Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Which child can you choose?

62 replies

Absolutelyfuckedup · 03/04/2022 22:35

Dd 17 suffering frequent mental health crisis. On medication that isn't working. Getting more and more angry. Police have been involved twice recently. Life is absolutely shit trying to deal with this.
Ds 12. Suffering more and more. Tonight dd has punched and kicked him for being a dickhead. Her words. He was been.cjeeky to me slightly then huffed to his toom, typical almost teenage behaviour which would be dealt with appropriately by me and his dad.
Dd is increasingly out of control and we are at our wits end. Dh can barely sleep. He's ill because of it. I'm up and down and carry on putting a brave face on. Ds has no choice but to live through this upheaval. Dd is clearly unwell. On waiting list for private therapy as no hope on nhs.
I am drained mentally. What the hell do you do. Youngest needs protecting before he is seriously damaged but dd doesn't deserve to be removed from home either. Help!

OP posts:
ThisIsNotARealAvo · 04/04/2022 10:23

Everyone who is suggesting that OP can just call the police and have DD carted off to a cell, or "put her in care" is completely deluded and has no clue what they are talking about.

We have a very similar situation at home. DS is 14 and DD is 12 and lots of things that OP has been through we have too. DS has been arrested, we have made 999 calls, nothing ever really changes. If you can access CAMHS it makes no difference. We have asked for DS to go into care (not a decision we take lightly as he is adopted so has been in care) or for some respite care, there is nothing available and SW will usually push for the child at stay in the family as that is the cheapest option.

If you've never dealt with these services you assume they are there to help you but I assure you they are not. Police in particular are terrible - they come out quickly but when they are you are a nice affluent white family they think "nothing to see here" and take no action.

OP message me if you want to.

TheirTheyre · 04/04/2022 10:12

I would tell dd that if she lays a finger or any other body part o a member of the household again, you will be calling the police. And MEAN IT. FOLLOW THROUGH and be prepared to dial 101 and tell them your dd is attacking her family. They can tell her that they are issuing a warning this time but if there’s a next time it’s off to the cell with her. This should most likely work. Make sure she knows if you do this again I will call the police in you. It’s totally unacceptable. Mh issues or not.

MichelleScarn · 04/04/2022 09:19

She’s basically having a giant toddler tantrum - a child having a tantrum can’t control their emotions. Think back to strategies in the toddler years ie avoiding her getting overtired would hopefully help. With my daughter she was worse just after school - we all agree to just leave her be for 1hr after school so she can unwind and process her day. I'm really sorry but l can't agree with that at all, as that places zero responsibility on her for her actions and has family walking on egg shells around her. If she was 'disturbed' in her alone time and assaulted them, would it then be their fault?

MarinoRoyale · 04/04/2022 09:10

Also consider that you may risk further SS intervention as your eldest sounds like a safeguarding risk to your youngest.

MarinoRoyale · 04/04/2022 09:09

@Timeforausernamechange22

My instinct is protect your 12yr old. They are still a child who needs protecting and who has done nothing wrong yet are being punished. The 17yr old is old enough to know right from wrong, mental health struggles are no excuse for physical violence against her younger sibling. Have you tried having her sectioned? Harsh but if she’s a danger to herself because she can’t control herself due to MH then that is the route you need to go down.
It’s a terrible situation but you must protect your 12 year old, mental health isn’t an excuse for violence.
badspella · 04/04/2022 09:04

Sorry to add, but as a parent, I experienced the same dilemma. I felt like I was encouraging my eldest to leave, when I should have been supporting him (he was very unwell). I know now that going into residential therapeutic accommodation was the right thing to do for all of us. My sons, now young men, are enjoying friendship and brotherhood again.

badspella · 04/04/2022 08:55

We had a similar situation. Children's social care were involved , and CAMHS for my eldest. My eldest does have additional needs and serious mental illness.

The crisis reached a head in 2016/7, so perhaps services were not quite as stretched then. It reached the point of Child Protection Plans, because the eldest son's behaviour was affecting his brother, and my youngest son's retaliation (they were closer in age - 17 and 14/5) was affecting the eldest. Both boys were unable to attend school at this time (extreme anxiety and other MH needs). This made other services get involved, and it also made the situation almost impossible to manage at home.

