Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SAHM for five years or so - AIBU?

160 replies

Whyisitsowet · 04/04/2022 07:46

I’m really not enjoying work at all and while there are advantages to my working most of these aren’t immediate - they are things we may benefit from in later life (pension) or when we retire.

Am really considering not going back after maternity leave second time around until school age so five / six years or so.

I can’t work out if sensible or not - what are your experiences?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ReeseWitherfork · 05/04/2022 16:40

Sorry to hear it's so shitty OP Flowers

I have a few friends who are teachers and it just looks horrendous. One of them walked away from it permanently last year and hasn't looked back.

I really don't think stepping away sounds like the worst idea in your circumstances. It will probably come down to how supportive and understanding your DH is. I said earlier in the thread to do it and not read anything that changes my vote!

Whyisitsowet · 05/04/2022 15:48

Thanks, all.

The trouble is I really am just despising my job at the moment and that’s getting me down (not currently on maternity leave, sorry that wasn’t clear.) I realise in part that’s clouding my thoughts but I have had a horrendous day today and it’s really getting me down.

OP posts:
Sceptre86 · 05/04/2022 08:12

You haven't said how old the children are. So your second is under 1 presumably since you are on mat leave but your eldest? Could you get away with breakfast and after school club for your eldest or are they not school age? Ultimately I'd say the choice lies with your dh and whether he is willing to shoulder the quote financial burden of your family. You seem reluctant to consider any kind of part time working too.

I'd also consider things like will your finances still be joint despite you being a sahm, if they are already? Or would you have an allowance that you'd have to manage. If you had an allowance what would it cover, by that I mean just your own expenses such as clothes, makeup, hair appointments, car, mobile, any debts you may have, presents for your side of the family, meals out with friends? Or would it also include things related to the children too? What would it look like in terms of doing the housework, cooking etc. as the sahp would you be doing the bulk of it and are you OK with that? What about the childcare, would you expect it to be 50: 50 once he got home? Who would do night wake ups with the baby?

A lot to think about and I would have a more in depth discussion and see how you both feel and what would work for your family.

Runnerduck34 · 05/04/2022 00:31

Is going back part time or on a job share a possibility ?
If you are a teacher then hopefully as a professional it will be easier to return to work at the same level although it will impact pension and career progression.
If you enjoy spending time with your DC and doing toddler groups and activities it's a really lovely time but can also sometimes be draining and exhausting being with them 24/7.
There are pros and cons only you and DH can decide what's best for your family.
You're not mad to consider it but go in with your eyes open.
Ensure all money is family money and you have equal access. I.e joint bank account DH salary is paid into.
The other thing is, if DH gets used to you being a SAHM and doing most/ all of childcare and housework , when you do return to work it can be rude awakening for DH that they suddenly have to consider school runs, child being off sick, etc and it can be a bumpy readjustment period

Flipflopssndsocks · 04/04/2022 18:05

It depends what subject and area you are in as to whether this matters. If in a core subject and an area with shortages or the willingness to return to tough schools then you can get back even if you need to do some supply first. No need to do nothing, join governors and see what else is around to pad the cv.

TatianaBis · 04/04/2022 17:59

I took time out when my kids where young as did one of my sisters. I had some income from existing business. I didn't experience loss of self - I know who I am. Parts of it were boring, parts were fun.

It was much less stressful than trying to work and parent small children at the same time.

napody · 04/04/2022 17:55

I think as a teacher you’d likely walk straight back into a job afterwards, possibly after a bit of supply to get back up to speed. Unless you’re in somewhere like Cornwall or the Scottish islands where there are more teachers than jobs. The teacher recruitment and retention crisis is going to keep getting worse. If it works for your family, do it.

Clymene · 04/04/2022 17:51

It's really sad that the two women who are really banging the SAHM drum have either a) insulted mums and said they're damaging their children like @Swayingpalmtrees or b) selectively quoted other posters like @Mischance did in order to make a point.

Many of us have done both. I thought @ThePlantsitter's post was excellent because it clearly laid out what she felt were the pros and cons.

We no longer live in a world where women have to make a choice between children or a career. Many of us have both. There are sacrifices and compromises made in each. What I want to see is a world where women support one another to make the best choice for them. And that does include making some very honest assessments of whether your career will survive, whether your marriage will survive and how good your relationship is.

In years gone by, men didn't leave their wives. They had affairs but they carried on supporting their family. Relying on that to happen now is dangerous.

