me sad to read these posts where people see their children as standing in their way, rather than as a joyful episode in their lives. To be honest I think it is about attitude of mind - if you see bringing up children as am important role, on a par with a professional role then there is no problem. If you are locked into the past, into the 60s women's revolution where we struggled to be recognised as equals in the world of work, then you will think negatively. Things have moved on - the struggle was for CHOICE, which we now have as women. We can work and have a career, or be a parent, or do both at different times and in different measure. There was nothing in that fight that said that being a parent is a lesser role.
How sad for these children, being an encumbrance to personal fulfilment. If you choose to make parenthood fulfilling, then it will be.

The poster you’re quoting, who says she was a SAHM for a while, also gave a long list of ‘pros’ which you’ve conveniently omitted when quoting her. At the top of her list of ‘pros’ is ‘time with the kids’.
ThePlantsitter · 04/04/2022 11:32

@Mischance

*cons: -no money -too much time with kids -lose sense of self -drudgery -lack of respect from others about your role -have to be very careful you don't become SAHM to your H/P as well as your kids -pension and financial standing (couldn't get a credit card in my own name shock -difficulty getting back into work (maybe less tricky as a teacher?) -boredom and frustration and lack of structure -have to wait until H gets home to go out in the evening, which is a LOT more significant than you might be imagining now.*

Gosh!!

Well it just goes to show how different people can be!

  • too much time with kids - I am not even sure I can grasp this concept as I loved being with them!
  • Lose sense of self - I am not sure I even understand what that means .... I guess it might apply if you define yourself by your job,
  • drudgery - what does this mean? Does it refer to making a happy home?
  • lack of respect from others about your role - who are these others? I never experienced such a thing at all!
  • boredom and frustration and lack of structure - a SAMP has to create structure - nothing to stop this, if you choose to do so.
- have to wait until H gets home to go out in the evening. That would apply even if children were in nursery.

It makes me sad to read these posts where people see their children as standing in their way, rather than as a joyful episode in their lives. To be honest I think it is about attitude of mind - if you see bringing up children as am important role, on a par with a professional role then there is no problem. If you are locked into the past, into the 60s women's revolution where we struggled to be recognised as equals in the world of work, then you will think negatively. Things have moved on - the struggle was for CHOICE, which we now have as women. We can work and have a career, or be a parent, or do both at different times and in different measure. There was nothing in that fight that said that being a parent is a lesser role.
How sad for these children, being an encumbrance to personal fulfilment. If you choose to make parenthood fulfilling, then it will be.

Mischance if you are going to comment on my post please comment on it in full not just the negative half which you then make judgy comments about.

I am not interested in people who are determinedly untruthful about life and only paint a positive picture of what they do. I made a decision to stay at home with my kids. I struggled. There, I said it. Not everyone is suited to looking after small children even if society makes us feel crap for not being. I think my kids benefited from it - and how DARE you suggest I don't love them or have a good relationship with them; my VERY FIRST SENTENCE said I did - but the cost to me was immense and not to be dismissed by your patronising twaddle and 'sadness'.

The OP asked for honest opinions and that is what I gave, my real life experience. You are out of order.

Chasingaftermidnight · 04/04/2022 11:30

@Whyisitsowet

Oh I totally understand that and I found that incredibly difficult about working FT - in the week I felt like we only saw him when he was hungry and tired and we were hungry and tired and stressed. And then it felt like there was huge pressure to make weekends really quality time. Which they were, to be fair, but it was the pressure of it - I’d get so upset if anything happened that ate into the precious weekend time.

Brefugee · 04/04/2022 11:27

It makes me sad to read these posts where people see their children as standing in their way, rather than as a joyful episode in their lives. To be honest I think it is about attitude of mind - if you see bringing up children as am important role, on a par with a professional role then there is no problem

JFC. Spiffy for you. Not so much for all women. Those judgypants must really be painful for you they are hoiked up so high.

For those who are still hanging in despite the onslaught: you are not a bad mother if you work FT use nannies and don't like doing finger painting. You are not a bad mother if you are a SAHP and do nothing but fingerpaint and knit your own yoghurt. You are not a bad mother unless you're lighting up the capstans while spoonfeeding puréd skittles to your offspring and dropping fag ash in the bowl. No i lied. That last one is an AWFUL mother. Thank goodness none of us are like that.

You are a most excellent parent if your family has a good discussion about how you will handle parenthood and when and who works outside the home and who works inside the home. And don't let the judgypants among us ruin that for you.

Mischance · 04/04/2022 11:21

cons:
-no money
-too much time with kids
-lose sense of self
-drudgery
-lack of respect from others about your role
-have to be very careful you don't become SAHM to your H/P as well as your kids
-pension and financial standing (couldn't get a credit card in my own name shock
-difficulty getting back into work (maybe less tricky as a teacher?)
-boredom and frustration and lack of structure
-have to wait until H gets home to go out in the evening, which is a LOT more significant than you might be imagining now.