At 18, my eldest moved into a residential home, for people with mental health difficulties. It was local and we met up very regularly and spoke daily. He is now living in a supported flat and is making steps toward independence.

Every situation is different, and I am skimming over a very complex situation. However, important factors which led to my eldest moving out of the family home are these.

My eldest son needed and wanted to move away from home but services are so hard to find for a 17 year old (this is a national problem). This is why we had to wait until he was 18.
Children's social care were involved at the highest level because both sons were in danger.

The residential unit was very close to where we lived, and had an open door policy. My eldest was able to get the support he needed, and to have lots of contact at home.
My youngest son's mental health suffered.

The effect that challenging behaviour has on a family and on individuals in the family cannot be underestimated.

ittakes2 · 04/04/2022 08:29

Please google inattentive adhd and see if that applies to her.
Also if she is getting physical - think of other ways to release physical energy. Get a mini indoor trampoline and encourage her to jump when feeling frustrated. Encourage her to sing when she feels like yelling.

ittakes2 · 04/04/2022 08:25

I am sorry - nightmare. Of course it’s not ok but I am sure if you knew the solution you would have solved it by now. You are doing your best. She is clearly unwell. For me with my daughter it was working out what was happening before the bad behaviour. When does she act up the most? At night after school? It’s likely she is feeling over whelmed / tired. She’s basically having a giant toddler tantrum - a child having a tantrum can’t control their emotions. Think back to strategies in the toddler years ie avoiding her getting overtired would hopefully help. With my daughter she was worse just after school - we all agree to just leave her be for 1hr after school so she can unwind and process her day.

Absolutelyfuckedup · 04/04/2022 08:18

Thank you for the answers

OP posts:
TrashyPanda · 04/04/2022 00:28

Protecting your young son from physical harm is essential.
It’s probably screwing with his mental health too, living with older sibling who assaults him.
Please don’t even consider sending him elsewhere
He needs your love and support.
Your DH sounds close to breaking point.

Your daughter sounds like she needs professional help, beyond what you can offer. Especially if the police are involved. That’s really serious.

Timeforausernamechange22 · 04/04/2022 00:08
  • Imagine , what were you doing at 15, meeting mates, going to the cinema into town

She went into lockdown! The most important time of your life, going from child to being independent, feeling a bit more freedom! These are the kids that suffered the most. In a week it was taken from them.*

As did many many other teenagers, who are also struggling with mental health issues (mine included), but that doesn’t give ANYONE the excuse the punch their 12yr old brother. Unless she is schizophrenic, then even with poor mental health she will still know right from wrong. And if she is that unwell that she cannot distinguish that then she should be sectioned and receive proper medical help and support.
The OP is not, I presume, a mental health professional and likely has zero experience in supporting people like her dd, and she needs professional help. Sometimes you have to do the drastic to get it.

tkwal · 03/04/2022 23:55

The best way to get help for your 17year old is to report the assaults she is carrying out on your 12 year old to the police. Do this before she turns 18 or you will not be able to access any help for her at all. Youth Justice will offer one to one work on managing anger and developing coping strategies. Instead of launching directly into therapy pay for a private assessment by a psychologist and if necessary a psychiatrist. Psychiatrists deal with actual illnesses of the brain, chemical imbalances etc. Psychologists more with learned behaviours and how the brain is wired to respond. You may need to get some help for your 12 Yr old too. He is being abused in what should be his safe place and could suffer long term trauma because of it

Vipersea · 03/04/2022 23:52

Beyond help!!!! Jesus are you serious!

Imagine , what were you doing at 15, meeting mates, going to the cinema into town

She went into lockdown! The most important time of your life, going from child to being independent, feeling a bit more freedom! These are the kids that suffered the most. In a week it was taken from them.

