Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We have so many homeless

30 replies

NameChangeObvsx1 · 04/04/2022 01:52

Yet no push to take them in. My heart goes out to the people from the Ukraine but why don’t we welcome the UK homeless in so readily?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WiddlinDiddlin · 04/04/2022 04:33

I do also agree with @nosafeguardingadults - shelters are frequently vile, I never used them, but I was lucky I was young enough to access a young homeless persons housing scheme (which was effectively a hostel, manned 24/7 with support staff in office hours and security guards at night, but still had drugs, rape, assault, etc issues, but we DID have our own rooms and lockable doors)..

The place I lived, that put me on the path from supported hostel, to supported flat, to rented council flat... that doesn't exist any more and there is nothing out there to support young people too old for the care homes and too young to fend for themselves.

In that area (I thankfully no longer live there) those kids end up wherever the council can put them, that may be a town where they know no one, it may be one of the many b&b's that are in fact bail hostels, unmanned at night, full of addicts, theives, rapists... Sleeping in a doorway is infinitely more appealing than those places.

It is very much a postcode lottery, there is a huge degree of luck involved. I was lucky I didn't slip down the drugs addiction route, I have a very addictive personality, I avoid alcohol as both parents are/were alcoholics... I didn't make a concious choice not to take drugs, in fact I did take drugs... I just got moved to a flat elsewhere, and the person really manipulating me was moved on to another town, before the point of no return.

My first night in the hostel though.. as I was having my paperwork processed and being shown my room, a boy was being taken out on a stretcher by paramedics having tried to kill himself (spoiler, he walked back in two days later fine and dandy. Second spoiler, he killed himself 9 years later after doing 6 years for manslaughter of his abuser, getting out, getting a job and suffering bullying in the workplace when a co-worker found out about his prison sentence).

There are soooooo many issues going on with homelessness, its not an easy thing to sort, there is no one single answer, no magic wand that can be waved.

Local authorities don't have the funds, charity run efforts can only go so far, the media like to paint all homeless people as lazy shirkers who brought it on themselves, the general public pretend they can't see or typically, patronisingly hand over a coffee and a sandwich that can't be drunk because you know you wont get near a toilet for another 8 hours and are allergic to tuna mayo in any case...

We're going to see more of it though - most people and I include anyone on here who hasn't got 10's of thousands in savings, are only a couple of 'life disasters' - death of a spouse, forget to insure the house, house fire, job loss, significant injury - away from the streets. You may scoff and say 'oh no, not me' but it's true.. your lives are FAR more precarious than you would EVER allow yourselves to believe.

Porridgealert · 04/04/2022 04:32

@nosafeguardingadults. I'm replying because I don't want you to think that no one's listening or isn't interested. I understand that you are homeless through DV and feel if someone just gave you somewhere safe to live, you'd be fine. I can't really engage with your circumstances as they are unknown to me but I wish you well and hope your situation is resolved soon.
My post that you quoted was in response to the op wanting to take homeless people into her spare room. I am sure there are a number of people,who would be grateful for that opportunity and for whom it would be advantageous. However, many homeless people do have multiple problems, regardless of why and how they started, and I stand by my opinion based on experience that I wouldn't take a homeless person into my home except under very specific and limited circumstances.

WiddlinDiddlin · 04/04/2022 04:20

Here we go, a 'why aren't we opening our homes to our own when we're so willing to open them to jonny foreigner..'

The issues surrounding homelessness in the UK are vastly different to those displaced by the war in Ukraine. Those people are homeless because their homes are unsafe or.. gone.

Uk homeless people are homeless for myriad reasons, surprisingly enough (though if you did literally ANY research on the subject you'd find this out in minutes)... not having had the chance to have a home.. actually isn't top of the list!

As a previous poster said - you need some serious knowledge, skills and the back up of professionals to take in 'the homeless', and even then, simply providing someone with somewhere to live does NOT fix all their problems.

There are addiction issues, though, not in every case and not every addict is homeless either - there are huge mental health issues - there are many people who simply do NOT want to live in a house, pay bills, go to work or endlessly fight the benefits system to get what they need.

