Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SAHM for five years or so - AIBU?

160 replies

Whyisitsowet · 04/04/2022 07:46

I’m really not enjoying work at all and while there are advantages to my working most of these aren’t immediate - they are things we may benefit from in later life (pension) or when we retire.

Am really considering not going back after maternity leave second time around until school age so five / six years or so.

I can’t work out if sensible or not - what are your experiences?

OP posts:
Mischance · 04/04/2022 13:45

I thought I might get jumped on for saying that being a SAHM is a valuable choice; and that word CHOICE is the important one. Women did not fight for choice for us in order to finish up feeling a "lack of respect from others about your role" as a mother. That is truly very sad.

The idea was that we would be able to have a career on an equal footing with men: not that we would only be valued if we had that career. We do have choice now: we can have a career and choose not to have children; we can have a career and children, using child care while we are out at work; we can choose to work part time, and "mix and match", maybe having the best of both worlds. All are valid choices which once women did not have.

There was nothing in the women's liberation movement that said women SHOULD choose to have a career, or indeed should choose to stay at home. There was nothing that said that women who choose to stay at home should be devalued. It was, as I say, about giving choice. And there was nothing that said that women should drive themselves into the ground trying to do everything. I see around me some very very tired and frantic women - it is very sad. Is this what we fought for?

And there was nothing in my post that was judgemental, although it clearly hit a raw nerve with some.

We have come round in a loop where the fight for choices has become loaded with value judgements; from having no choice, to now being under pressure to have a career or be seen as a lesser being. That cannot be right.

None of my education felt wasted while I was home with the children. I learned a lot from them and they learned a lot from me. It was a two-way traffic. And much of what I learned as a parent could transfer to my career, when I picked it up once more.

It is about valuing women whatever choices they make about career or home or both.

Mary46 · 04/04/2022 13:01

Hi op I was at home a good few years between ill parents/cost childcare. My kids had me here. I do feel the cv suffers I did get work (2017) but you have to build up all your experience again. Part T was very hard to get

NottheSAHP · 04/04/2022 12:55

About the tutoring, I should have said that DH found a niche where he was mainly tutoring pupils who were homeschooled/doing a subject off timetable. So not supporting in-class learning but teaching a whole subject/exam course 1:1. Might something like that appeal more? We also made sure to budget excluding his tutoring income for a long time, so for many years he didn't have to work but was choosing to spend some time that way and the money was a nice bonus...

Myboypink · 04/04/2022 12:52

@Whyisitsowet

Just had baby 1 . Im a primary teacher - so so so stressful . I will go back after end of maternity. I want another baba !!! So after second is born it will cost more for them to go to nursery than I earn . So I’m planning on being a SAHM for 5 years ( until both are at school )

I worry if my references will be out dated ?
Will anyone employ me ?

But I believe there is such a huge shortage of teachers there will always be jobs !

I pray anyway I’ll never have to go back to teaching when I finish as I blood my hate it !

Bunnycat101 · 04/04/2022 12:46

worriedatthistime Yes but that wouldn’t necessarily be free or affordable. Yes in theory she could access the 15 hours but there is no-where near me that would offer someone the 15 hours for free.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 04/04/2022 12:39

I'm at home since the pandemic began.

My DC have benefited from me being here, especially DS he needed it, great.

However my MH, self care, motivation has gone down the drain doing the same thing everyday, it's so easy to stick on jogging bottoms.

My motivation is "this time next year".

Theforkistootall · 04/04/2022 12:38

[quote Whyisitsowet]@Elpheba that’s definitely a problem and a similar thing happened to me. I returned FT because there weren’t PT ones available. And I do wonder if it’s that which is killing me. The problem is I’m just not enjoying it at all and that makes dropping off at nursery so hard.[/quote]
I was in a similar position and I deeply regret not doing it. In hindsight, it would have been fine financially, and I shouldn’t have let work and my DH bully me to into working full time and parenting a difficult child that slept poorly with zero support. I would absolutely SAHM if you want to and you can. My child has problems with anxiety and I will never know if my being so stressed when she was little contributed.

worriedatthistime · 04/04/2022 12:38

@Bunnycat101 but they can still go to nursery when 3 and there are toddler groups etc , no need for a child to only be at home with mum and sibling, lots of options for socialising

worriedatthistime · 04/04/2022 12:37

@ThePlantsitter I get that we all have different feelings about it , its a shame so many judge others for what they choose
Happy mum normally equals happy children in my experience

Bunnycat101 · 04/04/2022 12:34

On the other side, I’ve carried on working but found it quite hard at times but the money brings us additional choices. I have wanted to throw it in at times especially when they’ve both been tag teaming sickness and it feels relentless.
What I would say though is don’t make a decision until your second has arrived. Dealing with one is different to two and also there is a personality element . My eldest would have been bored out of her mind if she wasn’t in nursery. She’s a very sociable creature who wants to be wish children her own age and has done since she was about 2. It wouldn’t have suited her at all to be at home with me and my other child.