Newmumatlast · 04/04/2022 17:37

@Swayingpalmtrees

bringiton What a shame you don't enjoy motherhood, and could only list the negatives. Shame for your children too, no doubt they are happier elsewhere than with a depressed, empty vassal as you describe yourself so eloquently. I wonder why you choose to have so many children if was such a negative experience? I would have stopped at one hating home life as much as you clearly do. Odd to have three given your feelings.
This is quite a mean post. I am not sure why you're so triggered. She didnt say she didnt enjoy motherhood. She didnt enjoy being a SAHM. I love motherhood but maternity leave was enough to tell me I could never be a SAHM. That doesnt mean for others it isn't great but I feel a bit more like bringiton. I totally see the value in a SAHP - it would just likely be my husband not me if we decided to go down that route. There is nothing wrong with that. Bringiton's post, as I read it, was more a warning that it isnt always as good as it sounds with her own experience demonstrating how the OP could feel.
ReeseWitherfork · 04/04/2022 17:31

Your posts read very defensive Mischance. I don’t think anyone has said women shouldn’t have a choice or judged anyone for choosing different. Theplantsitter offered a balanced post of her own experiences. Certainly no comment on the entire concept of stay at home parenting. Are you perhaps being defensive because you’ve been judged elsewhere?

Mischance · 04/04/2022 16:32

I am not interested in fighting with anyone, but I have a view to express which I think it important in this climate when women have lost a real sense of choice, that many fought so very hard for - my mother included. It is deeply sad that the emphasis on giving women the choice to have a career has left them in this terrible bind where they feel uncomfortable about making any other choice - where they feel they are being judged if they do not pursue a career, but choose instead to build their life around making a home.

I apologise unreservedly if my words have caused anyone offence - but I do believe very sincerely that something has gone wrong somewhere, when what was meant to be an opportunity for choice has lead to mothers feeling that there is only one worthwhile direction now. That is very sad. Choosing a career or choosing homemaking and child-rearing should have equal merit and neither should be valued above the other.

It has turned into a situation where women feel bad whatever they do: if they are at home they feel they should be at work; if they are at work, they feel they should be home with the children.

That is not what my mother fought for. I would urge women to do what is right for them and their family and to forget what society thinks they should be doing. Once upon a time society judged women who went out to work as neglecting their families; now women who choose to stay at home with their children feel judged by society for being at work and "wasting" their education.

What triggered my diatribe was the fact that one poster said she felt judged in her role as a SAHM - that is very very sad indeed.

Chasingaftermidnight · 04/04/2022 15:30

@Mischance

I thought I might get jumped on for saying that being a SAHM is a valuable choice; and that word CHOICE is the important one. Women did not fight for choice for us in order to finish up feeling a "lack of respect from others about your role" as a mother. That is truly very sad.

The idea was that we would be able to have a career on an equal footing with men: not that we would only be valued if we had that career. We do have choice now: we can have a career and choose not to have children; we can have a career and children, using child care while we are out at work; we can choose to work part time, and "mix and match", maybe having the best of both worlds. All are valid choices which once women did not have.

There was nothing in the women's liberation movement that said women SHOULD choose to have a career, or indeed should choose to stay at home. There was nothing that said that women who choose to stay at home should be devalued. It was, as I say, about giving choice. And there was nothing that said that women should drive themselves into the ground trying to do everything. I see around me some very very tired and frantic women - it is very sad. Is this what we fought for?

And there was nothing in my post that was judgemental, although it clearly hit a raw nerve with some.

We have come round in a loop where the fight for choices has become loaded with value judgements; from having no choice, to now being under pressure to have a career or be seen as a lesser being. That cannot be right.

None of my education felt wasted while I was home with the children. I learned a lot from them and they learned a lot from me. It was a two-way traffic. And much of what I learned as a parent could transfer to my career, when I picked it up once more.

It is about valuing women whatever choices they make about career or home or both.

You didn’t get ‘jumped on’. You misquoted a thoughtful and balanced post from a poster who had in fact been a SAHM, in which she set out what she saw as the pros and cons of her decision, and you wrote a very judgmental diatribe about part of her post which you’d taken out of context.

The OP is trying to make the same decision now so clearly a view on the pros and cons from someone who’s been through it may be helpful.

Stop trying to manufacture a bunfight when there isn’t even one there.

worriedatthistime · 04/04/2022 15:07

@Hotheadwheresthecoldbath not all of us have pensions or certainly not good ones
Im temping at the moment and haven't taken up the pension as i cannot afford the loss of my wages due to 2 years of little work due to covid and being made redundant
Some if the temp jobs the pensions have been very little contribution from employee the bare minimum and I know a lot who opt out as they literally can only afford to live for the here and now

ThePlantsitter · 04/04/2022 14:36

@mischance I don't find it surprising that you make no apologies. You should though, because you have misquoted me, judged me incorrectly, and insulted me and my relationship with my kids. Nothing to do with what either of us think about SAH - weirdly I believe we actually agree on that point.