Gosh!!

Well it just goes to show how different people can be!

  • too much time with kids - I am not even sure I can grasp this concept as I loved being with them!
  • Lose sense of self - I am not sure I even understand what that means .... I guess it might apply if you define yourself by your job,
  • drudgery - what does this mean? Does it refer to making a happy home?
  • lack of respect from others about your role - who are these others? I never experienced such a thing at all!
  • boredom and frustration and lack of structure - a SAMP has to create structure - nothing to stop this, if you choose to do so.
- have to wait until H gets home to go out in the evening. That would apply even if children were in nursery.

It makes me sad to read these posts where people see their children as standing in their way, rather than as a joyful episode in their lives. To be honest I think it is about attitude of mind - if you see bringing up children as am important role, on a par with a professional role then there is no problem. If you are locked into the past, into the 60s women's revolution where we struggled to be recognised as equals in the world of work, then you will think negatively. Things have moved on - the struggle was for CHOICE, which we now have as women. We can work and have a career, or be a parent, or do both at different times and in different measure. There was nothing in that fight that said that being a parent is a lesser role.
How sad for these children, being an encumbrance to personal fulfilment. If you choose to make parenthood fulfilling, then it will be.

Whyisitsowet · 04/04/2022 11:18

@Chasingaftermidnight I don’t think you’re an awful mother, mine EXHAUSTS me. However, I find dealing with him as well as a FT job more tiring somehow, he’s definitely better when we’re out of the house so I can structure the days around this. As it is I currently have him at his most difficult ‘witching hour.’

OP posts:
Whyisitsowet · 04/04/2022 11:17

Thanks so much: lots to think about.

So to give a fuller picture, I’ll definitely consider PT but the problem with this is that it doesn’t give us the flexibility we’d ideally want with preschool children to holiday outside of school holidays. The other problem, which is bigger, is my school are a bit awkward with PT. They give you a day but anything more than a day is in afternoons or mornings. So for example, if I reduced my hours to three days a week, I would have something like off Tuesday, off Wednesday afternoon, off Friday morning, which is good with school aged kids but not with preschool.

I also find the emotional sort of headspace hard.

DH does earn well - £80,000 and I have a property from before I met him which provides a small income from rent.

I’d be reluctant to do tutoring, I don’t really enjoy it much.

References being outdated is a worry.

I’m probably best staying part time and maybe trying to reduce to two days a week, not sure if they’ll let me but can only ask!

OP posts:
Chasingaftermidnight · 04/04/2022 11:14

There’s no right or wrong answer at all because it depends entirely on circumstances and lots of other people on the thread have outlined various considerations to take into account.

A couple of things I’d say:

  1. Obviously finances play a huge part in this decision and only you know the numbers and can do the maths, but we are facing a massive cost of living crisis which will get worse over the course of this year and will very likely lead to a recession. I appreciate that your job is super stressful but it is also very recession-proof - is your husband’s similarly recession-proof? If he’s in an industry that’s very vulnerable to economic downturns then that might be something to consider. How easily could you find a job again if you desperately needed to? (Probably easily I expect).
  1. I thought I hated working while being a parent but it turned out that I actually hated working FT while being a parent. In my experience there’s a world of difference in terms of stress and pressure between being FT and PT. I know you say there are no PT jobs available but could you put in a flexible working request and try PT before giving up altogether? Then you’d keep your pension etc.
  1. Finally, how old are your children? The reason I ask is that I have a toddler who’s 2 years 8 months. I love him but he’s absolutely peak terrible twos and it can be very challenging. I do find solo time with him much more exhausting and draining than when he was 12-24 months old, and I do need a break sometimes. What I’m saying is, I think if I’d given up work when he was a super cute, easy 16 month old, I might be regretting it now. That probably makes me an awful mother but I’m just being honest.
ExConstance · 04/04/2022 10:53

What age group do you teach? One of y friends had flagging motivation as she reached retirement age and got a part time contract teaching maths in a F.E. college, she also picked up some tutoring before retiring altogether in her late 60's. I did some teaching for a short while in an F.E. College too - part time courses for graduates in industry - I really enjoyed that.
I know of someone who trains teaching assistants and enjoys it, another possibility?

Somebodyelsestrain · 04/04/2022 10:49

I did it OP and don't regret it at all, but my situation was as follows:

Very generous offer from work that a job would be available at the end of five years.

Just about doable on my partner's salary.

Very clear between partner and me that we were a partnership, and financially equal (ie his earnings came to both of us).

Got involved with lots of stuff to give me things to do that were more than "just" being a sahp. Set up a charity, lots of volunteering using skills from my career, a few hours of paid work once the kids were at pre-school.

When I went back to work full time my partner took a career break for a few months which was great for the family and great for him to realize how tough it can be. As a result, now we both work full time and domestic matters are split very equly between us.