On the whole, the people who are homeless who desperately do not want to be, and have no addiction issues and are making efforts to manage mental health problems.. will find somewhere. These are the people who can abide by the rules of shelters and housing schemes, who can avoid the trap of becoming dependent and reliant on other mentally ill or addicted people, who are in a position to take the opportunties there are out there.

Not all of them will, unfortunately much of this work is down to charities rather than the government helping significantly, some will slip through the cracks before help gets to them.

Those who are not yet in a place to take advantage of opportunities available, not strong enough to stand alone away from the 'support networks' of similarly unwell people... just putting them into a home will not help - they need much much more than this and it isn't available, for homeless and non-homeless alike.

On the other hand, housing people who on the whole, have no unusual mental health issues, addiction issues.. who literally JUST need a home and the back up of someone who speaks the language and can facilitate practical stuff like washing, printer, internet... thats very 'cheap' and easy to provide.

nosafeguardingadults · 04/04/2022 04:13

Lots of us very resilient and capable but need safe homes. Imagine applying for job, getting interview but getting physically attacked night before so can't go. Happens again and again. Also having to be ready to flee in emergency at any time. Can't try to recover, focus on health or working. Same if homeless including unsafe shelters or temp no security constantly waiting to have to leave. With keys to own safe longterm home, lots of us that's all we need.

nosafeguardingadults · 04/04/2022 04:08

There's some who need extra support so why aren't they given it, but lots are like me.

Very capable and need only a safe home. With a safe secure home longterm, we can recover from domestic violence or illness and then be contributing to society. Even for the ones who can't recover from illness enough to work again, no problems holding down tenancy and managing bills. Just need safe longterm affordable homes.

Lots not even domestic violence. Very easy to become homeless if lose job cos housing allowance lower than lots of rents but even if can afford rent, landlords won't take benefits. Nothing to do with addiction or mental health. It's not being allowed to rent if on benefits and councils not giving social housing to people even when legally supposed to. Lots of councils break law. It's being homeless that causes lots of the addiction and mental health.

nosafeguardingadults · 04/04/2022 03:55

@fallfallfall

our community has shelter for all the homeless, but because of rules that need to be followed (no drugs or alcohol no antisocial behavior) many rooms are available. with warmer weather many will prefer to sleep rough and save the government funds meant to pay rent to purchase drugs and alcohol. once they reach 65 and are eligible for senior care, many are ready for long term care placement and semi forced upon them treatment rarely before sadly.
Lots of homeless shelters are very unsafe. Safer on streets sometimes especially for women. Violence, rapes, stealing, and whatever rules say often drugs, no privacy or dignity. We human beings who need own safe homes not dangerous scary homeless shelter.

It's a lie that being homeless is because of severe addiction or mental health, suggesting people incapable of managing bills or tenancy. Lots of us it's very simple lack of access to safe affordable longterm homes. Being and feeling safe in own safe private home is big solution to lots of mental health problems and is way to recover, not unsafe no security frightening no privacy shelters.

Had to return to abuse after refuge because safe rehousing postcode lottery and lots of housing departments break the law. I'm not the only one. It's a big reason why victims go back or don't leave.

Street homeless no need for addiction. Lose job or get ill physical or mental and end up not enough money to pay rent cos housing allowance less than lots of rents. Even if can afford rents which is possible, landlords don't take benefits. It no children under 18, street homeless. Nothing to do with addiction.

Lots get addicted after being homeless cos life hell and need to be out of it. Homeless is big cause of addiction.

Porridgealert · 04/04/2022 03:50

@nosafeguardingadults
I was quite clear that I was not talking about all homeless people. I never worked with victims of DV so I can't comment about that but I do strongly agree that people have a right to feel safe.
It might not be your case but the plain truth is that for many homeless people, it's not as easy to say here are the keys to your new flat and think that everything will work out fine. As I said, they need a lot more support put in place and that's expensive. And even when they have support packages, it still often doesn't work out. Even if you it were true that people only get addiction and mental health problems because they became homeless, unfortunately, those issues don't just disappear when they get a home.