OP I'm sure you'll make the right decision for you. There are disadvantages to everything even if some people kid themselves there are not. Only you know whether the advantages outweigh them.

worriedatthistime · 04/04/2022 14:26

@Bunnycat101 toddler groups were free or donation that I went too some of the business ones more expensive
Mine also had at the time 15 3 hrs from 3 but we had to take the place at 2 years 9 months but I knew all this so we planned accordingly
Whichever way you go you have to think long term
Im not career orientated so a break for me was fine , I had no pension anyway and wasn't on a huge salary
Plus going from nothing to something was an increase and I got a part time job around school hrs so no childcare costs even then.
As more jobs become flexible hopefully there will be more choice for working parents both men and women,
Its a shame not all have a choice
We sacrificed holidays and a car for me to sahm but we didn't have a mortgage , where as some do have so they have to work to pay that

Mischance · 04/04/2022 14:24

I make no apologies for finding it sad that someone is not enjoying their children; it is equally sad when someone does not enjoy their job.

I want women to have choice and make the right choices for them.

It is of course all rather academic if you are stuck in a miserable job on minimum wage and faced with astronomical rises in bills.

Hotheadwheresthecoldbath · 04/04/2022 14:22

I went back to work part time when did was 7 months.
I did 2 compressed days.She went to a childminder 1 day,it was initially tone 2 but her dad decided to compressed hours too and had her on his own for 1 day.
I'm glad I kept my job going,I still missed promotions but did manage to keep my pension going.My solid marriage broke down after 18 years so being able to bring in an ok wage and move to a cheap house near DDS school made it work.
I am now retired and working part-time,until you're there you don't get how important the pension is it saves having to work long hours plus overtimes as others do and still help DD financially through uni.
Your children are with you for a lot longers than those few tough years before they go to school.

ThePlantsitter · 04/04/2022 14:08

Saying you feel sad for someone's kids is judgemental.

Mischance · 04/04/2022 14:07

[quote ThePlantsitter]@mischance you pulled apart my post in a very judgemental way. 'Do you mean 'making a happy home' by drudgery?' Not judgemental? 'I feel sad for your children' not judgemental? 'I don't know what you mean about spending too much time with your kids you should love every second' (I paraphrase) not judgemental? Nothing judgemental my arse.

I completely agree that SAHM should be seen as of value. Of course I do, I did it for 6 years. I also think that silencing women when they talk about their personal experiences - I was not making any value judgement other than how I felt and about myself - is extremely patronising and not doing what you say you think is important, i.e valuing women.[/quote]
Making a different judgement and outlining that is not judgemental.

tigertreats · 04/04/2022 14:06

I am a working mom. I popped out today at lunch time to do some errands and saw some moms with their babies having lunch. I got that terrible missing my baby pain (16months and at nursery) . So I would take the time with the baby . My career wouldn't be there in 5 years .
Only thing is would you be able to do much ? Coffees , baby clubs etc ? If money is too tight I think it can be tough all day.
Let us know what you decide Smile

ThePlantsitter · 04/04/2022 14:02

@mischance you pulled apart my post in a very judgemental way. 'Do you mean 'making a happy home' by drudgery?' Not judgemental? 'I feel sad for your children' not judgemental? 'I don't know what you mean about spending too much time with your kids you should love every second' (I paraphrase) not judgemental? Nothing judgemental my arse.

I completely agree that SAHM should be seen as of value. Of course I do, I did it for 6 years. I also think that silencing women when they talk about their personal experiences - I was not making any value judgement other than how I felt and about myself - is extremely patronising and not doing what you say you think is important, i.e valuing women.

Mischance · 04/04/2022 14:01

When I did return to work after 5 years, my OH shared much of the care and fitted it round his job, in the same way I was fitting it round mine.

They loved their "Daddy Days" - I did not enquire too closely as to what they got up to.

Mischance · 04/04/2022 13:55

I think that either choice is hard. Freedom to make those choices is what matters.

I guess it depends how much you value the idea of getting to the top of your career. Returning after a period of looking after your children might indeed mean a bit of catching up - but it all depends whether you mind about that - it is about weighing up values.

OfstedOffred · 04/04/2022 13:54

However I would say the biggest thing among my friends has been the need for mutual agreement between spouses that one party should stay at home with children.

Among my parents generation I think for men this was the default, it was expected that you would support a family on one salary.

I think few younger men are as happy to accept that financial responsibility, especially when seeing the impact a second salary has on family finances. Housing is more expensive etc. I think also women used to earn so much less that it was a smaller impact a wife stopping work to have a family. Now many young women earn as much as their partners so that salary is sorely missed if they stop work.

Having a SAHP is only feasible if both parties 100% agree its what's best.

OfstedOffred · 04/04/2022 13:50

Everyone thinks they'll "just stop for 5 years".

Then they find that in fact, getting back in at the level the expect is much harder than envisaged.

Barriers to returning can include:

  • struggling to go back in at the level you left
  • needing to upskill/refresh your knowledge or training
  • simply being out of the habit of working and juggling that with family needs
  • not being able to accept that childcare is expensive so you bring home less than you envisaget/expect
  • part time working tending to be more available to people who've remained in the workforce than new joiners
  • partners being used to having a SAHP and not picking up enough share of the family responsibilities to allow you to commit properly to a job
Swipe left for the next trending thread