Also to throw a curve ball, the nursery years are significantly easier then primary. I’m glad I worked through and if anything, I might take a career break when both of mine start school so I can be fully around, attend the assemblies and performances and be more present.

ThePlantsitter · 04/04/2022 12:21

[quote worriedatthistime]@ThePlantsitter but everyone is different
I think its peoples attitudes nowadays to sahm ( you see it on here a lot) than can make people feel less important if a sahm
For me for that aspect I didn't care as my kids were all that matters not others opinions, I wouldn't criticise someone who puts their kids in nursery all day as if thats what is right for them then so be it
I loved being a sahm and we def had structure as we attended many toddler groups and get togethers so our days were busy
My dh never took me for granted and although i did more of the household chores as was home more he did a fair share and also really got to spend quality time with the kids as well and I got plenty of free time to
The op seems to want fo be home , isn't enjoying work so why not if they can afford it, you won' know until your try it[/quote]
I completely agree with you that everyone is different @worriedatthistime. I certainly didn't say OP shouldn't do it and I think people should live as they choose without judging other people or feeling sad for their children. I just said I wouldn't make that choice again, and I wouldn't. I was simply adding my experience (of the pros as well as the cons) as more evidence for her decision making.

Brefugee · 04/04/2022 12:19

my dh always said he would of done it but as he was the bigger wage earner we couldn't afford for him to stay home

well that's a whole other discussion. But they need to start doing it. Or nothing will change.

It's a pity the thread descended into some of the usual shitshow. Because these discussions are useful to so many people.

The pension thing: ok if you think you will have a too small pension - what are you doing to save for your retirement/future? What will you do as a SAHP to be sure not to be left penniless. Especially if something disastrous happens?

AliasGrape · 04/04/2022 12:15

I’m one who thought I’d return to teaching but didn’t yet. DD is coming up to 2, I’m thinking of registering for supply work on set days come September, then looking at returning either part time (I know I might not be so lucky as the PT jobs are rarer than hens teeth) or full time next year.

What’s complicating it a bit is that I’ve started some freelance work in a field I used to work in pre- teaching. I’ve totally fallen on my feet with it in that it was a relative with their own business that asked me to do a bit for them, and that led to a few other contacts and so I now work roughly equivalent to 2 days a week doing that. She has one day with a childminder and I fit the rest in evenings, a couple of hours with her grandparents if they offer, weekends when DH is off etc. It works well but is a bit of a feast or famine situation where I never quite know where I’m up to or how much work I’ll have.

Anyway the point is there may be an in between point somewhere, I know I was lucky to get an opportunity to do something different and more flexible for a while, and that DH can cover the bills and essentials if I didn’t make much one month (and is totally happy to). But I do think if you take the leap you might either love it and be happy with your choice, or perhaps find something else that works better for you somewhere between SAHM and full time teaching.

We had a discussion about how it would work, how everything else would be divided etc. I’m happy to take on the majority of the domestic stuff since I’m at home the most, but DH knows not to take the piss - I told him I’m staying home to raise our daughter not be his personal maid and he knows not to expect a perfectly tidy house and me work a full face of make up and dinner on the table when he gets home (I think he’d die of shock to be honest). We work as a team and he will cook dinner or stick a wash on or run the hoover round etc, but I definitely do I’ve also become the default parent with all the mental load in terms of DD. Sometimes this is frustrating but overall I have to admit I want it this way. I’m her primary carer and I want to be the one who decides a lot of this stuff. He does loads with her and is a brilliant, involved dad but it’s certainly not 50/50 the way that is held up as ideal on here often. I know I’m supposed to see that as a bad thing but it works for us. You would have to be honest with yourself and each other about how that would work in your situation/ family.

worriedatthistime · 04/04/2022 12:13

Also on these threads people talk about pensions for many of us we may not even have a pension or such a low paid one that a few years out will make no difference

worriedatthistime · 04/04/2022 12:12

@Brefugee my dh always said he would of done it but as he was the bigger wage earner we couldn't afford for him to stay home
In general many men will be the bigger earner , although that is slowly changing and maybe why we see more sahd
But in reality there are lots of parents doing a bit of both, both mum and dad work opposite shifts so the other one can cover the childcare as one salary is not often enough for many to live off , which is a shame

LittleBearPad · 04/04/2022 12:12

There’s always some extreme examples on these threads - some people don’t seem to be able to be happy unless they can put others down. Interestingly it’s often those who seem to think WoHM are unfeeling

Part time is a good option OP, if it doesn’t work then you can rethink. Good luck.

reluctantbrit · 04/04/2022 12:10

For me the biggest. factor would be how my husband/partner would see the financial. situation.