I don't want to mix Ukrainian refugees in here because that's a red herring. Their issues are very different from the issues that often cause someone to be homeless in their own country.

MrsTerryPratchett · 04/04/2022 03:47

Lots of adduction happens after being homeless cos life hell and if no safe home especially street homeless but also homeless temp is very unsafe and bad and people need to be high to not be in bad hell reality.

This is so true. Then when you finally find out you need to house people because the society wakes up, it's now much much harder. Because people who were muddling through now have serious addictions, trauma from homelessness, with all the violence, health issues, survival dealing and sex work, witnessing violence. Now their housing is more likely to fail again.

It's shit.

fallfallfall · 04/04/2022 03:42

@MrsTerryPratchett, yes more people living on the edge of problems. yes due to poor support.

nosafeguardingadults · 04/04/2022 03:40

@fallfallfall

Because of mental health drug and addiction issues. Unlikely it’s simply a lack of shelter.
Lots of homeless or at risk of it, it's 100% lack of affordable homes.

Right now people losing jobs or ill can't pay too expensive rents when savings run out. Also lots of landlords don't take benefits. No addiction.

Lots of adduction happens after being homeless cos life hell and if no safe home especially street homeless but also homeless temp is very unsafe and bad and people need to be high to not be in bad hell reality.

Also with mental health, lots of people have mental health problems but very capable of managing tenancy. Problem of mental health and also physical is being too ill to work so benefits and landlords not wanting benefits.

The ones who do need more support, why isn't there the support. If need it shld be given it, not left to rot and die homeless.

nosafeguardingadults · 04/04/2022 03:30

@Porridgealert

Because most, not all, homeless people have a lot more problems than just not having a home. Sadly they need a whole package of care and not just someone's spare bedroom.
I'm domestic violence victim with disabilities. Severe trauma/PTSD but not incapable of managing a home/tenancy. You right lots of us need own private home but was in refuge and lots of younger victims especially if no children who would be very happy with safe spare room of a safe home.

Lots of homeless problem simple not enough money for too expensive housing if get ill or job loss and some even are working but homeless cos housing so expensive.

The problem for domestic violence is 100% not having safe affordable longterm home. Refuges are only temporary and postcode lottery of safe rehousing after with lots of lawbreaking councils.

All homeless have no more problems, mental trauma stuff, than Ukrainian refugees who also have trauma and need package of support.

Some homeless people have drug or alcohol addiction or mental health problems but massive reason for those problems is being homeless. Also can't get proper help with safe home and also why can't people be given the support package needed.

100% want Ukrainian refugees to get help too but we homeless or at risk of it need help too and there shldnt be excuses of having problems. Cos the problems for lots of us are not having safe homes.

MrsTerryPratchett · 04/04/2022 03:27

Think bout it this way. There are loads of people who are struggling. MH, drugs, alcohol, low incomes, abusive pasts, disability, currently abusive homes, trauma impacted.

In a society with good supports, there are shelters, women's refuges, healthcare, counsellors, parents' supports, cheap housing and benefits. People muddle through, still housed. In a shit society there aren't. People fall out of housing. Then any trauma, addiction or MH is amplified, increased and self medication becomes the obvious outward sign. Coupled with housing being treated as a profit making asset, not a human right.

But if you kept the person housed, they'd be healthier, happier and, although not great, they'd be fine. Cheaper as well for the Tories at the back.

It's ideological. To have a big homeless population is ideology. We shouldn't blame the person.

fallfallfall · 04/04/2022 03:20

in your view @MrsTerryPratchett, what is it (or are there too many factors to generalize)?

MrsTerryPratchett · 04/04/2022 03:14

I have housed homeless women in my house. A few. Through a very specific program and with very specific support. I'm also trained and able. I would absolutely never ever suggest anyone who isn't do this. However a mum and children who've left a boring home in Ukraine? Would probably work out.