I realize I was fortunate to be in this situation, but all of the above made it worth it and minimized the disadvantage. I did get back into my career and found ambition I just didn't have when my children were younger.

Chely · 04/04/2022 10:46

If it is financially viable and you don't have a career that will suffer from an absence then go for it.

I became a sahm after my maternity pay finished after 2nd, I was made redundant when pregnant so would have been job hunting. I was pregnant with 3rd too so not the most desirable for potential employers. I didn't love what I did, I was good at it but just kind of fell in to the career path when I wasn't sure what I wanted to do after school which made it a much easier decision. I've been sahm for 11 years now so would retrain and start fresh if I did return to working once kids are all at school and dh retires from his career that has him working away most of the time.

shiningstar2 · 04/04/2022 10:45

Retired teacher here. FT teaching is tough. It isn't 9.00 to 5.00 it takes over your evenings and impacts your weekends. If you could negotiate PT you might enjoy it and would make for cheaper childcare. I did PT for a year before I retired. It was a revelation. I used a weekday at home to do paperwork leaving weekends and most evenings free. I also sometimes was able to book holidays a few days in advance of school holidays which, with 4 people, does help a bit with costs. Keeping PT going until school age also keeps more career options open than staying at home full time

Ossoduro2 · 04/04/2022 10:43

If I were you I would just do a flexible working application and reduce your working hours right down to, say, 2 days a week if you need to. I wouldn’t quit altogether because I would find the insecurity of having no job really stressful.

toogoodforthisworld · 04/04/2022 10:42

I stopped work for 4 years after no.2 was born. I knew I couldn't manage it all if I didn't. Money was tighter - but we knew we couldn't have afforded childcare for 2 kids anyway.
It de-stressed us no end. No rush to get the kids to day care before work and then no stress to collect in time in the evening.
I cooked every evening so we saved on the occasional take away.
And it's true what they say- these young years are so special. Priceless to be able to be at home with them.
Plus - you might absolutely hate it- if so - you find something else. But if you never try it - you'll never know.
Xx
I actually found being a SAHM more hard work than actually working outside of the home - but I'm so glad I did it. X

Isonthecase · 04/04/2022 10:40

This is really interesting how different opinions are. Most of the people I know who gave up work are now at the point where they are really struggling with loss of identity and confidence so trying to go back to work has been very hard for them. Obviously not the case for everyone!

Gowithme · 04/04/2022 10:39

I was a SAHM and have only worked very part time since - I bloody loved it and have no interest in a career as I find full time working incredibly stressful and draining. Fortunately OH earns well although he's now seen the light too and realised working is shit and is planning on going part time in a few years.

OnTheBenchOfDoom · 04/04/2022 10:39

The main things for SAHPs are access to money and attitudes to spending by both people. And then housework/life admin.

On return to work the housework/life admin dividing can cause issues if someone hasn't had to do much for many years. Dh admitted years ago that he loved not having to do housework as he hates it but loves cooking and has always done all the weekend meals. However, we are a team and he steps into anything needed without complaint.

ThePlantsitter · 04/04/2022 10:32

I did it for a while.

pros:
-time with kids was fun
-time with kids really means they know me and that relationship makes it easier to get them to do what I want now they're older (I know that's controversial but it's true)
-zero stress about sick days, school pickup and events etc
-not having to be bossed about by work
-freedom to go places whenever you want

cons:
-no money
-too much time with kids
-lose sense of self
-drudgery
-lack of respect from others about your role
-have to be very careful you don't become SAHM to your H/P as well as your kids
-pension and financial standing (couldn't get a credit card in my own name Shock
-difficulty getting back into work (maybe less tricky as a teacher?)
-boredom and frustration and lack of structure
-have to wait until H gets home to go out in the evening, which is a LOT more significant than you might be imagining now.

On balance I wouldn't do it again given the choice.

Mischance · 04/04/2022 10:31

I did it - they were the happiest years of my life and I felt it gave my children a really good start in life. We had lots of fun together.

No problems getting back into my career (social work) and only a small loss of pension.

caringcarer · 04/04/2022 10:25

I was a teacher too, HoD. I stayed home for 3 years after dd was born during which time I also had D's so stayed home a further year. I found no problems at all going back first part time for 2 years then full time when D's started school. They grow up so quickly and I didn't want to miss anything. DH earned enough for me to stay home plus I saved up for 2 years before I got pregnant so I would still have some of my own money. Pension took a bit of a knock but still good. I really enjoyed time home with children we lived rurally and we went out walking or to park or to see horses in a field near to us everyday even if it was raining. We baked, painted and did messy craft and I taught both children to read fluently and to write, and did number work before they started school. I have wonderful memories of our special time and kids grown up now but remember the things we did too and say they had lovely childhoods. I also looked after a friend's son 1 morning a week for 6 months too during this time once dd was at school. I have never regretted my choice.