Is it really a shared one or a. "I am the money earner and you have have every spending approved"? Could you pay into a pension privately to cover the 5 year loss?

Are you able to pay for a serious illness cover and life insurance for your DH?

worriedatthistime · 04/04/2022 12:05

@ThePlantsitter but everyone is different
I think its peoples attitudes nowadays to sahm ( you see it on here a lot) than can make people feel less important if a sahm
For me for that aspect I didn't care as my kids were all that matters not others opinions, I wouldn't criticise someone who puts their kids in nursery all day as if thats what is right for them then so be it
I loved being a sahm and we def had structure as we attended many toddler groups and get togethers so our days were busy
My dh never took me for granted and although i did more of the household chores as was home more he did a fair share and also really got to spend quality time with the kids as well and I got plenty of free time to
The op seems to want fo be home , isn't enjoying work so why not if they can afford it, you won' know until your try it

Brefugee · 04/04/2022 12:05

Having a parent at home during formative years in my mind really is what being a parent is.

it is apparently about what being a mother is since I am seeing conversations by men falling over themselves wanting to do it.

YingMei · 04/04/2022 12:04

I used to be a teacher. Took 3 years out after my 2nd DC was born as we moved abroad for DHs job. Got a part time job easily when I got back. If you've already got 20 years in a TPS I don't think taking a couple of years out would be too harmful.

Alliswells · 04/04/2022 12:02

@twinsetandpearl

To be honest your husband gets the final say - he's the one who would be taking on the financially responsibility of being the sole earner. I do find it odd that the often crippling responsibility and pressure of being the primary sole earner is so easily overlooked on MN (I'm a mum of 3 and I'm the main earner so perhaps I see things from a different perspective). If my husband who regularly says he hates his job said he'd like to be a STAHP (which would be cheaper as he earns less than our childcare some months) I'd take a dim view of it to be honest
If it would be cheaper then it would make sense so why would you take a dim view of it?
chubbachub · 04/04/2022 11:56

I'm just about to do the same. My mat leave ends soon and I'm not returning for at least 2 years.
I say do it. You wouldnt regret spending that time with your little ones.

Itsbackagain · 04/04/2022 11:55

If you can afford it - do it! Having a parent at home during formative years in my mind really is what being a parent is.

Panicmode1 · 04/04/2022 11:54

I haven't read the whole thread as I'm sure it's the usual bunfight and judgements. Do what is right for you - from your original post, it sounds as though you have built up a solid pension so far, and if you and your husband are on the same page about it, it works really well.

I had a professional career, big salary and London job, but I also had four children - by the time my 4th came along, I was doing everything badly, so gave up my (paid) job, and became a SAHM - for about 10 years, until my youngest was in Y5 ish. I volunteered during my time at home, including setting up a Free School, and did various PTA/charity type things to keep my brain active and my CV peppered with 'stuff'.

I am now working 2 part time jobs, both of which are very different, both of which I really enjoy, and I get the best of both worlds - being around at the beginning and end of the school day when they need you (even if the teens deny they do - they do!), and also earning some money for myself and saving a little bit. Luckily DH earns very well and has a solid pension life insurance and redundancy package, (and being brutally honest, my inheritance will be quite chunky), so we do have financial security, but it is REALLY important to communicate with each other about the expectations you both have of each other if you give up work.

I do wish that I have more in my pension pot, and there are days when you just want to throw something at the wall and ask yourself what on earth you thought you were doing - BUT they are with you for such a short time (my eldest just turned 18 and I don't feel that it's been 18 years since he arrived!), so if you have the opportunity, then I would take it.

Brefugee · 04/04/2022 11:50

I think it's not all or nothing. You can quit and, if it turns out that sahm is not for you, go back. Or apply to work part-time and see how it goes. No need to commit to the decision for 5/6 years yet.

i also think that people often forget that children grow very fast in the early years, so you need to be open to revisiting your arrangements quite often (at least in the early years, later on it changes relatively organically)