Yes obviously protect your youngest, that goes without saying. It can be done, we have lived through it but fgs DON'T put your 17yr old child in care. You be a parent! Grit your teeth, man your husband up but do not take the easy way out! These other people commentating any different are not parents or don't deserve to be and I am raging at their views. You do not get to give up if you are a parent full stop!

Neverreturntoathread · 03/04/2022 23:41

I’m so sorry 😭

DD17 is nearly an adult. She physically assaulted a 12 year old. I’m not sure I agree with you that she doesn’t deserve to be removed from home. I wonder if being sectioned might actually help her, at least with more observation she might finally get meds that work.

Which child do you choose? The youngest one. The one still learning how to be.

I wish you the best of luck and hope things get easier for you. But if she is beyond help - don’t let her destroy the rest of you, I’ve seen how one person can wreck the whole family.

BluebellsGreenbells · 03/04/2022 23:41

I wouldn’t put a lock on the door, if he’s not quick enough she could trap him in there.

I would ring the police and let her know you are reporting the assault.

They usually send community officers and put the wind up them. I would tell her in no uncertain terms that is the plan of action going forward .

If a 17 year old lad assaulted him what would you do?

ElegantlyTouched · 03/04/2022 23:36

If you want a relationship with at least one of your children in the future you need to spend some quality time with your son without your dd being around. Do not send him elsewhere as you have considered in another thread. Her actions have hospitalised him, he needs to know you love him.
If you send him away, even for his safety, what message does that give him? That regardless of how his sister treats him she'll be the one cared for by you whilst he gets banished. I'm sure you tell him she's ill and needs to be treated with consideration, but he's ill now. She can't be seen to be able to carry on regardless whilst he gets punished by being sent away.

My mum pandered to my sister for years. My sister is a bully so Mum would pander to her to keep the peace, ignoring how much she hurt me in the process. I was meant to just put up with it. And I did until it went too far, and I realised how much hurt I was expected to put up with. I now have v little to do with my mum, and my sister still treats her like shite. I do feel incredibly sad about it but I have to protect myself as nobody else will. Do you really want to lose your relationship with your son?

parietal · 03/04/2022 23:35

protect your 12yr old - let him have a lock on his bedroom door & stay safe. can his school give him counselling & support too?

fight for services to help your 17 yr old.

BlooberryBiskits · 03/04/2022 23:34

Sorry, this must be so difficult

If 1 parent & 12 yo can stay with family from time to time (eg weekends?) might give you a break to help you get through this time

Obviously the need is to protect your younger child but the teen is clearly acting out MH issues so ‘having a talk’ may not be effective…

Vipersea · 03/04/2022 23:29

Oh and you don't chose! They are both your children that need hekp!

Vipersea · 03/04/2022 23:26

Sorry I was so enraged at the comments I had to come back!
Practically : go to GP first stop, what is the reason and what are the drugs prescribed? Any medication is trial and error of May need doses revisted. My DD we had to double dose of citralopram to see any difference.

  1. CAHMS waiting list is v long and with your daughters age they prob be won't much use but tbh they aren't any good anyway so wouldn't worry
  2. They will or prob have redirected to minds matters, again, long waiting list and not great
  3. If you are seriously worried about DD mental health take her to A & E to get fast tracked.
If police have been involved like you say then they should have fast tracked this already??? You should be assigned your own case worker. Has this happened?
StoneofDestiny · 03/04/2022 23:16

The 17 year old is a child too. I'm surprised she hasn't been sectioned for her own safety if she is so out of control and her meds aren't working. No advice - but keep pressing for help.Contact GP and tell them you are at breaking point.

Vipersea · 03/04/2022 23:11

I bet you all did posts on how you support MH too! Ffs! Yes keep children separate but 17 is still a child with MH issues you horrors!

Viviennemary · 03/04/2022 23:11

I think she needs to be taken into care even if only on a temporary basis. Your other child needs to be protected from this violence.

Ivegotalovelybunch · 03/04/2022 23:09

I’m harsh but if she assaulted him I’d be taking her down to the police station for some tough love. Actions have consequences and mental health is not an excuse for abuse, even in teenage years

Swipe left for the next trending thread