However we did at one time have massive addiction issues and low rates of homelessness. So don't kid yourself it's addiction which causes homelessness. It isn't.

RagingRagingAndMoreRaging · 04/04/2022 02:59

We are all only a couple of traumatic life events from the risk of serious mental health issues and homelessness. Let’s not generalise shall we ‘fallfallfall*.

fallfallfall · 04/04/2022 02:33

@mjf981, they never should have closed Riverview (city land grab) in vancouver.

Porridgealert · 04/04/2022 02:32

@Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase

I went to Bristol city centre recently and it was utterly depressing seeing so many homeless people on the street. This is Tory Britain. The Government doesn’t care if people can’t afford to pay their bills and end up losing their homes. It’s only going to get worse until they get voted out at the election in 2024.
Most people are not homeless because they can't afford to pay their bills. They have all sorts of problems and even when given somewhere to stay, they can't make it work. The idea that by voting Labour in, homelessness will disappear is very simplistic and naive. There are organisations that are trying to develop strategies to house people whilst delivering counselling, physical health care, mental health care, financial support and addiction support services. But it's extremely expensive and, even then, does not always succeed.
mjf981 · 04/04/2022 02:25

Have you been to California (mostly LA/San Fran)? Or East Hastings St in Vancouver? Absolutely shocking the number of people who are homeless. I can't imagine the UK ever getting as bad as this and yet I fear it in the next few years.

fallfallfall · 04/04/2022 02:23

i've lived and voted long enough to reassure you no one really cares about the homeless issue. homeless projects require money that is taken from other pots meant for other issues. ex. an on the street liaison officer to assist police is a newly created position...that same person would have been a nurse at the mental health unit and that position left unfilled.
it has nothing to do with them being able to pay their bills. most need residential care, and that suggests they don't have capacity to make their own decisions. but at times they have capacity and facility care is not what they want long term. not to mention many are young and plug up long term housing. they are a very very costly group to care for.

Forgottenmypasswordagain · 04/04/2022 02:17

@NameChangeObvsx1

I hear you, but they still need help, and how do we know anything about the potential problems any Ukrainians might have. There’s a homeless guy who leaves his duvet - I say ‘duvet’ but it’s the inner of a duvet with the cover ripped off - in a nearby bike shed.

Before anyone asks, I’m a single woman in a one bed flat so not something I could realistically help with, but every time I see him pick up his duvet ‘shell’ to go off to find somewhere to sleep it breaks my heart.

Maybe you can add a sleeping bag beside the duvet in the bike shed? Or something? Pin a note saying "For the guy who uses this duvet, good luck". He may not get it if others see it there, but probably anybody who would take it would be in a similar situation and needs it.
fallfallfall · 04/04/2022 02:16

our community has shelter for all the homeless, but because of rules that need to be followed (no drugs or alcohol no antisocial behavior) many rooms are available. with warmer weather many will prefer to sleep rough and save the government funds meant to pay rent to purchase drugs and alcohol.
once they reach 65 and are eligible for senior care, many are ready for long term care placement and semi forced upon them treatment rarely before sadly.

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 04/04/2022 02:12

I went to Bristol city centre recently and it was utterly depressing seeing so many homeless people on the street. This is Tory Britain. The Government doesn’t care if people can’t afford to pay their bills and end up losing their homes. It’s only going to get worse until they get voted out at the election in 2024.

The4teddybears · 04/04/2022 02:11

My above post was in reply to fallfsllfall’s post of “ Because of mental health drug and addiction issues. Unlikely it’s simply a lack of shelter“”

The4teddybears · 04/04/2022 02:09

This is so true . I work in housing and even when we have special projects that help house homeless , the majority fail mainly due to addiction issues

fallfallfall · 04/04/2022 02:09

situational trauma is one thing and yes needs help, but the ones living rough will have such serious disorders that it's unlikely to be safe to house them with volunteers.
do you have experience with serious mental health conditions? even seasoned workers go home after 8 hours of "work" to recoup from the never ending supervision they need.